If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

...

You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

I rarely break my "ghosting" and actually post, but this forced it out me. This is so evil as to take my breath away. I am very, very glad I do not know anyone in my life such as "DOC".
 
Originally Posted by DOC View Post
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

Which one of the things I mentioned that I believe would be legalized if everyone was an atheist do you consider evil?

And I would encourage any of the regulars to answer that also.

Hmm. Even I think that 'godless communism' is a pretty evil system, but they didn't make adult-child sex, polygamy, homosexual marriage, or public sex legal. They have mandatory school attendance, and abortions were illegal in Soviet Russia (not so much in the PRC). You're fine with the ethics of Soviet Russia, apparently. Communists didn't go the route you're afraid of, but you think humanists would? Bizarre. It is hard to find an ethical system that is more concerned with the protection of young children from sexual abuse and exploitation than humanism.

Of course you ended your despicable, nasty accusation with 'eventually', so no matter how long an atheist-only society lasted you can say it will still suffer moral decay 'eventually'. Way to hedge your bet.
 
Why not, isn't that the goal of most atheists- to eradicate religion from society. And if that is not the goal than atheists must believe that religion is good for society. But I don't think that is the case or there wouldn't be the constant attacking and mocking of religion in the threads.

Nope and nope. I don't even personally know any atheists who want to eradicate religion, and I have a meetup group and everything! :) The only way to eradicate religion is by force, and none of us believe you should use force to change people's beliefs. I don't think religion is good for society in general, but particular religous communities can be, through charity, despite their superstitions. Too bad that churces who care more about the poor, needy, and handicapped than their next fellowship dinner are the exception rather than the rule. Sadly, those 'points of light' are more than offset by greedy televangelists, fake healers, megachurches that only exist to grow, and Christianist who try to undermine the religous freedom of others.

Nontheist religions are a different story, but I have a feeling you didn't have them in mind.

So: we don't believe in eradicating religion because killing and terrorizing people is bad, which doesn't imply that we think religion is good for society. It only implies that we don't think it is as bad as killing and terrorizing people.
 
I rarely break my "ghosting" and actually post, but this forced it out me. This is so evil as to take my breath away. I am very, very glad I do not know anyone in my life such as "DOC".

Not to GODwin anything, but a song went tumbling through my head reading that: (To be sung by Gott-Leibing Trupers in rank and full pack):
Doc-land Doc-land over everything; Doc-land, Doc-land alwa-ay's right!
Always hating, Master (race)bai-aiting, Thin-iceskating, Not real nice...........
Quote misusing, fact abu-using (well, I'm sure you get the idea.). The Nazi's and the KKK (just for a couple) were ostensibly Xtian. (and the tune is Deutschland uber alles)
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by DOC View Post
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

Which one of the things I mentioned that I believe would be legalized if everyone was an atheist do you consider evil?

And I would encourage any of the regulars to answer that also.

I guess I'm a regular now. Adult-child sex? Bad. Children aren't capable of understanding what they're getting into, so getting them to consent to being sexually exploited is no more a defense against the act being rape than getting a child's consent to being electrocuted is a defense against a child murder charge. Incest involving adults and children also right out. It's harder to justify a law against incest between consenting adults, but that is a pretty rare situation, isn't it?

Public sex is dangerously distracting. In a modest culture like ours, public nudity can be, also. I think the majority of atheist parents would prefer to keep both off Main Street so they can be in charge of their children's exposure to sexuality. Which answers the porn on public tv question, too.

Why would you even think that atheism has anything to do with school being optional? Who doesn't want their children to get a good education? Heck, who wants them home all day? :boggled:

This may be hard for someone who only refrains from killing defenceless children because of their religous convictions, but murder is bad, even if the victim needs some help to get along. Those of us without God have to get along on empathy and compassion.

All abortions were legal at all stages a few years ago. It was a completely similar society then. And believe it or not, many atheists have an issue with a late-term abortion that isn't necessary to protect the health of the mother. Even when they were legal, partial-birth abortions were very rarely chosen when the mother's health wasn't in danger. You see, most pregnant women don't wait until the last minute to decide not to deliver, even given the option.

I don't give a crap who or how many people you marry, though. It doesn't diminish me when someone else makes a different choice than I would in their adult relationships.
 
For example, think of a poor neighborhood in your area. Now take away all the churches in those poor neighborhoods, because if everyone was atheistic there would be no church going.
And if you take away those churches you'll also have to take away any charity work done by those churches. I have to believe if you took away the churches and charity work those churches do, crime would increase in that area.

But those churches espouse the idea that 'materialism' is bad and that lusting for 'earthly' success is a sin. "It is easier for a camel to go through the eye of a needle, than for a rich man to enter into the kingdom of God."

So consider that poor neighborhood might not exist at all if being poor were not glorified. And if those churches were not taking money from the already poor.

In general a population's affluence can be shown to be inversely proportionate to a the amount a culture embraces religion. So it's arguable that the 'help' these churches offer might be a lot less needed if the churches didn't exist in the first place.
 
Public sex is dangerously distracting. In a modest culture like ours, public nudity can be, also. I think the majority of atheist parents would prefer to keep both off Main Street so they can be in charge of their children's exposure to sexuality. Which answers the porn on public tv question, too.
Have to disagree with you there. 'Atheistic' Scandinavia has a fairly liberal view on nudism and typically don't shield children from naked bodies. Take your typical Scandinavian swimming pool locker room and you'll see at least one naked child (up to the age of 3-5) - often of the opposite gender.

They don't mind that we see them nude, we don't mind that they see us nude.

School would be optional at all ages.
What immediately comes to mind is fundamentalists homeschooling kids.

Why not, isn't that the goal of most atheists- to eradicate religion from society.
No.

And if that is not the goal than atheists must believe that religion is good for society.
False dilemma.

But I don't think that is the case or there wouldn't be the constant attacking and mocking of religion in the threads.
And of course this forum is representative of atheism as a whole now. Wow. Heard of 'silent moderates'?
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by DOC

If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.


This is a parody, right? Doc has been posting all this time, just yanking chains and seeing how high he can ratchet up the ridiculousness before people get it.

Because NOBODY is this stupid.

This Princeton professor who New Yorker magazine called the most influential philosopher of our time is that stupid. From post # 201

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3365329#post3365329
 
Last edited:
That list also includes Kim Jong Il, but no rational person would say, "If Time magazine listed Kim Jong Il as one of the 100 most influential people in 2005, then the majority of North Koreans support him and his views."

Similarly, no rational person would say, "If Time magazine listed Peter Singer (a noted and self-professed atheist) as one of the 100 most influential people in 2005, then the majority of atheists support him and his views"

Then who are all of people he is influencing, Christians??
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
This Princeton professor who New Yorker magazine called the most influential philosopher of our time is that stupid. From post # 200

http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?postid=3365329#post3365329

We saw you be stupid and ignorant in that particular way the first time. You had to quote yourself, just in case somebody missed it? Really?

Keep in mind the Membership Agreement and do not use personal attacks or insults to argue your point.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Lisa Simpson
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I don't think I've seen a post quoted and responded to more in any given thread than this one. It is truly mond-boggling.

I scribbled down some notes as I read the post in preparation for my reply. But I see that many others have already responded to my points - probably more persuasively than I could have.

So I am left only with a few questions: DOC, have you learned anything from the responses to your post? If so, what?

I've learned not many people in these threads read Time and the New Yorker.
 
Last edited:
I've learned not many people in these threads read Time and the New Yorker.


What does that have to do with anything?

You seem to have this weird obsession with appeals to authority. Just because someone is listed as being influential in a magazine, it does not follow that:

a) Their ideas are widely accepted.
b) Their ideas correctly reflect the ideas and values of others who may be loosely associated with them.
c) Their ideas are correct.

On the flip side, since this person is listed as being important by Time magazine, does that mean he is more likely to be correct than the philosophers you favor who have not be so listed?
 
His influence is probably in support of PETA and animal rights, not for the wonderful evil hedonistic amoral carnival you suggest.


eta: upon a quick Google, even what I said was wrong:

“Singer is a powerful advocate for the better treatment of animals, and is certainly an important influence on the recent changes in the law that have given more emphasis to animal welfare. But he is not a supporter of animal rights”. Do Animals Have Rights? by Alison Hills (2005: 23-4):

distinction between better treatment and animal rights...

Hitler liked animals too. Professor Singer just doesn't seem to like the handicapped though.
 
Last edited:
Hitler liked animals too. Professor Singer just doesn't seem to like the handicapped though.
DOC, please give the exact reference of Singer's statement.

And any time you'd like to aplogize for your false accusations against me, I will happily forgive you for them.
 
I've learned not many people in these threads read Time and the New Yorker.
Actually, I do believe you. I think that is, in fact, the only thing you have learned in this thread and I'm not sure it's true. But it's certainly reflective of your ability or willingness to engage in serious dialog and take something away from the exercise. In that light, DOC, why do you hang out here?
 
And any time you'd like to aplogize for your false accusations against me, I will happily forgive you for them.

Your welcome to start a thread and thoroughly explain any false accusations, but you'll never do it because there are no false accusations.

And don't mention it anymore in here because it's off topic.
 
Last edited:
Your welcome to start a thread and thoroughly explain any false accusations, but you'll never do it because there are no false accusations.
Am I to believe that you will actually admit apologize when I prove that you made false statements about me or anyone? I'd be happy to start such a thread.:)

And don't mention it anymore in here because it's off topic.
Well, if you wanted to stay on topic, why not answer my topic related question?

DOC, please give the exact reference of Singer's statement.


ETA: DOC, here's the thread!
http://www.internationalskeptics.com/forums/showthread.php?p=3380226#post3380226
 
Last edited:
What does that have to do with anything?

You seem to have this weird obsession with appeals to authority. Just because someone is listed as being influential in a magazine, it does not follow that:

a) Their ideas are widely accepted.
b) Their ideas correctly reflect the ideas and values of others who may be loosely associated with them.
c) Their ideas are correct.

On the flip side, since this person is listed as being important by Time magazine, does that mean he is more likely to be correct than the philosophers you favor who have not be so listed?

lol, wasnt times person of the year "you" a few years back, like it had a ghetto mirror thing on the cover? so we were all the person of the year... yeah.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom