If it doesn't agree with experiment, it's wrong.

Status
Not open for further replies.
See my reply to abaddon. I was simply summarising the content, not offering an opinion.

Quite right.

Somehow, I got you confused with a poster who, elsewhere, seems to support CD, and "melted steel", and "the hole isn't big enough for a real plane", and "living hijackers", and "switched planes", and some other stuff...

And for that I apologize.

It is not without reason that one is encouraged, when supping with the devil, to use a "longge spoone".
 
Last edited:
Actually, this is the point. A lot of debunkers get the "Jet fuel can't melt steel" meme completely wrong.

The meme starts with a position that there was melted steel at ground zero, then insists that jet fuel and office fires cannot account for the presence of this melted steel. (This is the premise of the meme, I offer no comment or opinion).

Therefore, the blacksmith, amongst others, is trying to disprove the wrong theory. The response is valid as a response to an erroneous assumption in some ways. The blacksmith implies with his experiment that there was multiple white hot columns and/or beams (it's not clear as it's not part of a proper model). They do throw in a red herring about a white hot lobby, and probably other things that I can't recall.

The problem is that the "jet fuel can't melt steel" meme is too vague, and we usually don't know what those spreading it think when they say it.
I don't know if the origin of this meme is known, and what was originally meant.

I agree that many truthers believe that there was in fact molten steel, and they would be correct to state that jet fuel can hardly have been the proximate cause for that.
But there are also truthers who believe that "jet fue melted steel" is part of the official story, and/or that steel must melt in order for a steel structure to come apart. The blacksmith addresses this believe - and successfully debunks it.
You are correct to point out that his demonstration does not debunk the claim that there was molten steel which jet fuel couldn't have produce - he simply doesn't address it.

From here, we can go on to the "So there was molten steel" thread. Molten steel is irrelevant. No one has actually presented any theory of CD that would explain the alleged specific (time, location, amount...) observations of molten steel.
 
The problem is that the "jet fuel can't melt steel" meme is too vague, and we usually don't know what those spreading it think when they say it.
I don't know if the origin of this meme is known, and what was originally meant.

I agree that many truthers believe that there was in fact molten steel, and they would be correct to state that jet fuel can hardly have been the proximate cause for that.
But there are also truthers who believe that "jet fue melted steel" is part of the official story, and/or that steel must melt in order for a steel structure to come apart. The blacksmith addresses this believe - and successfully debunks it.
You are correct to point out that his demonstration does not debunk the claim that there was molten steel which jet fuel couldn't have produce - he simply doesn't address it.

From here, we can go on to the "So there was molten steel" thread. Molten steel is irrelevant. No one has actually presented any theory of CD that would explain the alleged specific (time, location, amount...) observations of molten steel.

The origin of the meme is for the molten material flowing from the towers, and the reports of molten steel, Steven E Jones used the meme in his original paper with the picture of the fire fighter supposedly sticking his arm down into molten steel. :D
 
Sure.

The first video proves, via experiment, that the viral blacksmith video is BS.

Well thank you ! I would have lost time watching it if you had no summarized this. As someone which which 1) watched the blacksmith video 2) watched somebody hammer iron horseshoe 3) got to try it once for fun knows by my own experience and the one of others that heated metal DO weaken when you heat them, and the local forge was not that hot to melt anything whatsoever. In fact most of the time the shoe was only bright cherry red.

So anybody pretending that the experiment is wrong, that it did not purport to demonstrate what it did (that steel weaken with temperature) is obviously misleading and do not need to bother watching what he blabbers.

PS: the blacksmith video is not the only one, somebody else had a video of an I beam heated by jet fuel, weakening considerably under load. Maybe that one is BS too, he ? LOL.
 
I hope that any truther who stumbles onto this website sees this post early on in their research. The fact that no one (or not everyone) is willing to watch the videos should be a clear sign that there is a problem here.

I hope that any truther who stumbles onto this website sees this post early on in their research too. The fact that I was able to identify a fatal flaw in Cole's video without even needing to watch it should be a strong indication of exactly what the problem is; truthers make the same stupid errors over and over and over again.

Dave
 
Anyone who thinks scale is irrelevant in any assessment of structural behavior should try the following experiment. (And please, if you do, make a YouTube video of it for the Official Scientific Record!)

1. Pick up a cupcake or muffin (unwrapped) by holding it between two fingers across its diameter.

2. Pick up a 2-foot diameter wedding cake (unsupported by any rigid non-cake base) by holding it between two forearms across its diameter.

Notice any difference?
 
A much better experiment I think is to advice them to try to carry about 100 time their own weight. Or even 10 times. Or heck 1 time their own weight.

If scale did not matter that should be easy peasy.
 
Anyone who thinks scale is irrelevant in any assessment of structural behavior should try the following experiment. (And please, if you do, make a YouTube video of it for the Official Scientific Record!)

1. Pick up a cupcake or muffin (unwrapped) by holding it between two fingers across its diameter.

2. Pick up a 2-foot diameter wedding cake (unsupported by any rigid non-cake base) by holding it between two forearms across its diameter.

Notice any difference?

You left out the part of the experiment where I attempt to jam them into my mouth.
 
The problem with these "scaleability" thought problems is they forget to scale up the atoms, molecules and intermolecular forces. If you do that, it all works out as planned.

It works in the other direction too. If you have a small rod to heat and want to scale down, you shouldn't heat it with a temperature needed to heat a beam to its softening point. You should scale it down. Maybe breathe on it using a cat which has recently exercised. Bet it won't bend then.

That's a mistake Cole makes too. Instead of using firecrackers (which produce the same kind of explosive energy as demolition charges) he should have used something appropriate to the scale. Finch farts would be ideal, but any small bird-produced anal wind would suffice.
 
FalseFlag, could you please state in you own words what Cole's experiment is and what it proves?

I started watching the first video but at 0:20 Cole says, "There's plenty of evidence of temperatures high enough to melt steel." Then he rattles off six pieces of "evidence" that are either abject BS or completely irrelevant to any CD theories if he can't actually (a) tie it directly to the collapse and (b) show that CD is the best explanation.

I don't think you should ask readers to wade through Cole's BS to get to whatever it is you think is significant about his experiment, only to be sadly disappointed. What is the experiment and what does it prove?
 
Sure.

The first video proves, via experiment, that the viral blacksmith video is BS.

The second video proves, via several experiments, that the official story is BS. The video also contains an experiment that closely replicates the actual collapse of WTC1 and WTC2. Mr. Cole does this by blowing out the support columns in sequence, much like a controlled demolition.

Wow, the video is not BS, 911 truth is BS.

woodbeambentsteel-full.jpg

The second video is proof 911 truth has a super steel delusion based on overwhelming ignorance. Idiots like Jones in 911 truth lie about 911, and followers believe. A cult movement celebrating ignorance and failed logic.

Actually, this is the point. A lot of debunkers get the "Jet fuel can't melt steel" meme completely wrong.
...
Therefore, the blacksmith, amongst others, is trying to disprove the wrong theory. The response is valid as a response to an erroneous assumption in some ways. The blacksmith implies with his experiment that there was multiple white hot columns and/or beams (it's not clear as it's not part of a proper model). They do throw in a red herring about a white hot lobby, and probably other things that I can't recall.
911 truth, the movement for lies dumbed down for people who can't think for themselves.

The blacksmith proves steel fails in fire, fails in heat. 911 truth fails to produce evidence for 14 years of dumbed down CD, thermite, and other idiotic claims based on ignorance. 911 truth can't learn.

Like still alive terrorists, or can't figure out which planes, 911 truth believers don't understand, but try to make BS about "debunkers" to make themselves feel better since 911 truth followers have no evidence.
 
Last edited:
Sure.

The first video proves, via experiment, that the viral blacksmith video is BS.

The Blacksmith video was simply to prove that steel loses a significant amount of strength before it's "molten". He did that. To claim otherwise is to admit to psychosis.
 
If you want to do proper experiments your self to prove Cole wrong, I could easily write up a design explaining why Cole's experiments did not work and showing how to properly design actual experiments that would be accurate.
Doing real and accurate experiments is expensive though, my last one cost me about 1100$ and that was a simple one!
I just can't see spending my money debunking Cole.
PS. Stating the obvious is not attacking Cole, it is only stating the obvious, debunking either the blacksmith or Cole is Irrelevant, because I did that long ago, in a chimney effect experiment, Cole has never ever done a chimney effect experiment, because they are costly and dangerous to duplicate, you have to actually build a multistory structure and the place inside the fuels.
A chimney effect is key to understanding the chemistry of the fires without it any experiment into the fires is worthless.

If there's an experiment to simulate the joltless collapse of WTC 1, then by all means at least write the blueprints for us. You said it would be easy.
 
When I was in university there was a joke among the physics students:
Theory: All odd numbers are Prime numbers.
Experimental observations
1 Prime
3 Prime
5 Prime
7 Prime
9 not Prime
11 Prime
13 prime

9 may be ignored as experimental error.
QED Theory is correct.
 
If there's an experiment to simulate the joltless collapse of WTC 1, then by all means at least write the blueprints for us. You said it would be easy.

What is joltless? What engineering school did 911 truth followers go to, and what the heck does joltless mean?

lol, joltless rides again. How many years will 911 truth fail... infinite years.

911 truth claims are clueless, and now we have joltless. The speed of collapse is proof of a gravity collapse with no CD. When will 911 truth prove CD? Never. With great engineering statements of joltless, 911 truth has reached new levels of BS.


When I was in university there was a joke among the physics students:
Theory: All odd numbers are Prime numbers.
Experimental observations
1 Prime
3 Prime
5 Prime
7 Prime
9 not Prime
11 Prime
13 prime

9 may be ignored as experimental error.
QED Theory is correct.
911 truth in action.
 
Last edited:
If there's an experiment to simulate the joltless collapse of WTC 1, then by all means at least write the blueprints for us. You said it would be easy.
As per my last post, framing an experiment properly, as Feynman would have been assuming is the case, is of primary importance.
The severity of 'jolt' will depend greatly on the dimensions of the model. Ie. the difference between surface area/volume/mass in differing scale models.
The 'measured jolt' in the videos also is highly dependent on the distance from the camera and the resolution of the video.


Then there is the odd idea that the collapse was column on column. It wasn't, it couldn't be and thus any and all 'jolts are not necessarily transferred to columns and made visible as jolting motion of the facade.
Then there is the work done by internet poster "Major Tom" who determines that the upper block did not all start moving at the same time, various sections came down ahead of others, which in turn would limit the visibility of any facade jolts.
 
Last edited:
When I was in university there was a joke among the physics students:
Theory: All odd numbers are Prime numbers.
Experimental observations
1 Prime
3 Prime
5 Prime
7 Prime
9 not Prime
11 Prime
13 prime

9 may be ignored as experimental error.
QED Theory is correct.

The full version involves a Mathematician, a Physicist, and an Engineer. The Mathematician goes first, accepts 1 as a special case (1 is not prime) but stops at 9, and rejects the theory.

The Physicist goes next and proceeds as you describe.

The Engineer (for Truth) goes last...
1 Prime
3 Prime
5 Prime
7 Prime
9 Prime
11 Prime
13 prime
...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom