Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
So if I build a machine to automate a simple mindless job, I am evil now?

I don't know. Are you actually talking about a machine to lighten the burden of having to perform a simple mindless job day in and day out, or are you talking of a machine to lighten the expenses of factury owner for the wages of workers performing simple mindless jobs?
For some weird reason the act of depriving people of their livelihood is usually referred to with very different words.

That is the legal term for what is being done.

Yes, maybe it is. Where did they take him?

It is rather like "Assault? I just slapped that bastard"

No, it isn't.
 
Similar polls in France have given the same results. About 50% to 60% of people disapprove but understand, while the other half totally disapprove.

Being French, I'd like to point out something, which does not justify but might at least partly explains the authorities leniency regarding bossnapping.

Demonstrating, protesting, and the "common people against the elite" is an important foundation myth of the Nation and the Republic, coming from the French Revolution. There is a massive emphasis in education and more generally in public life on symbols from that era.

After all, Bastille day, the French national holiday, celebrates the storming of the Bastille prison by an angry mob, which spent the rest of the day parading in Paris with the severed head of the prison governor on a pike. Well in fact it celebrates a federation/union/reconciliation feast one year after the event at the Bastille but it is ignored by most people.

I have the impression that Americans gives much more importance to personnal freedom, which can be traced back to the foundation of the country, from the Frontier pioneer to the self made man.

I am not saying that personnal freedoms are bad, but that in the French collective unconscious "rising against the aristocrats" is more present that preserving the individual freedom of everyone.

(I have a lot more to say but it is harder to convey in English that it would be in French :))
 
Last edited:
Is that in the US? I didn't think there was a Western democracy left that didn't have mandatory vacation time. Looking at some of the information it appears you might be right though.

Yes, I'm in the U.S., and my employer is an international corporation (I know of offices in 39 countries).

If the gummint has decreed by law that there shall be specific days for all employees to have off, then I'm not aware of them.
 
... Are you actually talking about a machine to lighten the burden of having to perform a simple mindless job day in and day out, or are you talking of a machine to lighten the expenses of factury owner for the wages of workers performing simple mindless jobs?

What's the difference? None that I can see. Lowering production costs is more important to the profit margin than providing charity for drone-workers.

And that's what running a business is all about - maximizing profits.
 
Last edited:
Morality survey: Is bossnapping OK?


No. Sleeping on the job is unacceptable, and the boss should lead by example. If you catch your Boss napping you should be fully entitled to wake him or her in whatever unpleasant way you wish.
 
What's the difference? None that I can see. Lowering production costs is more important to the profit margin than providing charity for drone-workers.

And that's what running a business is all about - maximizing profits.
Definitely what the stockholders legally expect.
 
Some of the people trying to excuse this will try to justify the Somali Pirates for their next act.....
 
Yes, maybe it is. Where did they take him?

I think you need to re-read the thread. I had the same argument, that it wasn't technically kidnapping, but Wildcat posted a legal definition for kidnapping that covered what happened here.

Maybe you can find the actual French law in question, but until then, the evidence is on the side of calling it kidnapping.
 
Some of the people trying to excuse this will try to justify the Somali Pirates for their next act.....

I suppose it's a derail, but I'm definitely on the 'condemn but understand' side on that.

It's definitely something I want stopped, but it's not like the Somalis can go to the local temp agency and get a job to support them going to tech school and earn a living. Grinding poverty tends to increase my sympathies. Not to the point I think they shouldn't be shot the second they attack a vessel, but I get why they do it.
 
http://www.straitstimes.com/Breaking+News/World/Story/STIStory_361079.html

'They are free to come and go within the site, but not to leave it,' a union official told AFP.

http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2009/apr/08/bossnapping-france-scapa

He described the hostage taking as a "non-aggressive action", adding that the unions had brought the four managers dinner.

http://www.google.com/hostednews/afp/article/ALeqM5jIIM90WyRdtmDowkRXClzkxsM7Xg

"It's true that this might seem surprising abroad, but it's less surprising in France, where we're more used to this kind of situation," said a Sony spokeswoman.

This article points out that the workers withheld food from the boss until he partially agreed to their demands. This seems to be bordering on going too far, but the article doesn't offer much detail. If he had been there a few hours before capitulating, or even for most of the night, that's more discomfort than serious.

After reading a bunch more of these articles, I will attempt to sum up position, lest people continue to somehow compare this to the Somali pirates:

1) It has to be understood in its cultural context. It has happened regularly in France since 1968, and is usually the final measure in a stalled negotiation.

2) I have found no evidence that anyone has ever been remotely harmed. In fact, if you read the articles, the spokespeople for management dismiss it as nothing to get worked up about.

3) It seems to be happening more frequently and President Sarkozy has denounced it. This at least leaves open the potential that it could become something more than harmless theatre. If and when it does, I'm sure there will be arrests and some sort of backlash.

If someone has any evidence at all that this tactic is anything more than drama, please share it. But all of this exaggerated outrage and wimpy hyperbole is getting a little tiresome.
 
1) It has to be understood in its cultural context. It has happened regularly in France since 1968, and is usually the final measure in a stalled negotiation.

I think we should still be able to criticise despite cultural context (for example, I reserve the right to criticise Iran for hanging homosexuals from cranes) (Or prior to 1918 in the "West" women did not have, and had never had, the vote... did that make it right to deny them the suffrage?).

2) I have found no evidence that anyone has ever been remotely harmed. In fact, if you read the articles, the spokespeople for management dismiss it as nothing to get worked up about.

Perhaps they are in negotiations and do not wish to get even more aggro from their negotiating partners? (Especially if the public/government/police is not behind them to the extent that they would be in America)

3) It seems to be happening more frequently and President Sarkozy has denounced it. This at least leaves open the potential that it could become something more than harmless theatre. If and when it does, I'm sure there will be arrests and some sort of backlash.

For all the "it's just harmless theatre", people have been held against their will by the threat of force... all that means is that they should be charged with kidnapping rather than kidnapping and bodily harm.
 
For all the "it's just harmless theatre", people have been held against their will by the threat of force... all that means is that they should be charged with kidnapping rather than kidnapping and bodily harm.

I'm still not seeing this as anything more than a protest. At worse, forced negotiations.

I'm curious how binding and negotiations made this way would be? Seems to me the boss could simply agree to everything and leave, then get the courts to nullify the contract. The fact that they don't suggests the bosses are willing participants or have something to hide.
 
I think we should still be able to criticise despite cultural context (for example, I reserve the right to criticise Iran for hanging homosexuals from cranes) (Or prior to 1918 in the "West" women did not have, and had never had, the vote... did that make it right to deny them the suffrage?).

Really, is the poin that tough? It is ok because it's a cultural tradition, it's an ok cultural tradition because it isn't that big of a deal. People on the board were supplying their concept of "kidnapping" and reacting like scared toddlers. The point is that our understanding of what was going on was incorrect. You have to actually study the specifics of what is happening.

The activities in Iran are, themselves, violent and reprehensible. The comparisson is more hysteria from this side of the argument. For once I would enjoy a constuctive point instead of insane exaggeration: Pirates, hanging homosexuals, the right to vote...


Perhaps they are in negotiations and do not wish to get even more aggro from their negotiating partners? (Especially if the public/government/police is not behind them to the extent that they would be in America)

Please. They eat dinner with their "kidnappers." It's not like an anonymous group of assailants. If it were a big deal every single one of those workers would be arrested.

Once again, you guys need to actually supply facts. I know I'm asking a lot, but if you could show a single arrest or injury or even a boss complaining about the inconvenience, you might be able to build some semblance of an argument.

For all the "it's just harmless theatre", people have been held against their will by the threat of force... all that means is that they should be charged with kidnapping rather than kidnapping and bodily harm.

Once again, nonsensical fear-mongering. Read the damn articles. In most of them they park trucks in front of site's exit. There's no force, it's an understanding, hence, theater. If the bosses were desperate to leave they could, and if it is a worry, why has no one been arrested? Not a single one of you has tried to answer that question. Please, take a shot, a "crime" is being commited. The facts of the scenario aren't in question, the identity of the perpetrators isn't in question, why no arrests?
 
If my employees kidnapped me, I'd gladly see them hauled off to jail for their criminal trials. Then I'd file civil suits against each one for "pain and duress" and settle for nothing less than everything they own.

But of course, this is in America, the country that has twice bailed France out after their leadership has surrendered to foreign powers. It's no surprise that the French teach their business leaders to capitulate to to workers' demands, just as it's no surprise that American business leaders rarely allow their businesses to be held hostage by workers - even unionism is losing it's hold here!
 
If my employees kidnapped me, I'd gladly see them hauled off to jail for their criminal trials. Then I'd file civil suits against each one for "pain and duress" and settle for nothing less than everything they own.

But of course, this is in America, the country that has twice bailed France out after their leadership has surrendered to foreign powers. It's no surprise that the French teach their business leaders to capitulate to to workers' demands, just as it's no surprise that American business leaders rarely allow their businesses to be held hostage by workers - even unionism is losing it's hold here!

And the fact that they don't do that in France tells you they don't approach the issue with the same humorless self-righteousness.
 
TraneWreck -- I just want to be clear, here: You're okay with people violating other people's freedoms, as long as there's a cultural tradition of it?

I'm not. I don't care how many "colored" schools, bus seats, bathrooms, or ballparks were in the American South--it was and is wrong to deny people the right to come and go where they please, as long as they're not committing a crime or violating someone's property rights. I don't care how long the Prophet's followers have decreed that women should not travel without their husband, father, or brother with them: It's wrong for those people to be denied the right to come and go as they see fit.

Whether you think the workers whose jobs have been threatened have a legitimate complaint or not, the method is invalid. Somehow, this point seems to be a big divider for some folks here.

If you think that imprisoning the worker's rep would be wrong, you should think that the imprisoning the management rep is equally wrong. Or, you think that the Ends Justifies the Means, in which case you have surrendered the entire issue of use of force to anyone who can "justify" their cause.

That the French government does not press charges is sad; that they demonstrably do not do so explains why there are no arrests. Your assertion that "the bosses could leave if they wanted to" and others assertions that "the bosses will easily get another job" and "made millions" are unsupported by evidence at this time.

The second, underlying issue here is a big difference between--broadly--North American and European worldviews. You don't have a right to any particular job. The grand tradition of Hiring For Life does not exist on this side of the Atlantic. Not that there aren't lifetime employees; but that is based upon the employee wanting to stay, and the employer wanting him/her to stay.

The European system (and some American union contracts) make firing an employee so punative that it's literally cheaper and easier to pay someone to be unproductive than to go through the exhausting, expensive, and difficult process of firing them. The tradeoff is that the "standing" unemployment rate in Europe for most of the last 30 years has been 10% or higher, and in some countries, twice that. The cost of living and taxation rates are also enormously higher than here, and on the whole Europeans are fine with that. They're happy to trade the opportunity to make free choices and take their own risks for the security blanket of the government and employer -provided benefits for those lucky enough to be inside the cocoon.

The citizens of Community Europe who didn't like that approach to life, who value freedom over security and realized that you cannot have freedom to succeed without also having the possibility and consequences of failure, left Europe--and came here.

It is a worldview difference. Fnord eloquently stated the core American view: that violating one's personal freedom is both a crime and a tort, and one of the gravest of crimes. Europeans prefer to excuse it as a "social tradition" or just "the way the game is played", and not deal with it on a principle level.

It has been an enlightening exercise in seeing why the Bill of Rights was written, and is the core of America's continuing existance. By protecting the freedom of individuals from the viewpoint of the majority, even as embodied in the elected representatives of that minority, the Constitution defends us against violations that were undreamt-of when the document was written.
 
See, I'm perfectly happy with TraneWreck's "cultural tradition" excuse. It speaks directly to my first post in this thread: The French have a cultural tradition of being jerks.
 
TraneWreck -- I just want to be clear, here: You're okay with people violating other people's freedoms, as long as there's a cultural tradition of it?

This is melodramatic and non-responsive. I've posted my view, supported it with articles that discuss what's going on, and explained that the French don't view it as a big deal. You've just reiterated your exaggerated misinterpretation of the tradition.

What world do you live where this is a violation of other people's freedoms? I can see the tears in your eyes and the handwringing as you write that, but again, find me an injury, arrest, or even voicing of mild complaint by the detained managers.

The French have a 40 year established practice of this activity, and no one has ever been hurt, as best as I can determine. You're going into histrionics because someone loses a night's sleep. Amazing.

I'm not. I don't care how many "colored" schools, bus seats, bathrooms, or ballparks were in the American South--it was and is wrong to deny people the right to come and go where they please, as long as they're not committing a crime or violating someone's property rights. I don't care how long the Prophet's followers have decreed that women should not travel without their husband, father, or brother with them: It's wrong for those people to be denied the right to come and go as they see fit.

Time and time again the folks posting on this thread have blown this practice so far out of proportion that it borders on insanity. So far it's been compared to piracy, Iran hanging homosexuals, women not being able to vote, and to add a cherry to this massive, steaming ******** sunday, it's compared to Jim Crow laws. Unless you guys are playing an elaborate joke on me, this is the lamest, most overblown nonsense I've seen on this board, including the 9-11 tards.

Lynchings, beatings, church burnings, dogs attacking children, segregation was not just an afront to the concept of equality, it was violent, brutal repression. Did you read the article where the workers brought their bosses dinner as they continued the negotiations?

At some point you're going to have to deal with the facts, and they're all against you.

Whether you think the workers whose jobs have been threatened have a legitimate complaint or not, the method is invalid. Somehow, this point seems to be a big divider for some folks here.

If you think that imprisoning the worker's rep would be wrong, you should think that the imprisoning the management rep is equally wrong. Or, you think that the Ends Justifies the Means, in which case you have surrendered the entire issue of use of force to anyone who can "justify" their cause.

Haha, who are you? As I said earlier, if a country had a tradition similar in every way except it was the union reps that were held, I wouldn't really care. This is harmless.

That being said, you're completely ignoring the massive disparity in bargaining power, and the historical coersion used by managers against workers.

http://libcom.org/news/report-workers-rights-120606

This is a modern assessment, so it can't deal with the legacy of violent labor suppression, like this:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ludlow_Massacre

But no, forcing an employer to lose a night's sleep is just as bad, sweet argument.


That the French government does not press charges is sad; that they demonstrably do not do so explains why there are no arrests. Your assertion that "the bosses could leave if they wanted to" and others assertions that "the bosses will easily get another job" and "made millions" are unsupported by evidence at this time.

Where exactly did I write that? You're using quotes around things I've never said. So in addition to overly dramatic, I will add confused or dishonest to your argumentative style.

What I will say is that these bosses could 1) hire private security 2) press charges 3) lobby the government for stricter penalties 4) try to leave, if violence was used to keep them to stay, the practice would end tomorrow 5) fire everyone involved in the activity, instead of hiring them back and continuing to work with them and 6) complain about somewhere instead of having their spokespeople describe it as nothing to worry about.

Given that they have done NONE of these things, it's safe to conclude that they aren't too upset about it. Don't you think there'd at least be an editorial or two?

The second, underlying issue here is a big difference between--broadly--North American and European worldviews. You don't have a right to any particular job. The grand tradition of Hiring For Life does not exist on this side of the Atlantic. Not that there aren't lifetime employees; but that is based upon the employee wanting to stay, and the employer wanting him/her to stay.

The European system (and some American union contracts) make firing an employee so punative that it's literally cheaper and easier to pay someone to be unproductive than to go through the exhausting, expensive, and difficult process of firing them. The tradeoff is that the "standing" unemployment rate in Europe for most of the last 30 years has been 10% or higher, and in some countries, twice that. The cost of living and taxation rates are also enormously higher than here, and on the whole Europeans are fine with that. They're happy to trade the opportunity to make free choices and take their own risks for the security blanket of the government and employer -provided benefits for those lucky enough to be inside the cocoon.

A poor summation of the issues, to say the least, but completely irrelevant to the topic at hand. If you want to discuss labor theory and the difference between Eurpoe and the US, start a new thread.

The citizens of Community Europe who didn't like that approach to life, who value freedom over security and realized that you cannot have freedom to succeed without also having the possibility and consequences of failure, left Europe--and came here.

It is a worldview difference. Fnord eloquently stated the core American view: that violating one's personal freedom is both a crime and a tort, and one of the gravest of crimes. Europeans prefer to excuse it as a "social tradition" or just "the way the game is played", and not deal with it on a principle level.

It has been an enlightening exercise in seeing why the Bill of Rights was written, and is the core of America's continuing existance. By protecting the freedom of individuals from the viewpoint of the majority, even as embodied in the elected representatives of that minority, the Constitution defends us against violations that were undreamt-of when the document was written.

Well, thank you for that rambling, stream of consciousness babble about the Bill of Rights and other assorted nonsense.

I might partially take you seriously if you bothered to insert A SINGLE FACT about the situation. Your just spinning in the wind and getting hysterical over a relatively harmless activity. Your words are so choked with a maudlin, misplaced incoherence that it's hard to imagine you're even talking about the same events as the ones published in all of those articles I linked.
 
See, I'm perfectly happy with TraneWreck's "cultural tradition" excuse. It speaks directly to my first post in this thread: The French have a cultural tradition of being jerks.

Awesome reading comprehension.

Again, the fact that it is a tradition does not make it harmless, the fact that it's a harmless tradition makes it not worth worrying about.

But I guess you'd rather advance tired stereotypes from the post-war era in an attempt at humorous pith.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom