I'm thinking of writing a book - can I quote you?

A Christian Sceptic

Master Poster
Joined
Dec 7, 2007
Messages
2,288
I've really enjoyed much of your witty banter and posts and really appreciated some of the great ideas many of you have.

I'm playing around with writing a book. I don't have the complete specifics down as I'm still deciding whether I want to write this. But I thought I'd throw this out to see what sort of responses I get. Since you all are technically owners of the posts you make I wanted to get permission to quote you. If I can't get permission or you don't want to give it to me I still might write the book but just generalize, but that wouldn't be as personal. It's going to be a nonfiction book aimed for Christians who might be interested in reading some of your great arguments and thoughts and observations along with some of my own impressions and knowledge gained while hanging with you all.

Anyway - if you have taken part in any exchanges with me or threads I've been involved in and won't mind me quoting you and referring to your Screen Name respond to this thread with a YES. Otherwise respond with NO or no response.
 
I can offer a conditional YES. I would want to see how my posts are being used in context, as I can think of several things I may have said on one of your threads that, if context is lost, may sound like I am arguing the opposite of my real opinion. I do not mean to suggest that you are likely to quote mine or quote out of context, but I absolutely hate it when my words are used in a manner that makes them likely to be misconstrued, and have seen it happen unintentionally.
 
What Hokulele said. I can't think of anything I've posted that you might want to quote, let alone out of context, but just in case.
 
No.

I usually very carefully consider what I say and how I say it. The danger of being misrepresented is simply too high. If I want my stuff in a book, I'll write it myself. Thanks for the offer, though.


What is this "respond with no response" thingy you speak of? :D
Will it help us...
Win Powerball!!!
 
Last edited:
I do not have anything principally against being quoted. But since any posts here are written "quickly" without being overly careful I have a caveat:

I would want know of any quotes taken from me here, and to have the opportunity of phrasing something more careful, if I am not happy with having a particular formulation printed in a book.
 
I can offer a conditional YES. I would want to see how my posts are being used in context, as I can think of several things I may have said on one of your threads that, if context is lost, may sound like I am arguing the opposite of my real opinion. I do not mean to suggest that you are likely to quote mine or quote out of context, but I absolutely hate it when my words are used in a manner that makes them likely to be misconstrued, and have seen it happen unintentionally.

If I quote you I'd put a footnote where someone should be able to find the quote online and check for themselves whether it's in context.

Mainly I want to organize peoples answers in such a way where the reader can draw their own conclusions of any significance of what anyone said. I know I've drawn some of my own conclusions on certain things and will obviously sometimes share those. But I'd be making sure the reader understood those were only my opinions.

I can assure that my intent is more of an attempt to show the diversity amongst Atheists views then any sort of argument against Atheist views.

There was so much good information that people have shared, but it's rather a pain to surf through the silliness and derails. So I'm more writing this for myself and maybe someone else will find it interesting.
 
Last edited:
I can assure that my intent is more of an attempt to show the diversity amongst Atheists views then any sort of argument against Atheist views.
I think that's good. I dislike it when people are lumped into one big group, be it atheist or Christian. From what I can tell, you truly are a Christian Skeptic. There is an incredible variety of beliefs out there and they change every time somebody has a new thought, so I support any effort to prevent stereotyping. It is a buffet. It is foolish, in my opinion, not to taste lots of different things.
 
"I'm thinking of writing a book - can I quote you?" -- Christian Sceptic.

No.

Never.

Not at all.

No way - no how.

Neither in whole or in part.

Clear enough?
 
Last edited:
I can't imagine why you would want to quote me, since I'm not an atheist. But since I've taken part in threads with you, it isn't outside the realm of possibility, I suppose.

Yes, you can quote my typo-prone and bizarre posts for the purpose of discussion and criticism.

Of course, some degree of quoting would be allowable under "fair use" anyways. At least, as far as US law goes...I think. Better to get explicit permission, though.
 
No.




ETA: I think you deserve an explanation.

You are a slippery, artfully dodging weasel incapable of answering a question directly or representing anyone honestly. You are so untrustworthy that if you told me it was raining, I would look outside.
 
Last edited:
No.

Not that I expect that you'd find much of what I've posted to be quote-worthy, but I also don't consider you to be a particularly trustworthy person, or one who possesses a large measure of integrity. I believe that you will take any opportunity to twist and manipulate the words of people who disagree with your position, in order to make your position look better.
 
I'm amazed at the noes!

if you don't want to be quoted, why the hell are you posting on a public forum?

ACS, if you find anything worth quoting me on, go ahead. Also feel free to scam as much as you like from my site/s if you're interested.
 
A conditional yes, as per Hokulele. If you want to quote me, I'll want to know how my words are being used.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom