"If you build it, they will come." So, why not build it?

Actually, by Noah and his sons using all manual tools, no power saws, drills or equipment to move the trees or lumber to the construction site.

As for building it, you've witnessed Ken Ham waxing rhapsodical about a fake Ark. So a real, working model that would withstand the conditions extant in a forty day rain storm and a 150 days of highly unsettled weather as the climate went to hell in a handbasket, that would be a real inspiration.

So, believers, either your faith is weak or the story is ********. Please chose.

And don't forget all those animals turning feed into manure and fresh water into bilge water.
And getting ALL the animals from around the world to turn up meanwhile hiding the flood from the Chinese...
 
Assuming the story in the bible is true, how long would it take for all of those animals to multiply into the numbers we have today? Obviously it is completely ridiculous, but I wonder what kind of timeframe that would be.

Large predators would need to make kills at least twice a week. The herbivores would need decades to reproduce to the level where this could happen. So the predators are dead. The herbivores would have to wait until the grass and grazing recovered enough to allow them to have enough to eat. So the herbivores are dead. That leaves what, fungi?

Believers, are you really this stupid?

Never mind, believers, you're :covereyes right now, and very http://rationalia.com/forum/images/smilies/lalala.gif
, which is a damn shame. The 21st C. won't wait for you.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
The last few posts have pointed out a few of the vast number of reasons why the story as written is patently absurd and demonstrably impossible.

I really would like to hear how someone that thinks the bible is literal truth can explain that without miracles. And if they do explain it with miracles how they decide there was a miracle if none was specifically mentioned.
 
I posted a question about this perspective in another thread and was ignored so maybe this is a good place to try again. (This isn't directed at you personally but more toward people that insist on literal interpretation of the bible)...

How does a literal interpretation of the bible reconcile the story of Noah’s ark? I know the flood has been brought up already but I’m wondering about the reality of the actual ark, animals etc. As far as I know the bible does not mention any direct interference from god with the ark beyond giving Noah the instructions. The idea that a wooden boat could have been built to hold representatives of every animal on earth, and their food, is clearly ridiculous. I’ve heard the explanation that “it was a miracle” no other explanation needed. So, did god make the boat like Harry Potter’s tent and the Tardis (bigger on the inside than the outside), or shrink all of the animals, or make it so they didn’t need to eat. Did god magically transport animals from other parts of the earth, create microclimates inside the boat, etc. ?

From a literalist perspective is it acceptable to just decide that there must have been a miracle to explain impossible events even if the miracle is not actually mentioned in the literal text? If so, how do you decide which parts are miracle and which are not?

I am neither a literalist nor even a Christian, but I'll have a go.

A literalist would read your last paragraph and ask you if you are even listening to yourself. The way to determine which parts are miracles is to look and see if the event is impossible under TLOP and if the event furthers God's plan. If yes and yes, then it was a miracle.

Or even simpler:
Every impossible event was the result of a miracle. Why are you asking about decisions - it is obvious.
 
The last few posts have pointed out a few of the vast number of reasons why the story as written is patently absurd and demonstrably impossible.

I really would like to hear how someone that thinks the bible is literal truth can explain that without miracles. And if they do explain it with miracles how they decide there was a miracle if none was specifically mentioned.

Again, I am playing Devil's Advocate and am not a true believer. If there are hundreds of miracles recoded in the Bible and the only way to explain an event that God has predicted is to use a miracle in the explanation, then a God-produced miracle occurred.

Here in the 21st century, it would seem strange for a scribe to skip a mention of God's miraculous abilities being used in a specific story about a servant of God performing an action that God explicitly defined. But to any objective observer, the Bible could never be described as "thorough and complete, leaving no hanging strings anywhere." If the Book itself never rises to the level of thoroughness, then why complain that one particular story is not thorough in its telling?
 
Last edited:
I think there was Gopher Wood on the Love Boat.

(wow I just made myself feel really old and grossed myself out at the same time)
protest.gif
 
How do literalists explain the distribution of different animals around the world, given they were replenished from one place?

Okay well it seems umm err..........I got nothing
 
As maybe, clinker-built dates from no earlier than the 4th C. before Christ, so it wouldn't have been used on the Ark.

If that is your biggest problem with the story we need to talk lol. But as I think you said, just securing the timber for the job in the first place would be virtually impossible
 
If that is your biggest problem with the story we need to talk lol. But as I think you said, just securing the timber for the job in the first place would be virtually impossible

I did say "in addition to the other problems". There's a place where the Navy tests their ship designs in a large, long tank. They make the world's worst coffee there, but its a great place to talk nuts and bolts.
 
I have to take the other side of the OP.
If one has a God that can create heaven and earth and all forms of life (including humans) then such a God could easily wrap His Hands around a long wooden boat to keep it from all the forces that would cause an actual vessel to founder. Modern man's ability or inability to build a wooden ship with the dimensions cited in Genesis is irrelevant to determining the truthfulness of scriptures.
.
An inarguable position.
 
.
His family might help, in between collecting those breeding pairs from South America and Australia.
Cutting the trees and shaping them to fit would take some time, and might tire out a single person.

He probably hired a lot of locals. Not much of a wage but a killer of a retirement plan.
 
I did say "in addition to the other problems". There's a place where the Navy tests their ship designs in a large, long tank. They make the world's worst coffee there, but its a great place to talk nuts and bolts.

Yeah I can see how bad coffee would scew up your ark project lol
 
The absolute upper limit for wooden ships appears to be either:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wyoming_(schooner)

Or HMS Mersey and Orlando

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/HMS_Orlando_(1858)

Depending on how much iron you allow to be used. There are a couple of larger ones but they used even more iron and even steel.

Using iron makes things a lot more straightforward. HMS Warrior built a couple of years later was about 70 feet longer thans HMS Mersey and is still afloat.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom