"If you build it, they will come." So, why not build it?

My questions:

1: Where did Noah get enough food to feed two of every animal alive which would have to include the picky dietary needs of certain animals?

2:What did Noah do with the staggering amount of urine and feces produced by all those animals for 40 days and nights combined with the smell?

Maybe he regurgitated manna from heaven like a mother penguin.
 
Marduk? Question?

I don't see the relevance of dating Gilgamesh to see when the first wooden boat is mentioned, Gilgamesh doesn't have a wooden boat in it. The most famous wooden boats in the ancient world which most people are aware of date to the construction of the great pyramid and they were buried beside it, but they are not the earliest wooden ships. In mesopotamia they used reed boats and wooden ships, but the Gilgamesh story copies the convention derived from the Atrahasis story and has the ship being made from reeds for two hypothetical reasons
1. The flood hero is not a shipwright, so doesn't understand wooden ship construction
2. The flood hero has little time and only a reed hut for materials

;)
 
Last edited:
The absolute upper limit for wooden ships appears to be either:
.

.
Stone Age.

Iron age, from c. 1300 BC in the Middle East.

.
Gilgamesh dates from 1800 BC.

Yeah, but I was leaning toward the date the story was actually written into the Hebraic mythology.
I don't see the relevance of dating Gilgamesh to see when the first wooden boat is mentioned, Gilgamesh doesn't have a wooden boat in it.
I didn't do that.

perhaps then I'm reading it wrong, so what relevance does "the date the story was actually written into the Hebraic mythology" have to do with the discussion
I'm obviously missing part of the conversation
any help ?
:D
 
I was referring to the date clinker built ships were first used. .
The earliest evidence we have for clinker built boats post dates the Bible 300-400 BC
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hjortspring_boat
and is from an unrelated culture
Unless Noahs surname turns out to be Gundesson, I still don't think its relevant as the Arks actual construction isn't detailed
:D
And trying to relate that date to the date they first included the Flood in their mythology. It's not an important issue, just me chasing details.
Between 600 and 400bce, more likely towards the former than the latter date
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torah
Most Modern biblical scholars believe that the written books were a product of the Babylonian exilic period (c.600 BCE) and that it was completed by the Persian period (c.400 BCE)
;)

my main point if I have one, is that the Ark story is known to be based on a mesopotamian story about a reed boat, so any discussion of the reality which isn't discussing reed boats is moot
 
Last edited:
perhaps then I'm reading it wrong, so what relevance does "the date the story was actually written into the Hebraic mythology" have to do with the discussion
I'm obviously missing part of the conversation
any help ?
:D
.
I heard the folk tales weren't written until the time of Solomon.
Long time after all those fanciful events.
 
.
I heard the folk tales weren't written until the time of Solomon.
Long time after all those fanciful events.

There are a couple of theories about authorship, proponents of the four document theory suggest some of the first five books may date to 900BC
 
.
I heard the folk tales weren't written until the time of Solomon.
Long time after all those fanciful events.

no, the Torah was compiled if not during the diaspora, then immediately after it, Solomon if he lived at all was 400 years before that event.

and we're not talking about the book of Noah being a general retelling, its choice of words and chronology shows it was basically copied from a Mesopotamian text. This combined with a wealth of other mesopotamian literature which appears in the Old Testament means that can't have happened until the Hebrews had access to original copies of the texts. That requires two things
1. Libraries
2. Access to those libraries
;)

There are a couple of theories about authorship, proponents of the four document theory suggest some of the first five books may date to 900BC

Cite ?
:confused:
 
Last edited:
The earliest evidence we have for clinker built boats post dates the Bible 300-400 BC
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hjortspring_boat
and is from an unrelated culture
Unless Noahs surname turns out to be Gundesson, I still don't think its relevant as the Arks actual construction isn't detailed:D

Between 600 and 400bce, more likely towards the former than the latter date
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Torah

;)

my main point if I have one, is that the Ark story is known to be based on a mesopotamian story about a reed boat, so any discussion of the reality which isn't discussing reed boats is moot

Oh ye of little faith:

14 Make yourself an ark of gopher wood.[d] Make rooms in the ark, and cover it inside and out with pitch. 15 This is how you are to make it: the length of the ark 300 cubits,[e] its breadth 50 cubits, and its height 30 cubits. 16 Make a roof[f] for the ark, and finish it to a cubit above, and set the door of the ark in its side. Make it with lower, second, and third decks.


There you go, god's the big picture man, the one with the concepts, you don't expect him to go into all the sordid details.:)
 
Oh ye of little faith:

14 Make yourself an ark of gopher wood.[d] Make rooms in the ark, and cover it inside and out with pitch. 15 This is how you are to make it: the length of the ark 300 cubits,[e] its breadth 50 cubits, and its height 30 cubits. 16 Make a roof[f] for the ark, and finish it to a cubit above, and set the door of the ark in its side. Make it with lower, second, and third decks.


There you go, god's the big picture man, the one with the concepts, you don't expect him to go into all the sordid details.:)

I do not call that detailed, if I were Noah that would not help at all. Nowhere does it describe any method that could be described as "clinker built", which is what we were discussing and which prompted my response
Theres more details than that in Gilgamesh
Just as dawn began to glow
the land assembled around me-
the carpenter carried his hatchet,
the reed worker carried his (flattening) stone,
... the men ...
The child carried the pitch,
the weak brought whatever else was needed.
On the fifth day I laid out her exterior.
It was a field in area,
its walls were each 10 times 12 cubits in height,
the sides of its top were of equal length, 10 times It cubits each.
I laid out its (interior) structure and drew a picture of it (?).
I provided it with six decks,
thus dividing it into seven (levels).
The inside of it I divided into nine (compartments).
I drove plugs (to keep out) water in its middle part.
I saw to the punting poles and laid in what was necessary.
Three times 3,600 (units) of raw bitumen I poured into the
bitumen kiln,
three times 3,600 (units of) pitch ...into it,
there were three times 3,600 porters of casks who carried (vege-
table) oil,
apart from the 3,600 (units of) oil which they consumed (!)
and two times 3,600 (units of) oil which the boatman stored
away.
I butchered oxen for the meat(!),
and day upon day I slaughtered sheep.
I gave the workmen(?) ale, beer, oil, and wine, as if it were
river water,
so they could make a party like the New Year's Festival.
... and I set my hand to the oiling(!).
The boat was finished by sunset.
The launching was very difficult.
They had to keep carrying a runway of poles front to back,
until two-thirds of it had gone into the water(?).
Whatever I had I loaded on it:
whatever silver I had 1 loaded on it,
whatever gold I had I loaded on it.
All the living beings that I had I loaded on it,
I had all my kith and kin go up into the boat,
all the beasts and animals of the field and the craftsmen I
had go up.
Shamash had set a stated time:
'In the morning I will let loaves of bread shower down,
and in the evening a rain of wheat!
Go inside the boat, seal the entry!'
That stated time had arrived.
In the morning he let loaves of bread shower down,
and in the evening a rain of wheat.
I watched the appearance of the weather--
the weather was frightful to behold!
I went into the boat and sealed the entry.
For the caulking of the boat, to Puzuramurri, the boatman,
I gave the palace together with its contents.


:p
 
Last edited:
I do not call that detailed, if I were Noah that would not help at all. Nowhere does it describe any method that could be described as "clinker built", which is what we were discussing and which prompted my response
Theres more details than that in Gilgamesh
Just as dawn began to glow
the land assembled around me-
the carpenter carried his hatchet,
the reed worker carried his (flattening) stone,
... the men ...
The child carried the pitch,
the weak brought whatever else was needed.
On the fifth day I laid out her exterior.
It was a field in area,
its walls were each 10 times 12 cubits in height,
the sides of its top were of equal length, 10 times It cubits each.
I laid out its (interior) structure and drew a picture of it (?).
I provided it with six decks,
thus dividing it into seven (levels).
The inside of it I divided into nine (compartments).
I drove plugs (to keep out) water in its middle part.
I saw to the punting poles and laid in what was necessary.
Three times 3,600 (units) of raw bitumen I poured into the
bitumen kiln,
three times 3,600 (units of) pitch ...into it,
there were three times 3,600 porters of casks who carried (vege-
table) oil,
apart from the 3,600 (units of) oil which they consumed (!)
and two times 3,600 (units of) oil which the boatman stored
away.
I butchered oxen for the meat(!),
and day upon day I slaughtered sheep.
I gave the workmen(?) ale, beer, oil, and wine, as if it were
river water,
so they could make a party like the New Year's Festival.
... and I set my hand to the oiling(!).
The boat was finished by sunset.
The launching was very difficult.
They had to keep carrying a runway of poles front to back,
until two-thirds of it had gone into the water(?).
Whatever I had I loaded on it:
whatever silver I had 1 loaded on it,
whatever gold I had I loaded on it.
All the living beings that I had I loaded on it,
I had all my kith and kin go up into the boat,
all the beasts and animals of the field and the craftsmen I
had go up.
Shamash had set a stated time:
'In the morning I will let loaves of bread shower down,
and in the evening a rain of wheat!
Go inside the boat, seal the entry!'
That stated time had arrived.
In the morning he let loaves of bread shower down,
and in the evening a rain of wheat.
I watched the appearance of the weather--
the weather was frightful to behold!
I went into the boat and sealed the entry.
For the caulking of the boat, to Puzuramurri, the boatman,
I gave the palace together with its contents.


:p

Did you think I was serious?:eek:

I put a :) at the end.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom