Wow. In this post you admit that multiple stories instantaneously cease to provide support.
Yes. Multiple columns failed simultaneously.
And they failed over about 7-8 stories.
And, yes, NIST’s WTC collapse sim shows this.
So, you can no longer argue against NIST.
Nonsense. These are two logically orthogonal assertions.
NIST said hundreds of things. The multiple column, NEAR simultaneous buckling over several stories is only 4 of them.
An enormous permutation of NIST’s assertions could be argued to be correct or incorrect.
Here's why it's gold. OMG, I can't believe a skeptic has failed so hard. You have claimed, in your own words, that multiple stories buckled. Freefall is undeniable evidence that they did so instantaneously, and simultaneously. This means that every support column across multiple stories failed at the same time. There is absolutely no other conclusion that supports a freefall of the entire top of the building for any length of time, let alone 2.25 seconds.
No. Not nearly “every”. Not even close. The columns supporting the EPH failed many seconds before the global collapse.
Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But the factor of safety to total collapse was getting smaller.
Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But the factor of safety to total collapse was getting smaller. etc.
Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But now, the factor of safety to total collapse is zero.
So the building is brought to the brink of collapse by thousands, of sequential, non-simultaneous failures. Each time one component failed, other nearby components picked up its shed load. But there is no more redundancy.
Then one more component failed, and the remaining columns/components had no margin left to take up the shed load, and could not support the remaining building. One of the column starts to buckle, then the next buckles, then the next, in very fast (still not simultaneous) timing. The top block starts to pivot, … and all the rest of the columns buckle, as a result. Nearly simultaneously.
So. Not simultaneously. Nearly simultaneously.
And just like in any total progressive collapse, it is the last component’s failure that sets off the chain reaction that brings the whole building down.
You have "cause & effect" reversed, for ALL 3 buildings.
The start of the global collapse CAUSES the near simultaneous failure & buckling of the remaining, perhaps 70% of the peripheral columns. The core columns buckled before the peripheral ones.
Does NIST's computer model show this? No, it doesn't.
Wrong.
Yes NIST model shows exactly this.
Can a progressive collapse cause multiple support columns throughout an entire steel-framed high rise to fail instantaneously and simultaneously? Of course not. You have argued CD for me. Thanks.
Not all the columns.
Not instantaneously.
Not simultaneously.
Not CD.
Other than all that, you got almost everything … uh, … wrong.