Is bossnapping OK?

Is kidnapping your boss, to try and save your job, acceptable?

  • Yes. Desperate times, desperate measures

    Votes: 18 15.0%
  • No. Taking someone hostage is a step too far

    Votes: 102 85.0%

  • Total voters
    120
Is that in the US? I didn't think there was a Western democracy left that didn't have mandatory vacation time. Looking at some of the information it appears you might be right though.

I have mandatory vacation time of 125 hours a year and many employers supply more through exchange of bonus for time off (and vice versa).

There are federal holidays were you either get the day off, or paid extra for working.

Now many jobs give vacation time, I have federal holidays, 2 weeks vacation, and personal/sick days that together would add up to over 125 hours.
 
Presumably the bosses will be getting paid double time for those periods during which their employees incarcerate them; so what are they complaining about?
Here's wishing you the best on your incarceration, when you advance to that point ;)
 
That seems to be not an exemption for when people die, the criminals still committed a crime. If it was what you ment, then kidnapping would only be a federal crime if a boarder was crossed.
And a cross boarder is not to be laughed at. Might just hit you!!
 
So this poll/thread is a result of my incredulity at the results of the Guardian's poll on whether bossnapping is a protest too far, where 48% think it is fine.
I'm still incredulous that these rocket surgeons think that assaulting and imprisoning your boss is a good way to keep your job. France must truly be bizarro world.
 
Tranewreck -- Would you be okay with someone not letting you leave your office--or even your room--when you wished to do so? You'd be okay with someone not letting you leave the elevator? Or even the Men's room??

I don't think, if you were suddenly not allowed your freedom, that you'd think it was just "good theater". Not if it was your family commitment, hot dinner, meeting with friends, or chance to sleep that was suddenly denied to you. Not if your kid was the one waiting, wondering why Daddy didn't come home tonight...

I'm amazed that anyone thinks this is okay. I'm amazed the French goverment is not considered to be in violation of EU law by not trying to prosecute under "unlawful imprisonment" or kidnapping or whatever the equivalent is.

Let's try it this way: Workers want to go on strike. Bosses take union leader and sit him down in their office to "drink coffee and eat croissants" all night; don't let him go home. Is THAT okay with you, Tranewreck??

Just wondering, MK
 
There is no compulsory minimum in the states. I'd guess the standard for PTO is 2 weeks.
Actually, there's no real way to compare. Most positions do not have a fixed PTO. For hourly and non-executive salaried employees, PTO is typically accumulated based on time worked. The accumulation rate varies; but typically ranges from 80 hours to 160 hours a year for a full-time position, cumulative YoY, often with a cap; based on a 40 hour work week. In addition, most companies also include a minimum of 4 paid holidays a year, typically more; and a certain amount of unearned, non-cumulative PTO, aka "sick leave", usually between 3 and 5 days.
 
Not when you account for the intent requirement: "with the intent thereby to force the victim, or some other person, to give up anything of apparent present or prospective value, or to grant any advantage or immunity, in order to secure a release of the person under the offender's actual or apparent control". So luring someone to your used car lot isn't kidnapping unless you force them to buy a car.

IIRC, the target of that provision is most likely the persuasian or coercion of underage individuals, who cannot legally give informed consent.
 
Tranewreck -- Would you be okay with someone not letting you leave your office--or even your room--when you wished to do so? You'd be okay with someone not letting you leave the elevator? Or even the Men's room??

I don't think, if you were suddenly not allowed your freedom, that you'd think it was just "good theater". Not if it was your family commitment, hot dinner, meeting with friends, or chance to sleep that was suddenly denied to you. Not if your kid was the one waiting, wondering why Daddy didn't come home tonight...

I'm amazed that anyone thinks this is okay. I'm amazed the French goverment is not considered to be in violation of EU law by not trying to prosecute under "unlawful imprisonment" or kidnapping or whatever the equivalent is.

Let's try it this way: Workers want to go on strike. Bosses take union leader and sit him down in their office to "drink coffee and eat croissants" all night; don't let him go home. Is THAT okay with you, Tranewreck??

Just wondering, MK

If I owned a business, was in negotiations with my workers, and knew of the French tradition of "bossnapping," I would be mildly annoyed at losing a night's sleep. That's it.

It's amazing how overblown this criticism is. Yes, sometimes things happen in the world such that I cannot go exactly where I want, exactly when I want. These circumstances can range from tolerable to horrific. On a scale from "I can't get on the bus right away because there's someone with a wheelchair in front of me" to "I'm in a guy-pile in GITMO with electrodes strapped to my balls," bossnapping is about two notches above the bus.

It just isn't a big deal. If it were so horrific, don't you think the captains of industry in France would invest more time in keeping it from happening? Private guards, lobbying for legal changes, pressing charges against their "assailants?"

Edit: and as for your question, which has a whiff of trying to pin me down as some unquestioning commie union supporter, I would say it depends on how it's done. Confrontations over labor can be incredibly brutal (though history has shown us that 99% of the deaths in labor disputes are suffered by the workers), so one would have to examine the situation. If Denmark had a non-violent, almost cordial tradition like the French, save the bosses took the union boss hostage, I wouldn't really have a problem. If it was somehow used to intimidate and threaten, more than harmlessly and dramatically posture, then something would have to be done. It really isn't that complex.
 
Last edited:
According to Tranewreck, it's because it's fun to hang out at the office all night with your co-workers^H^H^Ha bunch of people you just laid off, drinking coffee and eating croissants!

Hilarious! You can't read! Funny stuff.

Haha, how many people have been arrested for this? Must be hundreds because it's such a big deal.
 
Then there is the factor that if people get away with one thing, the next time..or the time after that...they will try to get away with something more radical.

There's a first time for everything, and I never thought that I would agree with dudalb about anything, but it's true, you shouldn't let capitalism get away with this: "French workers threatened with redundancy have been taking their bosses hostage in an effort to save their jobs ". Faced with threats like this, you have to try to teach the CEOs a lesson, or they won't consider it twice the next time they feel like lowering your wages or laying you off, i.e. taking away from you your income, your livelihood.

The problem, however, is that in this situation there is no real way of pressurizing the employers into anything so the protest of taking the boss 'hostage' will be in vain. It merely works as a publicity stunt. A strike is useful only because you know that the factory owner's interest in profit will make him want to keep the wheels turning. As long as they don't, he doesn't earn anything because he cannot supply the market with goods. However, as soon as the demand for his goods declines and he cannot sell as much as he used to, the workers no longer have any means of pressurizing him. Therefor this futile protest: The workers are impotent against the powers of capital - unless, of course, they decide to do away with capitalism, which is the only real solution to the predicament of all workers faced with a threat like this.
But what dudalb didn't mean to imply is still true: You should not let bosses get away with making threats like this!

Recommended reading:
The Strike at AEG
Resistance to Mass Layoffs
Why wage sacrifice leads to ever more wage loss
Labor Unions
Wage reduction made in the USA
 
I'm still incredulous that these rocket surgeons think that assaulting and imprisoning your boss is a good way to keep your job. France must truly be bizarro world.

No, I guess that the kind of quiescent, well-behaved resignation of US employees is the way to keep your job in the real, proper world outside of 'bizarro' France, right?
Guess again! Guess again!
 
I didnt vote.
I find it somehow wrong, somehow not.

I can understand it somehow.

The hard working people that have nothing to say about the companys strategy or developement. loose their jobs and get nothing.
The management, especially the CEO also looses his job, but after he earned millions, and he will still get a compensation of some millions......

aslong such theft is regarded legal and moraly ok i have no problem with people force the CEO to negotioation.
 
Did you ever see the movie about this theme?
White Man's Burden.
(The first link doesn't seem to work, so I'll try again: White Man's Burden. And here's Roger Ebert's version.)

For some reason ruining people's lives by making them redundant isn't a felony. Locking a boss in his office is. Whether anybody is angry or not really doesn't affect anything, does it?
So at least to me the point isn't that locking the boss in his office is unacceptable. The point is that as a means of securing your livelihood it's inefficient.
I've been locked in (and out of) my high school a couple of times by students protesting against government cutbacks. It did not bother me much - mainly because I tended to agree with them. Didn't achieve much, though ...
And right-wing drama queens immediately start talking about kidnapping! Get real, won't you?!!! He wasn't held for ransom money, was he?
 
Last edited:
I didnt vote.
I find it somehow wrong, somehow not.

I can understand it somehow.

The hard working people that have nothing to say about the companys strategy or developement. loose their jobs and get nothing.
The management, especially the CEO also looses his job, but after he earned millions, and he will still get a compensation of some millions......

aslong such theft is regarded legal and moraly ok i have no problem with people force the CEO to negotioation.

I cannot agree more. If the CEO looses his job, he'll have a new one in no time plus all his compensation fees. That doesn't feel right. On the other hand it won't make any difference for your own job anyway, these people won't stop taking such actions.

I have the impression that here in Europe people value their job at a specific firm more than in the US. You don't change jobs every five years here, people easily stay with the same company for their whole life. I'm not sure about the reasons. You do get rewarded for staying, like extra days off after some years, which you loose if you switch jobs. Also you pay huge taxes when buying a new house (at least here in Belgium) so you won't do that often. All this might explain stronger reactions when something happens to "your" company.

Personally I do have some problems with the behavior of the Unions here who seem to go on strike for about any reason. As if the management cares about that. What if you go on strike for two weeks: all financial losses come back at the workers too in the end! That's bad for the survival of the company. If there is a real problem for the company I prefer the management to take though decisions and keep the company alive instead of going bankrupt.

As with many things it comes down to finding a good balance between safeguarding some privileges for workers and not impairing the economy too much. I feel hijacking the boss is tipping the balance too much to one side.
 
And right-wing drama queens immediately start talking about kidnapping! Get real, won't you?!!! He wasn't held for ransom money, was he?

He was, quite literally so, even.

And it has been pointed out that asking for ransom money is not a prerequisite for something to be called "kidnapping".
 
For some reason ruining people's lives by making them redundant isn't a felony. Locking a boss in his office is. Whether anybody is angry or not really doesn't affect anything, does it?

So if I build a machine to automate a simple mindless job, I am evil now?
And right-wing drama queens immediately start talking about kidnapping! Get real, won't you?!!! He wasn't held for ransom money, was he?

That is the legal term for what is being done.

It is rather like "Assault? I just slapped that bastard"
 
He was, quite literally so, even.

And it has been pointed out that asking for ransom money is not a prerequisite for something to be called "kidnapping".

It seems that he wants different terms for say non custodial parents who take their child away from the parent who has custody.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom