If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
If NIST didn't have to admit freefall, why would they? It's obvious they tried to ignore it during their first drafts.

Asked and answered earlier by another poster. They did not feel any need to include it but because public questions were put forth about it they ammended the report to invlude a reference to it. Still doesnt make it relevant.
 
.
Excuse me, but we established that you didn't understand inertia when you claimed it was a "different concept" from Newton's first law.

My post is correct, valid, and it can stand on its own. I am not the one trying to use Newton for his own purposes.
 
Asked and answered earlier by another poster. They did not feel any need to include it but because public questions were put forth about it they ammended the report to invlude a reference to it. Still doesnt make it relevant.
It is relevant. If it wasn't they would not discuss it. What you are doing, clearly and undeniably, is ignoring something you don't like. That is the only explanation.
 
And this point is really meaningless, because the instantaneous velocity of the reference point at each measurement could be the same. You are trying to use the definition of something to try to lessen its importance. If this was a valid argument, NIST would use it.
So its meaningless now that you have back tracked away from claiming the instantaneous measurements of velocity were mafe.
Got it sparky.
 
The issue is “does scaling of one’s models play a significant impact on the outcomes of structural experiments?”

Cole is NOT performing a structural experiment. It is absurd to think his experiment is modeling structural data when his floors consist of paper and toothpicks, or matchsticks.

Cole is performing experiments to show Newton's laws of motion in action. Although everyone seems to be kicking and screaming while denying this, scale has no effect on Newton's laws. They apply equally regardless of the magnitude of the mass of the object and the magnitude of the forces involved.

I keep saying this, correctly, and it keeps being ignored. It is being ignored because you don't like it, so you refuse to accept it.
 
I propose to build a model that's similar to one of Cole's models, but only 1/10th the size. FalseFlag, if scale doesn't matter, do you predict that it will behave like Cole's model?
In regards to Newton's laws of motion scale won't matter.
If your argument is over the structural strength then scale will matter.
 
Can you provide the original video? You might be right, but without the video we won't know for sure, will we? I wonder why it is so hard to find? Could that be some sort of clue?

I completely agree that 5fps doesn't seem right.

That still begs the following question. If the quality of the video was too poor to measure velocity, why would NIST use it? Why would they admit something they didn't have to?

Fact is that it N..America, 29.97 fps has been the standard for TV video since colour TV took hold.
Fact is that it is not possible to directly measure velocity. It is determined by noting displacement over a time interval.

Given that tfk went over all of this in detail and better than I did, I find it odd you chose to only respond to my posts

BTW, I received my 20 year bonus at work this year. I am a video tech and editor. If the video is from CBS ENG equipment, then it IS 29.97 fps. Hell even Chandler says it is. Why do you question that?
 
Wow. In this post you admit that multiple stories instantaneously cease to provide support.

Yes. Multiple columns failed simultaneously.
And they failed over about 7-8 stories.

And, yes, NIST’s WTC collapse sim shows this.

So, you can no longer argue against NIST.

Nonsense. These are two logically orthogonal assertions.

NIST said hundreds of things. The multiple column, NEAR simultaneous buckling over several stories is only 4 of them.

An enormous permutation of NIST’s assertions could be argued to be correct or incorrect.

Here's why it's gold. OMG, I can't believe a skeptic has failed so hard. You have claimed, in your own words, that multiple stories buckled. Freefall is undeniable evidence that they did so instantaneously, and simultaneously. This means that every support column across multiple stories failed at the same time. There is absolutely no other conclusion that supports a freefall of the entire top of the building for any length of time, let alone 2.25 seconds.

No. Not nearly “every”. Not even close. The columns supporting the EPH failed many seconds before the global collapse.

Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But the factor of safety to total collapse was getting smaller.

Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But the factor of safety to total collapse was getting smaller. etc.

Then more columns failed. No global collapse. But now, the factor of safety to total collapse is zero.

So the building is brought to the brink of collapse by thousands, of sequential, non-simultaneous failures. Each time one component failed, other nearby components picked up its shed load. But there is no more redundancy.

Then one more component failed, and the remaining columns/components had no margin left to take up the shed load, and could not support the remaining building. One of the column starts to buckle, then the next buckles, then the next, in very fast (still not simultaneous) timing. The top block starts to pivot, … and all the rest of the columns buckle, as a result. Nearly simultaneously.

So. Not simultaneously. Nearly simultaneously.

And just like in any total progressive collapse, it is the last component’s failure that sets off the chain reaction that brings the whole building down.

You have "cause & effect" reversed, for ALL 3 buildings.

The start of the global collapse CAUSES the near simultaneous failure & buckling of the remaining, perhaps 70% of the peripheral columns. The core columns buckled before the peripheral ones.

Does NIST's computer model show this? No, it doesn't.

Wrong.
Yes NIST model shows exactly this.

Can a progressive collapse cause multiple support columns throughout an entire steel-framed high rise to fail instantaneously and simultaneously? Of course not. You have argued CD for me. Thanks.

Not all the columns.
Not instantaneously.
Not simultaneously.
Not CD.

Other than all that, you got almost everything … uh, … wrong.
 
My post is correct, valid, and it can stand on its own. I am not the one trying to use Newton for his own purposes.

Four lies in two sentences; at least you're getting more efficient. Your statement that inertia and Newton's first law are "different concepts" is absolutely incorrect and any reasoning following from that is invalid. It does not stand on its own because inertia acts as a force, and force is a vector having both direction and magnitude. Saying that the direction doesn't depend on scale while ignoring that the magnitude does is a position that's indistinguishable from gross stupidity. And surely there isn't anyone here who isn't aware of the purpose of such imaginary physics.

In regards to Newton's laws of motion scale won't matter.
If your argument is over the structural strength then scale will matter.

:jaw-dropp
Is this a breakthrough? Now try applying this new-found understanding to Cole's idiotic model.
 
Amazingly incompetent.

YouTubez:

NIST: nist.gov/el/disasterstudies/wtc/
In left side, click on "Photos, Videos & Simulations”

The video is called: "CBS-Net Dub5 24.avi”
Search for it, stick it into your “basket”, then download your basket.

If you're going to call me incompetent then at least point to the actual video. This is nothing more than a dirty trick. It shows just how low you will go.

This is NOT the video Chandler used. The absence of the CBS logo is one clue, and the extremely low quality and pixelation is another clue. I already knew about the videos you posted.

You should learn the definition of incompetence before you use it again. You should also look up fraud.
 
Now, notice that number circled in red: "-9.885". What do you think that means?
It obviously means downward acceleration, which is within 1 percent of the actual value in New York.

Now, here's the really interesting part. Notice the number beside it:
"± 0.456" What do you think that means?

That is the standard deviation.

Now, show me your technical acumen. Do you think that Chandler's data really shows "Free fall acceleration"?

Or do you think that "9.885" number needs to be, uh, "embellished" or perhaps "clarified" a little bit?

I don't need to be the expert on this. All I have to do is know who to trust. NIST says freefall for 2.25 seconds. Chandler says approximately the same thing.

In case you need any more convincing,

I don't.

Yes, in fact it DOES make sense to use every 6th data point instead of every one.
Thanks for walking head first right into that one. If he has a video with 29.97 fps, and he intentionally extracts every 6th frame, and NIST does the same thing, then why on earth would any competent person demand 30 data points per second? Why use less reference points when they exist?
Oh, you answer this question for me.

Remember that I told you that taking derivatives of discrete data was an “ill posed math problem”. This is EXACTLY WHY it is “ill posed”. Do you see that “∆t” in the denominator of the “velocity calculation” just above. Well, as ∆t gets shorter, then uncertainties in the velocity start to grow. The velocities start to jump greatly up & down due to small errors in the position. Then uncertainties in the acceleration, from point to point, skyrocket out of control. There are methods for taming this behavior, but a simple way to do so is to just use every nth point, which keeps ∆t reasonably large. This is exactly why he uses every 6th point.

Thanks again for answering your own question.

And then he runs up against one of the problems with translating discrete data into continuous data, the Nyquist Criteria. Which says that, at a sampling rate of 5 samples/second, the acceleration could be oscillating all over the place, and his analysis will never be able to see any oscillation with a frequency greater than about 5/6 = 0.8 Hz. So, the tower could be accelerating & decelerating at frequencies higher than this very slow oscillation (1.2 seconds / cycle), and Chandler’s technique will never see it.

Does NIST's technique see this? If so, and it matters, why don't they mention it and deny freefall?

This is something that Chandler, being a high school physics teacher, is clueless about.
You posted a link to his paper, so you must have seen where he lists his education. It's really an absurd argument to claim he doesn't know what he's doing. It's also absurd to claim he doesn't know what he's doing when he is the one who got NIST to admit freefall.
 
So, you admit I'm right. If so, I don't need to explain, because you have done it for me.

LOL, nope, you clearly still don't understand WHY scale matters for a structural model, but let's take it one step at a time. So, you now realize that scale matters for a structural model, can you please tell us just what you would like to infer from Cole's experiments?
 
Remember I told you about compression artifacts.

Post the original video used in NIST's calculation and we will talk about artifacts. Actually, no we won't. Does NIST mention this? If they don't, then why does this matter?
 
LOL, nope, you clearly still don't understand WHY scale matters for a structural model, but let's take it one step at a time. So, you now realize that scale matters for a structural model, can you please tell us just what you would like to infer from Cole's experiments?
Watch the video. You can infer whatever you want.
 
Its a bit of a chore to navigate but I can find everything I want to find anytime the notion hits me. I guess some people aren't really looking for facts and truth.
OK, then find the actual video NIST used, and the actual video Chandler used. Please post working links. If you can't find it then I guess you aren't looking for facts and truth, according to your own statement.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom