I'm thinking of writing a book - can I quote you?

OK - so here's the responses:

Anyone who's given conditions, if I quote you I'll send it in context for you to approve.
- Anyone who's said no won't be quoted
- and anyone who says I'm just untrustworthy - well - that's just a bit odd for a person you know only on a forum. I'll be referring to you with the Username: AtheistsWhoThinksI'mUntrustworthy1 , 2, etc and I won't be quoting you - I'll just make something up.
- And of course, I'll defer to the Jedi Lord Darth Rotar's wishes.

And if you're curious - I've written plenty of short stories - which have never been published. I've written a horror novelette that was turned down, when reviewed by a published horror author he trashed it, but when I self-published it people occasionally buy it and seem to like it. So whatever.

But yes- there's been plenty of books I've never started and plenty I've started that I've never finished.

This one is looking pretty easy as it looks like it's going to be mainly me writing and generalizing - I don't have to do much of the difficult research of quoting correctly and making sure it's in the correct context. :)
 
Last edited:
Would a couple of you naysayers please answer as to why you've written stuff on a public message board which you don't want repeated?

My mind is boggling at the thought.

Hokulele's answer is as irrelevant - if you don't want to be quoted "out of context", don't make comments!
 
I've really enjoyed much of your witty banter and posts and really appreciated some of the great ideas many of you have.

I'm playing around with writing a book. I don't have the complete specifics down as I'm still deciding whether I want to write this. But I thought I'd throw this out to see what sort of responses I get. Since you all are technically owners of the posts you make I wanted to get permission to quote you. If I can't get permission or you don't want to give it to me I still might write the book but just generalize, but that wouldn't be as personal. It's going to be a nonfiction book aimed for Christians who might be interested in reading some of your great arguments and thoughts and observations along with some of my own impressions and knowledge gained while hanging with you all.

Anyway - if you have taken part in any exchanges with me or threads I've been involved in and won't mind me quoting you and referring to your Screen Name respond to this thread with a YES. Otherwise respond with NO or no response.

I would not give you a blanket "yes" or "no" to quote me. As long as the quote was in the context I used it and referred to the subject it was originally aimed at, I give you a definite "Maybe."

Now, let's talk payment for my words of wisdom! :D
 
Hokulele's answer is as irrelevant - if you don't want to be quoted "out of context", don't make comments!

Actually, the purpose of this forum is not to give wannabe authors material for their books. Being quoted out of context is a perfectly good reason to not agree to having your words published.

This isn't a public forum. One must be a member in order to post and that makes it a private forum. Of course, the laws may have changed since the last time I looked.
 
No.




ETA: I think you deserve an explanation.

You are a slippery, artfully dodging weasel incapable of answering a question directly or representing anyone honestly. You are so untrustworthy that if you told me it was raining, I would look outside.

Can I at least have permission to quote you on why you won't let me quote you?
 
Would a couple of you naysayers please answer as to why you've written stuff on a public message board which you don't want repeated?

My mind is boggling at the thought.

Hokulele's answer is as irrelevant - if you don't want to be quoted "out of context", don't make comments!

I have to admit, I'm a bit puzzled by the reluctance myself - particularly given that posts are made under user names, so they are essentiallly anonymous anyway with the exception of those who post under their full names which is rather rare.
 
Last edited:

Well, nothing of the sort actually.

The whole point with quotes is that they be indentifiable, otherwise the writer may as well just make it up. If someone wants to ruin their own credibility by changing quotes to change the meaning, go ahead.

This isn't a public forum. One must be a member in order to post and that makes it a private forum. Of course, the laws may have changed since the last time I looked.

See it how you like, but posts in the public sections are demonstrably available to be read by anyone, member or not.

I have to admit, I'm a bit puzzled by the reluctance myself - particularly given that posts are made under user names, so they are essentiallly anonymous anyway with the exception of those who post under their full names which is rather rare.

Well, none of them are prepared to answer anyway.
 
Well, nothing of the sort actually.

The whole point with quotes is that they be indentifiable, otherwise the writer may as well just make it up. If someone wants to ruin their own credibility by changing quotes to change the meaning, go ahead.


Not all readers will be honest (or skeptical) enough to check context before using the quotes in other places to support their position.

Exhibit A - http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3531895#post3531895

Exhibit B - Anything DOC has ever posted.

ETA: To address Beth's point, it is not the point that these quotes would be associated with me, but that they could be used to support something I do not agree with. I am not accusing ACS of doing so deliberately, but I have seen it happen unintentionally. See Exhibit A.
 
Last edited:
Would a couple of you naysayers please answer as to why you've written stuff on a public message board which you don't want repeated?

My mind is boggling at the thought.

Why is the idea of not wanting someone else to make money off of one's own words mind-boggling?
 
Why is the idea of not wanting someone else to make money off of one's own words mind-boggling?

How much money do you reckon he's going to make?

Not all readers will be honest (or skeptical) enough to check context before using the quotes in other places to support their position.

Which is the same as saying they just make it up, which nobody can stop anyone else doing anyway. The defence you're trying to establish just doesn't fit for messages written on a public message board.
 
Which is the same as saying they just make it up, which nobody can stop anyone else doing anyway. The defence you're trying to establish just doesn't fit for messages written on a public message board.


I said "readers", not "writers". Again, my main point is that I do not want my words being used to justify discriminating against atheists. I absolutely do not care if it can be traced to the real life me or not. By making my approval conditional, I can at least guarantee that my words will not be used this way.
 
How much money do you reckon he's going to make?

What difference does it make? I didn't see where there was any wiggle room left for you. They don't want him to make money off their words . . . ANY money.

Which is the same as saying they just make it up, which nobody can stop anyone else doing anyway. The defence you're trying to establish just doesn't fit for messages written on a public message board.

No, no one can stop him from making it all up but then it is just another fairytale for his readers to believe. It is like Dawkins and Gould said, allowing your words to be used in any form by someone with a religious agenda simply adds a measure of respectability that is completely undeserved.
 
I don't mind. Let me know which quote and in which context and give me credit. That's all the common courtesy I think anyone here expects. Credit to me isn't necessary, but just clarification that those weren't your words. The same honesty I expect from any other text.
 
And that matters how?

Jesus, there are times you just amaze me. If you stand on a street corner and shout out messages to people, are those people able to quote you without your permission? If a statement is made in the public domain, it's pretty pointless to try to preserve some form of "copyright" on the words.

Tell me, do you ever link to press releases, comment or links from other sites? Do you always ask for permission first?

What difference does it make? I didn't see where there was any wiggle room left for you. They don't want him to make money off their words . . . ANY money.

Yeah, ACS is going to write a bestseller based on the pearls of wisdom from JREF.

Riiiight.

No, no one can stop him from making it all up but then it is just another fairytale for his readers to believe. It is like Dawkins and Gould said, allowing your words to be used in any form by someone with a religious agenda simply adds a measure of respectability that is completely undeserved.

:dl:

comparing yourself to Dawkins now?

If past experience counts - probably enough for a #3 Combo Meal.;)

Must be hysterical reading the responses though. Seriously, if you'd asked me whether people would have said "no", I'd have laughed, thinking it wasn't possible.

Humans.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom