This is why Biblical literalism fails--not because it's impossible, but because two people can read the same book and come to entirely different conclusions. The line the RCC fed us back in school was that Original Sin was rather the whole POINT of the Bible. The book started with where the sin came from (the Fall), then admitedly wandered off for a bit following the Jews around, but after the break came back to the main point with Jesus dying to give us a means to overcome Original Sin. This interpretation has been supported by Biblical scholars for so long that anyone asking for proof is merely showing that they are completely ignorant of historical thought on the matter (to pre-empt the question, the Rule of St. Benedict explicitely states much of this in the first chapter, and the Roman Catholic mass includes this as part of the litergy).
My point isn't that AvalonXQ is right or wrong--I think anyone who thinks the Bible is anything more than historical fiction is wrong, so I've got no dog in this fight. My point is that both AvalonXQ and those whom he opposes (theologically) can claim to be literalists. Because the Bible is written quite ambiguously in places and is open to interpretation (and you MUST interpret some of it, even if it's only at the level of "Is this their culture or something that I have to do?" or "Does this discussion that fits every definition of Original Sin, but which doesn't use those exact words, discussing OS?"), there's not one literalist interpretation but numerous. There's also no way for any of these literalists to convince one another of anything; at least, not consistently. A few individuals may find a particular argument convincing, but the standard is the thing in question, which has rather obvious consequences.