Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

Isn’t this thread a false dichotomy?

Instead of being "a conspiracy theory or a religion" it could just be that some people are just a bit sceptical of the assertions made by global warming researchers ...

There's no dichotomy there, the thread title was just a slander. (A)GW denialism is something very specific and analysing it doesn't start by saying "are they dumb or dumber?" as the thread opener intended.

...given that they have in the past been demonstrably less than factually accurate, an actually somewhat alarmist?

I'm thinking of this little gem here
http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/snowfalls-are-now-just-a-thing-of-the-past-724017.html

Or this
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8468358.stm

There’s also the indisputable fact that global warming is being used by the government (UK, but probably lots of other places too) as an excuse to raise taxes, as if that’s going to stop the Indonesian peat fires or stop the Chinese building a new coal power station before breakfast every day.

There’s also the indisputable fact that the climate has changed before and indeed is in a permanent state of flux and that maybe people feel like we don’t need any anthropogenic effects to explain it and even if it is anthropogenic then ‘meh’

The rest of your post is not suitable for this thread. It has to be with the general warming thread, a moderated thread. Please, don't avoid the moderated status of that thread by posting here your heart about the "no-ongoing GW and indisputability of political manipulation behind it". You, and your links, are welcome in the moderated thread. The "glaciargate" is very important and needed of discussion there, not here.
 
The forces behind climate denialism are quite easy to pin-point, but a bit harder to understand.

First, there's the rank-and-file denier - the ones you see on forums such as this. These people are basically conspiracy theorists. Often, they start off as being part of the internet "skeptic" movement, but soon venture into pure contrarianism. The need to be "right" soon washes away any skepticism that might have existed in the first place, and that is replaced with the conspiracy theory.

The gurus; people like Fred Singer, "Lord" Monckton, Steve McIntyre and the rest, are in it for the money and the fame. A few of the big-name deniers get payed handsomely for doing no science at all, simply appearing a few times a year in the media and at denialpaloozas. Others - best example is McIntyre - just needs people to pay attention to him. He's most alike the rank-and-file deniers, but as opposed to them - who only lie to get out of a losing argument, more or less involuntarily - he most likely knows he's lying, but he can't help himself. Seeing his name quoted is too much of a drug.

Well, I'm not sure this thread has to deal with the "leaders". Analysing a supposed McIntyre trying to attract attention, like a supposed hyperthyroidism in Monckton are, in my opinion, private matters that guide us off the track of what drives the actions of a run-of-the-mill denialist.

Yesterday I had the sad experience of scanning the comment section following one piece of news of my favourite local newspaper, a piece with interviews to climate science dealing with GW being an important contributor to climatic events like La Plata's and its 51 to 72 dead and 2 to 5 missing people. Some local denialists -there are not many, as denialism is strong in the Anglosphere but not in most of the planet- started with their usual preach, and people reacted in a violent way. It made me think about what makes a denialist so fanatic that in front of an article about a recent catastrophe when everybody is looking for guilty people and groups, they decide that that is the place and opportunity to do their preach.

There's a viral aspect in the behaviour of many denialists and it's not easy to analyse it as that viral aspect is active in so many groups, like the thingos that knock our doors to "share information about God".
 
Well, I'm not sure this thread has to deal with the "leaders". Analysing a supposed McIntyre trying to attract attention, like a supposed hyperthyroidism in Monckton are, in my opinion, private matters that guide us off the track of what drives the actions of a run-of-the-mill denialist.

Yesterday I had the sad experience of scanning the comment section following one piece of news of my favourite local newspaper, a piece with interviews to climate science dealing with GW being an important contributor to climatic events like La Plata's and its 51 to 72 dead and 2 to 5 missing people. Some local denialists -there are not many, as denialism is strong in the Anglosphere but not in most of the planet- started with their usual preach, and people reacted in a violent way. It made me think about what makes a denialist so fanatic that in front of an article about a recent catastrophe when everybody is looking for guilty people and groups, they decide that that is the place and opportunity to do their preach.

There's a viral aspect in the behaviour of many denialists and it's not easy to analyse it as that viral aspect is active in so many groups, like the thingos that knock our doors to "share information about God".

Like I said, I'm firmly of the opinion that "run of the mill" climate deniers are simply conspiracy theorists. "Fallen skeptics" I suppose you could call them in an effort to be poetic.
 
There's no dichotomy there, the thread title was just a slander. (A)GW denialism is something very specific and analysing it doesn't start by saying "are they dumb or dumber?" as the thread opener intended.



The rest of your post is not suitable for this thread. It has to be with the general warming thread, a moderated thread. Please, don't avoid the moderated status of that thread by posting here your heart about the "no-ongoing GW and indisputability of political manipulation behind it". You, and your links, are welcome in the moderated thread. The "glaciargate" is very important and needed of discussion there, not here.

It's kind of funny you come off as reasonable about the policies issue now ans seem content to merely deflect it to the more general topic... however I can't help but recall you were doing your darndest in that topic to disrupt discussion of it with a lot of ad hominem and dog piling immaturity.

Not to mention that thread is in the science forum and his concerns will be labelled off topic by the hard core AGWers, AND the moderations seem to have little rhyme nor reason in many cases.

I guess about all I can say is to remind you as merely a user it's appropriate to suggest to this user what is on topic or not, but the tone you're taking as a self assumed thread police is one usually reserved for moderation staff and I don't see that on your profile.

Perhaps I'm mistaken and we do have the right to all run around being little dictators pretending each of us wrote the rules for the site. Could be fun, I'll wait and see.

And for the person you replied to, I'll inform him this is the game the local AGW ideologues play here. It's off topic here, and everywhere... and when that doesn't work they'll run you and your valid concerns off labelling you something you're not, all the while denying what they are.
 
Did I ever tell you you're pretty when you're angry?

Pretty what?

I'm no longer subject to the mental abuse you just received, but you might want to ask about this:

No, it's not being used to raise taxes. Taxes are being used to mitigate climate change. Get it right.

Specifically how and what has been the result so far- and how can it possibly rein in emerging polluters who have far surpassed those being "taxed" to "mitigate".

Climate Gestapo. Go figure.
 
Isn’t this thread a false dichotomy?

Instead of being "a conspiracy theory or a religion" it could just be that some people are just a bit sceptical of the assertions made by global warming researchers given that they have in the past been demonstrably less than factually accurate, an actually somewhat alarmist?

I'm thinking of this little gem here
http://www.independent.co.uk/environment/snowfalls-are-now-just-a-thing-of-the-past-724017.html

Or this
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/8468358.stm

There’s also the indisputable fact that global warming is being used by the government (UK, but probably lots of other places too) as an excuse to raise taxes, as if that’s going to stop the Indonesian peat fires or stop the Chinese building a new coal power station before breakfast every day.

There’s also the indisputable fact that the climate has changed before and indeed is in a permanent state of flux and that maybe people feel like we don’t need any anthropogenic effects to explain it and even if it is anthropogenic then ‘meh’

I'm not sure what you think those two links prove. Snow was getting rarer and rarer in the UK and spring was starting earlier and earlier. That only changed about three winters ago. Winters have been much colder and summers much wetter.The reason for that is because of changes in the jet stream. Almost certainly caused at least in part, by the arctic ice melt and global warming.
Your second link shows somebody admitting to a mistake in a 3000 page report. What does that prove accept that they will admit when they have made emistakes?
 
It's kind of funny you come off as reasonable about the policies issue now ans seem content to merely deflect it to the more general topic... however I can't help but recall you were doing your darndest in that topic to disrupt discussion of it with a lot of ad hominem and dog piling immaturity.

Not to mention that thread is in the science forum and his concerns will be labelled off topic by the hard core AGWers, AND the moderations seem to have little rhyme nor reason in many cases.

I guess about all I can say is to remind you as merely a user it's appropriate to suggest to this user what is on topic or not, but the tone you're taking as a self assumed thread police is one usually reserved for moderation staff and I don't see that on your profile.

Perhaps I'm mistaken and we do have the right to all run around being little dictators pretending each of us wrote the rules for the site. Could be fun, I'll wait and see.

And for the person you replied to, I'll inform him this is the game the local AGW ideologues play here. It's off topic here, and everywhere... and when that doesn't work they'll run you and your valid concerns off labelling you something you're not, all the while denying what they are.

You write a lot in forums.randi.org but you read very very little, don't you? It seems you are just trolling, lady/sir. And it seems you do clearly know this is not the right place to discuss global warming as a general topic. Why? Because your last posts here are just philippics or "reconventions", and nothing else.

I know it's difficult to get you on topic, and the "quality" of your posts speaks for yourself, but this is a thread about denialism and why they are what they are. Does that group include you? It's not clear. Denialism is a state of mind in absence of evidence or in absence of the ability to determine what is evidence and what is not. If you or anyone want to discuss the evidence of global warming -or lack thereof- and show your skills and education in judging what is evidence and what is not, the moderated general global warming thread was created by the moderator team to that effect.

The use here is to have flushed into the general warming thread all the content proving or disproving that an A(GW) is happening, and sanctioned those who repeatedly force the intervention of moderators in doing so.
 
No, it's not being used to raise taxes. Taxes are being used to mitigate climate change. Get it right.
But some of the taxes that have been introduced seem to be unavoidable without the companies themselves suffering heavy losses or going out of business.

Let companies pollute as much as they like, as long as they pay the tax. ;)

Pretty much like the government introducing a "breathing tax" TBH.
 
Pretty what?

I'm no longer subject to the mental abuse you just received, but you might want to ask about this:



Specifically how and what has been the result so far- and how can it possibly rein in emerging polluters who have far surpassed those being "taxed" to "mitigate".
Climate Gestapo. Go figure.

are you talking about those Country that are catching up on CO2 Emission per capita to us? but are still far far behind us on that?

what has it done?

well the Deniers tell us how surface temperatures are not rising at all. :D
 
When I do as you ask, I find strong evidence that you don't know what "global" or "socialism", or indeed "global socialism" is. I don't find anything explaining why cutting emissions is global socialism. So, again: why is cutting emissions global socialism?

Could somebody quote this just in case batvette's finally made good on his promise to ignore me? He keeps dodging questions.
 
Last edited:
But some of the taxes that have been introduced seem to be unavoidable without the companies themselves suffering heavy losses or going out of business.

Let companies pollute as much as they like, as long as they pay the tax. ;)

Pretty much like the government introducing a "breathing tax" TBH.

The point is to curb emissions. If the company can't curb emissions without going out of business, they should go out of business.
 
uke2se said:
When I do as you ask, I find strong evidence that you don't know what "global" or "socialism", or indeed "global socialism" is. I don't find anything explaining why cutting emissions is global socialism. So, again: why is cutting emissions global socialism?

Could somebody quote this just in case batvette's finally made good on his promise to ignore me? He keeps dodging questions.
Ask and ye shall receive.
 
The point is to curb emissions. If the company can't curb emissions without going out of business, they should go out of business.
If you cant afford to pay the breathing tax or get by with breathing less then you deserve to die.

;)
 
But we don't have a breathing tax. A CO2 tax is nothing like a breathing tax.
Isn't it?
It's a tax that companies didn't have to pay but now do in order to maintain their businesses due to it being implemented by a government pretending to be concerned about the environment.
If you pay the tax you can carry on polluting if you cant pay or reduce emissions you go out of business.

Its exactly like a breathing tax.

Oh and another thing
If the company can't curb emissions without going out of business, they should go out of business.
I hope you are not one of the thousands of people who may become unemployed because the company you work for has to cut costs to pay the said tax.

Things are not as simple as they first appear. ;)
 
Isn't it?
It's a tax that companies didn't have to pay but now do in order to maintain their businesses due to it being implemented by a government pretending to be concerned about the environment.

How do you know the government is just pretending to be concerned about the environment? Because the government has a pretty damn good reason to be concerned about the environment.

If you pay the tax you can carry on polluting if you cant pay or reduce emissions you go out of business.

The tax is an incentive to make it profitable for companies to develop and implement lower-emission procedures. It's not about "if you can pay you can carry on polluting". It's about shifting the economic paradigm.

Its exactly like a breathing tax.

No, it's nothing like a breathing tax. A breathing tax would kill people who can't pay it. A CO2 tax is there to prevent people from dying in the long run.

Oh and another thing

I hope you are not one of the thousands of people who may become unemployed because the company you work for has to cut costs to pay the said tax.

I am not, and it's sad that people lose their jobs. But it's better that people lose their jobs than their lives.

Things are not as simple as they first appear. ;)

It would seem as though this thing is more complex than you thought.
 
Isn't it?
It's a tax that companies didn't have to pay but now do in order to maintain their businesses due to it being implemented by a government pretending to be concerned about the environment.
If you pay the tax you can carry on polluting if you cant pay or reduce emissions you go out of business.

Its exactly like a breathing tax.

Oh and another thing

I hope you are not one of the thousands of people who may become unemployed because the company you work for has to cut costs to pay the said tax.

Things are not as simple as they first appear. ;)

I think you will not be one of the millions of people having to resettle or die do to water and food shortages. but i wish you would see it instead of your children having to go true it when they are old.

things are far more complicated than you think.
 
How do you know the government is just pretending to be concerned about the environment? Because the government has a pretty damn good reason to be concerned about the environment.
It's my opinion.
The tax is an incentive to make it profitable for companies to develop and implement lower-emission procedures. It's not about "if you can pay you can carry on polluting". It's about shifting the economic paradigm.
I think the tax is there to squeeze funds from profitable companies who can pay it and continue to pollute the environment.
No, it's nothing like a breathing tax. A breathing tax would kill people who can't pay it. A CO2 tax is there to prevent people from dying in the long run.
A CO2 tax will shut down companies who can't pay it. Just like a breathing tax will kill people who cant pay it.
I am not, and it's sad that people lose their jobs. But it's better that people lose their jobs than their lives.
Drama queen, has the current emissions tax saved lives yet if not how long do you think it will take?
It would seem as though this thing is more complex than you thought.
Emissions taxation is a knee-jerk reaction that doesn't eliminate the problem, it just hits business in the pocket short term.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom