I have to admit, I'm not quite sure if the WHO presently has a very strict definition for "community level outbreak". Another chance to play "quiz the expert" then. Five percent or more of a population affected?
They seem to be ignoring a couple European 'outbreaks' at the moment. I doubt that will work for long.
I suppose it depends a lot on what you're looking for in an "effective" mitigation strategy. Stop the virus in its tracks? No. Slow the spread? Sure.
Effective in this sense includes 'practical'. You can slow the spread by doing what Mexico did as well. It is not practical or called for.
You say. Seattle & King County Public Health say: "While there is plentiful supply of Tamiflu in King County, distribution may be slightly backlogged." The CDC's interim guidance recommendations still include antiviral chemoprophylaxis for household contacts and health care workers.
And this is exactly why drawing conclusions without expertise is a problem. King county has enough Tamiflu to treat very sick people, but not enough to give prophylaxis to people exposed unless they have medical risks.
And private clinics cannot purchase Tamiflu right now. Distributors don't have any and Roche isn't selling to anyone but the CDC. So, your patient has the flu, needs Tamiflu, you have to send them to the ED which is the only place King County has so far offered to supply the Tamiflu to.
Should we just send every patient with flu to the ED? No. The ED is already overtaxed. So the patient exposes twice as many people and traipses all over while ill because of the process.
Suppose you have mild flu the first 2 days but develop complications? You were not a candidate for Tamiflu the first 2 days and by day 3, Tamiflu has little to no effect. Because we don't have enough, we have to
guess on the first day of symptoms whether or not your case is going to be severe. It would be nice to be able to treat everyone.
There are many problems here one does not see from reading a rosy news report.
....By the way: get a lot of sunshine up there this time of year do you?
Rainy and windy at the moment and it's been rain/Sun/rain/Sun several days running.
I'm not going to presume to be able to peek inside the heads of the folks at King County Public Health who made that tough call, but it seems reasonable to expect that they are familiar with the historical data which strongly indicate that the timing of measures such as school closures can significantly impact pandemic outcomes. Sounds to me like the observation that "the disease has proven to be relatively mild" had as much to do with it as anything.
Absolutely. But as I said before, to have made that call before you had enough cases to actually know would have been negligent.
Yes. What exactly is the difference? Receptor binding specificity? So how is it that when that changes, permitting a virus to cross a species barrier, the virus remains a member of the same subtype?
I suggest you read a little in the area of genetics and evolution, not of the flu virus, but read about the similarities between species. You might be surprised to find out how similar different species can be, depending on the genes and proteins involved. The divisions between subtypes do not exclude receptor binding in different species because the same or similar receptors are not confined to single species.
Nor are all receptors the same within a species. The CCR5 deletion is a genetic variation that changes the receptor sites on human white blood cells for example. If you have 2 copies of the gene, your white blood cells have different receptors than a person with no copy of the mutation.
You're trying hard to make the process sound more sophisticated than it really is. If you know flu is circulating in a community, it doesn't take a genius to figure out that a person presenting with classic flu symptoms probably has the flu (which makes it an especially bad time to come down with one of the other jillion things that present with similar symptoms). Are you going to tell me that you have data on which specific strains are most widespread in your community at a given time during the course of the season? If a high risk patient had presented with flu sypmtoms in, say, February, what antiviral therapy would you have most likely favored?
So you think doctors and nurse practitioners are over rated? Heck, you could do the same thing, you've been reading about flu.

You and Ivor should open up your own clinic. (See
post 227)