Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

I'm still trying to figure out how accepting global warming means we steal from the rich and give to the poor.

Seems to me most plans involve taxing companies that contribute to the problem in order to pay other companies to clean up the problem. Aside from giving the poor a better planet to live on how does this really benefit them?
 
I'm still trying to figure out how accepting global warming means we steal from the rich and give to the poor.

Seems to me most plans involve taxing companies that contribute to the problem in order to pay other companies to clean up the problem. Aside from giving the poor a better planet to live on how does this really benefit them?

"Companies do not pay taxes. Companies are only the collection agent for the consumer who must pay all the taxes charged to companies. Who is hurt the most from such taxes? The rich or the "poor?" A better planet is one where in a large country like the USA an average middle-class American is free to travel long distances without having to take out a loan for the gas it requires. Like it used to be in the good old days of leaded gas, at 25 cents a gallon.
 
Robert you do know the prices for petrol (gas as you call it) are dictated by OPEC and the international oil trade market, it has very little to do with the decisions of national governments other than the members of OPEC.
 
Robert you do know the prices for petrol (gas as you call it) are dictated by OPEC and the international oil trade market, it has very little to do with the decisions of national governments other than the members of OPEC.

That's the base price. My friends in England pay about four times what I do for a gallon of gas. (And yes, yes, yes, they buy by the liter, I know that.) The difference is in taxes.
 
Robert you do know the prices for petrol (gas as you call it) are dictated by OPEC and the international oil trade market, it has very little to do with the decisions of national governments other than the members of OPEC.

The price of petrol, or gasoline is dictated by supply and demand, not OPEC though OPEC can influence supplies to a degree. Added to that are the taxes paid by the consumer to be collected by the oil companies, and passed on to the government. Business taxes are never paid by businesses, but only collected from consumers and passed on to governments. Econ 101.
 
The price of petrol, or gasoline is dictated by supply and demand, not OPEC though OPEC can influence supplies to a degree. Added to that are the taxes paid by the consumer to be collected by the oil companies, and passed on to the government. Business taxes are never paid by businesses, but only collected from consumers and passed on to governments. Econ 101.

You contradict yourself somewhat there. If the business passes along the taxes and they want to stay competitive they have to accept less profit. Otherwise some company will undercut them.
 
The price of petrol, or gasoline is dictated by supply and demand, not OPEC though OPEC can influence supplies to a degree. Added to that are the taxes paid by the consumer to be collected by the oil companies, and passed on to the government. Business taxes are never paid by businesses, but only collected from consumers and passed on to governments. Econ 101.

Coming back to reality how on earth do you manage to claim OPEC has nothing to do with it????
 
RP you came out with this piece of conspiricism (not that there's anything intrinsically wrong with conspiricism as long as it's based on evidence rather than gut feelings/ideological dogmatism) on the 1st page of this thread

Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft.
Incredible, over 100 years of scientific endeavour (the AGW theory, more CO2= warmer world, was first proposed in 1896) is all a political plot.
Several posters asked you to justify or provide evidence for this statement, you completely ignored them and moved the goalposts until you replied to travis's post

I'm still trying to figure out how accepting global warming means we steal from the rich and give to the poor.

Seems to me most plans involve taxing companies that contribute to the problem in order to pay other companies to clean up the problem. Aside from giving the poor a better planet to live on how does this really benefit them?

with this non sequiter

"Companies do not pay taxes. Companies are only the collection agent for the consumer who must pay all the taxes charged to companies. Who is hurt the most from such taxes? The rich or the "poor?" A better planet is one where in a large country like the USA an average middle-class American is free to travel long distances without having to take out a loan for the gas it requires. Like it used to be in the good old days of leaded gas, at 25 cents a gallon.

so you seem to be agreeing with travis that this will not benefit the poor so how does that tie in with it all being a leftie plot to redistribute wealth?
 
It's A Commie Plot

The Marxist roots of the global warming scare​

As the late Natalie Grant put it, "Protection of the environment may be used as a pretext to adopt a series of measures designed to undermine the industrial base of developed nations. It may also serve to introduce malaise by lowering their standard of living and implanting communist values.

http://www.renewamerica.com/columns/vernon/080616
 
UN Admits Marxist Goals in Global Warming Fraud​

IPCC Official: “Climate Policy Is Redistributing The World’s Wealth”

Posted on November 18, 2010 by Anthony Watts

Neue Zürcher Zeitung, 14 November 2010

"Climate policy has almost nothing to do anymore with environmental protection, says the German economist and IPCC official Ottmar Edenhofer. The next world climate summit in Cancun is actually an economy summit during which the distribution of the world’s resources will be negotiated."

– Ottmar Edenhofer, Co-Chair of hte IpCC Working Group III.

http://www.nationalreview.com/plane...-redistributing-worlds-wealth-greg-pollowitz#
 
Last edited:
The price of petrol, or gasoline is dictated by supply and demand, not OPEC though OPEC can influence supplies to a degree. Added to that are the taxes paid by the consumer to be collected by the oil companies, and passed on to the government. Business taxes are never paid by businesses, but only collected from consumers and passed on to governments. Econ 101.

Supply and demand? Sounds great. Somehow the Oil companies always have record quarters every time prices skyrocket.

Do you really think OPEC is instigating anything?

Supply and demand? Now there is a conspiracy if there ever was one.
 
"Climate policy has almost nothing to do anymore with environmental protection, says the German economist and IPCC official Ottmar Edenhofer. The next world climate summit in Cancun is actually an economy summit during which the distribution of the world’s resources will be negotiated."

– Ottmar Edenhofer, Co-Chair of hte IpCC Working Group III.

Only trouble here is that the quote is not from Ottmar Edenhofer but rather a biased interpretation of what he said. so here's an english translation of what he actually said
http://rabett.blogspot.co.uk/2010/11/ottmar-repeats-himself.html
and my interpretation
Climate policy isn't purely an enviromental policy, it has lots of political and economic ramifications, it will mean a lot of coal will have to stay in the ground, and like all structural changes will lead to a redistrbution of wealth, in this case away from the countries and companys that presently own those resources to the innovators in a post-carbon economy.
 
As the late Natalie Grant put it, "Protection of the environment may be used as a pretext to adopt a series of measures designed to undermine the industrial base of developed nations. It may also serve to introduce malaise by lowering their standard of living and implanting communist values.

Why should I care about the opinions of a christian singer, and btw I don't think she's dead
 
Why should I care about the opinions of a christian singer, and btw I don't think she's dead

Seems like a different person - from the link:
"Natalie Grant Wraga (who died in 2002 at age 101) was an internationally-recognized expert on the art of disinformation. In her Washington Post obituary, Herbert Romerstein — veteran intelligence expert in the legislative and executive branches of government — described Grant/Wraga as "one of our leading authorities" on Soviet deceit."​

...this doesn't make her any more an authority on climate science of course.
 
Last edited:
Only trouble here is that the quote is not from Ottmar Edenhofer but rather a biased interpretation of what he said. so here's an english translation of what he actually said
http://rabett.blogspot.co.uk/2010/11/ottmar-repeats-himself.html
and my interpretation
Climate policy isn't purely an enviromental policy, it has lots of political and economic ramifications, it will mean a lot of coal will have to stay in the ground, and like all structural changes will lead to a redistrbution of wealth, in this case away from the countries and companys that presently own those resources to the innovators in a post-carbon economy.

So what is it about "redistribution of wealth" that is a mis-translation????
 
Seems like a different person - from the link:
"Natalie Grant Wraga (who died in 2002 at age 101) was an internationally-recognized expert on the art of disinformation. In her Washington Post obituary, Herbert Romerstein — veteran intelligence expert in the legislative and executive branches of government — described Grant/Wraga as "one of our leading authorities" on Soviet deceit."​

...this doesn't make her any more an authority on climate science of course.

But a recognized authority on Lefty Disinformation. And her quotation as to how to create climate disinformation is exactly what the Chicken Littles of the Marxist Left are all about.
 
But a recognized authority on Lefty Disinformation. And her quotation as to how to create climate disinformation is exactly what the Chicken Littles of the Marxist Left are all about.

so the disinformation come from Marxist left? Heartland Institiue is Marxist? Christopher Monckton is a Marxist? Antony Watts is a Marxist?
do you have any evidence for this?
 
So what is it about "redistribution of wealth" that is a mis-translation????

I did not say mis-translation, I said interpretation. It's all about context, the guy is talking about an effect not a goal, though obviously if your denial of the science leads you to believe that there must be a hidden agenda (or is it your dogmatic belief that there is a hidden marxist agenda that leads you to deny science), I'm guessing the latter, you probably won't understand the difference.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom