"If you build it, they will come." So, why not build it?

Q: What could possibly sink Noah's God-designed ark?

A: Water.

Actually it would be lack of water. A vessel that large is going to have it's center keel unsupported when the trough of a wave comes through, basically breaks its back and snaps in half
 
I emailed the Van Noach Society (the email address on their website).

It took a while, but they responded with answers to my questions. Here's their response. My original questions are in regular typeface; their answers are in bold.

Reply from info @ arkvannoach.com said:
1. What wood was used for the ark? Pine wood from scandinavia.

2. Was any metal used in its construction (excluding non-structural materials like seats in the amphitheater, etc.)? Yes we used metal for the consturction.

3. Were the joins caulked? If so, with what? Yes, with all the wood. Just as in the biblical time (gen 4 : 22 Tubal Kain)

4. Has the ark been floated yet? Yes it floats!


Kind regards

Nadine Mbok
Note especially question and answer #2. They used metal in the construction.

I have sent a follow-on email asking for more information about that, but I do not know if or when I will get a response.




​
 
Last edited:
Garrette, the Ark floats, but it floats because it has been built on a metal barge that floated before it was chosen for the faux Ark project. He lied to you in the old-fashioned way. He told the bare minimum truth and then shut up. Skilled liar.
 
I knew the smaller version was on a barge but saw no indication that this was is. Not that I doubt you; it is just that I was looking for that, though I didn't spell it iut in my email. Another is in order, I suppose.
 
I emailed the Van Noach Society (the email address on their website).

It took a while, but they responded with answers to my questions. Here's their response. My original questions are in regular typeface; their answers are in bold.


Note especially question and answer #2. They used metal in the construction.

I have sent a follow-on email asking for more information about that, but I do not know if or when I will get a response.

​

Cool. I googled the name ("Nadine Mbok") because it sounded strange. Turns out her name is Nadine Mboko. Probably this one. I found this newspaper article from 1 June, where she acts as spokeswoman for the Ark project; and this earlier one from 8 March from the same orthodox-protestant newspaper.

The gist of the articles: the town Dordrecht considers the Ark a building. And because it will get lots of visitors, they want detailed drawings. Lots of drawings simply don't exist because they just started building and adjusted things on the fly. In the March article, Huibers implored that the Ark will nevertheless open on 1 June. In the 1 June article, Nadine Mboko says it won't open, but that it can happen "any day". Earlier, the opening date was planned for 17 February.
 
Oops. It is Mboko. Copy paste error on my part. And thanks for the article summaries. I think their website still implies it has sailed though I haven't visited it in a while.
 
Last edited:
Oops. It is Mboko. Copy paste error on my part. And thanks for the article summaries. I think their website still implies it has sailed though I haven't visited it in a while.

You can subscribe to their newsletter here and be notified when they're opening. :) It's only € 12.50 for an adult on Monday thru Saturday. It doesn't mention the admission price on Sunday though.

Apparently, smaller parties are welcome already. This article details a meeting on 7June of the Scientific Bureau of the fringe theocratic political party SGP with the caretaker-deputy minister of agriculture Bleker. Main items on the agenda: factory farming and mink farming. The Lord God made garments of skin for Adam and his wife and clothed them (Genesis 3:21) so mink farming is OK.

Am I evil when I say it's a pity the ark didn't sink during this meeting? :D
 
Last edited:
I knew the smaller version was on a barge but saw no indication that this was is. Not that I doubt you; it is just that I was looking for that, though I didn't spell it iut in my email. Another is in order, I suppose.

I posted upthread a link to an earlier thread from begin 2011. Here's my post with a youtube which discusses that this big ark was also built on a foundation of 24 barges. Click CC on the youtube to get English captions. Enjoy!
 
I knew the smaller version was on a barge but saw no indication that this was is. Not that I doubt you; it is just that I was looking for that, though I didn't spell it iut in my email. Another is in order, I suppose.

Any response yet?

For the record, a "one-to-one replica" would be one built exactly as the Bible states it, using only technology and material available to Noah. Unless they chose to remain fuzzy in Step 2 ("And then a miracle occurs.") there will be no reproduction of the Ark, because it is impossible. So the story is impossible. So yet another part of the Bible is rendered impossible, and therefore false.
 
The 'vapor canopy' in another thread would prevent photosynthesis on the earth.
No photosynthesis, no gopher wood trees, or grass, or flowers...
 
The only images I find are the one on the barge. You got something else?
Not that I'm willing to go back and search for. I'm willing to admit I searched/looked poorly.

Any response yet?
Got this this morning:

Dear xxxx,

Thank you so much for your interst in the Ark. May I ask you a question? What are all those questions for, do you have a specific purpose?

I want to invite you personaly to visit the Ark when we will be open, so that you can see it for yourself. Is is ok for you?

We are very busy with the preparation of the opening so we cannot answer all the questions all the time. I hope you understand.

Hope to hear from you.

Kind regards,

Kind regards,

To which I replied:

Dear Nadine,

Thank you so much for taking the time to help. I understand why my questions might cause you to wonder why I'm asking; my answers are below. The invitation to visit the ark is very kind, and I wish I could take you up on it. Sadly, I have not been in Europe for many years, though I hope to visit again some day. When I do, if my travels take me near the ark I will do my best to arrange a visit.

In regard to your question: I have always been curious about demonstrations of biblical authenticity, and since the physical plausibility of the ark as described in the bible has long been a source of skepticism I would find it remarkable that such a vessel would finally be proven possible. My specific questions follow from that curiosity, particulary since your website strongly implies that the ark is a functional replica, exact to the details (excepting, of course, the obvious additions to allow for tourism).

I shared your previous answers with some skeptical friends, one of whom responded by saying (paraphrased): "It may have floated, but only because it sits on a barge and the barge floats." That would not lend itself to arguments for authenticity, so I am hoping you can respond to that, too. Another friend says that while it may be floating, it has not yet sailed and recent articles indicate it may not sail in time for the London Olympics. (Those articles were not in English so I could not verify what he said).

Does this answer your question about my interest? If you would like more information, just ask and I will answer as best I can.

To summarize my two questions (one from the previous email and one added here based on comments from my friends):

1. What functions does the metal used in the construction serve?
2. Does the barge float or has it floated on its own without resting atop some other vessel such as a barge?

I understand you are quite busy and may not be able to answer right away, but whenever you do get the time I will very much appreciate your comments.

All the best,



Gawdzilla said:
For the record, a "one-to-one replica" would be one built exactly as the Bible states it, using only technology and material available to Noah. Unless they chose to remain fuzzy in Step 2 ("And then a miracle occurs.") there will be no reproduction of the Ark, because it is impossible. So the story is impossible. So yet another part of the Bible is rendered impossible, and therefore false.
Can't say I disagree.
 
Last edited:
Is that a revamp of Hovind's miles of water in a shell around the Earth, because that's just awesome.
.
Yes.
As sunlight disappears within a few hundred feet under the surface, how any could have passed through miles of water to do the photosynthesis thing is another reason to toss the Flood out.
 
Garrette, as a student of history and diplomatic history especially, I see Nadine is ducking and dodging. She's doing a classic fundy stunt. If you don't provide the correct response you'll either get another lie or a non-response. The fail is strong in this one. I guess they didn't think anyone would question the validity of their "feat".
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom