"If you build it, they will come." So, why not build it?

The absolute upper limit for wooden ships appears to be either:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wyoming_(schooner)

Or HMS Mersey and Orlando

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Orlando_(1858)

Depending on how much iron you allow to be used. There are a couple of larger ones but they used even more iron and even steel.

Using iron makes things a lot more straightforward. HMS Warrior built a couple of years later was about 70 feet longer thans HMS Mersey and is still afloat.

.
Stone Age.
 
I am neither a literalist nor even a Christian, but I'll have a go.

A literalist would read your last paragraph and ask you if you are even listening to yourself. The way to determine which parts are miracles is to look and see if the event is impossible under TLOP and if the event furthers God's plan. If yes and yes, then it was a miracle.

Or even simpler:
Every impossible event was the result of a miracle. Why are you asking about decisions - it is obvious.

I can accept that as someones position. I still think it's silly but at least it's an explanation. I would still point out that it requires the reader to make interpretations and assumptions that are not part of the literal text.

And I'd still like to hear from somebody who does consider themselves a literalist if that is an accurate representation of their position.
 
Last edited:
I can accept that as someones position. I still think it's silly but at least it's an explanation. I would still point out that it requires the reader to make interpretations and assumptions that are not part of the literal text.

And I'd still like to hear from somebody who does consider themselves a literalist if that is an accurate representation of their position.

Yes. I am starting to come around to your position. I've heard many fundies describe the Bible as complete and accurate. Some of the required assumptions are big enough to make the claim of completeness unwarranted.

When I want to ask fundies something, I go to the RaptureReady.Com forum. But be careful, their passion rises to a level of intenseness not often found on other message boards.

..............
Off topic: the Rapture Ready Index is at its lowest point for 2012. Good news - No Rapture expected tonight.​
 
Last edited:
How do literalists explain the distribution of different animals around the world, given they were replenished from one place?

My questions:

1: Where did Noah get enough food to feed two of every animal alive which would have to include the picky dietary needs of certain animals?

2:What did Noah do with the staggering amount of urine and feces produced by all those animals for 40 days and nights combined with the smell?
 
My questions:

1: Where did Noah get enough food to feed two of every animal alive which would have to include the picky dietary needs of certain animals?

2:What did Noah do with the staggering amount of urine and feces produced by all those animals for 40 days and nights combined with the smell?

This contains all the answers you will ever need

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bputeFGXEjA
 
.
Stone Age.

Yes but people haven't generaly built very large wooden ships just to see what would happen. So maxium size is going to involve some guessing as to what would happen if you took the iron out.
 

The same Dutch guy, Johan Huibers, built a full-size ark, which is now open for visits. Here's his website.

The boat is built on top of an base structure consisting of 24 (?) steel pontoons. He doesn't mention that anywhere on his website, as far as I can see. So he's a liar. There was an earlier thread about this last year. I linked there to a youtube video (on page 5) where he's also lying through his teeth (press CC on youtube for English captions on the video). You can also see his mates using power tools. :D There are more videos to be found of this project, don't know if they all have English subtitling.

There are also two older threads on the topic (here and here) on earlier "Arks".

And there's this thread and this thread
 
its a story they want to believe in, not a story they want to know to be impossible,
 
To me, it doesn't make a difference if it happened exactly the way it was described or if the story is a metaphor or myth designed to illustrate a point. In either case God is portrayed as an absurdly cruel, comically inefficient, and patently chuckle-headed a-hole who has no respect for the sanctity of human life.

That people could include this anecdote in a Book designed to show how loving God is, is just ◊◊◊◊◊◊* crazy. If one reads this Book and comes away with the belief that God loves humans as a father loves his children, then one should call those Guiness-book people and ask if there is a record for strongest cognitive dissonance ever.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom