Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

I'd like to introduce thunderf00t. No doubt many people here know of him and have seen some of his videos, perhaps selections from his "Why Do People Laugh at Creationists?" series of 29 videos. He has done a set of four videos as this flu crisis has evolved and his viewpoint, I think, is very good. As for credentials, he is a biochemist, I believe, living in the UK.

Remember, these were produced as the news came in about the epidemic, so some of the points in the earlier videos have been overridden by events. If you haven't the patience to watch all four, then watch the latest one at the bottom.

April 28:

May 1:

May 3:

May 5:
 
Reminds me of something I once read right here on the forums, though I can't remember by whom: During a gastroenteritis epidemic, it is important for the doctor to rule out appendicitis in every case he sees because, if he sees enough cases, one of them will eventually turn out to have appendicitis.
Public health infrastructure is often pushed to the limits at the peak of a seasonal flu epidemic. At the peak of a pandemic, it's not realistic to expect that most of the affected people will be able to get anywhere near a doctor. The FDA acknowledges this in the Emergency Use Authorization it issued on April 27. See footnote #4:

"It is possible that public health officials or other volunteers might distribute authorized oseltamivir phosphate products to recipients, if permitted, in accordance with applicable state and local law and/or in accordance with the public health and medical emergency response of the Authority Having Jurisdiction to prescribe, administer, deliver, distribute, or dispense the covered countermeasures, and their officials, agents, employees, contractors, or volunteers following a declaration of an emergency. For ease of reference, this letter will use the term "health care provider(s)" to refer collectively to these individuals."
 
Reminds me of something I once read right here on the forums, though I can't remember by whom: During a gastroenteritis epidemic, it is important for the doctor to rule out appendicitis in every case he sees because, if he sees enough cases, one of them will eventually turn out to have appendicitis.

Ivor would send that patient home to die of peritonitis.

BillyJoe
Or bacterial meningitis. ;)
 
Public health infrastructure is often pushed to the limits at the peak of a seasonal flu epidemic. At the peak of a pandemic, it's not realistic to expect that most of the affected people will be able to get anywhere near a doctor. The FDA acknowledges this in the Emergency Use Authorization it issued on April 27. See footnote #4:

"It is possible that public health officials or other volunteers might distribute authorized oseltamivir phosphate products to recipients, if permitted, in accordance with applicable state and local law and/or in accordance with the public health and medical emergency response of the Authority Having Jurisdiction to prescribe, administer, deliver, distribute, or dispense the covered countermeasures, and their officials, agents, employees, contractors, or volunteers following a declaration of an emergency. For ease of reference, this letter will use the term "health care provider(s)" to refer collectively to these individuals."
Again you are unaware of the aspects of this you are unaware of.

I write standing orders for vaccinations so that nurses can give the injections. Pharmacists have prescriptive authority so they can give vaccines and refill some prescriptions. Both of these professions and including public health nurses have licenses to practice. While not qualified to make medical diagnoses and prescribe drugs, they are licensed to make skilled assessments of patients.

Any standing order for Tamiflu would have specific limited criteria for who gets it, who gets referred to be seen first, and what instructions to give to patients regarding reasons to return. There would likely be some restrictions like all kids under age 3, anyone with a rash, anyone with underlying medical conditions, or anyone pregnant would need to be seen. Standing orders for dispensing Tamiflu might only be to people exposed but not yet ill.

Those "public health officials or other volunteers" would need to have some basic skills to recognize red flags. And the volunteers would have back up if they were not sure about something they observed. And above all that, the provider who writes the standing orders would be responsible for those orders. That means they would assess the situation and ascertain that the standing order procedure was appropriate for the circumstances. The prescriber might even develop a training protocol for volunteers that were recruited because of the emergency.
 
I'd like to introduce thunderf00t. No doubt many people here know of him and have seen some of his videos, perhaps selections from his "Why Do People Laugh at Creationists?" series of 29 videos. He has done a set of four videos as this flu crisis has evolved and his viewpoint, I think, is very good. As for credentials, he is a biochemist, I believe, living in the UK.

Remember, these were produced as the news came in about the epidemic, so some of the points in the earlier videos have been overridden by events. If you haven't the patience to watch all four, then watch the latest one at the bottom.


I only watched the last one. It was good, but for the short attention span, a bit long. But he makes a valid argument.
 
I might have missed it but thunderfoot seems not to have mentioned the infectivity factor. In fact, one of his diagrams which depicts the spread of a new virus assumes everyone who comes into contact with the virus will become infected - presumably because they have no immunity against it. However, even if the immunity levels are zero, if the infectivity of the virus is low enough (<1), it will not get a foot hold.

BillyJoe
 
If you get it just rub on some oinkment or you will come out in rashers. Take that for grunted. The outbreak has generated a lot of of spam though. I'll stop now. Junior school mode off.
 
Oh yeah, I forgot about that one. :cool:
I know you guys probably miss me, but I've decided to put myself in the penalty box for a while, in the hope that it may help improve the quality of the discourse in this thread and return the focus to where it belongs.
 
I'd like to introduce thunderf00t. No doubt many people here know of him and have seen some of his videos, perhaps selections from his "Why Do People Laugh at Creationists?" series of 29 videos. He has done a set of four videos as this flu crisis has evolved and his viewpoint, I think, is very good. As for credentials, he is a biochemist, I believe, living in the UK.

Remember, these were produced as the news came in about the epidemic, so some of the points in the earlier videos have been overridden by events. If you haven't the patience to watch all four, then watch the latest one at the bottom.

April 28:

May 1:

May 3:

May 5:

Wow. Thank you for posting those. They sure answered my questions on "what is the big dea?l".
 
Originally Posted by macdoc
Round two anticipated.....
http://www.newscientist.com/article/...cond-wave.html

I'd call that speculation more than anticipation. While we have seen herald waves with severe epidemics, we don't know how many herald waves went unnoticed because they did not turn into severe pandemics.
I think its a given that this mild form is not contained at all is far wider spread than tracking is indicting as it's mild.
Canada's cases are growing and it's loose all over the world.

That it's mild makes it very difficult to track and contain. There is simply no way to know what a second wave might look like as in my view there is no way to know just how wide spread it is and it's not severe enough to initiate containment or even do heavy duty tracking.

A mild pandemic could actually be a good thing and we might not know it has occurred until it shows up as a wide spread influence in the next one that is severe enough in mortality and serious sickness to do the tracking and tests required.

Few other than "at risk" are going to risk a hospital or even a doctor for a mild flu.

http://www.theglobeandmail.com/servlet/story/RTGAM.20090507.wflumain0507/BNStory/International/home

Staff at the hospital I was at today were busy practicing with the face shields and more advanced masks and how to remove gowns and masks to avoid migration of contamination.....girls wash your hands THEN fluff your hair....made me laugh.

Trainer had clearly seen THAT before...

I think WHO is on track - widespread and mild and be prepared to deal with a nastier version that might arise.
From the article above
Keiji Fukuda, acting assistant director-general for the World Health Organization (WHO), also said it was “quite likely” the WHO would declare a pandemic in the near future but a final decision had not been made.
 
I might have missed it but thunderfoot seems not to have mentioned the infectivity factor. ....

BillyJoe
Well here's something to add to the infectivity factor, human nature.

I was at the Goodwill a few hours ago. This is a store obviously no one is at buying much in the way of essentials. IE they didn't need to be there. There was a crying kid who clearly looked ill. A woman with a frequent hoarse cough was in the toy isle for quite a while. She told me she was a school teacher and she "didn't have the flu". And, there were two adults with a child, all three coughing. The man used his arm to cough into while the young child and the woman didn't cover their coughs. When the woman noticed I was looking, she put her hand over the kid's cough. Eeeeewww!

Then one of the employees at the hospital I am advising returned to work after caring for her child with a fever, cough and a headache. The clinic flu screen on the child was negative so they told her the kid didn't have the flu. But the rate of false negatives on some of those rapid tests are quite high.

A friend at another place I was giving vaccinations at told me her daughter who is going to Stanford said none of the sick kids are staying out of class. She believes the policy is, if they have the flu they are supposed to leave the dorm and classes and go home for a week. Some of these kids live out of the state or out of the country. No student wants anyone to know they are ill because of this absurd policy.

Health care workers, I learn from my employee health nurse network are asking for worker's comp but because the infection is being acquired off the job, they do not qualify. Yet they are required to stay home for a week if ill and use their own sick time. So many of them are also are not reporting flu symptoms because they cannot afford the time off work.

Stay home if you are ill is a bit too inconvenient for many people and regardless of the risk, lots of people simply don't care.
 
Last edited:
Stay home if you are ill is a bit too inconvenient for many people and regardless of the risk, lots of people simply don't care.

The worst thing is, they do nobody any favours by doing so.

Ignorance is strength.

There was a survey done around the same time, that I can't find now, which showed that a majority of people work when sick instead of staying home.
 
I think its a given that this mild form is not contained at all is far wider spread than tracking is indicting as it's mild.
Canada's cases are growing and it's loose all over the world.

That it's mild makes it very difficult to track and contain. There is simply no way to know what a second wave might look like as in my view there is no way to know just how wide spread it is and it's not severe enough to initiate containment or even do heavy duty tracking.


And yet this is the current situation where I am.

HPS report on influenza A (H1N1) for 7th May

Four confirmed cases. That is the honeymoon couple who came back from Mexico and went back to work before falling ill, plus one (1) person they were in contact with. And one other unrelated traveller who returned from Texas.

Zero probable cases at the moment.

12 possible cases under investigation.

How come we're not seeing anything more? Is it because we've got stacks of Tamiflu all ready to roll out and as soon as a probable case is detected everyone in contact gets 5 days Tamiflu as routine?

Rolfe.
 
Because people are not going into the hospital to report a mild flu for a whole bunch of reasons.
It's allergy season, they don't think it's the flu at all, they don't want to be off work or school yada yada yada.
Many people have stocked Tamiflu - will you truck off to the doc or pop a pill??

Of course there is this too :boggled:

How about having a swine flu party?
The buzz is: Get a mild strain now, be safe later

May 08, 2009 04:30 AM Donald McNeil

The New York Times
Deliberately get swine flu?
What at first appears an absurdity – seeking out infection with swine flu instead of avoiding it – is being actively debated on flu websites and by some flu experts.
Infectious-disease specialists say they understand the logic: Surviving the current, apparently mild strain of the virus may be protective if a more virulent strain emerges next fall. But they are generally against it.
Dr. Anne Moscona, a flu specialist at Weill Medical College of Cornell University, says she was called by a reporter for a women's magazine "asking if mothers should hold swine flu parties, like chickenpox parties.''
http://www.thestar.com/article/630877

It's way early yet.

Because Canada is working directly with Mexico in identifying cases and due to the SARS situation which hit us very hard, there may be a higher awareness here. Also there is no cost here to see a doctor so reporting may be higher than in a co-pay or pay area especially for poor patients.

We have swine flu in all but two provinces
http://www.phac-aspc.gc.ca/alert-alerte/swine-porcine/surveillance-eng.php

oops that's down to one province free and the territories...

New swine flu cases bring Canada's total to 213 Fri, May 08, 2009

>OTTAWA, Canada - The first cases of swine flu in Canada's western plains were reported Thursday, bringing the total number of people infected with the virus to 213 nationwide.

Saskatchewan province, with its vast prairies, identified two cases of the A(H1N1) virus, said health authorities.

Three new cases in neighbouring Alberta province and seven new cases in Ontario were also confirmed.

The island province of Newfoundland in the North Atlantic Ocean remains the only region of the country not affected. -AFP
Ontario reports seven new H1N1 cases
May 7, 2009
Ontario confirmed seven new cases of the swine flu today, bringing the total number of cases in the province to 56.

Flu virus baffles Canadian scientists
Joanna Smith May 7, 2009
Canadian scientists discovered nothing in the genetic makeup of the H1N1 virus that would explain why symptoms are far more severe in Mexico than in all but one of the 201 confirmed cases here.
Given it's mild nature outside Mexico ( there is one unconfirmed death in Alberta ) there is simply no way of knowing how wide spread it is...period.

It's in the general population and very likely to stay there.

Pretty much confirmed....you have it in 41 states now

http://www.cdc.gov/h1n1flu/
 
Last edited:
Because people are not going into the hospital to report a mild flu for a whole bunch of reasons.
It's allergy season, they don't think it's the flu at all, they don't want to be off work or school yada yada yada.
Many people have stocked Tamiflu - will you truck off to the doc or pop a pill??


Was that an answer to my question in the previous post? Because I don't think that's the case at all.

HPS definitely seems to have a handle on this. They are testing a lot of people and getting very very few positives (four to be exact). People here don't go to a hospital with mild flu, but they do consult their GP - probably more so at the moment with all the media coverage. Remember, it's free. As is any treatment that might be needed (OK, a £5 prescription tax unless you're in an exemption group).

HPS have been tracing and testing contacts of all the confirmed cases. So far, one single case acquired from contact with a known case (same five-a-side football team) - who actually said he was pretty sick. No probables at present. So no, I don't think we have widespread flu and HPS just doesn't know about it.

And no, virtually nobody "stocked" Tamiflu. It was never available OTC, though I believe some people with prescription rights stashed some away when the H5N1 scare was at its height, and some probably bought it (possibly fake) from the internet. But that's only a few people, relatively speaking. (And even back in 2005 when some people on TV were talking about doing this, I wondered about expiry dates - I bet there are people with useless expired packs of Tamiflu right now.)

We're less than 30 miles from Polmont, where the honeymoon couple live who had the flu. Nobody is off sick, nobody I know is ill, the grapevine is resolutely silent concerning any respiratory disease in the community. Four cases in the entire country of 5 million people appears to be it.

Why?

Rolfe.
 
Last edited:
We are even closer to Polmont, and though I know quite a few sick people at the moment, that seems to be down to chickenpox and a stomach virus going around.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom