The o'le trick of using resounding short phrases, Robert?
♫ Long as you keep 'em way off balance ♫ ♫ How can they spot you've got no talents ♫ ♫ Razzle-dazzle 'em, and they'll never catch wise ♫
But the thread is still about what is global warming denialism and how it works. When you're not trying to derail the thread you're just providing a monochord, limited example of how denialism communicates.
so you agree that the world average temperature has risen sharply in the later half of the 20th century?
and you agree that CO2 levels have been rising and that humans increase CO2 levels by burning fossil fuels?
you also agree that the world is loosing ice mass?
you also agree that the greenhouse effect as measured by satellites has increased indeed?
you also agree what CO2 has IR absorbing properties as has been measured by spectrography?
those are all measurements done by scientists around the world.
so where are the liars? where is the lie?
Where's that from? your pocket book of handy witticisms? Did it come in a bundle with Dale Carnegie's?
Your inability to express the slightest original idea is noted. That's another characteristic you share with the denialist ilk, like using "they" the same way you did with your previous unoriginal "mouthful"; that basic "they" or the hate speech. However, take into account that short worded derails and/or small talk derails are still derails.
is this conspiracy theory more realistic than the conspiracy theory that the IPCC and the vast majority of scientists in the relevant field of science togeher with almost all governments around the world conspired to lie to the world in order to create more taxing revenues?
which conspiracy theory does have more supporting evidence?
after my 9/11 trutherism i wanted to stay away from conspiracy theories for a while And while i was already convinced of AGW even during my truther phase, i startet to dislike the idea about speculating about the possibility that big corporations might pay scientists to make flawed studies like Soon and Baliunas and others.
i am totaly sure that there are scientists that are not yet fully convinced that AGW is a problem. and that even some of them might think we should not take any action yet, and they think so no matter who gives them money.
But there seems to be atleast some evidence that shows there might actually be some companies that finance think tanks that publish vrey biased reports and studies.
is this just conspiracy nonsense like most conspiracy theories. or is it slightly more realistic and better supported by evidence than other theories?
DC, the fact that some companies aren't playing fair does not invalidate the hard science that is being done, it just shows that some folks put profit ahead of honesty.
DC, the fact that some companies aren't playing fair does not invalidate the hard science that is being done, it just shows that some folks put profit ahead of honesty.
no sure not, not even the funding itself ivalidates the science being done, if science is being done.
while Exxon seems to be one of those that do fund think tanks with bias and pseudoscientific reports and studies. Exxon is also funding good and sound research like here :
but i do wonder to what extend is the denial machinery funded by industries that are fearing to loose profit over CO2 regulations.
the denial machinery in the US seems to be so strong that one can even argue that they won the political battle about AGW. in the presidential elections AGW was almost a non topic. while it should have been one of the main topics.
i find this very scary.
is this conspiracy theory more realistic than the conspiracy theory that the IPCC and the vast majority of scientists in the relevant field of science togeher with almost all governments around the world conspired to lie to the world in order to create more taxing revenues?
which conspiracy theory does have more supporting evidence?
after my 9/11 trutherism i wanted to stay away from conspiracy theories for a while And while i was already convinced of AGW even during my truther phase, i startet to dislike the idea about speculating about the possibility that big corporations might pay scientists to make flawed studies like Soon and Baliunas and others.
i am totaly sure that there are scientists that are not yet fully convinced that AGW is a problem. and that even some of them might think we should not take any action yet, and they think so no matter who gives them money.
But there seems to be atleast some evidence that shows there might actually be some companies that finance think tanks that publish vrey biased reports and studies.
is this just conspiracy nonsense like most conspiracy theories. or is it slightly more realistic and better supported by evidence than other theories?
Well I guess that depends very much on your definition of conspiracy theory, but I would say no, not if you define conspiracy as a secret plot to do something illegal.
While the Kochs may not have sought publicity for and used various front groups to obscure their funding of the denier groups it would be a bit of a stretch to say it was a secret plot, and they're not being accused of doing anything illegal in this video.
Also as you suggest in your last sentence the term conspiracy theory usually implies a paranoid speculation with little or no supporting evidence whereas this seems to be backed by sound investagative journalism, and a quick googling revealed no claims that it'd been debunked or wasn't true.
no sure not, not even the funding itself ivalidates the science being done, if science is being done.
while Exxon seems to be one of those that do fund think tanks with bias and pseudoscientific reports and studies. Exxon is also funding good and sound research like here :
but i do wonder to what extend is the denial machinery funded by industries that are fearing to loose profit over CO2 regulations.
the denial machinery in the US seems to be so strong that one can even argue that they won the political battle about AGW. in the presidential elections AGW was almost a non topic. while it should have been one of the main topics.
i find this very scary.
Doing the former is a part of doing the latter. Or will new ways to actively achieve a goal be a bad thing for some reason? Care to supply your cost analysis?
Well I guess that depends very much on your definition of conspiracy theory, but I would say no, not if you define conspiracy as a secret plot to do something illegal.
While the Kochs may not have sought publicity for and used various front groups to obscure their funding of the denier groups it would be a bit of a stretch to say it was a secret plot, and they're not being accused of doing anything illegal in this video.
Also as you suggest in your last sentence the term conspiracy theory usually implies a paranoid speculation with little or no supporting evidence whereas this seems to be backed by sound investagative journalism, and a quick googling revealed no claims that it'd been debunked or wasn't true.
Doing the former is a part of doing the latter. Or will new ways to actively achieve a goal be a bad thing for some reason? Care to supply your cost analysis?
What you are doing now instead of supplying a cost analysis to show that research projects funded by energy suppliers around the world are cheaper than "actually" doing something about pollution?
Or was your apparent observation not based on any actual fact?
Even if one is cheaper than the other, care to show that nations and corporations do one but not the other?
This isn't about scientific research it's about lobbying.
How much do denier groups such as Americans for Prosperity, the Heritage Foundation, the Cato Institute, and the Manhattan Institute spend on actual scientific research?
Though ironically,
The Charles G. Koch Foundation gave $150,000 to the Berkeley Earth Surface Temperature (BEST) study in 2011, which was embraced by the denial machine until it redundantly re-confirmed that the surface of our planet has been warming increasingly for decades. While David Koch had previously claimed that “global warming could be good for the planet,” neither Charles nor David has explained how the BEST study they funded contradicts their denial of climate change
What Clayton Moore said with "research is cheaper than actively trying to prevent pollution" was that some real research may be a product of PR needs and come from a cost-benefit analysis. That is common sense, it's thought as a bit to trigger reflection, yet it doesn't need to be proved nor it depicts a reality where everything is necessarily subsumed by lobbying.
It looks like forums.randi.org did it again: in a sort of "argumentum ad hitlerum" everything "Big Oil" does is malicious and, as he holds some strange opinions and foster some wacky causes, everything Clayton Moore is saying needs to be thoroughly substantiated.
He who said "Lord, protect me from my friends. I can take care of my enemies" was thinking in these fora.
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.