Is there a doctor in the house?

That is a totally bogus product and you would have gotten over the headache without it. They like to do double blinded studies to try to eliminate all the reasons why it may appear that a product worked when it did not. The application of that product to your head should result in you being short a few dollars for no good and nothing more unless you have allergies to some of the ingredients. Water doesn't cure headaches either although dehydration may lead to headaches so drinking water should fix those headaches. Let me tell you a more confusing headache story. When I was a child I had about 3 headaches and each time my father gave me some aspirin. Each time within 30 minutes the headache was gone. Then I moved out of my parents house and had another headache. I had no aspirin so I went to the store and bought some which took about 30 minutes. At home I was about to take the aspirin when I realized the headache was gone. Now aspirin might be effective in treating headaches but it apparently had no effect on mine. Since then almost every headache I ever had (I rarely get them) was gone in 30 minutes without treatment. No time for the products to work.
 
Please, read my posts. I'm begging you here. For the ten billionth time, I'm not saying head-on works. I am asking a simple question about ingredients. Honestly, read the posts in their entirety without skimming, and you'll see what I mean.
 
Applying anything cold or damp to the forehead works for me when I have that type of headache.
 
Hi Remie!

I understand what you are asking. I can't offer expert advise but Head On is an old remedy brushed off and updated. In the past, Vicks Vapo Rub and Menthalatum was used to treat headaches. One simply rubbed a dab on the forehead and temples. In genteel times, ladies used cologne for the same purpose. Today, at Asian grocery stores, there is a product similar to Tiger Balm for headaches.

I'd say the main ingredient in all these remedies is simply massaging one's forehead and temples.
 
I understand what you are asking. I can't offer expert advise but Head On is an old remedy brushed off and updated. In the past, Vicks Vapo Rub and Menthalatum was used to treat headaches. One simply rubbed a dab on the forehead and temples. In genteel times, ladies used cologne for the same purpose. Today, at Asian grocery stores, there is a product similar to Tiger Balm for headaches.

I wonder if HeadOn would help with my strained hip flexor muscle, in the same manner as Bengay. If my hip didn't hurt so much, I would go to the store and buy some.
 
The order I wrote the ingredients in is indeed the order that they appear in.

I'm sorry. Now that I look at it again, it looks like I thought you got it wrong, and that's not what I meant. I was wondering if it was sloppiness or a mistake on the part of the manufacturers.

No, it didn't work because the stuff was massaged in - it wasn't. Not any more than one massages in lipstick.

My question doesn't have anything to do with where my mind is or the possible psychological effects or whether I drank any water. I promise.

I am aware of how many variables one must take into account when looking at this. I was only asking about the possible efficacy of the ingredients that were listed as inactive.

Thanks to the people who seemed to catch that.

-- Remie

I hope it was clear that I did catch that.

Linda
 
I'm sorry. Now that I look at it again, it looks like I thought you got it wrong, and that's not what I meant. I was wondering if it was sloppiness or a mistake on the part of the manufacturers.



I hope it was clear that I did catch that.

Linda

Yes, it was :D

You rock my little world.
 
Please, read my posts. I'm begging you here. For the ten billionth time, I'm not saying head-on works. I am asking a simple question about ingredients. Honestly, read the posts in their entirety without skimming, and you'll see what I mean.

What?? You think "Head On" works in some paranormal way??

:D :D :D
 
Yes, I think magic elves leap out of the container and inject morphine directly into your brain. Totally.
 
If there's a doctor out there, I'd love to hear if any of these ingredients can a) be absorbed via forehead and b) cure headaches.

Two points to make: First, pain comes and goes. Most pain is benign and disappears for one reson or another. That's why faith healers and homeopaths love treating it.

Second, there are many, many types of headaches. I mean, dozens. Wikipedia, not the world's best reference, lists ten specific types of headaches in five main classes. That doesn't include the headaches that are just a symptom of another ailment. I'll list just two types: vascular, caused by dilation of blood vessels in and around the brain (caffeine, Viagra and nitroglycerin can cause them); and muscular, as tense muscles cause pain near the brain.

Neadless to say, these are two very different types of disorder. An effective treatment for one - vasoconstrictors - will have no effect on the other.

Even if HeadOn were effective in some way by causing some physiological change to the user, it would still be ineffective for some headaches. It would require knowing what type of headache you had in order to begin to discuss what types of treatments might have worked. Only then could we examine whether HeadOn had any of the ingredients necessary to do the job.

My guess? Nope.
 
My question doesn't have anything to do with where my mind is or the possible psychological effects or whether I drank any water. I promise.

I am aware of how many variables one must take into account when looking at this. I was only asking about the possible efficacy of the ingredients that were listed as inactive.

Thanks to the people who seemed to catch that.

Oh, the abject shame. I am one of the people who failed to catch that.

I foolishly thought that since the question about known medical effects of the ingredients of Head-On had already been answered in the thread, as well as in three previous threads, you might actually be curious about possible explanations for the relief you experienced.

I'm such an idiot. I'll never be able to show my face in public again.

Thus I... I can hardly even say it, it was so wrong of me, it's hard to admit... I... I... okay, let me just blurt it out: I mentioned water!

How can mere words convey how sorry I am?

And just look at the consequences. This thread, this entire forum, the Internet, and two lives, yours and mine, all in ruins. And now I have to live with that fact for the rest of my life! Even though I can't really say that I deserve to live, at this point.

I'll never do it again.

I hope you can find it in your heart to forgive me someday, even though I don't deserve it.

Remorsefully,
Myriad
 
GMAFB . . .<eyeroll>

I'm inclined to go with the counterirritant theory. The menthol will give an immediate cooling sensation, which could have an effect on the perception of headache; in concert with the irritation from the urea, it might introduce enough nervous-system "noise" to mask the ongoing headache pain. The magic elves theory is intriguing, though.
 
... the order of ingredients on the listing is very important (the standard is listing from highest to lowest concentration). ....
It isn't concentration, it's weight. But I understand what you meant.

Must I list the ingredients in a specified order?
Yes. You must list the ingredients in descending order of predominance by weight. This means that the ingredient that weighs the most is first and the ingredient that weighs the least is last.

21 CFR 101.4(a)
A particular compound can have more weight but the active component might be relatively weak compared to another ingredient.
 
I realize the listing of ingredients is from highest to lowest. I think you are suggesting that the alcohol/fatty acid combination accounts for the "stick", so the diazolidinyl urea must form a large portion of the ingredients (if present)?

I was thinking that they may not include "paraffin" in the ingredient list in something like that, and that the ingredients on the list could all be in small to very small concentration. Maybe the "wax" from the stearate/alcohol helps soften the main base?

If that's not the case, then it does sound like that list can't be accurate.

Linda

-

Same source as above post:
What is an "ingredient"?

The Dietary Supplement Health and Education Act uses the term "ingredient" to refer to the compounds used in the manufacture of a dietary supplement. For instance, when calcium carbonate is used to provide calcium, calcium carbonate is an "ingredient" and calcium is a "dietary ingredient." The term "ingredient" also refers to substances such as binders, colors, excipients, fillers, flavors, and sweeteners.

Public Law 103-417, 60 Federal Register 67194 at 67199 (December 28, 1995)
 
wrote to thirty pharmacology professors asking if any of the ingredients could possibly cure headaches. I didn't think about it being finals week, so of course no one wrote back.

If there's a doctor out there, I'd love to hear if any of these ingredients can a) be absorbed via forehead and b) cure headaches.
The above is the question I answered.
"The product contains menthol which does have a physiolologic effect....Applying menthol to one's forehead does result in fairly rapid inhalation of the chemical compound. And, a few chemicals are absorbed via skin in small amounts. Drugs absorbed via the skin include nicotine, nitroglycerin, scopolamine, clonidine, and fentanyl. But sometimes small amounts can be effective.

Then there is DSMO which is a solvent that can carry drugs more efficiently through the skin. It is a common woo treatment and not anything I'd put in my body but it is efficient in passing through the skin barrier."


I understood what you were asking Remie, but you dismissed my answer because it contained additional information you weren't asking.

You claim to not believe Headon ended your headache yet want to know if it could have. Then you get annoyed at all the replies which offer alternative explanations for your headache ending at the time you applied Headon. If you don't believe the product worked, then why would you be inquiring if any of the ingredients could be effective?

You are guilty of the same thing you claim the people posting here are guilty of, not reading the actual posts. You read, "A sample size of one doesn't meet my standards. So your report, while interesting, is not persuasive." and drew incorrect assumptions about the meaning of my post.

If you run a skeptic site, then I assume you understand skepticism isn't just discounting woo products and claims. It is understanding how one goes about determining what is woo and what isn't. I find skeptics understand evidence and false logic, but I can sometimes add additional observations which either aren't articulated so aren't noticed, or involve the bigger picture.

For example, one hears anecdotal evidence is unreliable. Skeptics repeat this often. But it really isn't that anecdotal evidence is unreliable. We use anecdotal evidence in most retrospective studies involving asking someone to describe any past event such as degree of pain relief. The reason skeptics including you discount an anecdote such as yours with Headon is because one report without controls is unreliable. You knew it was unreliable. I was just articulating why it was unreliable.

An example of the bigger picture is to look at the reason people are offering alternative explanations for your headache ending, and the reason I included the assessment it was a sample size of one. It is because you haven't presented any evidence Headon works. I understand you didn't present this evidence because you don't believe it exists. However that leads to the simple observation, if you don't think the 'whole' worked, why are you asking if the 'parts' could have?

In order for any ingredient in Head On to actually work for a headache, whether it is a coincidental ingredient such as the parafin, or a specific ingredient such as you listed in your question, you start by seeing if the product works. If it does, then you can proceed with your inquiry. But unless there is evidence the product actually works, then how would you expect any of the ingredients to have an effect?


Instead of describing your frustration the answers are not addressing what you were asking, then blaming the repliers, you could have merely noted the answers you already knew to consider. For example you could have said, "I already know coincidental factors that could have ended my headache, I'm only looking for pharmacological factors involving the ingredients". Afterall, it could just as easily be the way you worded your question as the way the responders read it.
 
Last edited:
It isn't concentration, it's weight. But I understand what you meant. ...
Proportion-by-weight is a measure of concentration. But I know what you meant.

Since nobody here knows the menthol concentration (or any other, save the homeopathic ingredients), speculation is useless.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom