Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
Why how much paid holiday is the compulsory minimum in the states? Is it less than 28 days???

cj x

My company gives new hires 17 days (7 holiday and 10 vacation). Having 10 years with the company I am at max time off of 27 (7 holiday and 20 vacation)
 
Here's a "serious" defense: It's a mostly harmless publicity stunt. The boss isn't going to harmed, he isn't a hostage in any real sense, it's just a way to spice up the protest.

I was in Paris a few years ago when they were having one of their endless strikes. They had a protest march down the Champs Elysees. The protesters were smiling and playing music and giving food and drinks to the officers policing the activity. It wasn't like a protest in the US, with rubber bullets and tear gas, it was a national game, of sorts.

I think the poll is too vague. Actually holding the boss hostage under the threat of some harm is always unacceptible, but what's going on in most of these cases is just theatre.
 
How is this actually handled by the justice system in France? Do bossnappers face any serious legal consequences?

I assume it would not happen very often if it was treated as a serious felony that could land you in prison for many years. The identities of the culprits are known.
 
Here's a "serious" defense: It's a mostly harmless publicity stunt. The boss isn't going to harmed, he isn't a hostage in any real sense, it's just a way to spice up the protest.

I was in Paris a few years ago when they were having one of their endless strikes. They had a protest march down the Champs Elysees. The protesters were smiling and playing music and giving food and drinks to the officers policing the activity. It wasn't like a protest in the US, with rubber bullets and tear gas, it was a national game, of sorts.

I think the poll is too vague. Actually holding the boss hostage under the threat of some harm is always unacceptible, but what's going on in most of these cases is just theatre.
Assuming the boss is one of the actors by choice, fine.
 
Here's a "serious" defense: It's a mostly harmless publicity stunt. The boss isn't going to harmed, he isn't a hostage in any real sense, it's just a way to spice up the protest.
So the boss can leave any time he wants, then?

I was in Paris a few years ago when they were having one of their endless strikes. They had a protest march down the Champs Elysees. The protesters were smiling and playing music and giving food and drinks to the officers policing the activity. It wasn't like a protest in the US, with rubber bullets and tear gas, it was a national game, of sorts.
Peaceful protests happen all the time in the US. Conversely, France has had many protests in recent years that have turned disturbingly violent and destructive. You might want to reconsider your stereotypes.
 
Assuming the boss is one of the actors by choice, fine.

Even if they aren't, it's not that big of a deal. They just sit in their office overnight and drink coffee with a few of their workers.

There has to be some perspective to these things. I'm sure the boss didn't give them the "ok" to hold them hostage, but it's a tradition with a set of rules and guidelines. If you can find me an example of someone being harmed any more seriously than losing some sleep, I might be more drawn to the horrified reactions in this thread.
 
So the boss can leave any time he wants, then?

You're just being silly. Of course they're being "held," but it isn't that serious. No one gets hurt, and the boss goes back to work with the employees. If it such a horrific activity, one would imagine some sort of armed guard or national response, but the bosses just sit in a room and munch some croissant for the night.

Peaceful protests happen all the time in the US. Conversely, France has had many protests in recent years that have turned disturbingly violent and destructive. You might want to reconsider your stereotypes.

Sure, not all protests in America are violent, and not all protests in France are peaceful. That's why you have to judge the activities independently. "Kidnapping" in this sense is very different from what the Somali pirates are doing right now.

I was simply adding some context. There is a long tradition of strikes and protests in France that are handled quite calmly. This doesn't mean that everything is peaceful, but it might help temper some of the outrage over the word "kidnap."
 
kidnap isn't appropriate anyway, since it requires moving the victim to another location. This would be unlawful imprisonment or somesuch.
 
My impression is that it was a group, not one person. Groups have a way of becoming mobs. I do not plan to die or be injured because someone else is distraught - unless the nature of the distraught leads me to CHOOSE to put myself in danger.

A group? Oh man you'd be so screwed. All they would do is say they feared for their lives because their supervisor carried a concealed weapon to work all the time.

A supervisor carrying a concealed weapon to work is about the only way I can legitimize kidnapping them. If I had a group of people I would be even more justified.
 
You're just being silly. Of course they're being "held," but it isn't that serious. No one gets hurt, and the boss goes back to work with the employees. If it such a horrific activity, one would imagine some sort of armed guard or national response, but the bosses just sit in a room and munch some croissant for the night.
Ah. I get it now. It's one of those compulsory midnight tea parties where you get beaten up if you try to leave early.

If these little soirees are so awsome, how come the manager and his employees don't hold them every night? How come the manager doesn't lock the front doors once a week or so, and insist that his staff spend the night in the office with him, sucking down workplace coffee, eating stale croissants, and wishing they were at home in their beds asleep with their loved ones?

Protip: Because it's actually not very awsome at all. Which is exactly why we're against it.
 
France is actually doing extremely well economically though compared with Britain and the USA? And these are the normal working conditions in almost every civilized nation - "The average leave and public holiday entitlements across all EU states is 34 days. The UK and Netherlands provide just 28 days off while Ireland gives 29. At the other extreme, Greece, Austria, and Finland provide the most time off - 37, 38 and 39 days respectively." This is paid holiday - paid bereavement, sickness and maternity leave are in addition. source: http://www.prnewswire.co.uk/cgi/news/release?id=106596 Most of these countries are performing well enough economically, compared to the USA and Japan? Dunno.

Why how much paid holiday is the compulsory minimum in the states? Is it less than 28 days???

cj x

At my old job I had a week off. Holidays were normal but you got paid more.
 
I wonder if this was being done by someone on the right if Trainwreck would be just as understanding.
Then there is the factor that if people get away with one thing, the next time..or the time after that...they will try to get away with something more radical.
 
Here's a "serious" defense: It's a mostly harmless publicity stunt. The boss isn't going to harmed, he isn't a hostage in any real sense, it's just a way to spice up the protest.

He is a hostage in the real sense. Unless you have very specific legal status you any forceably holding someone against their will is kidnapping. It is entirely possible for EMT's to get into trouble for taking sick people to the hospital for kidnapping if they did not want to go.
 
Why how much paid holiday is the compulsory minimum in the states? Is it less than 28 days???

Compulsory paid holidays? D'you mean as in, "Required by law"? I don't think there are any. All the holidays I've ever been awarded seem to have been at the discretion of my employers. Then again, I've worked so long for this employer that I accrue about 6 weeks of discretionary vacation time each year (a little over 240 hours per year).
 
Even if they aren't, it's not that big of a deal. They just sit in their office overnight and drink coffee with a few of their workers.

It is legally kidnapping though. When do you consider it forceably holding someone against their will kidnapping or not?
 
It is legally kidnapping though. When do you consider it forceably holding someone against their will kidnapping or not?

I suspect that it would not be "kidnapping" as that implies abduction, rather you're looking at a matter of "false imprisonment" (the French equivalent anyway), it's a bit like the difference between robbery and theft, it doesn't excuse it though.
 
As I've said before, once in this thread and once in the other, no.

Under almost all definitions kidnapping requires the victim be transported from one location to another. Being held in the same building you already were in is not kidnapping.

http://legal-dictionary.thefreedictionary.com/Kidnapping

See

(a) Whoever unlawfully seizes, confines, inveigles, decoys,
kidnaps, abducts, or carries away and holds for ransom or reward or
otherwise any person, except in the case of a minor by the parent
thereof, when -
(1) the person is willfully transported in interstate or
foreign commerce, regardless of whether the person was alive when
transported across a State boundary if the person was alive when
the transportation began;
(2) any such act against the person is done within the special
maritime and territorial jurisdiction of the United States;
(3) any such act against the person is done within the special
aircraft jurisdiction of the United States as defined in section
46501 of title 49;
(4) the person is a foreign official, an internationally
protected person, or an official guest as those terms are defined
in section 1116(b) of this title; or
(5) the person is among those officers and employees described
in section 1114 of this title and any such act against the person
is done while the person is engaged in, or on account of, the
performance of official duties,

shall be punished by imprisonment for any term of years or for life
and, if the death of any person results, shall be punished by death
or life imprisonment.

No specific provision in federal law to say that you have to transport someone instead of just holding them against their will.

link
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom