If Everyone in the world was atheistic would there be more or less crime

The problem is that if you make this claim it is not possible to ever definitively say what is and what is not a religion. And you get possibilities like scientific organizations classed as religions.

Not at all. A lot of religions are atheistic, like Buddhism and Taoism.

Or are you saying they're not religions?
 
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.


Okay DOC, now that you're dumped this steaming pile of bigotry on us, perhaps you could tell me...

  • Where in the bible does it prohibit sex with children, marriage to children, marriage to multiple partners?
  • Where in the bible does it say public sex is not allowed?
  • Where in the bible does it say public nudity is not allowed?
  • Where in the bible does it say abortion is not allowed?
  • Where does it say leaders should not be ruthless dictators? Where does the bible endorse democracy?
  • Where does it say school should be mandatory?
  • Where does the bible require care of handicapped and mentally ill children? Or adults?
I'm sure you can supply specific chapter and verse to illustrate where the bible directly confronts these issues, since clearly the world would run amok without biblical guidance.
 
Well, using that line of thinking, then Jesus was a racist.
DOC, I feel like I need to explain something.
This argument doesn't really help you in any way.

For it's impact to be felt, people would have to agree that Jesus was perfect. Only then would the concept of jesus being racist (or possess bigotry equivilent to racism as what was mentioned in the post you were replying to) be ludicrous.

In order for us to think Jesus was perfect is to think he was actually the son of god. Since most people you are debating against don't believe in god, they would not have any reason to believe that jesus is the son of it.


Therefore, your statement of

"Well, using that line of thinking, then Jesus was a racist."
Has the same weight of
"Well, using that line of thinking, then Jefferson was a racist."
"Well, using that line of thinking, then Gahndi was a racist."

It may still have validity, but it isn't nearly as shocking a statement you'd like to think it is.
 
Not at all. A lot of religions are atheistic, like Buddhism and Taoism.

Or are you saying they're not religions?

This is not really the thread for this, but the point is how do you define religion so that they are religions, and science isn't.
 
Originally Posted by DOC View Post
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

Don't beat around the bush the DOC for some strange reason you sound as though you believe that atheists are evil, I never knew you felt that way.

Which one of the things I mentioned that I believe would be legalized if everyone was an atheist do you consider evil?

And I would encourage any of the regulars to answer that also.
 
Last edited:
Originally Posted by DOC View Post
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.



Which one of the things I mentioned that I believe would be legalized if everyone was an atheist do you consider evil?

And I would encourage any of the regulars to answer that also.
Which of the following secular american ways do you find evil?

Freedom of Religion?
Freedom of speech?
Right to Bear arms?
The Right to a fair and speedy trial?
The Right to face your accusers?
The protection against wrongful search and seizures?
women's rights?
Civil Rights?
Abolition of slavery?
Social security?
medicare medicaid?
disability rights?
Welfare?
No religious test required to take office?
equal rights acts?
FHA programs?
Peace Corps?
 
Posted by DOC

You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.

Now you’re just really sad… if that’s what’s going on in your head, then I think it is indeed better you hold on tightly to you’re delusion and fear of imaginary celestial retribution.

Which one of the above things I mentioned do you believe is sad and would not be legalized in a all atheist society.
 
Posted by DOC

You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consenting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.



Which one of the above things I mentioned do you believe is sad and would not be legalized in a all atheist society.


I gave my answer to that question back in post #163.


I know you are backed up with questions and have a limited time to respond, but please don't forget my questions in post #146.
 
Which of the following secular american ways do you find evil?

Freedom of Religion?
Freedom of speech?
Right to Bear arms?
The Right to a fair and speedy trial?
The Right to face your accusers?
The protection against wrongful search and seizures?
women's rights?
Civil Rights?
Abolition of slavery?
Social security?
medicare medicaid?
disability rights?
Welfare?
No religious test required to take office?
equal rights acts?
FHA programs?
Peace Corps?

None of those are secular because God would approve of all of them, even free speech and freedom of religion because God gives free will.
 
Last edited:
None of those are secular because God would approve of all of them, even free speech and freedom of religion because God gives free will.
So, now you're even lying about the Bible... nice trick! Either that, or you reject the 10 Commandments?
 
DOC, that's too much of a leap to be taken seriously and I don't think any questions based off such a ridiculous premise deserve answers.

If there are positive results of religion in terms of how it effects crime, such as rehabilitation programs or charity to the homeless that can be demonstrated through statistics, that'd be a better place to start than with things you're making up as you go.
 
You've got a point there. If everyone were atheists I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.
What this translates into is basically this:
You've got a point there. If everyone were exactly like me but didn't have GAWD keeping them in check I'd be willing to bet sex with any consulting child would be legal. Incest would be legal. All drugs would be legalized. Polygamy would be legal. Homosexual marriages would be allowed. Public sex and nudity would be allowed. Porno would be allowed on all public TV channel that any child could watch. School would be optional at all ages. Handicapped and the mentally ill children would be allowed to be killed by their parents because they would be considered a burden to society. All abortions would be legal at all stages. We'd live in a totally different society. And after the society collapsed, the military would take over and of course it would be run by a ruthless dictator who would run a police state. Yes I'd be willing to bet all these actions would take place eventually.
Way to equate same sex marriage with child rape or the murder of handicapped children. Never mind that you offered no evidence or reasoning whatsoever for your slippery slope fallacy.

Also, way to ignore the fact that some of the most brutal, violent, and barbaric societies in recent history have been theocracies run by religious fanatics. Look at Iran or Saudi Arabia. Look at Serbia under Milosevic, or Afghanistan under the Taliban. (I would point out the classic example of a 20th century regime that murdered millions of people in the name of God, but I don't feel like getting into Godwin's Law territory today.)
 
DOC, that's too much of a leap to be taken seriously and I don't think any questions based off such a ridiculous premise deserve answers.

Why not, isn't that the goal of most atheists- to eradicate religion from society. And if that is not the goal than atheists must believe that religion is good for society. But I don't think that is the case or there wouldn't be the constant attacking and mocking of religion in the threads.
 
DOC, that's too much of a leap to be taken seriously and I don't think any questions based off such a ridiculous premise deserve answers.

If there are positive results of religion in terms of how it effects crime, such as rehabilitation programs or charity to the homeless that can be demonstrated through statistics, that'd be a better place to start than with things you're making up as you go.
Is he making it up? Or is it what he feels in his heart? Which sort of monster is he dying to be, if only Jesus didn't hold him back?
 
Why not, isn't that the goal of most atheists- to eradicate religion from society. And if that is not the goal than atheists must believe that religion is good for society. But I don't think that is the case or there wouldn't be the constant attacking and mocking of religion in the threads.


No, the goal of most atheists is to be free of the yoke of other people's superstitions.
 
None of those are secular because God would approve of all of them, even free speech and freedom of religion because God gives free will.

That's a really dumb answer. If there is a punishment associated with an action, that action isn't permitted and you are therefore not FREE to make it. By your logic, we are free to commit murder, as long as we are willing to go to jail for it. dumb, dumb dumb.

That list I gave is a direct result of our secularized government. They happend in spite of religion, not becuase of.

BASED UPON THE BIBLE:
God doesn't permit freedom of religion, he clearly states that no god before him. That's not freedom of religion.

God doesn't permit freedom of speech, becuase he forbids taking his name in vein.

god does permit guns and killing in his name.

God permits slavery.

god doesn't believe in equal rights for women
 
That's a really dumb answer. If there is a punishment associated with an action, that action isn't permitted and you are therefore not FREE to make it. By your logic, we are free to commit murder, as long as we are willing to go to jail for it. dumb, dumb dumb.

That list I gave is a direct result of our secularized government. They happend in spite of religion, not becuase of.

BASED UPON THE BIBLE:
God doesn't permit freedom of religion, he clearly states that no god before him. That's not freedom of religion.

God doesn't permit freedom of speech, becuase he forbids taking his name in vein.

god does permit guns and killing in his name.

God permits slavery.

god doesn't believe in equal rights for women
God, IOW, hates the American Constitution.
 
Why not, isn't that the goal of most atheists- to eradicate religion from society.
Many atheists do think that as a goal. I very much doubt most. But, i haven't done any polls.

And if that is not the goal than atheists must believe that religion is good for society.
Stupid statement. False dichotomy.
You can also subscribe to the live and let live viewpoint.

But I don't think that is the case or there wouldn't be the constant attacking and mocking of religion in the threads.
Confirmation bias.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom