If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
My concern is what Cole's excuse is. He's supposedly an engineer.
That's what the guy who fixes my washing machine calls himself, too. And the guys who repairs phone cables. I don't think it's a protected term.
 
56 seconds in he uses the molten steel running down the channels nonsense and jet fuel can't melt steel beams crap. There's never been any evidence of the presence of liquid steel or iron in any significant quantity at ground zero.

1 min 30, he states that the bloke who says steel at 1800°F (982°C) will compromise any structure is wrong. He then shows what he thinks is proof of liquid steel by showing a crumpled or buckled rusted steel section that has clearly not melted.

The guy is a moron, he thinks falling is a remarkable motion. 4:24 - what an idiot. His argument against the viral video is based on where the steel was heated and the direction of force applied. He's completely misunderstood the point of the blacksmiths video.

Now he's heated a steel bar roughly equidistant from the top where the fires where in the WTC. Then he hits the top with a hammer and uses this laughable exercise as some sort of proof that the WTC couldn't have collapsed because his steel bar heated in the middle doesn't. He didn't heat it too much either, certainly nowhere near 1000°C.

The whole video is drivel. It's based on the false assumption that liquid steel was present. He fails to understand the blacksmith's point and strawmans a whole lot of nonsense about where the heat was applied and where the force was coming from. And then produces a stupid experiment that negates scale and structure to try to show that the towers would not have collapsed.

It's a total fail. Only truthers could possibly think this video has merit. It's beyond stupid. Infact the stupid burns.

Stupid can't melt steel beams!
 
Last edited:
I don't know what you mean by this.

When I say Upshot... I am summarising the conclusion of Cole, not offering an opinion. Any hints, implications etc are made by Cole in the video.

If anything my review was scathing towards Cole, not endorsing him.

I agree you didn't support Cole, who could, such experiments are doomed to fail but they are a really comedy act to watch, I have several oil well pump rods, 20 ft by 1/2 inch steel, I stand one on end it would bend under it's own weight.
 
Cole's experiments show nothing because as stated above.... you cannot scale forces and the properties of materials!

Once the collapse initiated... it was a floor destruction / collapse... no columns participated, resisted or were involved... the floors were not strong enough to support or resist the falling mass and yielded in a tiny fraction of a second... making the entire COLLAPSE time about 14 seconds which is slower that a fall through air.

Truthers show a stunning lack of understanding of physics and cherry pick and misapply physics to fool the naive.
 
56 seconds in he uses the molten steel running down the channels nonsense and jet fuel can't melt steel beams crap. There's never been any evidence of the presence of liquid steel or iron in any significant quantity at ground zero.

1 min 30, he states that the bloke who says steel at 1800°F (982°C) will compromise any structure is wrong. He then shows what he thinks is proof of liquid steel by showing a crumpled or buckled rusted steel section that has clearly not melted.

The guy is a moron, he thinks falling is a remarkable motion. 4:24 - what an idiot. His argument against the viral video is based on where the steel was heated and the direction of force applied. He's completely misunderstood the point of the blacksmiths video.

Now he's heated a steel bar roughly equidistant from the top where the fires where in the WTC. Then he hits the top with a hammer and uses this laughable exercise as some sort of proof that the WTC couldn't have collapsed because his steel bar heated in the middle doesn't. He didn't heat it too much either, certainly nowhere near 1000°C.

The whole video is drivel. It's based on the false assumption that liquid steel was present. He fails to understand the blacksmith's point and strawmans a whole lot of nonsense about where the heat was applied and where the force was coming from. And then produces a stupid experiment that negates scale and structure to try to show that the towers would not have collapsed.

It's a total fail. Only truthers could possibly think this video has merit. It's beyond stupid. Infact the stupid burns.

Stupid can't melt steel beams!

That should be Stupidity Can't melt steel Columns, and I said that years ago.
 
I agree you didn't support Cole, who could, such experiments are doomed to fail but they are a really comedy act to watch, I have several oil well pump rods, 20 ft by 1/2 inch steel, I stand one on end it would bend under it's own weight.

I saw an interesting video snippet using dried spaghetti. If you took a full length piece, you could flex it with little pressure applied to and bottom.

Every time you halved the piece, it took more force to make it bend. The ratio of length to thickness changes.

Scale matters.
 
I saw an interesting video snippet using dried spaghetti. If you took a full length piece, you could flex it with little pressure applied to and bottom.

Every time you halved the piece, it took more force to make it bend. The ratio of length to thickness changes.
Scale matters.
Yes. And not only for the highlighted reason (which does count). There's a more complicated principle in play too, the square-cube lawWP. An ant can carry several times its weight, yet an elephant can barely support its own, and needs far thicker legs (in relation to their body) to do so.
 
I saw an interesting video snippet using dried spaghetti. If you took a full length piece, you could flex it with little pressure applied to and bottom.

Every time you halved the piece, it took more force to make it bend. The ratio of length to thickness changes.

Scale matters.

The other thing that's interesting about dried spaghetti is that, if you push down vertically on it till it breaks, the bits fly out sideways.

Just saying.

Dave
 
The whole video is drivel. It's based on the false assumption that liquid steel was present.

Actually, this is the point. A lot of debunkers get the "Jet fuel can't melt steel" meme completely wrong.

The meme starts with a position that there was melted steel at ground zero, then insists that jet fuel and office fires cannot account for the presence of this melted steel. (This is the premise of the meme, I offer no comment or opinion).

Therefore, the blacksmith, amongst others, is trying to disprove the wrong theory. The response is valid as a response to an erroneous assumption in some ways. The blacksmith implies with his experiment that there was multiple white hot columns and/or beams (it's not clear as it's not part of a proper model). They do throw in a red herring about a white hot lobby, and probably other things that I can't recall.
 
The other thing that's interesting about dried spaghetti is that, if you push down vertically on it till it breaks, the bits fly out sideways.

Just saying.

Dave

Actually, that gets in to the second video, where they do say that there should be down and out in a gravity collapse. He shows this with horizontal wood blocks with vertical hinges to represent the walls.
 
These characters are either intellectually dishonest... they know they are giving false information... or they are just uneducated about basic laws of physics... or both. To the naive typical person who is also uneducated about physics and materials science... it makes perfect sense. Very easy to fool an idiot.

What is really missing from the truther people is critical thinking and technical knowledge. What is ever present is their complete distrust of all things coming from the media or the government.
 
The thread title is part of a famous quote by Richard P. Feynman. The full quote is, "It doesn't matter how beautiful your theory is, it doesn't matter how smart you are. If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong."

I like this quote. What it doesn't say, however, and something just as important, is that if your theory does agree with experiment, the theory must be right. It may still be wrong for other reasons.

This is probably why my theory that Leprechauns destroyed the WTC is not generally accepted, even though it aligns exactly with all the evidence - because I constructed it that way.

Cole has done some experiments. They prove exactly what they address: paper rings and firecrackers. But there was another experiment, one done on 9-11. That experiment used airplanes and terrorists and the results are in - the buildings fell. You can't now go back with a different experiment and claim a strong analogy - not when we already have the fallen buildings.

As to his heated rod experiment, it directly contradicts the claims in his other video where heat doesn't do what he wants and firecrackers are added.

It is not enough to claim that one thing looks like another thing and then say the second thing captures the significant elements of the first. If that were so, I could point out how well my dog models a horse and insist he eat grass instead of meat. Yes, my dog has four limbs, eyes and a mouth. Yes, he eats at the nose end and poops out the other. But I have failed to model the critical item - his gut. All the rest is dumbed-down "this looks like that."

The really strange thing is we have the experiment of 9-11 already, and this is consistently ignored in favor of models that output different things. Here are the buildings as they stand. Here comes the airplanes. Here's what happened next. That's the gold standard, not some cartoonish version.

We already know the answer to the question, "What happened?" our task, if any, is to explore the details of how it happened. Any theory that adds extraneous elements (like explosives or thermite) is already wrong - because it adds things that weren't there. If our model has to add them, then our model is wrong. If our experiment needs additional elements, then our experiment doesn't match reality. It's still a neat experiment, it's just not applicable to what actually happened.
 
Any theory that adds extraneous elements (like explosives or thermite) is already wrong - because it adds things that weren't there. If our model has to add them, then our model is wrong. If our experiment needs additional elements, then our experiment doesn't match reality. It's still a neat experiment, it's just not applicable to what actually happened.


What they do.... is begin from disbelief... what we saw was not possible without some added energy inputs. Then they set about to make what amount to experiments which do not apply to the real event, ignore the issues of scaling and focus on false premises. For example the collapses PROGRESSED not from failed columns... but collapsing floor mass MISSING the columns.

The initiation was kicked off by a progressive load redistribution at one level which eventually robbed the axial members (columns) of their reserve and then some and so the mass above caused the remaining columns at that level to buckle... the mass came down... destroyed the floor it fell upon... passing the columns... and repeated this all the way to the ground. The engineering and physics is pretty damn basic. The concepts are not hard to grasp.

The exact set of mechanisms or processes which led to the loss of strength leading to the top drop are difficult to know because there were no transducers to measure things up there. It's likely that there was warping, elongation of members, breaking of beam splices, knife connections of bracing to columns, breaking of trusses... and loss of significant "strength" in some columns, bracing beams, truss seats, truss chords, spaulding failures of the concrete destroying its composite with the trusses and the pan. All of this was driven by heat and the initial damage from the plane and subsequent load redistribution. Once 3+/- floor masses were disengaged from the structural frame... the fate of the tower was sealed... total collapse of the floors and toppling of the columns made unstable without the bracing provided by the floor system.

7wtc experienced a not dissimilar progressive failure of axial members. It rapidly spread from the NE quadrant westward gutting the interior and causing the floors above to collapse inside the curtain wall connected to the perimeter moment frame. The perimeter moment frame and curtain wall dropped after losing support at floor 8. It has about 23(?) columns directly coupled to the foundation of the 57(?) above floor 8. Both the east and west side below 8 were braced framed trusses which apparently were pulled in... and the north side had half of the columns resting on cantilevers.

Missing from the truth guys analysis is an understanding the actual structures of the 3 buildings.
 
Actually, that gets in to the second video, where they do say that there should be down and out in a gravity collapse. He shows this with horizontal wood blocks with vertical hinges to represent the walls.

He fails to understand he has made the connections way to strong, it is the bolts and welds that broke in the towers, and he fails to accurately duplicate them?
 
False Flag, I've seen "experiments" on YouTube that demonstrate perpetual motion and free energy. I've seen "experiments" on YouTube that demonstrate levitation and mind reading.

If your claim is that Cole got it right, you can't just start by assuming he got it right. You have to actually show that he got it right. Only then can you demand that people think about what it means that he got it right.
 
What they do.... is begin from disbelief... what we saw was not possible without some added energy inputs. Then they set about to make what amount to experiments which do not apply to the real event, ignore the issues of scaling and focus on false premises. For example the collapses PROGRESSED not from failed columns... but collapsing floor mass MISSING the columns.

The initiation was kicked off by a progressive load redistribution at one level which eventually robbed the axial members (columns) of their reserve and then some and so the mass above caused the remaining columns at that level to buckle... the mass came down... destroyed the floor it fell upon... passing the columns... and repeated this all the way to the ground. The engineering and physics is pretty damn basic. The concepts are not hard to grasp.

The exact set of mechanisms or processes which led to the loss of strength leading to the top drop are difficult to know because there were no transducers to measure things up there. It's likely that there was warping, elongation of members, breaking of beam splices, knife connections of bracing to columns, breaking of trusses... and loss of significant "strength" in some columns, bracing beams, truss seats, truss chords, spaulding failures of the concrete destroying its composite with the trusses and the pan. All of this was driven by heat and the initial damage from the plane and subsequent load redistribution. Once 3+/- floor masses were disengaged from the structural frame... the fate of the tower was sealed... total collapse of the floors and toppling of the columns made unstable without the bracing provided by the floor system.

7wtc experienced a not dissimilar progressive failure of axial members. It rapidly spread from the NE quadrant westward gutting the interior and causing the floors above to collapse inside the curtain wall connected to the perimeter moment frame. The perimeter moment frame and curtain wall dropped after losing support at floor 8. It has about 23(?) columns directly coupled to the foundation of the 57(?) above floor 8. Both the east and west side below 8 were braced framed trusses which apparently were pulled in... and the north side had half of the columns resting on cantilevers.

Missing from the truth guys analysis is an understanding the actual structures of the 3 buildings.

Everything Cole does is designed to promote 9!11 truth, he is Gage's new pet engineering professional, designing stuff to promote Gage's Quest for more cash.
 
Not prepared to state specific claims, then. The first video is clearly irrelevant, because the heat resistance of steel is what it is irrespective of any video bickering. I'd almost bet money that the second video is based on ignorance of scaling laws, because that's one of the whole truth movement's signature errors. But if you can't be bothered to state the claim, I can't be bothered to address it.

Dave

Yes, he takes a bunch of squares supported by pegs and proves conclusively he understands nothing about scaling.
 
In this case, scale is irrelevant. If you watched the video you would know this.

I hope that any truther who stumbles onto this website sees this post early on in their research. The fact that no one (or not everyone) is willing to watch the videos should be a clear sign that there is a problem here. Absolutely nothing that the skeptics argue should be taken with any seriousness. It is abundantly clear they have an agenda to perpetuate the lies in the official story, regardless of what evidence they are presented with.

This thread, and the responses of the skeptics, can not make that fact any clearer.

REAlly?

:dl:
 
Well, I'm glad I've never got involved with this subject, because arguing with that level of ignorance would give me a headache.

Not much arguing actually going on it's really just truther preaching.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom