Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

So your argument about global socialism Batvette is about mitigation of the effect of AGW rather than saying it is a motivation for those who believe it is happening?


Not quite, what it does is cause them to support confused policies and agendas to support their environmentalism ideology, which actually harm the end goals of mitigating climate change because the global socialism policies- sometimes inserted by others for their own goals, conflict with them. Is that clearer?

Example being you want to save the planet and thought Kyoto was the ticket and argued strongly for it. You saw language exempting China from restrictions but figure aw hell they are poor let's give them a break. The exemption was engineered in by someone who didn't give a hoot about the earth only going to china and making a buck. It didn't alarm you because you feel sorry for poor China. You still want to save the earth. You didn't stop and think if it might cause a billion Chinese to now use electricity and drive cars because you were so sure you were saving the planet you resisted any question of the policy you supported. And the question itself confronted your sympathy for poor third world people, which was actually exploited by a profiteer who didn't care about your primary agenda at all.

Yes I think that is real clear now. Edit: For those who like the colorful regional flavor, feel free to insert in each appearance of the word "China" or "Chinese" above, the alternate phrase "Swarthy, Smart Alecky Argentinians with impressive English composition skills to hide their lack of relevance or substance". Or not. I liked it.


In that case I did misunderstand you but I didn't think that was the subject under discussion. I thought we were discussing whether AGW is real rather than how to mitigate it's effects.
As for your argument that it's all about climate scientists wanting to keep their jobs, here
is a list of some of the bodies who endorse the consensus position that "most of the global warming in recent decades can be attributed to human activities":

American Association for the Advancement of Science
American Astronomical Society
American Chemical Society
American Geophysical Union
American Institute of Physics
American Meteorological Society
American Physical Society
Australian Meteorological and Oceanographic Society
Australian Bureau of Meteorology and the CSIRO
British Antarctic Survey
Canadian Foundation for Climate and Atmospheric Sciences
Canadian Meteorological and Oceanographic Society
Environmental Protection Agency
European Federation of Geologists
European Geosciences Union
European Physical Society
Federation of American Scientists
Federation of Australian Scientific and Technological Societies
Geological Society of America
Geological Society of Australia
Geological Society of London
International Union for Quaternary Research (INQUA)
International Union of Geodesy and Geophysics
National Center for Atmospheric Research
National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration
Royal Meteorological Society
Royal Society of the UK

Can all these scientific bodies really be engaged in falsifying or supporting the falsification of scientific data just to keep some scientists in jobs?


Never said the data was outright falsified and I'll reiterate my position holds the climate likely is changing, the primary factor may however be solar or natural not man. And the climate change people may be entirely correct.

However by the individual these societies are hardly unanimous and what's probably going on is true to the scientific method, those in fields not directly qualified to make sound conclusions on this are deferring their position to the consensus of the climate change researchers. Trusting them as experts. If there is a fault it may be they are stalwartly defending them as fellow scientists while not confronting the fact their specific field of science leaves room for lack of objectivity their own does not.

Not a conspiracy, just science doing what it does.

We have however, on the part of the CC researchers, seen some real evidence of collusion to suppress dissent, fix the peer review process, etc. Yes climategate. Some was silly, there was substance to some of it and a few cases showed real skull duggery IMO. Not a conspiracy again, easily explained if environmentalism is ones religion.

Promoting the agenda and its end goal would justify malfeasance on the way.
 
Last edited:
It is stupid, indeed!

If some additional proof were needed, we have now this:



Denialism is just one of many social and intellectual disorders that come mostly from an age of mass democracy when some strayed people mix up their right to hold an opinion with the ridiculous pretension of an emerging right for that opinion to be the truth.

That is extra special my Amigo from the non annex one nation who probably applauds the current legislation regime which allows his country unfettered ability to poop on the environment while those in Europe, elsewhere, and soon the US, cut back.

Little facts have been tossed around so in reply to my hot air you give me your hot air, which was thinly disguised personal insult.

However one fact you can refute if you like is the current regime of Kyoto has coincided with sharp increases in global GGE and the rate it has increased. Obviously the policy is a failure yet you seem content taking immature cheap shots from the peanut gallery, presented as intellectual ramblings. I'm not fooled.

What, you don't care about the planet? Yet my posts here have been toward the end goal of waking people up to their failed policies they blindly support.

You would disgust me if I didn't realize this was just the internet.
 
the " climate scientists need to support AGW to get food on the table" is so flawed, with that logic we can say there is no AIDS no Cancer etc. the researchers researching cancer just have to claim there is such a thing like cancer, they need to put food on the table. .... its so flawed logic. but you hear it so often from the science deniers.
 
That is extra special my Amigo from the non annex one nation who probably applauds the current legislation regime which allows his country unfettered ability to poop on the environment while those in Europe, elsewhere, and soon the US, cut back.

Little facts have been tossed around so in reply to my hot air you give me your hot air, which was thinly disguised personal insult.

However one fact you can refute if you like is the current regime of Kyoto has coincided with sharp increases in global GGE and the rate it has increased. Obviously the policy is a failure yet you seem content taking immature cheap shots from the peanut gallery, presented as intellectual ramblings. I'm not fooled.

What, you don't care about the planet? Yet my posts here have been toward the end goal of waking people up to their failed policies they blindly support.

You would disgust me if I didn't realize this was just the internet.

we need to cut back beause the developing nations do not emit nearly as much CO2 per capita like we do. why is that so hard to understand for the deniers?
 
we need to cut back beause the developing nations do not emit nearly as much CO2 per capita like we do. why is that so hard to understand for the deniers?

That's global socialism. Pursue that and Climate Change will be accelerated.
 
That's global socialism. Pursue that and Climate Change will be accelerated.

How does cutting back emissions accelerate climate change?

Why is it "global socialism" to cut back emissions?
 
How does cutting back emissions accelerate climate change?

Why is it "global socialism" to cut back emissions?

Taxes or regulations in one area causes corporations and investment capital to avoid that and migrate to another area to exploit that. This increases the rate of industrialization of the non regulated areas.

Global socialism is a different point. I have already made these points clear in above posts.
 
Taxes or regulations in one area causes corporations and investment capital to avoid that and migrate to another area to exploit that. This increases the rate of industrialization of the non regulated areas.

So regulation means less regulation?

Jesus, how hard is it to come up with "logic" that contrived?

Global socialism is a different point. I have already made these points clear in above posts.

No, you haven't. Would you like to do so now?

I'll ask you again: Why is it "global socialism" to cut back emissions?
 
Stop trying to derail the thread, all of you, not only batvette. About global warming policy, there is a specific thread on such subject. This thread is about global warming denialism and its causes, being "global warming denialism", in the most benign light, the belief -and the reluctance and inability to examine scientific evidence that contradicts the belief- that there's no ongoing process of climate change that can be attributable mainly to human action and with a clear trend towards warming. The term belief is used in a broader sense, because it ranges from a whim-driven "I just know it's not happening" to selecting subsets of scientific data and knowledge to fabricate "convincing evidence", like listing 100 records on cold temperature to suggest it's cooling.

So, in spite of the unfortunate of the thread's title, this thread is to examine what's behind global warming denialism and not to harbour denialists doing denialism. If a global warming """"skeptic"""" feels like contributing his or her side of the discussion about the reality of climate change, there's a general moderated thread on the subject -convergent side of global warming-, and, as said, about the divergent problem of how to deal with it, there's a global warming policy specific thread.
 
Stop trying to derail the thread, all of you, not only batvette. About global warming policy, there is a specific thread on such subject. This thread is about global warming denialism and its causes, being "global warming denialism", in the most benign light, the belief -and the reluctance and inability to examine scientific evidence that contradicts the belief- that there's no ongoing process of climate change that can be attributable mainly to human action and with a clear trend towards warming. The term belief is used in a broader sense, because it ranges from a whim-driven "I just know it's not happening" to selecting subsets of scientific data and knowledge to fabricate "convincing evidence", like listing 100 records on cold temperature to suggest it's cooling.

So, in spite of the unfortunate of the thread's title, this thread is to examine what's behind global warming denialism and not to harbour denialists doing denialism. If a global warming """"skeptic"""" feels like contributing his or her side of the discussion about the reality of climate change, there's a general moderated thread on the subject -convergent side of global warming-, and, as said, about the divergent problem of how to deal with it, there's a global warming policy specific thread.

The forces behind climate denialism are quite easy to pin-point, but a bit harder to understand.

First, there's the rank-and-file denier - the ones you see on forums such as this. These people are basically conspiracy theorists. Often, they start off as being part of the internet "skeptic" movement, but soon venture into pure contrarianism. The need to be "right" soon washes away any skepticism that might have existed in the first place, and that is replaced with the conspiracy theory.

The gurus; people like Fred Singer, "Lord" Monckton, Steve McIntyre and the rest, are in it for the money and the fame. A few of the big-name deniers get payed handsomely for doing no science at all, simply appearing a few times a year in the media and at denialpaloozas. Others - best example is McIntyre - just needs people to pay attention to him. He's most alike the rank-and-file deniers, but as opposed to them - who only lie to get out of a losing argument, more or less involuntarily - he most likely knows he's lying, but he can't help himself. Seeing his name quoted is too much of a drug.
 
So regulation means less regulation?

Jesus, how hard is it to come up with "logic" that contrived?



No, you haven't. Would you like to do so now?

I'll ask you again: Why is it "global socialism" to cut back emissions?

ctrl+f type global socialism then enter.

if you don't find the answer you seek you didn't want it in the first place and I have better things to do than let you waste my time. I made my position clear in above posts and have no obligation to reword it so you can understand.
 
Global Warming Denialism is neither a conspiracy theory or a religion.

It is the natural live forever road chosen by the immature who can't see the forest for the trees and will not until their vision starts to wane and become stronger.
 
Isn’t this thread a false dichotomy?

Instead of being "a conspiracy theory or a religion" it could just be that some people are just a bit sceptical of the assertions made by global warming researchers given that they have in the past been demonstrably less than factually accurate, an actually somewhat alarmist?

I'm thinking of this little gem here
http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/snowfalls-are-now-just-a-thing-of-the-past-724017.html

Or this
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8468358.stm

There’s also the indisputable fact that global warming is being used by the government (UK, but probably lots of other places too) as an excuse to raise taxes, as if that’s going to stop the Indonesian peat fires or stop the Chinese building a new coal power station before breakfast every day.

There’s also the indisputable fact that the climate has changed before and indeed is in a permanent state of flux and that maybe people feel like we don’t need any anthropogenic effects to explain it and even if it is anthropogenic then ‘meh’
 
ctrl+f type global socialism then enter.

if you don't find the answer you seek you didn't want it in the first place and I have better things to do than let you waste my time. I made my position clear in above posts and have no obligation to reword it so you can understand.

When I do as you ask, I find strong evidence that you don't know what "global" or "socialism", or indeed "global socialism" is. I don't find anything explaining why cutting emissions is global socialism. So, again: why is cutting emissions global socialism?
 
Isn’t this thread a false dichotomy?

Nope.

Instead of being "a conspiracy theory or a religion" it could just be that some people are just a bit sceptical of the assertions made by global warming researchers given that they have in the past been demonstrably less than factually accurate, an actually somewhat alarmist?

Denial of AGW requires a conspiracy theory.


It's an article written by a non-climate scientist about a CRU climate scientist speculating about what will happen in the future. It isn't demonstrably factually inaccurate or alarmist.


Jesus... that old canard. It's ONE mistake in a 3000-page report. One mistake. Most people make more mistakes than that in simple conversation. Do you believe this justifies years of vicious attacks on climate scientists and outright lies by denialists in the media?

There’s also the indisputable fact that global warming is being used by the government (UK, but probably lots of other places too) as an excuse to raise taxes, as if that’s going to stop the Indonesian peat fires or stop the Chinese building a new coal power station before breakfast every day.

No, it's not being used to raise taxes. Taxes are being used to mitigate climate change. Get it right.

There’s also the indisputable fact that the climate has changed before and indeed is in a permanent state of flux and that maybe people feel like we don’t need any anthropogenic effects to explain it and even if it is anthropogenic then ‘meh’

Seriously, read the thread in the science forum before you spew any more old PRATTs. This particular one was dealt with just a few pages ago.

FWIW, thank you for an excellent demonstration of denialism in action.
 
Last edited:
Nope.



Denial of AGW requires a conspiracy theory.



It's an article written by a non-climate scientist about a CRU climate scientist speculating about what will happen in the future. It isn't demonstrably factually inaccurate or alarmist.



Jesus... that old canard. It's ONE mistake in a 3000-page report. One mistake. Most people make more mistakes than that in simple conversation. Do you believe this justifies years of vicious attacks on climate scientists and outright lies by denialists in the media?



No, it's not being used to raise taxes. Taxes are being used to mitigate climate change. Get it right.



Seriously, read the thread in the science forum before you spew any more old PRATTs. This particular one was dealt with just a few pages ago.

FWIW, thank you for an excellent demonstration of denialism in action.

Did I ever tell you you're pretty when you're angry?
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom