Is the swine flu going to be pandemic?

It seems to me that the cat is out of the bag and this will go phase 6 in the not so distant future.
[qimg]http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/3/30/Influenza-2009-cases.png[/qimg]

Wouldn't it be more meaningful for this graph to be logarithmic?

Maybe I'm having a dumb day or something... but I don't understand this graph.

How come there are 2 different sets of y axis numbers?
How are there deaths when the flu numbers seem to be at 0?
Are 1 in 50 people who get H1N1 really dying??
 
Maybe I'm having a dumb day or something... but I don't understand this graph.


:D

How come there are 2 different sets of y axis numbers?


The numbers to the right apply to the total number of deaths.
For example, on 8th May, there were a total of 42 deaths.

The number at the left apply to all the other graphs.
For example, on 8th May, there were 2500 confirmed cases worldwide, just over 1200 in Mexico, and about 900 in USA.

How are there deaths when the flu numbers seem to be at 0?


This is an artifact of the different scales on the two Y axes.
Reading off the right side Y axis, the number of deaths on 24th April is 3, and reading off the left Y axis, the number of confirmed cases is about...hmmm...hard to tell...but certainly either equal to or in excess of 3.

Are 1 in 50 people who get H1N1 really dying??


On 8th May, there were 42 deaths (right side Y axis), and 2700 confirmed cases world wide (left side Y axis), which is about 1 in 60. But we are talking confirmed cases here and the disease tends to be confirmed (ie blood test done) preferentially in people who are very unwell and hence more likely to die.

regards,
BillyJoe
 
Last edited:
As for the impression this swine flu is mild, the news media contributes to the stereotype. I am guessing the reporters are reporting their own confirmation bias. 36,000 average annual deaths in the US alone is not a mild disease by any standard.

US confirms 2,254 swine flu cases, 104 hospitalizations
Most of the hospitalized patients, Schuchat said, also had other health problems.
So what does "most" mean, and just what kind of health problems are we talking about?

From ProMed report on the Mexican demographics of the fatalities:
Predisposing illnesses/conditions among fatalities included:
Neoplasia: 2.2 percent
Autoimmune disorders: 2.2 percent
Smoking: 8.9 percent
Cardiovascular disease: 11.1 percent
Metabolic diseases (diabetes and obesity): 24.4 percent
I wonder what the reporters would think if they knew an underlying health condition might just be the person was a smoker or that they were obese?
 
It shows exactly how big a threat H5 is and this current round is a potential combinant - THAT's why it's relevant and that's why it's far from over.
I understand that, and the concerns some of us have had about H5N1, for a number of years now, are hardly diminished by the emergence of this virus. But the possibilities for reassortment with H5N1 are pretty uncertain. That virus has been around for long enough that there must surely have been plenty of opportunities for it to reassort with other strains already, and while a global pandemic would increase those opportunites several fold, it remains largely a theoretical concern at this point. (The importance of the subtype distinction rears its head again when we consider the implications of a reassortment event between two viruses of different subtypes; unless one accepts recombination as a significant driving force in viral evolution, the hemagglutinin gene would have to come from one or the other, but exactly where the factors most significant in determining either virulence or pathogenicity are located on the viral genome is not known with certainty).

The possibilities that this virus may aquire antiviral resistance, either through reassortment or de novo, are also a concern, though also theoretical. If this one comes back twice as mean in the fall, and picks up resistance to oseltemivir (it's already resistant to amantadines), and if the vax flops (or if the decision is made not to attempt widespread production of a vaccine at all), then we could end up facing it essentially empty-handed. That would be scary bad.

But I always like to rembember something Winston Churchill once said: "My life has been punctuated by a long series of tragedies -- most of which never actually happened".

This virus -- in its present form -- already represents enough of a threat to deserve attention. The press is going to do with it what they will, but it's important that it receive just the right amount of attention from the epidemiological community. If they overplay it, the loss of credibility with the public could end up costing a great many lives later on. Because sooner or later, we will encounter a truly deadly strain of influenza. Is this one it? Not yet anyway. Still, even if none of the above comes to pass, the potential for, say, five times the usual number of deaths due to complications from influenza is... er... nothing to sneeze at. (Sorry).
 
I understand that, and the concerns some of us have had about H5N1, for a number of years now, are hardly diminished by the emergence of this virus. But the possibilities for reassortment with H5N1 are pretty uncertain. That virus has been around for long enough that there must surely have been plenty of opportunities for it to reassort with other strains already, and while a global pandemic would increase those opportunites several fold, it remains largely a theoretical concern at this point. (The importance of the subtype distinction rears its head again when we consider the implications of a reassortment event between two viruses of different subtypes; unless one accepts recombination as a significant driving force in viral evolution, the hemagglutinin gene would have to come from one or the other, but exactly where the factors most significant in determining either virulence or pathogenicity are located on the viral genome is not known with certainty).

The possibilities that this virus may aquire antiviral resistance, either through reassortment or de novo, are also a concern, though also theoretical. If this one comes back twice as mean in the fall, and picks up resistance to oseltemivir (it's already resistant to amantadines), and if the vax flops (or if the decision is made not to attempt widespread production of a vaccine at all), then we could end up facing it essentially empty-handed. That would be scary bad.

But I always like to rembember something Winston Churchill once said: "My life has been punctuated by a long series of tragedies -- most of which never actually happened".

This virus -- in its present form -- already represents enough of a threat to deserve attention. The press is going to do with it what they will, but it's important that it receive just the right amount of attention from the epidemiological community. If they overplay it, the loss of credibility with the public could end up costing a great many lives later on. Because sooner or later, we will encounter a truly deadly strain of influenza. Is this one it? Not yet anyway. Still, even if none of the above comes to pass, the potential for, say, five times the usual number of deaths due to complications from influenza is... er... nothing to sneeze at. (Sorry).
Resistance to anything we are currently using to treat this new virus is an eventual certainty. That is the nature of evolution and rapidly multiplying organisms. In the future, genetic research will possibly give us drugs which resistance does not develop against, but we are not there yet.

OTOH, there is no reason to think a vaccine will not work and one will be developed by next winter. I see nothing that is going to result in a decision not to go ahead with a vaccine. We're past that point where a vaccine production decision is unlikely regardless if the decision to produce the vaccine has been officially made or not.

For the southern hemisphere there are some logistical problems, but not for the northern hemisphere where our seasonal vaccine production is almost completed. Our manufacturing capacity is soon to be freed up. In the southern planet, not so much. They will have to choose where to focus their resources.


As for the theoretical risk of a reassorted H5N1+H1N1 virus, anytime you have amplification of a virus (such as you get with a pandemic) just by probability, the odds increase because there are increased chances for the two viruses to jointly infect a single host. If this were an avian virus or if the H5 was more common in swine, the risks would be even greater. But H5N1 has been found in swine and this new strain of H1N1 has taken off like a wildfire does. It does increase the risk of reassortment though obviously it doesn't make it inevitable. And we can only vaguely estimate just how much increased risk we are talking about here.

When the new swine strain spreads across Asia, we may be able to make a better estimate. That's when we'll see just how many backyard pigs get infected.
 
Last edited:
A tale of two news stories:

This one is absurd: Swine flu threat fades - for now. Yes, we don't have a 1918 level threat on our hands. But calling off the hazard when the virus has just barely begun its spread is ignorant. I am, however, not surprised the news media doesn't get that little fact yet.

This one, Washington man with swine flu dies hints at the problem we are going to see in the coming weeks. As evidenced in the Mexico deaths, and in the first 3 deaths in the US, there are more young people in the death demographic than we'd expect to see with seasonal flu. The woman in Texas was 33 and this man from WA was in his mid 30s. She was pregnant and had some kind of respiratory problem, he had some kind of heart condition. But we really don't know how serious these health conditions were. The reports do say the latest death was from viral and not secondary bacterial pneumonia. Also, he didn't die in a hospital.

These are not what one expects to see with the first 3 deaths from seasonal flu, but they do match the pattern seen in Mexico.
 
Costa Rica: first death was a man, 53, with history of asthma and diabetes.

Canada: first death was a woman, again in her 30s.

POSSIBLE OBESITY, DIABETES LINK

In Mexico, where diabetes is the nation's leading cause of death, officials said 24 percent of the dead were obese.

Diabetes was associated with many of the victims, as were cardiovascular problems such as angina and high blood pressure, Health Minister Jose Angel Cordova told a news conference.

These conditions can raise the risk of complications and death from seasonal influenza, which kills 250,000 to 500,000 people every year globally and 36,000 in the United States alone.

It's worth noting, the risk factors include smoking, diabetes, and obesity. Just because the news keeps pointing out these deaths as in people with underlying conditions, we really don't know just how bad the conditions were. How many people are going to have the risk factors of diabetes, smoking and obesity just due to the numbers of people with these conditions? It's not certain these are people with really bad lungs or a really bad heart which is the impression one gets from the news reports.
 
And the real concern is the teens to 30s cadre deaths.

That said - this wave is not the killer.......

•••

Skeptigirl wrote

And we can only vaguely estimate just how much increased risk we are talking about here.

When the new swine strain spreads across Asia, we may be able to make a better estimate. That's when we'll see just how many backyard pigs get infected.

exactly.....we have a killer without a vector in H5, an easy spread mild form in the current proto-pandemic....and a mixing pot in SE Asia.

Not a wonderful scenario.....unless the mild form conveys some protection.....THEN it could be a boon......:boggled:

Being very watchful especially in SE Asia is extremely worthwhile.

The National Geo programs also point out the poor allocation of resources versus actual threats to citizens.

Billions spent on weapons systems that are likely never ever to be used but poor preparation and lack of resources for what is only a case of WHEN not IF.
 
Last edited:
If this were an avian virus or if the H5 was more common in swine, the risks would be even greater. But H5N1 has (not) been found in swine and this new strain of H1N1 has taken off like a wildfire does. It does increase the risk of reassortment though obviously it doesn't make it inevitable. And we can only vaguely estimate just how much increased risk we are talking about here.

When the new swine strain spreads across Asia, we may be able to make a better estimate. That's when we'll see just how many backyard pigs get infected.
All pandemic strains are A type influenza viruses which are of avian origin. There has to be a bird involved somewhere, and the second host is the mixing pot. Should there be a "not" in there where I emboldened it?
 
A tale of two news stories:

This one is absurd: Swine flu threat fades - for now. Yes, we don't have a 1918 level threat on our hands. But calling off the hazard when the virus has just barely begun its spread is ignorant. I am, however, not surprised the news media doesn't get that little fact yet.

This one, Washington man with swine flu dies hints at the problem we are going to see in the coming weeks. As evidenced in the Mexico deaths, and in the first 3 deaths in the US, there are more young people in the death demographic than we'd expect to see with seasonal flu. The woman in Texas was 33 and this man from WA was in his mid 30s. She was pregnant and had some kind of respiratory problem, he had some kind of heart condition. But we really don't know how serious these health conditions were. The reports do say the latest death was from viral and not secondary bacterial pneumonia. Also, he didn't die in a hospital.

These are not what one expects to see with the first 3 deaths from seasonal flu, but they do match the pattern seen in Mexico.

I really don't get it. Flu cases are absolutely sky rocketing at this point and although this flu is far less deadly than the 1918 flu, it is also much worse than seasonal flu and the story is quickly fading the media spotlight. As far as I can tell, this flu is the real thing. I anticipate WHO will go phase 6 next week and eventually, millions will be infected and thousands will die. I hope I'm very wrong. The SFgate article is absurd with the notion that the threat is fading.
 
I still contend we are all far more likely to die from the next time we get into a car than from a flu pandemic. Unless you live in Mexico or frequent hospitals, I wouldn't lose any sleep over this one.
 
I really don't get it. Flu cases are absolutely sky rocketing at this point and although this flu is far less deadly than the 1918 flu, it is also much worse than seasonal flu and the story is quickly fading the media spotlight. As far as I can tell, this flu is the real thing. I anticipate WHO will go phase 6 next week and eventually, millions will be infected and thousands will die. I hope I'm very wrong. The SFgate article is absurd with the notion that the threat is fading.

Sorry that these things just don't seem to be able to hold the public eye.

Journalism, like the human senses, is sensitive to change, not to long-existing levels of threat. When you walk into a house where there is a smell of roses, say, after five minutes in the house you loose the scent, though the chemicals in the air haven't gone away; your sense organs just filter them out as irrelevant, since you have been apprised of their existence. Similarly, a news story is news when it changes in some way; reporting the same high alert as yesterday becomes increasingly ignored. Reporters know this well, and always endeavor to seek out new angles, but ultimately, news will fade, as the swine flu story is fading, regardless of the fact that the treat is not, and even regardless of whether the existance of the threat is effectively debunked or not.

That is why we pay people like the CDC to keep an eye on things and to warn us when something isn't going as "planned", or as they were pre-supposed to. They forcible overcome their own human tendency to ignore the commonplace by establishing and following a routine which forces recognition of the state of things, rather than the change in things. Humans do indeed have short attention spans - at least in our western civilization, that is true of people in their leisure, about things they choose not to make key in heir lives. Generally, while focused on a task at which they have trained themselves to (ie, while "at work"), humans can get truly tenacious in the long term. That's the kind of occurrence that got us to the moon, and to heart transplants, and Corelle plates to eat off of.
 
Last edited:
Oh well...

I still contend we are all far more likely to die from the next time we get into a car than from a flu pandemic. Unless you live in Mexico or frequent hospitals, I wouldn't lose any sleep over this one.


Maybe we should just ignore the fly-by shooters.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom