Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.
But... if he's stupid enough to ask then... why not say no?
Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.
Hokulele's answer is as irrelevant - if you don't want to be quoted "out of context", don't make comments!
Jesus, there are times you just amaze me. If you stand on a street corner and shout out messages to people, are those people able to quote you without your permission? If a statement is made in the public domain, it's pretty pointless to try to preserve some form of "copyright" on the words.
Tell me, do you ever link to press releases, comment or links from other sites? Do you always ask for permission first?
Yeah, ACS is going to write a bestseller based on the pearls of wisdom from JREF.
comparing yourself to Dawkins now?
They weren't made in the public domain.
Have you ever noticed that the people who don't give permission to be quoted in a news article are always listed as anonymous.

You are famous on this forum for your intellectual dishonesty so I expect nothing less from you. You made this red herring so go ahead and argue against it.
The point I was making is that the poster you quoted stated they don't want him making ANYTHING off their words. Even 1 penny is too much. So, regardless of your dishonesty, the point is not how much he will make, only that he may make SOMETHING.
It seems only fair that if you can compare yourself to the village idiot, I too can compare myself to someone close to my intelligence level. Granted there is more distance between me and Dawkins than between you and the idiot.

Can I at least have permission to quote you on why you won't let me quote you?
Emphasis added.- and anyone who says I'm just untrustworthy - well - that's just a bit odd for a person you know only on a forum. I'll be referring to you with the Username: AtheistsWhoThinksI'mUntrustworthy1 , 2, etc and I won't be quoting you - I'll just make something up.
qayak said:They weren't made in the public domain.
OMG! You really don't get it, do you?
I'll repeat the very easy questions:
Do you ever quote from elsewhere?
Have you always asked and received permission first?
qayak said:The point I was making is that the poster you quoted stated they don't want him making ANYTHING off their words. Even 1 penny is too much. So, regardless of your dishonesty, the point is not how much he will make, only that he may make SOMETHING.
See, even here, you just can't deal with a touch of realism, can you? Do you seriously think a bloke is going to make money out of this project?
Feel free to quote mine (but don't "quote mine" it - oh, never mind, not enough to do that.)If past experience counts - probably enough for a #3 Combo Meal.![]()
Feel free to quote mine (but don't "quote mine" it - oh, never mind, not enough to do that.)
But... if he's stupid enough to ask then... why not say no?![]()
Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.
It is rather fascinating.
Which makes me wonder - who owns insults, the person giving it or the person receiving it?
If someone calls you a "dishonest weasel" the person being called that can't quote it?
I'm amazed at the noes! If you don't want to be quoted, why the hell are you posting on a public forum?
In your case, that would be a compliment.
It's my current understanding based on general internet copyright law that the moment some publishes something on the internet it's considered copyrighted by the original creator. Of course - if you go to court you have three months (last time I checked) to fill out the copyright paperwork and pay the fees. Usually this is in regards to websites.
I think that in general fair use all works can have small sections quoted whether books or internet text - but since my original thoughts were to try to let your own words represent you - more lengthy quotes (if not entire posts) might need to be used. So I need to get explicit YES's. I am assuming someone not posting in this thread is giving me a NO and of course those who explicitly give me a NO. The Conditonal YES's I'll correspond with on an individual basis as needed.
But, based on the responses I think the book theme may change a bit to be more generalized instead of specific.