Is there a doctor in the house?

Skeptigirl, I didn't disregard your post. In fact, I said "Thank you for the post that addresses the absorption possibilities."

I also thought that this was very specific about the information I was seeking:

"If there's a doctor out there, I'd love to hear if any of these ingredients can a) be absorbed via forehead and b) cure headaches."

I don't think the "whole" worked because it is marketed as a homeopathic treatment for headaches, and I don't believe homeopathy works. However, I do believe it's possible that the product is being marketed as homeopathic when it really isn't, hence the questions about the ingredients. Which is apparently difficult to answer, and so I should clarify what I meant with that as well - I am asking if any of the inactive ingredients have been known to cure headaches in the same way that aspirin cures headaches. For example, I have no idea what iodopropynyl butylcarbamate is, which is why I posted the question here. For all I know, it is a super top secret code word for "aspirin". I know that even aspirin will not work on every kind of headache, yet if someone asked me whether or not aspirin cured headaches, I would more than likely say "yes".

I'm sorry if the question was poorly phrased, I also tried to clarify it on numerous occasions.

Oh, and most of the people who seemed to be totally making fun of me with their posts were responding to something I said in the chat room, and were intentionally being funny (with me, not at me). So if it seems like this thread has taken a dramatic turn, it's probably because the entire context isn't located here.

Thanks again everyone for your help. Those magic elves rock my world.

~Remie
 
Let me start this off with "I am a skeptic." I really am. No joke.

I'm hoping that there is a pharmacist out there who can explain something to me.

The other night, I had a killer headache. I hadn't eaten anything in a while, so, thinking maybe that was the source of the trouble, I had some dinner. Half an hour later, the headache raged on. It was the perfect time to test the power of "Head-On," a homeopathic headache remedy that comes in a tube sort of like a gluestick.

You apply it directly to your forehead. Within seconds, so the ads say, your headache will be gone.

I didn't buy it. But I wanted to write an article on the product saying how it didn't work for the SAPS site. So I dragged myself to the pharmacy down the road and bought some.

I felt awful in the pharmacy. The lights were bright, I was nauseated. My head was killing me, and I wanted to slap the checkout person, who was taking too long. Everything smelled too strongly, and I wanted to bang my head against the walls.

I got back home, perhaps ten minutes later, and applied the gunk directly to my forehead. It burned strangely. I kind of laughed internally, already beginning to phrase the stinging article I'd write about the worthlessness of "Head-On". About thirty seconds after I applied the stuff, I realized my headache was gone.

I shook my head really hard to make sure. It was definitely gone.

So I read the ingredients list, and wrote to thirty pharmacology professors asking if any of the ingredients could possibly cure headaches. I didn't think about it being finals week, so of course no one wrote back.

If there's a doctor out there, I'd love to hear if any of these ingredients can a) be absorbed via forehead and b) cure headaches.

The "active" ingredients are in very very very small amounts, it being a homeopathic treatment. So, undoubtedly, none of them are responsible.

Just in case, they are kali bichromium (6X H.P.U.S.) and bryonia alba (12X H.P.U.S.)

The inactive ingredients, which can be any amount, are:

diazolidinyl urea, ethyl alcohol, iodopropynl butylcarbamate, menthol, menthyl lactate, propylene glycol, sodium stearate, steareth-21, tetrasodium EDTA, triethanolamine water


I am also perfectly willing to admit that eating might be what cured the headache, and the timing just happened to perfectly coincide. It really doesn't *seem* that way, but it's a possibility.

Anyway, how about those ingredients, my phd friends?



Thanks,


Remie

It was me. I sent you positive energy from Planet X.
 
Proportion-by-weight is a measure of concentration. But I know what you meant.
...
While true, concentration can be defined by all sorts of things in addition to weight. Where as weight is weight.

Wiki on concentration
In chemistry, concentration is the measure of how much of a given substance there is mixed with another substance....There are a number of different ways to quantitatively express concentration; the most common are listed below. They are based on mass or volume or both. Depending on what they are based on it is not always trivial to convert one measure to the other, because knowledge of the density might be needed to do so.

What can I say? I'm a science geek. :)
 
Well this was the post that seemed a little condescending.
Please, read my posts. I'm begging you here. For the ten billionth time, I'm not saying head-on works. I am asking a simple question about ingredients. Honestly, read the posts in their entirety without skimming, and you'll see what I mean.

But I see this is what I suggested and it is actually what you had written:
I am aware of how many variables one must take into account when looking at this. I was only asking about the possible efficacy of the ingredients that were listed as inactive.

So, now that that is cleared up, if you don't think Headon worked, why would you think any of the ingredients could have?
 
While true, concentration can be defined by all sorts of things in addition to weight. Where as weight is weight.

What can I say? I'm a science geek. :)
What weight do you use? There may be 1 ounce of alcohol in a 1.1 ounce dosage unit, and 1 pound of menthol in a 1,000 pound manufactured batch. Which goes first on the label? You are really considering proportion-by-weight.

I made topical, pharmaceutical products in the 1970s. And I have taught the idea of concentration in introductory chemistry classes in a few universities.
 
Last edited:
Oh, and most of the people who seemed to be totally making fun of me with their posts were responding to something I said in the chat room, and were intentionally being funny (with me, not at me).

I was being intentionally funny, and I wasn't even in the chat room! :)

PS: WHERE is the JREF chat room? I swear, I looked, I used SEARCH, yet I see no chat room.
 
Water drinking is not just a psychological thing. Dehydration can cause headaches (among other nasty effects).

And psychologically speaking, taking control of one's situation (even in expectation of a woo-ish - or not - outcome) can make a difference in perception of said situation.
 
The above is the question I answered.
"The product contains menthol which does have a physiolologic effect....Applying menthol to one's forehead does result in fairly rapid inhalation of the chemical compound. And, a few chemicals are absorbed via skin in small amounts. Drugs absorbed via the skin include nicotine, nitroglycerin, scopolamine, clonidine, and fentanyl. But sometimes small amounts can be effective.

Then there is DSMO which is a solvent that can carry drugs more efficiently through the skin. It is a common woo treatment and not anything I'd put in my body but it is efficient in passing through the skin barrier."


I understood what you were asking Remie, but you dismissed my answer because it contained additional information you weren't asking.

You claim to not believe Headon ended your headache yet want to know if it could have. Then you get annoyed at all the replies which offer alternative explanations for your headache ending at the time you applied Headon. If you don't believe the product worked, then why would you be inquiring if any of the ingredients could be effective?

You are guilty of the same thing you claim the people posting here are guilty of, not reading the actual posts. You read, "A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards. So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive." and drew incorrect assumptions about the meaning of my post.

snip...

Aren't you over-reacting just a bit?
 
What weight do you use? There may be 1 ounce of alcohol in a 1.1 ounce dosage unit, and 1 pound of menthol in a 1,000 pound manufactured batch. Which goes first on the label? You are really considering proportion-by-weight.

I made topical, pharmaceutical products in the 1970s. And I have taught the idea of concentration in introductory chemistry classes in a few universities.
It isn't how I interpret it, it's how the labeling law is worded.

To review:
Must I list the ingredients in a specified order?

Yes. You must list the ingredients in descending order of predominance by weight. This means that the ingredient that weighs the most is first and the ingredient that weighs the least is last.

21 CFR 101.4(a)

What is an "ingredient"?

The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act uses the term "ingredient" to refer to the compounds used in the manufacture of a dietary supplement. For instance, when calcium carbonate is used to provide calcium, calcium carbonate is an "ingredient" and calcium is a "dietary ingredient." The term "ingredient" also refers to substances such as binders, colors, excipients, fillers, flavors, and sweeteners.

Public Law 103-417, 60 Federal Register 67194 at 67199 (December 28, 1995)
So if it is a compound, the weight of the compound is used. If it is a base the compound is carried in, the base substance is listed as an ingredient by its weight without the compound.
 
Aren't you over-reacting just a bit?
It's possible.

But there seems to be a lot of mis-reading the tone of posts here. I certainly felt my first post was mis-read. After that, "Please, read my posts. I'm begging you here. For the ten billionth time, I'm not saying head-on works. I am asking a simple question about ingredients. Honestly, read the posts in their entirety without skimming, and you'll see what I mean" sounded a bit condescending.

Remie's reply indicated she didn't have a tone of condescension in that statement and I take her word for it.

But people are just replying to the original problem. Is it possible the product had an effect? While Remie only wanted to know if the ingredients affected headaches, the question itself implied she was considering Headon actually did affect her headache regardless of why.

I'm trying to point out, you can't have it both ways. You can't claim to not believe a product worked while inquiring if maybe it did work. So the comments on all the possible variables affecting the headache are responding to the hidden message in how the question was posed. Paraphrased: "I don't believe it worked but I wonder if it did". Asking that brings out the skeptics' reflex answers, listing other variables to be considered.

Yes, I do live in a world all my own. ;)
 
I am also perfectly willing to admit that eating might be what cured the headache, and the timing just happened to perfectly coincide. It really doesn't *seem* that way, but it's a possibility.

When trying to analyze any results in life...if you do two or more things at once, then you will never be quite certain as to which was responsible for the action. I have gone through this when replacing parts on cars. Recently a car repair shop replaced 3 things that may have been responsible for the car shutting down. I will never know now really WHICH of the 3 was the actual culprit.
 
It's possible.

But there seems to be a lot of mis-reading the tone of posts here. I certainly felt my first post was mis-read. After that, "Please, read my posts. I'm begging you here. For the ten billionth time, I'm not saying head-on works. I am asking a simple question about ingredients. Honestly, read the posts in their entirety without skimming, and you'll see what I mean" sounded a bit condescending.

Remie's reply indicated she didn't have a tone of condescension in that statement and I take her word for it.

But people are just replying to the original problem. Is it possible the product had an effect? While Remie only wanted to know if the ingredients affected headaches, the question itself implied she was considering Headon actually did affect her headache regardless of why.

I'm trying to point out, you can't have it both ways. You can't claim to not believe a product worked while inquiring if maybe it did work. So the comments on all the possible variables affecting the headache are responding to the hidden message in how the question was posed. Paraphrased: "I don't believe it worked but I wonder if it did". Asking that brings out the skeptics' reflex answers, listing other variables to be considered.

Yes, I do live in a world all my own. ;)

I understand why Remie was saying that, though. Many did not read her post completely, jumped to the conclusion she was making some statement for the product and immediately launched an offensive. In your post, I was envisioning microscopes tipped on their sides, glassware hurling about the room and hysterical screaming somewhere in a laboratory. ;)

I'm not really sure I see your point this time, though. Put Remie's question in another context: "A psychic just bent a spoon in front of me. I know there is no such thing as psychic spoon bending, so how was it accomplished?" Using the same basic question but with a different subject, posters would react more favourably and praise her questioning something dodgy.
 
This is a homeopathic reply. All pertinent information has been distilled out so that all that remains is filler material.

That isn't to say that the filler material does not contain anything that would otherwise be considered an active ingredient....

Chalk it up to leaving to go to the store and getting a change of environment. If you had waited another 30 seconds to apply the "Head On" you never would have asked the question!

jbs
 
This is a homeopathic reply. All pertinent information has been distilled out so that all that remains is filler material.

Oops, I distilled it too well, I meant to add that if no-one speaks up about the possible inactive ingredients, you can always try an internet search on them. If there are any medicinal uses they'll show up. Of course then you have to determine which are woo-woo sites...

jbs
 
.....there is a product similar to Tiger Balm for headaches.
I'd say the main ingredient in all these remedies is simply massaging one's forehead and temples.
I really don't think so. I use something similar to Tiger Balm, basically pure peppermint oil, and I only apply it to my forehead and temples, I don't massage them. The peppermint oil has the effect of increasing blood flow subcutaneously, and my guess is that it also increases blood flow in deeper vessels in the area, tackling the areas causing the headache (in my case, the sinuses). Its effect is fairly easily absorbed by skin.
 
I really don't think so. I use something similar to Tiger Balm, basically pure peppermint oil, and I only apply it to my forehead and temples, I don't massage them. The peppermint oil has the effect of increasing blood flow subcutaneously, and my guess is that it also increases blood flow in deeper vessels in the area, tackling the areas causing the headache (in my case, the sinuses). Its effect is fairly easily absorbed by skin.


What of cologne, then? Mind you, that remedy went out with rotary phones, but it was used for centuries among the upper classes. Was it the alcohol or the essential oils that increased bloodflow - or was it useless? Just curious in this case, as cologne was my grandmother's remedy for minor headaches.
 
Chalk it up to leaving to go to the store and getting a change of environment. If you had waited another 30 seconds to apply the "Head On" you never would have asked the question!
jbs
I see. No need for any further investigation. You have it all figured out. A true "skeptic."
 
I might've still asked the question, actually, because I prefer to back up what I'm writing about with information from knowledgable sources. I wrote to pharmacology professors and asked for a doctor's opinion here. Not because I think it did work, but because there is a possibility it did work.

Now, I'm aware, again, that many things cause headaches. But if I had said the first ingredient listed was caffeine, followed by morphine, would there still be a problem? I'd still be curious to know whether morphine could be sucked in through the forehead.

Point being, I do not know what the ingredients mean. They might mean "morphine" or "aspirin". If they did, then yes, I would say Head-On was responsible for curing the headache. If they do not, then I would continue to research the issue.

This is for an article on a product, not a clinical trial. I wanted to have as much information about what the ingredients were and what they are normally used for as possible. That's all.
 
What of cologne, then? Mind you, that remedy went out with rotary phones, but it was used for centuries among the upper classes. Was it the alcohol or the essential oils that increased bloodflow - or was it useless? Just curious in this case, as cologne was my grandmother's remedy for minor headaches.

I would guess the alcohol evaporating would cause a cooling effect (because, you know...that's what happens when alcohol evaporates.) You'd get the same effect with a cloth soaked in cool water.

Also, a quick google shows one of the main allergens in peppermint oil is menthol. So we come back to how that works.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom