If the Earth isn't 6,000 years old...

Yes, I agree with that.

I thought you were talking about the specifics. I have my own views on the likely specifics, based on my reading of the Bible, but I acknowledge it's somewhat speculative.
OK, so if you agree with me that God - the all-good, all-benevolent wonderbeing - created the lord of all evil, lies and malice, then we have to ask a follow-up: WHY? Why not just create a perfect Eden-like existence for humankind and just leave it at that?

And the question we have to ask piggybacking on that is: What kind of God (who remember, knows and sees the future) would create the Lord of All Evil (Satan), allow him to corrupt man, and then spend the next stretch of thousands of years torturing and punishing man?

What kind of a 'benevolent' being is this?
 
lol, I'd like you to corroborate that, from my perspective Satan didn't exist until 500BCE, so you have perhaps a mention of him which predates that ?

I made reference to the New Testament for a reason, you know.

The writer of Genesis was clearly thinking "generic snake" when he wrote it, which is why he doesn't call him Satan at any point, :D

To be more accurate, it appears to be an allegorical origin story, with part of it used to explain why snakes don't have legs and don't get along with humans very well. The serpent as described in Genesis therefore appears to be a trickster figure, acting as the sort of representative example of serpents everywhere.

But somewhere during the Intertestamental Period, the Serpent of Genesis began to be associated with the originally-separate figure of the Adversary, ha-Satan. By the time the New Testament (especially Revelation) was actually written, a reference to "The Serpent" was understood by both the writers and contemporary readers to mean this merged Serpent/Satan figure, and this association became much stronger as Christianity developed its own identity and theology separate from the Judaism that originated it.

See The Birth of Satan: Tracing the Devil's Biblical Roots
 
Last edited:
No, my argument is that Revelation 12:9, and similar passages in Revelation referring to the Devil and Satan as "the serpent of old", are clearly a reference to the serpent from Genesis 3.

Does this not mean that whatever is in Revelation, "the serpent of old" as you call it here, was once created as one of the animals? It does.
Now the serpent was more crafty than any other wild animal that the Lord God had made. (Gen 3:1a; NRSV)​
 
The veracity of Revelation doesn't hold up to one minute's scrutiny.

You cant argue that way - For the sake of the argument you have accepted the story a talking serpent in the Garden - When another poster identifies the nature of the serpent using another section of the same book you cry foul saying it does not hold up to scrutiny.

There is no other primary source for either Genesis or Revelations, so you cant accept one chapter to advance a discussion, and reject another simply because it does not stand up to scrutiny.
 
No, it really doesn't.

This is why Biblical literalism fails--not because it's impossible, but because two people can read the same book and come to entirely different conclusions. The line the RCC fed us back in school was that Original Sin was rather the whole POINT of the Bible. The book started with where the sin came from (the Fall), then admitedly wandered off for a bit following the Jews around, but after the break came back to the main point with Jesus dying to give us a means to overcome Original Sin. This interpretation has been supported by Biblical scholars for so long that anyone asking for proof is merely showing that they are completely ignorant of historical thought on the matter (to pre-empt the question, the Rule of St. Benedict explicitely states much of this in the first chapter, and the Roman Catholic mass includes this as part of the litergy).

My point isn't that AvalonXQ is right or wrong--I think anyone who thinks the Bible is anything more than historical fiction is wrong, so I've got no dog in this fight. My point is that both AvalonXQ and those whom he opposes (theologically) can claim to be literalists. Because the Bible is written quite ambiguously in places and is open to interpretation (and you MUST interpret some of it, even if it's only at the level of "Is this their culture or something that I have to do?" or "Does this discussion that fits every definition of Original Sin, but which doesn't use those exact words, discussing OS?"), there's not one literalist interpretation but numerous. There's also no way for any of these literalists to convince one another of anything; at least, not consistently. A few individuals may find a particular argument convincing, but the standard is the thing in question, which has rather obvious consequences.
 
This is why Biblical literalism fails--not because it's impossible, but because two people can read the same book and come to entirely different conclusions. The line the RCC fed us back in school was that Original Sin was rather the whole POINT of the Bible. The book started with where the sin came from (the Fall), then admitedly wandered off for a bit following the Jews around, but after the break came back to the main point with Jesus dying to give us a means to overcome Original Sin. This interpretation has been supported by Biblical scholars for so long that anyone asking for proof is merely showing that they are completely ignorant of historical thought on the matter (to pre-empt the question, the Rule of St. Benedict explicitely states much of this in the first chapter, and the Roman Catholic mass includes this as part of the litergy).

My point isn't that AvalonXQ is right or wrong--I think anyone who thinks the Bible is anything more than historical fiction is wrong, so I've got no dog in this fight. My point is that both AvalonXQ and those whom he opposes (theologically) can claim to be literalists. Because the Bible is written quite ambiguously in places and is open to interpretation (and you MUST interpret some of it, even if it's only at the level of "Is this their culture or something that I have to do?" or "Does this discussion that fits every definition of Original Sin, but which doesn't use those exact words, discussing OS?"), there's not one literalist interpretation but numerous. There's also no way for any of these literalists to convince one another of anything; at least, not consistently. A few individuals may find a particular argument convincing, but the standard is the thing in question, which has rather obvious consequences.

I think that I'd go along with this. There's no doubt that Catholic interpretation of the bible relies hugely on Church tradition - and considers that perfectly valid. However, "literalist" interpretations rely just as strongly on tradition - they just don't let on. The literal interpretation has stuck, for the most part, with the biological and archeological areas of dispute, and has given up on geography and astronomy. There might be geocentric Christians out there, but they aren't considered of any importance. The necessity of interpreting the bible in light of current knowledge has been accepted for as long as there's been such a thing as a bible. And, fundamentally, the Christian church was not founded on the bible. It says as much in the bible.
 
My point isn't that AvalonXQ is right or wrong--I think anyone who thinks the Bible is anything more than historical fiction is wrong, so I've got no dog in this fight. My point is that both AvalonXQ and those whom he opposes (theologically) can claim to be literalists. Because the Bible is written quite ambiguously in places and is open to interpretation (and you MUST interpret some of it, even if it's only at the level of "Is this their culture or something that I have to do?" or "Does this discussion that fits every definition of Original Sin, but which doesn't use those exact words, discussing OS?"), there's not one literalist interpretation but numerous. There's also no way for any of these literalists to convince one another of anything; at least, not consistently. A few individuals may find a particular argument convincing, but the standard is the thing in question, which has rather obvious consequences.

One of the most interestingly odd books I own, End Times Fiction, is a pretty thorough dismantling of Tim Layhe's End Times theology (the one he used in his Left Behind books) by Gary DeMar, wherin DeMar accuses LaHaye of some pretty severe Scriptural and theological errors in his "literal" reading of the Bible that he used to ostensibly construct his eschatology.

Gary DeMar just so happens to be one of the leading lights in the theocratic Christian Dominionism movement (I have another book, co-written with Gary North, about DeMar's brand of Dominonism), which is itself based heavily on a literalist reading of the Bible.

Which means that the entire thesis of End Times Fiction is that Tim LaHaye's literal reading of the Bible is wrong because Gary DeMar's literal reading of the Bible says so.
 
No, they were not. The NT in particular is in Greek and seemed to be aimed at a primarily non-Jewish audience, so one should expect something rather different out of it even if we ignore how the world changed in the centuries between the writing of the OT and NT (or even how much changed between the earliest parts of the OT and the latest).

And pulling racist nonsense like dismissing the entirety of the ancient Hebrew people as "illiterate goat herders" isn't helping your case.

Wind your neck in Charlie. I may have a speck of dust in my eye, you appear to have a pole up your backside.
 
westprog said:
The literal interpretation has stuck, for the most part, with the biological and archeological areas of dispute, and has given up on geography and astronomy. There might be geocentric Christians out there, but they aren't considered of any importance. The necessity of interpreting the bible in light of current knowledge has been accepted for as long as there's been such a thing as a bible.
It's not just that--the use of words changes over time. Thomas Paine makes a very good argument that "to prophesy" used to mean "to make music", including numerous chapters and verses that are nonsensical if you use the modern definition of the verb but which are perfectly logical if you use Paine's interpretation. I wasn't referring to science in my post, but to linguistics.

ANTPogo said:
Which means that the entire thesis of End Times Fiction is that Tim LaHaye's literal reading of the Bible is wrong because Gary DeMar's literal reading of the Bible says so.
The arguments that get under the skin of our resident Biblical literalists the most amount to exactly this as well--they say that the literal interpretation presented by atheists is wrong, because it violates their literalistic interpretation.

Gao said:
And pulling racist nonsense like dismissing the entirety of the ancient Hebrew people as "illiterate goat herders" isn't helping your case.
It's not racism to make a true statement about a group of people. The ancient Hebrews were almost entirely illiterate. They had an oral history because of that fact. I've heard arguments that they likely made their living off of hearding goats, but 1) am aware that no culture can survive entirely in such a fashion (you need craftsmen and sedentary farmers, at minimum), and 2) am willing to be proven wrong here.

This statement isn't racism for another, more subtle reason, though: It wasn't JUST the Hebrews that were illiterate and largely herdsmen. EVERYONE in that time and in that place was. The Hebrews aren't singled out here; atheists don't believe what any of the other illiterate goat-herding tribes said either. The only difference is that no one expects us to take, say, the Babalonian religion seriously.

So it's not "Because they're Hebrews they're illiterate goat-herders and therefore are wrong", but rather "These were illiterate goat-herders and were wrong; oh, and they happened to be Hebrews".
 
No, it really doesn't.

Of course it does. The ENTIRE book starts with an original sin and the only reason why the bible includes the old testament is because the gospels were seen as the conclusion of the story: Jesus resolves the problem of the original sin by giving you a way out.

If there is no original sin, there is no need for it. The Bible implies that sin being passed down through the generations. It's inherited. Otherwise why would we all sin after the whole Eden debacle ?
 
It's not just that--the use of words changes over time. .

When Charles II saw the completed St. Paul's Cathedral he called it ''awful, pompous and artificial'', meaning that it was was inspiring, imposing and constructed with great skill.
 
When Charles II saw the completed St. Paul's Cathedral he called it ''awful, pompous and artificial'', meaning that it was was inspiring, imposing and constructed with great skill.

In Charles II time the statement possibly meant inspired reverence, stately, created by man (Although artificial was a word used in its current form) But both awful and pompous have seen their meanings change
 
Of course it does. The ENTIRE book starts with an original sin and the only reason why the bible includes the old testament is because the gospels were seen as the conclusion of the story: Jesus resolves the problem of the original sin by giving you a way out.
This is an example of what I'm talking about. It's entirely possible to interpret the Bible in two ways: as focused on Original Sin, and as ignoring it. The fact that the Bible never uses the term "Original Sin" is the basis for the argument that it doesn't deal with the issue, and as far as I know it's true. The fact that the Bible harps on the fall of man, our wretched nature due to Adam and Eve's transgression, and the necessity for God to to torture His son/Himself to death in a blood-sacrifice to Himself to create the potential to overcome this issue, is the bases for the interpretation that the Bible does address the issue. Both can be supported from a literary perspective.

It's one reason I'm not a fan of literary criticism (which is what interpreting the Bible essentially is): it is possible, and in fact encouraged, to read the same story in multiple different ways, often based on philosophies that didn't exist when the book was written. I know an British Lit professor that enjoys examining Shakespeare's plays from a femanist perspective, for example. She takes the plays literally--but her perspective leads her to wildly divergent conclusions from what nearly any other interpretation would conclude. Simply put, for a good enough literary analist it's trivial to come up with multiple mutually exclusive interpretations of any text, even if they confine themselves to only that text (ie, no letters or previous interpretations) and even if they accept ad arguendum that the text is supposed to be literally true.

dafydd said:
When Charles II saw the completed St. Paul's Cathedral he called it ''awful, pompous and artificial'', meaning that it was was inspiring, imposing and constructed with great skill.
That may be the funniest thing I've seen all week. :D I've got to remember that--that British Lit prof. I mentioned above would LOVE this!
 
In Charles II time the statement possibly meant inspired reverence, stately, created by man (Although artificial was a word used in its current form) But both awful and pompous have seen their meanings change

That was the point. ;)
 
When Charles II saw the completed St. Paul's Cathedral he called it ''awful, pompous and artificial'', meaning that it was was inspiring, imposing and constructed with great skill.

Although the earliest known reference to any such statement, as far as I can tell, is in a Poul Anderson science fiction story.

Dave
 
When Charles II saw the completed St. Paul's Cathedral he called it ''awful, pompous and artificial'', meaning that it was was inspiring, imposing and constructed with great skill.


I get your point, but I've heard this is likely an apocryphal story (sometimes attributed to Queen Anne as well--see here).
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom