If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
Idiots like Jones in 911 truth lie about 911, and followers believe. A cult movement celebrating ignorance and failed logic.
One nitpick. Jones may be an idiot, but does not explain the lying. No doubt Jones and people like him think they are getting some benefit out of running a scam that celebrates ignorance and failed logic - and they probably are.

And I suspect that the majority of 911 truthers are doing it for similar reasons. It's not that they believe the nonsense, but it gives them a heightened sense of importance and self-worth compared to the 'sheeple'. This why you will never convince them that they are wrong. They already know it.
 
...
Let the personal attacks begin. I know that is what will happen, because that is all the skeptics have.
LOL, the second video, a lie based on ignorance, a video which fools people who can't think for themselves. The comments from the video are proof of overwhelming ignornace in 911 truth cult members. Like a celebration of ignorance and BS.
Ahh, the scientific method. Proof that what we were told on that day, was an absolute evil and disgusting lie. Out and down. Perfect. Let the hangings begin.
A 911 truth cult member who want to kill... the best of 911 truth.
funny you had the build a support so the upper floors did not topple. makes you wonder how the upper portion of the wtcs didn't topple
911 truth minions think the WTC is like a tree... the ignorance is overwhelming in 911 truth followers.
If fire weakens steel I have a big problem: my wood stove is made of steel and it runs non-stop for 6 months per year for the last 35 years. Maybe next winter my steel stove will pancake?
Idiot thinks his wood stove is a WTC tower analogy BS.
Controlled nukes(isreali w54's) brought these structures down. Sending the blast upwards turning everything into dust(vaporized) including the huge antenna on the south tower.
911 truth, the movement which presents dumb, dumber, and dumbest, and new undefined levels of stupidity and idiotic claims.
out when they say fire melting supports etc, how did this jet fuel manage to burn so long? when the plane impact the fuel is kept in the wings. wings are normally designed to fall off on impact since they contain the fuel and during crashes would burn up the plane and survivors of said crash.
Can't believe the BS. Why would you design wings to fall off? lol, this is sad. Where do wings go at 590 mph when they fall off based on physics, super smart failed physics dolt for 911 truth? lol
I'm just an ordinary guy that's worked construction all my life and to me the whole 'official' explanation is a joke. Kerosene won't melt steel without an oxidizer and maybe not even then. The smoke was black indicating oxygen starvation and therefore a colder burn. Paper and vinyl in a oxygen starved place will burn hotter? Oh REALLY?? The building had to be built so the lower floors supported the upper ones or it would have fallen in on itself a long time ago. People will believe anything they're told. Pitiful, isn't it. Gravity never lies and a freefall doesn't either.
Then it gets dumber. Zero research, zero knowledge,... 911 truth followers are zero experts.

I thought it was impossible to find humans dumber than the 19 who did 911; then 911 truth proved me wrong.
 
Last edited:
The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

If you are going to quote Feynman you might want to read his writings on what he dubs Cargo Cult Science.

Because Mr Cole is doing just that.
 
The full version involves a Mathematician, a Physicist, and an Engineer. The Mathematician goes first, accepts 1 as a special case (1 is not prime) but stops at 9, and rejects the theory.

The Physicist goes next and proceeds as you describe.

The Engineer (for Truth) goes last...
1 Prime
3 Prime
5 Prime
7 Prime
9 Prime
11 Prime
13 prime
...
Yes, but everytime I tell the joke in full I get flack from engineers, so I condensed it. :cool:
 
If there's an experiment to simulate the joltless collapse of WTC 1, then by all means at least write the blueprints for us. You said it would be easy.

Yes there is, the lack of a jolt, was caused by the weak ness of the connections, and the bypass of the core columns, during buckling.
 

Yes, really. Scale is irrelevant. An object on earth, regardless of size (with possible exceptions at the atomic and sub-atomic levels), has the same acceleration due to gravity.

Your failure to accept this fact undermines any credibility you are trying to achieve in your other posts.

Once again, I will state my challenge. Pick one of Mr. Cole's claims, just one, and prove him wrong by experiment.

LOL. It's never going to happen.
 
Yes, really. Scale is irrelevant. An object on earth, regardless of size (with possible exceptions at the atomic and sub-atomic levels), has the same acceleration due to gravity.

Your failure to accept this fact undermines any credibility you are trying to achieve in your other posts.

Once again, I will state my challenge. Pick one of Mr. Cole's claims, just one, and prove him wrong by experiment.

LOL. It's never going to happen.

Just wanted to quote this for people that understand the limitation of scale in models.

Carry on oh seeker of "truth".................:rolleyes:

ETA: Actually this could be a good Stundie nomination.......
 
Last edited:
I saw an interesting video snippet using dried spaghetti. If you took a full length piece, you could flex it with little pressure applied to and bottom.

Every time you halved the piece, it took more force to make it bend. The ratio of length to thickness changes.

Scale matters.

You misunderstand the issue of scale.
 
Just wanted to quote this for people that understand the limitation of scale in models.

Carry on oh seeker of "truth".................:rolleyes:

ETA: Actually this could be a good Stundie nomination.......

I hope as many of you as possible go on record stating that scale matters in the experiments performed by Mr. Cole. What you are really doing is destroying your credibility. Please continue.
 
Just wanted to quote this for people that understand the limitation of scale in models.

Carry on oh seeker of "truth".................:rolleyes:

ETA: Actually this could be a good Stundie nomination.......
Your ETA was my first thought. That is Cluesforum level misunderstanding of physics.
 
Last edited:
Your ETA was my first thought. That is Cluesforum level misunderstanding of physics.
My question is, who would I be making this video debunking for? Cole made his for high school graduates that got a C in physics(or never took it). Obviously anything past that is pointless because anyone past that would be able to figure it out on their own. So, is the video geared to C+ student?

Sorry, the truth hurts.
 
Sure.

The first video proves, via experiment, that the viral blacksmith video is BS.

The second video proves, via several experiments, that the official story is BS. The video also contains an experiment that closely replicates the actual collapse of WTC1 and WTC2. Mr. Cole does this by blowing out the support columns in sequence, much like a controlled demolition.

Pure crap. I'm out.
 
You have no concept of the issue of scale.

Sure I don't. /sarcasm

That's why the formula F=ma changes depending on the size of the object, right? F=ma is only valid for certain sized objects. Once you get to skyscrapers, the formulas are different, right? So, if scale is relevant, like you claim, please post the formulas that apply to large objects only, and explain how they don't apply to smaller objects. Please post the formulas that apply to Mr. Cole's experiments, and then post the formulas that apply to the WTC buildings.

If I make a debunking video, should it be geared to (audience) the same level of education Cole uses?

It's your video, do whatever you want.
 
Sure I don't. /sarcasm

That's why the formula F=ma changes depending on the size of the object, right? F=ma is only valid for certain sized objects. Once you get to skyscrapers, the formulas are different, right? So, if scale is relevant, like you claim, please post the formulas that apply to large objects only, and explain how they don't apply to smaller objects. Please post the formulas that apply to Mr. Cole's experiments, and then post the formulas that apply to the WTC buildings.



It's your video, do whatever you want.

Quoting again to show you have no concept of scale in models.

Keep up the good work. The world population that did better than squeaked by in high school mocks your effort.
 
Last edited:
I hope as many of you as possible go on record stating that scale matters in the experiments performed by Mr. Cole. What you are really doing is destroying your credibility. Please continue.

Yanno, somehow "destroyed credibility" when it is being judged by a Truther doesn't worry me all that much, especially after watching that video.

I'm reminded of Spook and his chicken wire cage and how he had to step on it to make it collapse when fire didn't do it. That was in 2004 or 5. Amazing how far the Truth movement has come since then. (cough cough)
 
Quoting again to show you have no concept to scale in models.

Keep up the good work. The world population that did better than squeaked by in high school mocks your effort.

Just words.

Still waiting on an experiment that disproves just ONE of Mr. Cole's claims.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom