I'm thinking of writing a book - can I quote you?

Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.

But... if he's stupid enough to ask then... why not say no? :D
 
I think the issue of "fair use" comes into play (otherwise many books or term papers for that matter would never get written). There's even a legal precident - SwordoftheLord777 v. Fundies Say The Darndest Things. ;)
 
Last edited:
I can't imagine that any of my idiotic comments here are worth quoting, so this is probably academic. But then again, I never expected to be a pith award finalist a few months back either ...

Sorry, it's a no from me.
 
Last edited:
Hokulele's answer is as irrelevant - if you don't want to be quoted "out of context", don't make comments!

By that line of reasoning, nobody should talk, at least hardly ever. Nobody wants to be quoted out of context, and therefore nobody should say anything, lest it be taken out of context.

The dumb is strong in your reasoning.
 
Jesus, there are times you just amaze me. If you stand on a street corner and shout out messages to people, are those people able to quote you without your permission? If a statement is made in the public domain, it's pretty pointless to try to preserve some form of "copyright" on the words.

They weren't made in the public domain.

Tell me, do you ever link to press releases, comment or links from other sites? Do you always ask for permission first?

Have you ever noticed that the people who don't give permission to be quoted in a news article are always listed as anonymous.

Yeah, ACS is going to write a bestseller based on the pearls of wisdom from JREF.

You are famous on this forum for your intellectual dishonesty so I expect nothing less from you. You made this red herring so go ahead and argue against it.

The point I was making is that the poster you quoted stated they don't want him making ANYTHING off their words. Even 1 penny is too much. So, regardless of your dishonesty, the point is not how much he will make, only that he may make SOMETHING.

comparing yourself to Dawkins now?

It seems only fair that if you can compare yourself to the village idiot, I too can compare myself to someone close to my intelligence level. Granted there is more distance between me and Dawkins than between you and the idiot.
 
Last edited:
They weren't made in the public domain.

OMG! You really don't get it, do you?

I'll repeat the very easy questions:

Do you ever quote from elsewhere?

Have you always asked and received permission first?

Have you ever noticed that the people who don't give permission to be quoted in a news article are always listed as anonymous.

:dl:

Have you noticed that comments by you are anonymous? Unless your name is qayak?

You are famous on this forum for your intellectual dishonesty so I expect nothing less from you. You made this red herring so go ahead and argue against it.

Pssh. Cast all the aspersions you like, sonny. When you have some evidence to back it up, start a thread. I've said many times that my integrity remains intact. That some junior whistler in a canoe says otherwise bothers me not for a millisecond.

The point I was making is that the poster you quoted stated they don't want him making ANYTHING off their words. Even 1 penny is too much. So, regardless of your dishonesty, the point is not how much he will make, only that he may make SOMETHING.

See, even here, you just can't deal with a touch of realism, can you? Do you seriously think a bloke is going to make money out of this project?

Hello!!! Earth to qayak.....

It seems only fair that if you can compare yourself to the village idiot, I too can compare myself to someone close to my intelligence level. Granted there is more distance between me and Dawkins than between you and the idiot.

Ho hum, how tiresome. Yet again, when intellectually defeated you resort to ad hominem. Keep doing it, though, remember, this stuff is all available to any member of the public with a computer.

Mind you, it does explain why you'd rather not be quoted.

:bgrin:
 
Can I at least have permission to quote you on why you won't let me quote you?

No. Given that you already admitted you will make things up and attribute them to whomever you like, I doubt very much that niggling little things like copyright and courtesy would stop you.

- and anyone who says I'm just untrustworthy - well - that's just a bit odd for a person you know only on a forum. I'll be referring to you with the Username: AtheistsWhoThinksI'mUntrustworthy1 , 2, etc and I won't be quoting you - I'll just make something up.
Emphasis added.

You do not deserve to make a thin red cent off of my words, or the words of anyone else here. No one here, I think, posts so you can reprint our words for your own profit.
 
Last edited:
qayak said:
They weren't made in the public domain.
OMG! You really don't get it, do you?

I'll repeat the very easy questions:

Do you ever quote from elsewhere?

Have you always asked and received permission first?

You seem to be confused about the definition of public domain. It is a legal term that does not include words spoken on a street corner or messages posted on an internet forum.

As for posters here quoting from elsewhere, you'll notice that the board's moderators limit each JREF's poster's ability to quote stories and lengthy posts in their entirety.


qayak said:
The point I was making is that the poster you quoted stated they don't want him making ANYTHING off their words. Even 1 penny is too much. So, regardless of your dishonesty, the point is not how much he will make, only that he may make SOMETHING.
See, even here, you just can't deal with a touch of realism, can you? Do you seriously think a bloke is going to make money out of this project?


A touch or realism? Why is it unrealistic to expect a published author to make any money on his next book? I don't expect him to write a bestseller (as you sarcastically suggested in post #60) but I do believe it is quite possible that he could make more than $5. The amount of money he is making is irrelevant to me - the idea that he is making any money at all is the part that bothers me.
 
Last edited:
At least under US copyright law, every post made here is considered a copyrighted work. I suspect that ACS could use them not only without permission, but even if the author expressly forbade it, as long as he restricted himself to quoting short passages for the purpose of commentary or criticism.

Of course, if it ever went to court, anything could happen. After all, it is hard to quote a post without reproducing the whole darn thing. At what point would you cross the line from commentary or criticism to a bona fide derivative work? There is a "safe harbor," but it isn't a particularly large harbor.

But it is important to remember that the JREF membership rules expressly forbid using posts like that without the owner's permission. So, even if ACS stayed on the right side of the law, he could be banned...and I'm sure we all agree that being banned from JREF is a more fearsome punishment than any civil court could ever impose.
 
As a participant of the JREF community, I support any effort which will prove expose more people to healthy skeptical thinking. If someone makes money off of it, great. I hope some of it will be donated to JREF, but that's up to the person writing the book. I'm not against someone making profit.

But as a member of JREF community, I wish to reserve my approval to see how the quotes are used and if they are accurate to the intentions of the original posts. I'm simply against quotemining and misrepresentation. I have no reason to assume CS will do so, but I feel it is appropriate as a matter of course to exercise the skepticism that we attempt to practice and promote.
 
But... if he's stupid enough to ask then... why not say no? :D

It's my current understanding based on general internet copyright law that the moment some publishes something on the internet it's considered copyrighted by the original creator. Of course - if you go to court you have three months (last time I checked) to fill out the copyright paperwork and pay the fees. Usually this is in regards to websites.

I think that in general fair use all works can have small sections quoted whether books or internet text - but since my original thoughts were to try to let your own words represent you - more lengthy quotes (if not entire posts) might need to be used. So I need to get explicit YES's. I am assuming someone not posting in this thread is giving me a NO and of course those who explicitly give me a NO. The Conditonal YES's I'll correspond with on an individual basis as needed.

But, based on the responses I think the book theme may change a bit to be more generalized instead of specific.
 
Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.

It is rather fascinating.

Which makes me wonder - who owns insults, the person giving it or the person receiving it?

If someone calls you a "dishonest weasel" the person being called that can't quote it?
 
I'm amazed at the noes! If you don't want to be quoted, why the hell are you posting on a public forum?

1) To be difficult -- I'm in a pissy mood.

2) There was no offer of remuneration or compensation of any kind.

3) Because I can.

But since anything posted in JREF is essentially Public Domain, any protests on my part are irrelevant.

And you can quote me on that.
 
Last edited:
It's my current understanding based on general internet copyright law that the moment some publishes something on the internet it's considered copyrighted by the original creator. Of course - if you go to court you have three months (last time I checked) to fill out the copyright paperwork and pay the fees. Usually this is in regards to websites.

I think that in general fair use all works can have small sections quoted whether books or internet text - but since my original thoughts were to try to let your own words represent you - more lengthy quotes (if not entire posts) might need to be used. So I need to get explicit YES's. I am assuming someone not posting in this thread is giving me a NO and of course those who explicitly give me a NO. The Conditonal YES's I'll correspond with on an individual basis as needed.

But, based on the responses I think the book theme may change a bit to be more generalized instead of specific.

Apologies, ACS, that wasn't directed at you, though the way I put it, it was sure not the least bit clear that it wasn't. I was joking a little about that The Atheist seemed so sure that it's an absolutely given thing that you don't need to ask at all, and joked that you must be stupid then who still did, and that we then could just as well say no, even though we, apparently, doesn't have the right to say no. I did not actually mean that you ARE stupid, and I did understand your reasons for asking.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom