I'm thinking of writing a book - can I quote you?

If I quote you I'd put a footnote where someone should be able to find the quote online and check for themselves whether it's in context.

Mainly I want to organize peoples answers in such a way where the reader can draw their own conclusions of any significance of what anyone said. I know I've drawn some of my own conclusions on certain things and will obviously sometimes share those. But I'd be making sure the reader understood those were only my opinions.

I can assure that my intent is more of an attempt to show the diversity amongst Atheists views then any sort of argument against Atheist views.

There was so much good information that people have shared, but it's rather a pain to surf through the silliness and derails. So I'm more writing this for myself and maybe someone else will find it interesting.


Again, I would prefer to see the work prior to release. AFAIK, this is a common request when quotes are used. It is not that I do not trust you per se, but that you have demonstrated in the past a different understanding of what I have written than what I intended. I would prefer that my writings show my intentions. If you are not comfortable sharing your book before publication, that is fine, but in that case I would prefer not be quoted.

Not that I am assuming I am quote-worthy to begin with. ;)

Everything I've written on BBSs is public domain AFAIC.


Yes and no. If ACS plans this to be a profit-making venture, the public domain issue becomes tricky depending on jurisdiction. Then again, IANAL.
 
Yes and no. If ACS plans this to be a profit-making venture, the public domain issue becomes tricky depending on jurisdiction. Then again, IANAL.

Hence the "as far as I'm concerned". I make no copywrite claim to anything I post on BBSs, it's just there. Not that I think ACS wants to quote anything I've written here, I'm just noting I have a lassaiz-faire attitude towards the use of my writing.
 
Hence the "as far as I'm concerned". I make no copywrite claim to anything I post on BBSs, it's just there. Not that I think ACS wants to quote anything I've written here, I'm just noting I have a lassaiz-faire attitude towards the use of my writing.


I originally read this as "a lassaiz-faire attitude towards my writing", and was about to agree with you. :p
 
Hence the "as far as I'm concerned". I make no copyright claim to anything I post on BBSs, it's just there. Not that I think ACS wants to quote anything I've written here, I'm just noting I have a lassaiz-faire attitude toward the use of my writing.

I don't think anybody has any copyright claims to anything they write here. It is already in the public domain. Moreover, most of us are anonymous so it would be hard for us to insist that any person's reputation was being harmed by the misuse of our forum persona's words. At best, the owners of the forum might be able to claim some right to ownership of what is posted here.

While it is nice of ACS to ask our permission, I don't think that he has to, legally speaking.

In a slightly related question, whatever happened to that lawsuit by the guy who claimed he had been slandered on the forum? Wasn't he trying to sue some of the forum persona, though not even knowing who they were?
 
Again, I would prefer to see the work prior to release. AFAIK, this is a common request when quotes are used. It is not that I do not trust you per se, but that you have demonstrated in the past a different understanding of what I have written than what I intended. I would prefer that my writings show my intentions. If you are not comfortable sharing your book before publication, that is fine, but in that case I would prefer not be quoted.

Not that I am assuming I am quote-worthy to begin with. ;)

Once again, Hokulele reads my mind before I do!

IOW, what she said goes for me, too. I don't post anything online that I wouldn't put on a downtown billboard, but I wouldn't like to be quote-mined to create a strawman, quoted out of context or ... heavily ... ellipsied.
 
In a slightly related question, whatever happened to that lawsuit by the guy who claimed he had been slandered on the forum? Wasn't he trying to sue some of the forum persona, though not even knowing who they were?

I've even succumbed to the whine of libel/slander on this forum, but only due to frustration because I knew that any complaint about character damage would frivilous at best and pathetic at worst. While I'm not a lawyer or legal scholar, apart from stalker crap that goes on with sites like Facebook, Myspace, etc., everything I say here has the legal weight of me standing on a street corner shouting at people for wearing the wrong clothes.

Again, that's just how I look at it, I'd plead differently in court if.. oh crap, this post will serve as evidence against me... I've said too much.

More Lesbian propaganda!

Soooo tempting... but I got your girlfriend for her mockery of me above in the Quote out of context thread. DmKrispin gets a pass.
 
I don't know if I've conversed with you, very much, but: You can feel free to quote anything I have written on this forum, with the condition that I be notified of its usage before it goes to print, and you should give me the opportunity to object to its usage, if I see fit.
Though, I tend to be a relatively easy-going fellow: There are very few reasons I would object to being quoted.
 
I don't think anybody has any copyright claims to anything they write here. It is already in the public domain. Moreover, most of us are anonymous so it would be hard for us to insist that any person's reputation was being harmed by the misuse of our forum persona's words. At best, the owners of the forum might be able to claim some right to ownership of what is posted here.

While it is nice of ACS to ask our permission, I don't think that he has to, legally speaking.

In a slightly related question, whatever happened to that lawsuit by the guy who claimed he had been slandered on the forum? Wasn't he trying to sue some of the forum persona, though not even knowing who they were?

You can only put stuff into the public domain by explicitly stating so.

Now, then, unless ACS has written books before, I highly doubt he is going to do so now. Everyone is always planning to write a book. Many people even start one. Only some actually finish it. Very few manage to get a publisher involved. With that in mind, how can I possibly turn him down?
 
Do you even need to ask permission? Unless there is something on the forum rules you signed off on when you started the account, everything we say here is already public domain, right?
 
I don't think anybody has any copyright claims to anything they write here. It is already in the public domain.

While it is nice of ACS to ask our permission, I don't think that he has to, legally speaking.

Yes they do, no it isn't, and yes he does.

See the Registration Agreement:

Darat said:
Copyright

Any post or article published on the JREF forum by a Member is the copyright of the Member and may not be reproduced, copied or otherwise re-published without the express permission of the Member. By posting on the Forum a Member grants the JREF a non-exclusive licence to publish, republish or reproduce their work, in its entirety or as the JREF sees fit, in perpetuity. The James Randi Educational Foundation is the copyright holder of the JREF Forum.
 
Yes, AS LONG as you notify me and I approve of the quotes and the context.
 
My yes is conditioned upon the following:

As a source, I am to be quoted as

"An internet madman whose status as Dark Jedi/Sith makes it far too dangerous for me to provoke."

PM me for further details.

DR
 
Yea, you can quote me. Good luck on the book.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom