Is there a doctor in the house?

By the way, Linda, I always love your posts. You're just amazing. :D

And Vampire, thanks for speaking up and everything... I can't believe I wandered off at such a critical time :)
By the way, thanks JJM and Dogdoctor for taking the time and interest to point out the scientific principles involved in analyzing a product such as this, and thanks, Gurdur, for your addition re the effects of topical medications.

*Note to self, it's much more important to pat forum members on the back and exchange niceties than to have a legitimate discussion about science.
 
By the way, thanks JJM and Dogdoctor for taking the time and interest to point out the scientific principles involved in analyzing a product such as this, and thanks, Gurdur, for your addition re the effects of topical medications.

*Note to self, it's much more important to pat forum members on the back and exchange niceties than to have a legitimate discussion about science.

*Note to Skepigirl - having a good discussion starts with understanding the post first before spinning off into space and jumping all over someone. Relax before attempting pontification. It can save you embarrassing moments later and potential forum meltdowns.

That said, you seem tense. Here's a helpful hint and very seasonal: Get a cup of eggnog and pour in a good dollop of Southern Comfort. Watch the chemical reaction. The mixture will roil a bit and the egg whites will separate from the yolk. Dash in a bit of nutmeg and drink the elixir down. Take a couple of more belts and read a few skeptic blogs. Repeat this experiment. Soon you'll be having one heck of a time...
 
Couple points, vasodilation is not how NTG affects Gur's willy. It may not be what causes the headache either. I'll look into it later and follow up if no one has by then.

It looks like you're up.

I await with baited breath.

Linda
 
It looks like you're up.

I await with baited breath.

Linda
It would be nice if there was a simple translation to the following but I don't have one. My area of expertise is infectious disease and not the cellular level of ID either. However, I do understand in many of our physiological processes, there are typically chemical cascades that add or block catalysts, trigger absorption or release of neurotransmitters, add or block enzymes, open or block receptors and so on. In the case of nitroglycerin and related drugs, they are precursors which are turned into the active nitric oxide as part of the cascade.

While it's easy to think a headache is merely caused by dilated blood vessels or increased heart rate or other simple process, there are all sorts of other things going on such as histamine and prostaglandin release and other inflammatory processes which can actually be the mediator which triggers the perception of pain. And in many cases, there are other factors in the brain which can override or accentuate a pain impulse.

So with that in mind I tried to find articles related to the etiology of nitroglycerin headaches. But to really get to the specifics I'd need a lot more time. So here's a starting place:

Nitroglycerin-induced headaches
RESULTS: two types of headache developed after the nitroglycerin administration: (1) an immediate headache that does not fulfil the criteria for migraine, mild and disappears spontaneously within 1 hour; (2) a typical migraine attack without aura develops several hours after the nitroglycerin administration (mean latency: 250 min), moderate or severe, and warrants antimigraine therapy. The two types of headache developed independently. The nitroglycerin-induced headaches have not been determined solely by the previous migraine diagnosis, although both immediate (p = 0.0045) and typical migraine headache (p = 0.00047) were significantly more frequent among migraineurs compared to controls. Moreover, those control subjects who experienced migraine attacks had predispositions to migraine. Previous results of the authors supported that lower platelet serotonin concentration and higher plasma CGRP concentration, during the headache free period, are risk factors that express greater susceptibility to develop both spontaneous and nitroglycerin-induced migraine attack.

nitrolgycerin (NTG), which has been shown to induce migraine attacks in up to 80% of migraineurs.

Basically what it says is whatever causes migraines is triggered by nitroglycerin. And some people who had no history of migraine but still got a migraine like headache from NTG had risk factors for migraine.

It seems to be accepted that NTG triggers a migraine. If that is the case then it is curious if it is merely blood vessel dilation, why everyone doesn't get the same headache. But they don't.

Looking at a variety of additional information:

Sumatriptan causes parallel decrease in plasma calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) concentration and migraine headache during nitroglycerin induced migraine attack.
In those subjects whose migraine attack improved considerably 60 min after the treatment the plasma CGRP concentration decreased significantly (P<0.05). In contrast, plasma CGRP concentration failed to change in patients whose headache did not improve. In addition, plasma CGRP concentrations showed significant positive correlations with the headache scores both 60 and 120 min after sumatriptan administration (P<0.05). According to our results plasma CGRP concentration decreases parallel to headache intensity during sumatriptan treatment and this decrease in CGRP predicts effectiveness of antimigraine drug therapy. This supports that one of the main effects of triptans is to decrease CGRP release.

All migraine subjects developed headache after GTN (NO precursor)
....No reduction of GTN-induced migraine was found after propranolol compared with placebo...We found that 2 weeks of propranolol constricted the radial artery in healthy subjects but not in migraine subjects. GTN-induced vasodilatation abolished this difference....Propranolol does not constrict cerebral arteries, which therefore cannot be part of its mechanism of action in migraine.

Investigations into the role of nitric oxide and the large intracranial arteries in migraine headache.
Histamine is known to liberate NO from the endothelium via stimulation of the H1 receptor, which is present in the large intracranial arteries in man. Because both immediate histamine-induced headache and intracranial arterial dilatation and delayed histamine-induced migraine are blocked by H1-receptor blockade, a likely common pathway for GTN and histamine-induced headaches/migraines and intracranial arterial responses may be via activation of the NO-cGMP pathway.The delay in the development of these experimental migraines may reflect activation of multiple physiological processes. The intracranial arteries of migraineurs were found supersensitive to the vasodilating effect of GTN (exogenous NO). This relates to clinical findings suggesting dilatation of the large intracranial arteries on the headache side during spontaneous migraine attacks. The function of arterial regulatory mechanisms involving NO in migraine was therefore studied. In peripheral arteries, no endothelial dysfunction of NO was found and cardiovascular and intracranial arterial sympathetic function was normal. A mild parasympathetic dysfunction may be involved and may, via denervation supersensitivity, be responsible for the observed supersensitivity to NO. Another possibility is that NO initiates a perivascular neurogenic inflammation with liberation of vasoactive peptides. NO also mediates a variety of other physiological phenomena. One of these, the pain-modulating effect observed in animals, was evaluated in a human study using GTN infusion and measurements of pain thresholds. No definite effects of GTN were demonstrated. The precise mechanisms involved in NO-triggered migraines and which part of the NO-activated cascade that is involved remain to be determined.

And if that isn't enough to show there isn't a simple explanation, here's an odd paper on another action of NO in scar formation:

nitric oxide (NO) plays an important role in the inflammation stage of wound healing.
..the enhancing effect of exogenous NO (released from NO donor) on collagen expression in the keloid fibroblast (KF) as well as on the induction of collagen type I protein and TGF-beta1 expression in the KF were studied in this investigation....Exogenous NO was found to enhance the expression of collagens and elevate the cellular levels of cGMP. Moreover, to evaluate the effect of the elevated cellular cGMP levels on the expression of collagen and TGF-beta1, both cGMP and TGF-beta1 were measured by ELISA. The inhibitors for phosphodiesterase (PDE), such as IBMX (3-isobutyl-1-methylxanthine), Vinpocetine, EHNA, Milrinone and Zapriast, which have been reported to reduce the ability of PDE and subsequently produce an increase of cellular cGMP, induce the production of autocrine TGF-beta1 as well as the synthesis of collagen in the KF. In this investigation, the inhibition of the PDE enzyme activity was observed to enhance the effect on the collagen synthesis, and was induced by exogenous NO. Taken together, these results have suggested that the NO/cGMP pathway could positively influence the progression of keloid formation, via the TGF-beta1 expression in the KF.

If I had the time to get to the bottom of the issue (if research has even determined what the etiology of nitroglycerin headaches is) I'd have to see what serotonin neurotransmitter did in this case, what CGRP did, and what NO did to the cell's energy cascade (cGMP is what the cell does with those calories to make energy for use).

Terms for further investigation in order to determine the effect the nitric oxide cascade might have that mediates a headache:

platelet serotonin concentration
higher plasma CGRP
NO-cGMP pathway

If you want to take it from here then?
 
*Note to Skepigirl - having a good discussion starts with understanding the post first before spinning off into space and jumping all over someone. Relax before attempting pontification. It can save you embarrassing moments later and potential forum meltdowns.

That said, you seem tense. Here's a helpful hint and very seasonal: Get a cup of eggnog and pour in a good dollop of Southern Comfort. Watch the chemical reaction. The mixture will roil a bit and the egg whites will separate from the yolk. Dash in a bit of nutmeg and drink the elixir down. Take a couple of more belts and read a few skeptic blogs. Repeat this experiment. Soon you'll be having one heck of a time...

:D

Southern Comfort? Yuck. Now THERE'S a recipe for a headache. ;)

I'll take Jim Beam in my nog over So-Co any time.
 
It would be nice if there was a simple translation to the following but I don't have one. My area of expertise is infectious disease and not the cellular level of ID either. However, I do understand in many of our physiological processes, there are typically chemical cascades that add or block catalysts, trigger absorption or release of neurotransmitters, add or block enzymes, open or block receptors and so on. In the case of nitroglycerin and related drugs, they are precursors which are turned into the active nitric oxide as part of the cascade.

While it's easy to think a headache is merely caused by dilated blood vessels or increased heart rate or other simple process, there are all sorts of other things going on such as histamine and prostaglandin release and other inflammatory processes which can actually be the mediator which triggers the perception of pain. And in many cases, there are other factors in the brain which can override or accentuate a pain impulse.

So with that in mind I tried to find articles related to the etiology of nitroglycerin headaches. But to really get to the specifics I'd need a lot more time. So here's a starting place:

Nitroglycerin-induced headaches

nitrolgycerin (NTG), which has been shown to induce migraine attacks in up to 80% of migraineurs.

Basically what it says is whatever causes migraines is triggered by nitroglycerin. And some people who had no history of migraine but still got a migraine like headache from NTG had risk factors for migraine.

It seems to be accepted that NTG triggers a migraine. If that is the case then it is curious if it is merely blood vessel dilation, why everyone doesn't get the same headache. But they don't.

Looking at a variety of additional information:

Sumatriptan causes parallel decrease in plasma calcitonin gene-related peptide (CGRP) concentration and migraine headache during nitroglycerin induced migraine attack.

All migraine subjects developed headache after GTN (NO precursor)

Investigations into the role of nitric oxide and the large intracranial arteries in migraine headache.

And if that isn't enough to show there isn't a simple explanation, here's an odd paper on another action of NO in scar formation:

nitric oxide (NO) plays an important role in the inflammation stage of wound healing.

If I had the time to get to the bottom of the issue (if research has even determined what the etiology of nitroglycerin headaches is) I'd have to see what serotonin neurotransmitter did in this case, what CGRP did, and what NO did to the cell's energy cascade (cGMP is what the cell does with those calories to make energy for use).

Terms for further investigation in order to determine the effect the nitric oxide cascade might have that mediates a headache:

platelet serotonin concentration
higher plasma CGRP
NO-cGMP pathway

If you want to take it from here then?

Wow. That's a lot of work to say that vasodilation may not be the only mechanism involved in NTG headache. I don't know if anyone here thought it could be the only mechanism, but if they did, I think that what you wrote should be sufficiently persuasive. :)

And it was good for you to elaborate on the point that was mentioned briefly earlier - that the mechanism for headache is not a single (or simple) process.

You didn't address why you think vasodilation from NTG is not the mechanism by which topical NTG leads to erection. Or is it similar to the headache issue - you want to make the point that it may not be the only mechanism?

Linda
 
By the way, thanks JJM and Dogdoctor for taking the time and interest to point out the scientific principles involved in analyzing a product such as this, and thanks, Gurdur, for your addition re the effects of topical medications.

*Note to self, it's much more important to pat forum members on the back and exchange niceties than to have a legitimate discussion about science.

So, it's a bad idea to mention that I've always appreciated a certain person's posts? I'm not just talking about this conversation, Linda's posts are really always quite educational. I suggest the homeopathic cough medicine thread.
 
:D

Southern Comfort? Yuck. Now THERE'S a recipe for a headache. ;)

I'll take Jim Beam in my nog over So-Co any time.
Step in the right direction, but not far enough.

One more step gets you to Maker's Mark.

Final step (at least in the US) gets you to Woodford Reserve.

Administer as already prescribed. Check vasodilation later.
 
Step in the right direction, but not far enough.

One more step gets you to Maker's Mark.

Final step (at least in the US) gets you to Woodford Reserve.

Administer as already prescribed. Check vasodilation later.

No way, Garrette! :yikes:

Those bourbons are TOO GOOD for nog. Just some ice, thank you.

You didn't mention my favorite, though. Knob Creek is so tasty.
 
Last post of derail, then I promise I'll go back to reading the relevant posts of better members than I.

I'm ashamed I don't know of Knob Creek, Katana, as I live less than an hour from the Jim Beam distillery and used to live closer.

But I'll admit that, from its reviews, I might not be man enough for it.

Are you a Kentucky-area person? If so, we may have to have the second annual Kentucky-area JREFite get together. The first one was just me and Spidey13, but Bluegill is around here, too.
 
As for being man enough, you are. If you enjoy good bourbon and appreciate the differences between good bourbons, you will like Knob Creek. I am amused, though, to hear what you read to make you think that (not to prolong this derail or anything).

Unfortunately, I live in Vermont (unfortunate for a variety of reasons). Otherwise, I would love to meet up with you all, especially if bourbon is involved. ;)

If you do try Knob Creek, let me know what you think. I never want to think that I steered you wrong.
 
:D

Southern Comfort? Yuck. Now THERE'S a recipe for a headache. ;)

I'll take Jim Beam in my nog over So-Co any time.


That's fine too! I just like SoCo of late. I have Jim Beam as well as Ancient Ancient Age.

Katana, are you familiar with that clear liquid that comes in Mason jars? :D
 
So, it's a bad idea to mention that I've always appreciated a certain person's posts?.....
Under normal circumstances, not at all. But considering the way this thread has progressed, it was pretty hard not to see it as a pointed statement.
 
....
You didn't address why you think vasodilation from NTG is not the mechanism by which topical NTG leads to erection. Or is it similar to the headache issue - you want to make the point that it may not be the only mechanism?

Linda
That was in a previous post:

Nitric oxide in the penis: physiology and pathology.

Nitric oxide is perceived to exert a host of functional roles by binding with specific molecular targets. Its synthesis and action in the penis are influenced by many different regulatory factors. CONCLUSIONS: Nitric oxide exerts a significant role in the physiology of the penis, operating chiefly as the principal mediator of erectile function. Alterations in the biology of nitric oxide likely account for various forms of erectile dysfunction. The diverse physiological roles of nitric oxide suggest that it may also directly contribute to or cause pathological consequences involving the penis.
If you read the whole abstract it may make more sense.

It really wasn't a lot of work, I just searched for "nitroglycerin headache etiology" on MedLine. The abstracts I linked to gave a pretty good picture of the point I was making to Gurdur, that is the body's physiology is very complex and one size doesn't fit all when it comes to drug responses.

Such exercises searching MedLine or other information sources are great for learning and/or reviewing information. As I said earlier, I didn't realize all the places nitric oxide had very specific roles. I knew NTG had an effect on erections. There are articles on Viagra that often mention NTG. But I hadn't read any of them lately. And not only does NTG cause headaches, it exerts lots of different actions in the brain as well as the cardiovascular system.
 
Under normal circumstances, not at all. But considering the way this thread has progressed, it was pretty hard not to see it as a pointed statement.


I think you should stop with the decoder ring. Clearly it is malfunctioning.
 
Under normal circumstances, not at all. But considering the way this thread has progressed, it was pretty hard not to see it as a pointed statement.


I think you should stop with the decoder ring. Clearly it is malfunctioning.
 
That was in a previous post:

Nitric oxide in the penis: physiology and pathology.

If you read the whole abstract it may make more sense.

The abstract doesn't really say anything specific. Did you mean the full text article? Because this article makes it clear that the mechanism of action is vasodilation. I can't even find any real support for a secondary claim of "it may not be the only mechanism."

It really wasn't a lot of work, I just searched for "nitroglycerin headache etiology" on MedLine. The abstracts I linked to gave a pretty good picture of the point I was making to Gurdur, that is the body's physiology is very complex and one size doesn't fit all when it comes to drug responses.

Oh. I thought you were addressing the question of whether the NTG headache is caused by vasodilation. Now I understand why the information you presented didn't really counteract that idea.

Such exercises searching MedLine or other information sources are great for learning and/or reviewing information.

As general advice, I'm not so sure I agree. They work great for someone that is searching within their area of expertise, but if someone is generally ignorant on the topic, it rarely seems to work out well. Examples - the information is not directly applicable to the topic, it's not representative or complete, it may have a technical meaning that is misunderstood as the general meaning, only the abstract is read which means that critical information is missed, etc. (just based on my observations over the years of discussions in forums like this).

I do always encourage people to look up the original source material for newspaper articles, though (in fact, I don't think the average science article should even be read, except to extract enough information to track down the references :)).

As I said earlier, I didn't realize all the places nitric oxide had very specific roles. I knew NTG had an effect on erections. There are articles on Viagra that often mention NTG. But I hadn't read any of them lately. And not only does NTG cause headaches, it exerts lots of different actions in the brain as well as the cardiovascular system.

I'm glad you learned something. I also find directed-learning stimulated by discussion (and argument :)) to be one of the most valuable ways to really understand a subject.

Linda
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom