Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

Unlike the know-it-alls of the Chicken Little Left, I do not proffer
un-scientific conclusions, only scientific questions, such as:

Does Co2 cause Global Warming or
yes
http://www.skepticalscience.com/empirical-evidence-for-global-warming.htm
Does Global Warming cause a rise in Co2?
yes
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zQ3PzYU1N7A

Or is there no causal relationship either way?
there can be a causual relation in both cases.

These are not questions dogmatic Lefties ask, because they already have all the answers, but these are questions serious scientists do ask.
actually real sceptics have asked those questions a long time ago and have provided data so we are able to answer those questions.

Why is a rise in Co2 bad?
because when all other factors stay and CO2 concentration is increased it will lead to increased global temperatures, in the lower atmosphere, do to the IR absorbtion and reradiation of CO2 molecules.
Doesn't nature love Co2? Is it not the source of life for plants and the plant source of oxygen for humans?
it is without a doubt a very important gas. i love CO2. it played a huge role we even evolved. btw speaking of evolving, during the time we have fossil evidence of homo sapiens (200 000 years), CO2 levels have not been as high as they are today.
Would it not be a real crisis if there was a substantial lowering of Co2????
yes indeed, that would lead to cooling.
 
Last edited:
How can someone think they know enough about climate change to participate in a thread like this and yet not know that rising CO2 can be both a forcing and a feedback?
 
Addressing the OP original question:

Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

is on its face a fallacious question -- an example of the False Dilemma fallacy.

Fact is, a belief that there is no global warming or at least no solid evidence of man made global warming is quite possibly a legitimate theory, and not a conspiracy nor a religion. Perhaps the OP, Gawdzilla, would care to reconsider this fallacious question or offer proof that such belief is indeed either a conspiracy or a religion. But I sort of doubt it.
 
Last edited:
My take is that Global Warming is Plan B for those who were fighting a lose lose battle against the environmentalists. Plan B because there couldn't be a Plan A that would justify pollution. What better than to create an unprovable foe who could be ridiculed as loony tunes? What better than recreating a legion of foes, anti-pollutionists, into factless Global Warming nut jobs.

Who had the money to pay for research into such a nebulous precept?


Think about it. Legislation to prevent/lower pollution because pollution damages the environment can't really be challenged. Legislation to prevent/lower pollution because of Global Warming is called nonsense.
 
Last edited:
Addressing the OP original question:

Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

is on its face a fallacious question -- an example of the False Dilemma fallacy.

Fact is, a belief that there is no global warming or at least no solid evidence of man made global warming is quite possibly a legitimate theory, and not a conspiracy nor a religion. Perhaps the OP, Gawdzilla, would care to reconsider this fallacious question or offer proof that such belief is indeed either a conspiracy or a religion. But I sort of doubt it.

without a doubt there are genuine skeptics of AGW, you are not one, you are a denier, because you deny AGW without even knowing what you are talking about.
 
Addressing the OP original question:

Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

is on its face a fallacious question -- an example of the False Dilemma fallacy.

Fact is, a belief that there is no global warming or at least no solid evidence of man made global warming is quite possibly a legitimate theory, and not a conspiracy nor a religion. Perhaps the OP, Gawdzilla, would care to reconsider this fallacious question or offer proof that such belief is indeed either a conspiracy or a religion. But I sort of doubt it.

Actually, you've proven to me that it is both conspiracy theory and something of a religion. Well done, that denier.
 
without a doubt there are genuine skeptics of AGW, you are not one, you are a denier, because you deny AGW without even knowing what you are talking about.

And there we have the difference between scientists and deniers. Scientists will say, "let's see what the available information tells us" and deniers will say, "the available information DEFINITELY TELLS US that there is no AGW."
 
My take is that Global Warming is Plan B for those who were fighting a lose lose battle against the environmentalists. Plan B because there couldn't be a Plan A that would justify pollution. What better than to create an unprovable foe who could be ridiculed as loony tunes? What better than recreating a legion of foes, anti-pollutionists, into factless Global Warming nut jobs.

Who had the money to pay for research into such a nebulous precept?


Think about it. Legislation to prevent/lower pollution because pollution damages the environment can't really be challenged. Legislation to prevent/lower pollution because of Global Warming is called nonsense.

I also suspect that there is a deliberate plan to boost denialism to try and divert or delay efforts to make certain industries clean up their act. We've already seen that some businessmen will put profit over everything else, so this isn't the least bit surprising.
 
Addressing the OP original question:

Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

is on its face a fallacious question -- an example of the False Dilemma fallacy.

Fact is, a belief that there is no global warming or at least no solid evidence of man made global warming is quite possibly a legitimate theory, and not a conspiracy nor a religion. Perhaps the OP, Gawdzilla, would care to reconsider this fallacious question or offer proof that such belief is indeed either a conspiracy or a religion. But I sort of doubt it.

20 years ago it would have been possible to argue that much of the rejection of the theory of AGW was based on genuine skepticism, but all the efforts of the contrarians to falsify the theory have failed and those genuine skeptics who have looked at the evidence of man made global warming have concluded that it is solid and needs to be taken seriously. One good example of that is the BEST group set up by skeptics to independently re-examine the temperature records.http://berkeleyearth.org/results-summary/

However some "skeptics" reject the evidence of man made global warming and dismiss it as mindless dogma of marxist lefties or liberal brainwashing or chicken little alarmism, and show little understanding of the science. It is quite reasonable to think that this rejection is based more on an ideologically driven conspiricist POV rather than critical thinking.

For anyone who's interested here's a rather long article, actually a book chapter, "The Scientific Consensus on Climate Change: How Do We Know We’re Not Wrong?"
http://www.ametsoc.org/atmospolicy/documents/chapter4.pdf
and an introduction to the science
http://www.windows2universe.org/earth/climate/greenhouse_effect_gases.html

though any discussion of the science should be taken to the thread on the science sub forum
 
Travis & DC

You will note that Robert ignored your fine posts. He asks question solely to ignore the results or dismiss them.

Remember you are dealing with a denying troll - who doesn't have a clue about the subject
 
Addressing the OP original question:

Is Global Warming Denialism a conspiracy theory or a religion?

is on its face a fallacious question -- an example of the False Dilemma fallacy.

Fact is, a belief that there is no global warming or at least no solid evidence of man made global warming is quite possibly a legitimate theory, and not a conspiracy nor a religion. Perhaps the OP, Gawdzilla, would care to reconsider this fallacious question or offer proof that such belief is indeed either a conspiracy or a religion. But I sort of doubt it.

Baloney with a cherry on top
 
20 years ago it would have been possible to argue that much of the rejection of the theory of AGW was based on genuine skepticism, but all the efforts of the contrarians to falsify the theory have failed and those genuine skeptics who have looked at the evidence of man made global warming have concluded that it is solid and needs to be taken seriously.


"Climate Science vs Politics: The Road Ahead
By S. Fred Singer​

"There is good news and bad news about climate. The good news is that science evidence has made it quite clear that the human contribution to a possible global warming is minor; in fact it cannot even be identified in the data record. The bad news is that the media and politicians pay no attention whatsoever to the science and are marching ahead full-speed with efforts to control CO2 emissions -- thereby hurting the economy, destroying jobs, and stunting economic growth. They are under the illusion that there is a nearly complete scientific consensus in support of catastrophic anthropogenic global warming (CAGW)."

S. Fred Singer is professor emeritus at the University of Virginia and director of the Science & Environmental Policy Project. His specialty is atmospheric and space physics. An expert in remote sensing and satellites, he served as the founding director of the US Weather Satellite Service and, more recently, as vice chair of the US National Advisory Committee on Oceans & Atmosphere.


http://www.americanthinker.com/2012/12/climate_science_vs_politics_the_road_ahead.html
 
Last edited:
singer can hardly be taken as an unbiased source

http://www.sourcewatch.org/index.php?title=S._Fred_Singer

" Climate Change "Expert"

In the early 1990s, while officially "on leave" from the University of Virginia, Singer set up the Washington Institute for Values in Public Policy with the help of the Alexis de Tocqueville Institution and with funding support from the Unification Church (also known as "Moonies," followers of the Rev. Sun Myung Moon, founder of the Unification Church).

This organisation worked closely with Elizabeth Whelan and Frederick Stare's American Council on Science and Health in countering climate activism as it related to the chemical industry.[9] Later Singer's organisation changed into the Science and Environmental Policy Project with funding from the coal and oil industries and some support from PR firm APCO & Associates.2
 
I thought it was his most reasonable post yet, but that's not saying much:D

Howdy

You should go back and read his first posts were he put the Vatican into the same category on warming as.....

/Man made Global Warming is the mindless dogma of Marxist Lefties intent on extracting wealth from the haves to the benefit of the have nots and and their middlemen. In other words, another attempted reason for under color of law Theft. But since the past decade has cooled, the Global Warming Chicken Littles now prefer the safer name "Climate Change" since they can hardly go wrong with that title. As if climate has ever stopped changing.

He ignored my question about the Vatican......and conceded the point!

He concedes most everything...he even conceded that he is in fact a communist ........lol
 
Travis & DC

You will note that Robert ignored your fine posts. He asks question solely to ignore the results or dismiss them.

Remember you are dealing with a denying troll - who doesn't have a clue about the subject

i know, but the lurkers are still reading. ;)
 
it is beyoind me why people that dont accept AGW or are not fully convinced of it would even go near a guy like Singer.
i mean there are real active scientists still working and publishing in the field that argue against AGW and while they might seem a little lunatic they are 100000000 times better than singer.
Why don't they use people like Spencer, Christy , Svensmark , Lindzen or Curry.
while they might have some strange ideas, they are still somewhat credible, and they are not widely known for getting their money from lobbys.

and some use even strange people as Singer. atleast Singer does not deny the greenhouse effect itself.
i dont get that.
when i was a 9/11 CT nutter, i avoided using nutters like AJ or David Icke ... ok i used other nutters, but i eventually realized it and changed my position :D but i atleast tried to use the most credible sources that argued what i wanted to argue :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom