If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

What this translates into is basically this:

Way to equate same sex marriage with child rape or the murder of handicapped children. Never mind that you offered no evidence or reasoning whatsoever for your slippery slope fallacy

Well I never used the word rape, I said consenting children. And maybe you haven't heard of this atheistic "Princeton" professor who examines ethics from a atheistic point of view. He is for the right to kill handicapped newborns.

From Wikis article on Princeton Professor "Peter Singer"

American economist Steve Forbes ceased his donations to Princeton University in 1999 because of Singer's appointment to an honorable position.[19] Nazi-hunter Simon Wiesenthal wrote to organizers of a Swedish book fair to which Singer was invited that "A professor of morals ... who justifies the right to kill handicapped newborns... is in my opinion unacceptable for representation at your level."[20] Marc Maurer, President of the National Federation of the Blind, the leading organization for blind people in the United States, strongly criticized Singer's appointment to the Princeton Faculty in a banquet speech at the organization's national convention in July 2001, claiming that Singer's support for euthanizing disabled babies could lead to disabled older children and adults being valued less as well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer
 
Last edited:
God, IOW, hates the American Constitution.
The god of the bible certainly would.

It's no mistake that many of the founding fathers were diests and not christian.


I will give props to the fact that jesus would completely agree with social welfare and universal health care, which are both very liberal secular virtues.

The funny part is, and the irony that DOC seems to miss, is that if jesus were alive today, he wouldn't be a democrat or republican, He'd be communist.
 
Well I never used the word rape, I said consenting children. And maybe you haven't heard of this atheistic "Princeton" professor who examines ethics from a atheistic point of view. He is for killing of handicapped newborns.


That's just another argument from authority, from the flip side. You really can't help yourself can you?

He is one atheist. Just one. He speaks for himself. There is no reason to believe, none whatsoever, that his opinions would become law in an atheistic society.
 
Well I never used the word rape, I said consenting children. And maybe you haven't heard of this atheistic "Princeton" professor who examines ethics from a atheistic point of view. He is for killing of handicapped newborns.
And perhaps you've never heard of the christian fundamentalist, Fred Phelps, who takes a rather hard line view of the bible. He's for killing.....everybody

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Phelps.
 
That's just another argument from authority, from the flip side. You really can't help yourself can you?

He is one atheist. Just one. He speaks for himself. There is no reason to believe, none whatsoever, that his opinions would become law in an atheistic society.
DOC's understanding of the world:

One good christian proves christianity is good.
One bad christian is an outlier/no a true christian.

One bad atheist proves atheism is bad.
One good atheist is an outlier/must be bad in some other way...somehow...
 
Last edited:
DOC, frankly I am disturbed. Just because someone may not believe in God, yours or anyone elses, does not mean they wish to harm others. Because they believe in God does not mean they will NOT commit heinous crimes. We have plenty examples through history to prove it. I just read the Code of Hammurabi again. I would not consider it to be a set of Christian based laws in the sense that we have the ten commandments. But they did have laws against incest, murder, theft, loss of property, slander,.....
Also, you state God wants us to give till it hurts...I don't understand. Enlighten us please.
By chance, are you a preacher?
 
DOC said:
And maybe you haven't heard of this atheistic "Princeton" professor who examines ethics from a atheistic point of view. He is for the right to kill handicapped newborns.

From Wikis article on Princeton Professor "Peter Singer"

American economist Steve Forbes ceased his donations to Princeton University in 1999 because of Singer's appointment to an honorable position.[19] Nazi-hunter Simon Wiesenthal wrote to organizers of a Swedish book fair to which Singer was invited that "A professor of morals ... who justifies the right to kill handicapped newborns... is in my opinion unacceptable for representation at your level."[20] Marc Maurer, President of the National Federation of the Blind, the leading organization for blind people in the United States, strongly criticized Singer's appointment to the Princeton Faculty in a banquet speech at the organization's national convention in July 2001, claiming that Singer's support for euthanizing disabled babies could lead to disabled older children and adults being valued less as well.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Peter_Singer



He {Peter Singer} is one atheist. Just one. He speaks for himself. There is no reason to believe, none whatsoever, that his opinions would become law in an atheistic society.

I would strongly disagree when you have New Yorker magazine calling him "the most influential philospher alive".

http://www.worldmag.com/articles/9987

And Time magazine calling him one of the 100 Most Influential People in the World in 2005.

www.project-syndicate.org/series/31/description
 
Last edited:
Just a generation ago we had a "christian" who, not only proposed, but also terminated those with physical defects.
 
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

This is a parody, right? Doc has been posting all this time, just yanking chains and seeing how high he can ratchet up the ridiculousness before people get it.

Because NOBODY is this stupid.
 
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

Runs off to FSTDT.com and hopes he is the first to submit...
 
And Time magazine calling him one of the 100 Most Influential People in the World in 2005.

That list also includes Kim Jong Il, but no rational person would say, "If Time magazine listed Kim Jong Il as one of the 100 most influential people in 2005, then the majority of North Koreans support him and his views."

Similarly, no rational person would say, "If Time magazine listed Peter Singer (a noted and self-professed atheist) as one of the 100 most influential people in 2005, then the majority of atheists support him and his views"
 
Last edited:
This is a parody, right? Doc has been posting all this time, just yanking chains and seeing how high he can ratchet up the ridiculousness before people get it.

Because NOBODY is this stupid.

I would blame him on the writer's strike, but he's been around since before that.
 
Runs off to FSTDT.com and hopes he is the first to submit...

Damnit, now why didn't I think of that? :mad:

And why did I waste a minute trying to reason with an individual who says things like that? Oh well, at least I got to make fun of him in the process.
 
Last edited:
I'm actually quite sad that people will believe such things about me just because of my lack of belief in any gods.
 
I'm actually quite sad that people will believe such things about me just because of my lack of belief in any gods.

I'm more pissed off actually :mad:

BTW, it's not fair that you get penguins, too!! :( ;)
 
Posted by DOC

You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.



Which one of the above things I mentioned do you believe is sad and would not be legalized in a all atheist society.

I don’t think being freed from bronze-aged superstition will make the society run berserk; in fact I think the world could be a better place without bible bangers abusing their children with ideas about human sacrifice (scapegoating), hell or any such nonsense, nor would there be religious labelling dividing people in different superstitious camps. Don’t you think it’s bizarre that people can generate hate for each other strictly because of different superstitious beliefs imposed on them?

First of a all, homosexual marriages are not immoral, in fact you’re a bigot if you pretend to know the will of your imaginary celestial being and impose also that second illusion as some kind of truth on people you dislike (it is after all your own ideas you’re actually projecting, not the celestial being’s). Second, polygamy is allowed in some religious cultures. Third, some religious denominations already take their children away from public schooling in order to indoctrinate them with their own imaginary rubbish. Fourth, when you live in a tight religious community and almost everyone seems to be your cousin, start worrying. Etc., etc.

Your list is just speculative nonsense; in fact, secular ideas are preventing children from becoming dumbed-down and taught nonsense (like creationism in science classes). I would say some of what most of us consider immoral behaviour could become possible through some weird religious justification, if such indecency could have slipped in any “holy” text – that’s the downside of pretending to have morality derived from fictive narratives. I’ve already named one such immorality (scaring children with eternal punishment). What kind of sickness it that, really? Religious fundamentalist can say and do the weirdest things; you’re already a good example of that.

This is already the fourth time I ask you the following: 1) Name a moral act or statement by a theist that could not have been done by a non-theist. (2) Name a wicked action that could only have been derived directly from theistic justification.
 
I don’t think being freed from bronze-aged superstition will make the society run berserk; in fact I think the world could be a better place without bible bangers abusing their children with ideas about human sacrifice (scapegoating), hell or any such nonsense, nor would there be religious labelling dividing people in different superstitious camps. Don’t you think it’s bizarre that people can generate hate for each other strictly because of different superstitious beliefs imposed on them?

First of a all, homosexual marriages are not immoral, in fact you’re a bigot if you pretend to know the will of your imaginary celestial being and impose also that second illusion as some kind of truth on people you dislike (it is after all your own ideas you’re actually projecting, not the celestial being’s). Second, polygamy is allowed in some religious cultures. Third, some religious denominations already take their children away from public schooling in order to indoctrinate them with their own imaginary rubbish. Fourth, when you live in a tight religious community and almost everyone seems to be your cousin, start worrying. Etc., etc.

Your list is just speculative nonsense; in fact, secular ideas are preventing children from becoming dumbed-down and taught nonsense (like creationism in science classes). I would say some of what most of us consider immoral behaviour could become possible through some weird religious justification, if such indecency could have slipped in any “holy” text – that’s the downside of pretending to have morality derived from fictive narratives. I’ve already named one such immorality (scaring children with eternal punishment). What kind of sickness it that, really? Religious fundamentalist can say and do the weirdest things; you’re already a good example of that.

This is already the fourth time I ask you the following: 1) Name a moral act or statement by a theist that could not have been done by a non-theist. (2) Name a wicked action that could only have been derived directly from theistic justification.
DOC will never read your well written post. He doesn't like a lot of words.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom