Is there a doctor in the house?

I see. No need for any further investigation. You have it all figured out. A true "skeptic."

A true skeptic wouldn't have believed her headache went away - but that's beside the point. I'm waiting for the double blind study. Meanwhile, what little science I do know indicates the stick is pure shtick (i.e., gimmick).

jbs
 
Diazolidinyl Urea, Ethyl Alcohol, Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate: The first three ingredients in the inactive list all have some antibacterial effect (according to the Internet - if you can trust that) and are often used as preservatives. Diazolidinyl Urea and Iodopropynyl Butylcarbamate are usually used together. The alcohol probably evaporates quickly rather than being absorbed.

Menthol does have uses as an analgesic (and cough suppressant - no wonder they put it in cigarettes). It is a candidate for some degree of effectiveness.

Propylene Glycol might be there for its moisturizing properties - but it has a bunch of uses in medicines, cosmetics, and food (mostly related to moisture).

Sodium Stearate is typically the main component of soap. So just washing your face ought to be good for headaches, eh?

Steareth-21 is an emulsifier. I'm not sure how that would work in a headache remedy - I doubt it aids in through-the-skin absorption. Here it probably helps hold all the rest of the stuff together.

(These previous three are common is regular soap).

Tetrasodium EDTA is used in a lot of shampoo - I'm not sure what effects it might have - might be a bit of an irritant in larger quantities and certainly you'd cure your headaches with a good hair washing if it did anything for headaches!

Triethanolamine is probably used to neutralize in acids in the stick as that's its main use in other products. It doesn't seem to have any ability with regards to speeding absorption through the skin.

Water - the universal solvent. See my comment about washing the face.

Of this list, I think only Menthol has a chance for easy absorption into the skin - but at that not in 30 seconds. Eating a peppermint candy would be a tastier way to get the menthol.

So, my recommendation, if HeadOn actually worked, it'd be better to take a bath, washing the hair and face while eating a peppermint candy. This would provide all the same inactive ingredients and you don't need the $8.00 stick of lip balm. Actually, reading the ingredients of a typical medicated lip balm, those would likely work better! ;)

jbs
 
Last edited:
I understand why Remie was saying that, though. Many did not read her post completely, jumped to the conclusion she was making some statement for the product and immediately launched an offensive. In your post, I was envisioning microscopes tipped on their sides, glassware hurling about the room and hysterical screaming somewhere in a laboratory. ;)

I'm not really sure I see your point this time, though. Put Remie's question in another context: "A psychic just bent a spoon in front of me. I know there is no such thing as psychic spoon bending, so how was it accomplished?" Using the same basic question but with a different subject, posters would react more favourably and praise her questioning something dodgy.
Ahh, but the spoon was bent. So looking for how it was bent includes looking for all the usual suspects. The headache went away. It's only natural then to note the usual suspects as well.

In the case of the 'miracle' spoon bending, skeptics know to look for not so miraculous explanations. In the case of Headon, homeopathy has been sufficiently debunked. I don't think we need to keep proving that point. But if an ingredient in Headon actually relieves a headache, then the product would work regardless of the debunked 'miracle' explanation.

So the question, "Do any of the ingredients have potential to relieve a headache?" is one thing. But giving the anecdote first then asking that question carries the implication the person telling the anecdote is indeed wondering if Headon was the reason the headache subsided.

The anecdote changed the question from, "Are they claiming homeopathy but providing headache relief via another ingredient?" to, "My headache went away and while I don't believe in homeopathy, I wonder if Headon relieved the headache by another means?" The second question invites the usual suspect responses. The first question doesn't.

None of this changes the question from Remie's perspective. She knew what she meant and has clarified it sufficiently. But there is a message one hears differently with and without the anecdote. I am therefore inclined to give the responders slack for all the replies noting variables in headache relief that didn't address the actual question. I don't think it is because they didn't read the post. I think it is because the anecdote had unintended implications.
 
....
Of this list, I think only Menthol has a chance for easy absorption into the skin - but at that not in 30 seconds. ...

jbs
Don't overlook the fact these ingredients are readily absorbed when inhaled. You may get very dilute quantities but anything that evaporates off the face is close enough some of it will likely be inhaled. Many things are absorbed via the mouth and nasal passage mucosa as well. It's rapid enough we have drugs one puts under the tongue for their immediate response. And cocaine users wouldn't snort the stuff if they didn't get an immediate rush. The rush is part of the addiction. Cocaine is absorbed via the nasal mucosa.
 
Last edited:
I might've still asked the question, actually, because I prefer to back up what I'm writing about with information from knowledgable sources. I wrote to pharmacology professors and asked for a doctor's opinion here. Not because I think it did work, but because there is a possibility it did work.

...

Point being, I do not know what the ingredients mean. They might mean "morphine" or "aspirin". If they did, then yes, I would say Head-On was responsible for curing the headache. If they do not, then I would continue to research the issue.

This is for an article on a product, not a clinical trial. I wanted to have as much information about what the ingredients were and what they are normally used for as possible. That's all.
There are a lot of replies; but you can distill some ideas from them. Nobody, not even a doctor, can tell you more because almost ALL of the speculation about the pharmacology of the inactive ingredients is unwarranted; especially absent realistic (analytical) data concerning concentrations.

Switchtech got some of it right by finding the purpose of some of the ingredients (the preservatives, triethanolamine and steareth-21).

I will say this another way- I made topical pharmaceutical products for ten years, before I went to graduate school. I know the uses of all the ingredients, depending on concentration (which I cannot get from our data; which is suspect). What is "suspect" is the order in which the ingredients are listed by the manufacturer.

Remie, I don't see how you can write an article concerning a product about which so little is known. If you can't cite clinical trials or facts about ingredients- what can you say? Will you consider the popularity of an unproven remedy and the effect that has on the pocketbook? This is not an attack- I would really like to know.
 
I agree with JJM's point and it goes to what I was saying. First you need evidence the product works. Otherwise speculating the ingredients might explain the product's effect is no different than speculating homeopathy might have an effect.
 
skeptigirl wrote
None of this changes the question from Remie's perspective. She knew what she meant and has clarified it sufficiently. But there is a message one hears differently with and without the anecdote. I am therefore inclined to give the responders slack for all the replies noting variables in headache relief that didn't address the actual question. I don't think it is because they didn't read the post. I think it is because the anecdote had unintended implications.

So you are saying, because Remie phrased this query in a way similar to a passing woo, you suffered a meltdown, stamped your feet, wandered into ad hominem territory and you are correct in doing so?

Sorry, but I see a simple case of bias. You and some others did not read the post thoroughly, jumped to a conclusion, shouted "Seize her!" and launched an offensive. It was a very simple post to begin with and was approached by some with all the logic of taking a sledgehammer to crack a walnut.

To break down Remie's post in more simplistic terms:

"Hello, I am Remie. I am a known skeptic in skeptic circles. I'm writing an article for my skeptical website. My subject: I had a terrible headache and used Head-On to see if it indeed is hooey. I thought it would be a good article. Shockingly my headache vanished. So I am asking JREF, as I cannot get up with several pharmacologists this weekend, could any of the active or inactive ingredients have any effect on a headache?"

To me it was a very simple question. As JREF is a repository of smart cookies, she merely wanted info, not to establish a clinical trial. Somewhere along the way, though, her post caused you to wobble on your axis and eventually spin out of orbit. I suggest you visit her website and read a few of her articles, then re-read the post. Perhaps then the question and the answer she was seeking will become more clear to you.
 
What of cologne, then? Mind you, that remedy went out with rotary phones, but it was used for centuries among the upper classes. Was it the alcohol or the essential oils that increased bloodflow - or was it useless? Just curious in this case, as cologne was my grandmother's remedy for minor headaches.
I know eau de cologne, in fact I live 40 Km away from the place where it was first produced and which gave it its name. But eau de cologne's main ingredient is alcohol --- when you speak of essential oils, then that's ingredients not described; can't describe the effects without knowing the ingredients. As for the alcohol part, I surmise it easily would have just such an anti-headache effect on the types of headache I was describing --- headaches centered on the forehead and temples, usually owing to sinus irritation or rhinitis. Increasing blood flow can easily have just such a headache-decreasing effect, and alcohol in that region is very easily absorbed; the blood vessels lie close to the surface there, and breathing in the alcohol through the nose is also easy there, again hitting the target blood vessels. So I would guess eau de cologne could be quite useful for that; never tried it myself though.
 
Remie, I don't see how you can write an article concerning a product about which so little is known. If you can't cite clinical trials or facts about ingredients- what can you say? Will you consider the popularity of an unproven remedy and the effect that has on the pocketbook? This is not an attack- I would really like to know.

I think you are overlooking the elephant in the room. She is simply trying to write an article about her first hand experience with Head On and asking for info on the ingredients. As there is no body of work to cite, she is asking knowledgeable posters for facts on the ingredients. Many skeptical bloggers do the same thing everyday and few hold clinical trials.
Example: Skeptico
 
Last edited:
I know eau de cologne, in fact I live 40 Km away from the place where it was first produced and which gave it its name. But eau de cologne's main ingredient is alcohol --- when you speak of essential oils, then that's ingredients not described; can't describe the effects without knowing the ingredients. As for the alcohol part, I surmise it easily would have just such an anti-headache effect on the types of headache I was describing --- headaches centered on the forehead and temples, usually owing to sinus irritation or rhinitis. Increasing blood flow can easily have just such a headache-decreasing effect, and alcohol in that region is very easily absorbed; the blood vessels lie close to the surface there, and breathing in the alcohol through the nose is also easy there, again hitting the target blood vessels. So I would guess eau de cologne could be quite useful for that; never tried it myself though.

Thanks for that. I figured it was the alcohol. Grand ladies of my grandmother's era ( and particularly in Victorian times) used cologne for insect bites and all manner of things, as well as headaches. It was about 1962 when I got the cologne treatment. Of course, I was 4 and was always having some mishap. I rememberGrandma telling me it was cooling and to go have a lie down. At any rate, all the talk about rubbing concoctions on foreheads to cure headaches brought back the memory of my cologne treatment.
 
I agree with JJM's point and it goes to what I was saying. First you need evidence the product works. Otherwise speculating the ingredients might explain the product's effect is no different than speculating homeopathy might have an effect.

I think that both you and JJM have missed the point of this exercise. I realize that I could be wrong. I just want to suggest another way of looking at it.

This is my perspective. The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question. And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say.

"Anecdotes" and an "N of 1" are evidence. They are evidence that a particular sequence of events happened. Sure, it's a logical fallacy to make the assumption that "post hoc ergo propter hoc", but our everyday experience tells us that most of the time "after this, therefore because of this" is true. The ball flies through the air because we threw it. Our toe hurts because we stubbed it on the coffee table.

What it looked like to me, was that Remie recognized that even though she's a skeptic and made an effort to take cognitive bias and chance into consideration, it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".

Linda
 
I really don't think so. I use something similar to Tiger Balm, basically pure peppermint oil, and I only apply it to my forehead and temples, I don't massage them. The peppermint oil has the effect of increasing blood flow subcutaneously, and my guess is that it also increases blood flow in deeper vessels in the area ...
If it does increase blood flow in deep vessels, it is not by direct penetration. After permeating the skin, it goes into the circulatory system and is distributed throughout the body. (When you apply dimethylsulfoxide (DMSO) anywhere, you immediately taste it in your mouth.) So, if your hypothesis is correct, you should get the same result by applying the oil to your chest.

Drug manufacturers often design "patches" to be used over the affected area simply for the psychological benefit. For example, most people know sea-sickness is an inner ear problem- so the first patch was worn behind the ear.

By the way, DMSO is among a small number of "bulk chemicals" that I really worry about coming in contact with my skin. It has the ability to enhance the absorption of many other compounds. DMSO is also a very good solvent, so the ordinary bottle of it contaminated with dissolved junk. As a result, if you treat yourself with it (as some people with arthritis do), you have no idea what else you are absorbing. (DMSO designed for clinical use is highly purified.)
 
I think that both you and JJM have missed the point of this exercise. I realize that I could be wrong. I just want to suggest another way of looking at it.

This is my perspective. The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question. And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say.

"Anecdotes" and an "N of 1" are evidence. They are evidence that a particular sequence of events happened. Sure, it's a logical fallacy to make the assumption that "post hoc ergo propter hoc", but our everyday experience tells us that most of the time "after this, therefore because of this" is true. The ball flies through the air because we threw it. Our toe hurts because we stubbed it on the coffee table.

What it looked like to me, was that Remie recognized that even though she's a skeptic and made an effort to take cognitive bias and chance into consideration, it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".

Linda

Thank you. I think many assumed "article" meant "scientific research paper."

I must say this brouhaha over a simple question has been amusing, if sadly so. It reminds me of a similar experience I had on a woo forum. This summer, I proposed conducting a flash poll to see if the show Ghost Hunters is changing belief in the paranormal and to write of my findings. I floated the idea on the TAPS forum as it has the largest collection of viewers. Since I was known to be skeptical of the paranormal in the first place, soon the board melted down over the proposal. The last I heard, some members think I follow the actors of Ghost Hunters around and spy on them. To get to the point - I expect such histrionics from a forum with a collective IQ of 5, but I expect better from the members of JREF.
 
... This is my perspective. The exercise isn't about evidence that the product is effective. It's about explaining something in a way that makes sense to the person asking the question. And I think it illustrates part of the reason why believers dismiss what skeptics have to say.
...
What it looked like to me, was that Remie recognized that even though she's a skeptic and made an effort to take cognitive bias and chance into consideration, it really seemed that her experience was consistent with other causal experiences; her headache went away because she used Head-On. And an explanation that takes that into account will be more satisfying than one that simply dismisses the connection as "not evidence".

Linda
Linda, I have only argued, from long, professional experience that we don't know how much of each other ingredient is in the product. There is one, obvious, large error in the listing; there could be others. Furthermore, now that I think of it, I am not sure you could put a therapeutic amount of menthol in this type of stick.

To summarize what we can say about this:

1) Bias against homeopathy is not merely cynical, it is based in knowledge of chemistry and physics, and a long history of clinical failure. So, it is reasonable for Remie to ask if the other ingredients are doing something. We can't answer this question; but it is doubtful.

2) The likely explanations are either coincidence or the placebo effect. Considering that there are more than six billion people having lots of experiences every day, lots of coincidences are expected. Pain is a subjective feeling, and, as such, it is the sort of thing that can show an impressive placebo-effect.

I heard a story (for those in the know- Ray, on "Car Talk"). He had a loud ringing in his ears, so he went to a doctor. The doctor suggested waiting a while longer before trying any treatment. Ray asked what it could be, and the doc nonchalantly suggested a brain tumor. After he left, Ray noticed that the ringing was gone (never returned). What was that? An anti-placebo, a coincidence? (A "placebo" that gives an undesirable effect is a "nocebo.")

It is not that the observation is "not evidence", we have insufficent data to suggest anything but #2, above.
 
<snip>

To summarize what we can say about this:

1) Bias against homeopathy is not merely cynical, it is based in knowledge of chemistry and physics, and a long history of clinical failure. So, it is reasonable for Remie to ask if the other ingredients are doing something. We can't answer this question; but it is doubtful.

2) The likely explanations are either coincidence or the placebo effect. Considering that there are more than six billion people having lots of experiences every day, lots of coincidences are expected. Pain is a subjective feeling, and, as such, it is the sort of thing that can show an impressive placebo-effect.

<snip>

And in making this summary, you have finally answered her question.
 
If diazolidinyl urea is irritating, then it would make sense that a small amount would provide a counter-stimulant effect. Essentially, the effect may be coming from the inactive ingredients with no effect from the active ingredients. :)

That's the problem with many many "homeopathic" remedies. They are clearly and misleadingly mislabled. Many of their so-called "inactive" ingredients are, in fact, highly active ones. Menthol causes a distinct biological effect, and therefore an "active" ingredient no matter what. I wonder if there are grounds for an FDA complaint, since ingredients are being clearly mislabled.

It reminds me of a "homeopathic" hangover/nausea treatment that my partner pointed out to me a few months ago. I forget what the actual homopathic crap was, but under "inactive" ingredients, it listed the product as being composed almost entirely of activated charcoal, a well-known and commonplace real medical treatment.

I don't seem to recall these sorts of things having been pointed out, or at least not more than mentioned in passing, in any of the info on Homeopathy i've read on skeptic sites. Anyone have a link to a site that has more info on this practice? If not, I may go ahead and start one myself. Having grown up with many quack medical practices, they are currently one of my biggest pet peeves.
 
Linda, I have only argued, from long, professional experience that we don't know how much of each other ingredient is in the product. There is one, obvious, large error in the listing; there could be others. Furthermore, now that I think of it, I am not sure you could put a therapeutic amount of menthol in this type of stick.

To summarize what we can say about this:

1) Bias against homeopathy is not merely cynical, it is based in knowledge of chemistry and physics, and a long history of clinical failure. So, it is reasonable for Remie to ask if the other ingredients are doing something. We can't answer this question; but it is doubtful.

I simply don't think we should have been chastized for speculating.

2) The likely explanations are either coincidence or the placebo effect. Considering that there are more than six billion people having lots of experiences every day, lots of coincidences are expected. Pain is a subjective feeling, and, as such, it is the sort of thing that can show an impressive placebo-effect.

It seemed clear to me that Remie understood that that was the alternate/default explanation.

It is not that the observation is "not evidence", we have insufficent data to suggest anything but #2, above.

Sir, yes sir! :)

Linda
 
So the question, "Do any of the ingredients have potential to relieve a headache?" is one thing. But giving the anecdote first then asking that question carries the implication the person telling the anecdote is indeed wondering if Headon was the reason the headache subsided.
This just looks like an justification for overreaction to me, rather than admitting that you overreacted. When reading the OP, it was quite clear to me that she was asking if the "inactive" ingredients might have been responsible for the effect. I'm not how anyone would have gotten anything else from the OP, aside from a knee-jerk reaction due to a purely superficial reading of the entire post. But then, incomplete reading and knee-jerk reactions tend to be far too commonplace around here, i've noticed.

And the practice of including actually useful ingredients in homeopathic treatments, but listing them as "inactive", is a very well-established one. I pointed out another example in my previous post. One manufacturer was required to pull his product after it was demonstrated that it contained substantial amounts of non-homeopathic herbal ingredients, and therefore fell afoul of regulations regarding those ingredients.
The anecdote changed the question from, "Are they claiming homeopathy but providing headache relief via another ingredient?" to, "My headache went away and while I don't believe in homeopathy, I wonder if Headon relieved the headache by another means?" The second question invites the usual suspect responses. The first question doesn't.
I'm not seeing your point here. Both statements are simply different ways of saying the exact same thing.
 
I simply don't think we should have been chastized for speculating.

That's why I'm shocked at some of the reactions to this topic. Skeptics ask questions and weigh possibilities. I feel some have a secret books called "The Skeptics Handbook of Skeptic Laws" and are falling back on arguments from authority.
 
skeptigirl wrote


So you are saying, because Remie phrased this query in a way similar to a passing woo, you suffered a meltdown, stamped your feet, wandered into ad hominem territory and you are correct in doing so?

Sorry, but I see a simple case of bias. You and some others did not read the post thoroughly, jumped to a conclusion, shouted "Seize her!" and launched an offensive. It was a very simple post to begin with and was approached by some with all the logic of taking a sledgehammer to crack a walnut.

To break down Remie's post in more simplistic terms:

"Hello, I am Remie. I am a known skeptic in skeptic circles. I'm writing an article for my skeptical website. My subject: I had a terrible headache and used Head-On to see if it indeed is hooey. I thought it would be a good article. Shockingly my headache vanished. So I am asking JREF, as I cannot get up with several pharmacologists this weekend, could any of the active or inactive ingredients have any effect on a headache?"

To me it was a very simple question. As JREF is a repository of smart cookies, she merely wanted info, not to establish a clinical trial. Somewhere along the way, though, her post caused you to wobble on your axis and eventually spin out of orbit. I suggest you visit her website and read a few of her articles, then re-read the post. Perhaps then the question and the answer she was seeking will become more clear to you.
Goodness! You certainly missed the point. As did a few others. I am not the least bit upset. Guess I'll try another version.

I merely defended the people who replied with all the reasons the headache went away which were not addressing the question saying it might not have been because they didn't read the post. I merely noted the anecdote implied Remie was considering Headon actually had an effect. (Nothing to do with anyone's belief in homeopathy.)

If any of you happen to make it to this year's TAM, come to my Sunday presentation on "Cracking the Language Code - Deciphering hidden messages you didn't know you were sending and receiving."

Look again but take all those silly assumptions out of your filter.

Statement 1): I don't believe Headon works.
Statement 2): Could any of the ingredients in Headon work?

Logic: If you don't believe Headon works then why would you inquire about the ingredients working?

Compare that to

Statement 1): I don't believe homeopathy works.
Statement 2): Could something in Headon work and be misleading people into thinking homeopathy worked?

The second 2 statements are what Remie was asking. The first 2 were the ones she initially used. The listener (or reader) hears the hidden message and includes that in their reply. Remie thinks the reader isn't reading carefully. Maybe not, but the reason is the hidden message as much as it is the care in reading.

Remie expresses frustration that the readers are not reading carefully. But she isn't aware of the hidden message the original post included.


In your case, your filter is telling you everything I'm writing is critical and whining. But I am merely describing my observation about the hidden message. It isn't bad or good. It is an insight into something about the original post that isn't being consciously picked up on, but is being unconsciously picked up on by some readers.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom