Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

Some of you people crack me up.

It's clueless navel gazers who have created a world in which coffee cups have printed on them, "Caution. Coffee is HOT. Do not spill on yourself or you could suffer burns. Please consult a medical professional before taking possession of this cup of HOT coffee."

What's next? Warnings to Hawaiians that ice cubes are cold? "Don't make a bed out of these ice cubes and go to sleep on them because you could freeze to death"?

:jaw-dropp This ain't pretty, people! Get a grip.



[sigh]

Oh dear, what an ill informed rant.

The law over the entire western world is quite clear. An organiser (or a supplier of goods) has a reasonable duty of care to ensure that an activity (or product) is safe for the intended purpose.

Now in America (in particular) your courts seem to have a problem with defining reasonable, however that is not a reason to throw the baby out with the bathwater.

Consider: When buying a car, you do not expect to have to carry out a full inspection prior to driving it. The garage have a duty of care to ensure that it's roadworthy.

Likewise when you buy food the shop has an obligation to ensure they're not poisoning you. It's no good them saying "well, he should have recognised the risk of e-coli contamination, it's just natural selection".

The radio station invited participants to engage in an activity which even a few of us on this board could have told them was dangerous. If they took no steps to ensure safety of participants, then they are culpable. If they ignored medical advice, they're culpable.

:covereyes
 
About a third of people who drown have no detectable water in their lungs. Their larynx closes and they "dry drown".

I would have thought a ubermensch like yourself would have known that. ;)

And then there are all the problems with near drowning, with osmotic pressure issues and such
 
About a third of people who drown have no detectable water in their lungs. Their larynx closes and they "dry drown".

I would have thought a ubermensch like yourself would have known that. ;)

Alright! Now we're getting someplace here! I LOVE it when the Bawl Brigade demonstrates their own fallacies!!! Keep it up. Only problem is.... you're making it too easy for me.

You're FINALLY acknowledging that WATER has numerous KNOWN deleterious effects on the body. And the totally cool thing about this knowledge is that the BODY instinctively knows it and has mechanisms to ward off the danger... hence the larynx closing to prevent water inhalation. AND the instinct TO QUIT DRINKING WATER WHEN SATED.

And, just as we're ALL here to testify, too much water can KILL you. All the smart people know it. All the average people know it. Babies know it or they'd drink themselves to death. Animals even know it (even the ones who don't attend college. LOLOLOLOLOLOL). 99.999999999999999999999999% of living organisms know it or they'd be dead. Even the people who fall out of the boat and can't swim know it or they wouldn't flail around trying to survive, water inhaled, larynx closed or what have you. So close to 100% of living breathing beings KNOW this to be true.

What the idiot woman did was let her OWN greed override her natural self-preservation instinct by VOLUNTARILY over consuming in the course of VOLUNTARILY participating in a contest involving the most basic and fundamental material of life. She was VOLUNTARILY able to stop at any point. By participating she encountered risk, but because of her VOLUNTARY participation, she assumed superseding responsibility to ameliorate that risk.

There's a restaurant in Texas that advertises a free steak dinner if eaten in one hour. The catch is that it's a HUGE dinner. More than nearly anybody on the planet can eat. Some idiot who suffered a heart attack while trying sued them and trotted out all these same goofy sobsister arguments. "Duty to provide a safe environment." "The free dinner enticement directly overrode the natural instinct to not overeat" "My client couldn't possibly be aware of the effects of overeating." "Overeating causes the body to dramatically alter bodily processes including heart rate so this lure to overeat is a direct and known danger to participants that the restaurant should have known about." Blah, blah, blah.

They lost the case. The restaurant won. On the principle that voluntary, non-coerced participation in a contest involving ordinary life materials does not make the contest sponsor liable for body reactions of contestants, despite the presence of an incentive to overdo. The contestant has primary duty to moderate personal intake to prevent personal harm. Not the contest sponsor. Same outcome when people sue bars for intoxicating them with alcohol. Cigarette companies for providing the cigarettes that give them cancer. Manufacturers for providing cars that can go in excess of the speed limit. It's your responsibility to keep yourself alive, not somebody else's.

That's it. All in. All done. She's a dumbass who got carried away. Play Taps, shovel the dirt, lets HAVE A DRINK. Adios, babe.
 
And, just as we're ALL here to testify, too much water can KILL you. All the smart people know it. All the average people know it. Babies know it or they'd drink themselves to death. Animals even know it (even the ones who don't attend college. LOLOLOLOLOLOL). 99.999999999999999999999999% of living organisms know it or they'd be dead. Even the people who fall out of the boat and can't swim know it or they wouldn't flail around trying to survive, water inhaled, larynx closed or what have you. So close to 100% of living breathing beings KNOW this to be true.

No they don't. They have behavioral habits such that they generally do not get into situations where they consume enough water to kill themselves. This is for various reasons: the natural scarcity of water, the sense of fullness when an organism has consumed "enough" water and would better spend its time doing other things, and so on.

I suspect that it wouldn't be that hard to set up a laboratory situation where some sort of animal drinks itself to death. (Without "cheating" by drugging the animal or anything.)

I'm not a big fan of instinct, at any rate. It's patently irrational to believe something just because your brainmeats are predisposed to make you think that way. Perhaps there is value to instinct, because evolution tended to select only instincts that were useful (although the environment in which human beings did most of their evolving is radically different from the environment that we currently live in) but it's still information that isn't confirmed by any sort of empirical or logical proccess. It's possible that making a bed out of ice could actually be quite comfortable. So in that sense, I somewhat support the idea that "common sense" things should be posted on objects. Coffee is indeed hot! (Ideally, of course, the information could be presented better, because "Coffee is hot" is somewhat less useful than "This coffee is served at 190 degrees farenheit, a temperature which has been shown to cause third degree burns if exposed directly to skin.")

What the idiot woman did was let her OWN greed override her natural self-preservation instinct by VOLUNTARILY over consuming in the course of VOLUNTARILY participating in a contest involving the most basic and fundamental material of life. She was VOLUNTARILY able to stop at any point. By participating she encountered risk, but because of her VOLUNTARY participation, she assumed superseding responsibility to ameliorate that risk.

Responsibility doesn't work that way. Responsibility isn't some magical fairy dust that gets tossed around whenever people perform "voluntary acts," (and I have my doubts on how meaningful that catagory is, since ultimately all our actions are ordained by the laws of physics) but rather it's a function of causality and to what degree the person could have knowingly prevented the act. Just because one person is responsible does not in any way impact another person's responsiblity. The woman could have known better, and in retrospect, made a mistake which cost her her life. But the radio station also could have known better. When you enter a contest, you are only risking yourself. When you start a contest, you are risking all the people who enter the contest. Perhaps the fact that they choose to enter the contest reduces things, but there are a lot of other variables.
 
Last edited:
There's a restaurant in Texas that advertises a free steak dinner if eaten in one hour. The catch is that it's a HUGE dinner. More than nearly anybody on the planet can eat.

More than one actually, a few restaraunts have this gimmick

http://www.bigtexan.com/

My entire group ate these for free on the way back from the Oklahoma City Bicycle Stunts contest. This steak didnt seem so huge after riding our bikes like madmen for three days. I was 125 pounds at the time and I think the biggest of us was 145.

On a further but hopefully more related derail, for our second video we had a gallon of milk drinking contest. According to what we read, the stomach is too small to hold in that much milk at one sitting. We got a LOT of white barfing on film. Great stuff, but there were a few that were able to down the whole thing. COuld we have killed them? They looked all dopey eyed and kinda drunkish

Now I look back somewhat in horror, though it was hillarious at the time
 
More than one actually, a few restaraunts have this gimmick

http://www.bigtexan.com/

My entire group ate these for free on the way back from the Oklahoma City Bicycle Stunts contest. This steak didnt seem so huge after riding our bikes like madmen for three days. I was 125 pounds at the time and I think the biggest of us was 145.

On a further but hopefully more related derail, for our second video we had a gallon of milk drinking contest. According to what we read, the stomach is too small to hold in that much milk at one sitting. We got a LOT of white barfing on film. Great stuff, but there were a few that were able to down the whole thing. COuld we have killed them? They looked all dopey eyed and kinda drunkish

Now I look back somewhat in horror, though it was hillarious at the time

Hey, I know the overeating problem. My wife's grandmother made this gigantic T-day meal including cornbread dressing. Everything was so delicious I had thirds, and 5ths of the cornbread dressing. THEN she pulled out my favorite, banana cream pie. I ate half of that. With lots of milk.

I went home, went to bed and didn't get up for 2 days. No hurling, but Lord I've never hurt so bad in my life. I still remember that meal. Good memories, but I'll never repeat that again ever.
 
And don't, like, totally bore me with the distinction between inhaling water thereby preventing blood oxygenation vs. imbibition resulting in solute dilution of cellular contents and membrane rupture. Yawn.

So you already know you're wrong but don't care? Well, at least you're forthright about it.

A contest to see how much water one can drink is not as inherently dangerous as, say, a contest to see who can jump off the highest bridge. Water is good for you. It makes up better than nine tenths of your body mass. You need lots of it every day. In fact, most could really use more than what they actually drink. People die left and right from dehydration. So the fact that you can drink too much of it is, though true, highly counterintuitive - and that's being modest.

This death was senseless and preventable, but that's the worst that can fairly be said about it.
 
More than one actually, a few restaraunts have this gimmick

http://www.bigtexan.com/

My entire group ate these for free on the way back from the Oklahoma City Bicycle Stunts contest. This steak didnt seem so huge after riding our bikes like madmen for three days. I was 125 pounds at the time and I think the biggest of us was 145.

On a further but hopefully more related derail, for our second video we had a gallon of milk drinking contest. According to what we read, the stomach is too small to hold in that much milk at one sitting. We got a LOT of white barfing on film. Great stuff, but there were a few that were able to down the whole thing. COuld we have killed them? They looked all dopey eyed and kinda drunkish

Now I look back somewhat in horror, though it was hillarious at the time

Brings to mind some of my drinking sprees.

I sometimes think it's amazing that there are any folks older than about 25 alive. I'm surprised we haven't all killed ourselves off by 30, by doing those stupid things we did in our youth. ;)

And as a further derail (oops! ;)) Why is it when we're young and have so much more life ahead of us, do we risk it so easily, and as we get older, and have less life to look forward to, we get all scared and careful? ;)
 
That's exactly my point. It's TOTALLY obvious if you're not stupid.

Wow, and here I thought I was fairly smart. You say this is TOTALLY obvious with the same conviction that Christophera says it should be obvious that the WTC had a concrete core.

Alright! Now we're getting someplace here! I LOVE it when the Bawl Brigade demonstrates their own fallacies!!! Keep it up. Only problem is.... you're making it too easy for me.

You're FINALLY acknowledging that WATER has numerous KNOWN deleterious effects on the body. And the totally cool thing about this knowledge is that the BODY instinctively knows it and has mechanisms to ward off the danger... hence the larynx closing to prevent water inhalation.

Um..there is quite a difference between the body instinctively not wanting to inhale water and deciding on purpose whether or not to drink water.
 
Um..there is quite a difference between the body instinctively not wanting to inhale water and deciding on purpose whether or not to drink water.

No distinction whatsoever. Both require overriding natural basic instincts, inherent bodily knowledge, when done voluntarily. Black still isn't white. Boohoo about something else.
 
Brings to mind some of my drinking sprees.

I sometimes think it's amazing that there are any folks older than about 25 alive. I'm surprised we haven't all killed ourselves off by 30, by doing those stupid things we did in our youth. ;)

And as a further derail (oops! ;)) Why is it when we're young and have so much more life ahead of us, do we risk it so easily, and as we get older, and have less life to look forward to, we get all scared and careful? ;)

Wisdom is wasted on the old. Youth is wasted on the young. Sure isn't fair.
 
there is a difference between inquiring into the dangers of breathing, and the dangers of forcing people to hyperventilate.
They may not have known the risks, but they should have made it their business to find out.

OK, so you're very tuned in to health risks, that's great. Just wondering, did you read the rest of my post?

Lets forget about lawsuits for a moment and just think about doing the right thing as human beings.

It appears that many of us in this forum didn't know that it's possible to die from water intoxication or overhydration. And as several have said, it really is counterintuitive that that is the case. (ETA: So counterintuitive that this is why I said in my earlier post that I would not have expected station management to consult with a lawyer or doctor about this before hand.) But this is apparently a well-known fact among people in the health field, sports field and probably even among a few news junkies. Yet, it seems, that only one nurse called in to say "Hey! What you guys are doing is life threatening!"

That one phone call should have been enough. From what I've been able to read over the Internet, if the contest had been stopped at that point, and all the contestants instructed to eat salty chips or pretzels, probably no one would have died. Unfortunately the DJ decided to ignore the nurse's warnings. Lets give him the benefit of doubt and say that he thought she was just a troll.

Well, why did only one person call in to say that this was a life- threatening stunt? Where were Sacramento's other nurses, doctors, physical therapist, and coaches? Sacramento is not a hick town, why didn't more people call in to say this was dangerous? If this contest was promoted in advance like many radio contests are, than that would make the situation even worse.

I'm sure things would have turned have quite differently if 10 or even only 5 people have called the station to say how dangerous this contest was. If these hypothetical callers had all been blown off by the station's manager -- well just imagine what would have happened if only one of them had called the city or county's health department. JenniferStrange (the woman who inspired this thread) would probably still be alive.

The whole thing is really sad, and I've been trying to figure out why people just didn't simply call in and say this contest was dangerous. The best I can come up with is that most people are probably socialized to unquestioningly trust and cooperate with authority, and to not be "troublemakers." And that's pretty sad too.
 
Last edited:
Does anyone know what audience the station appeals to? It could be that it's a downmarket audio equivalent of The Sun (UK tabloid for idiots), and healthcare professionals were unlikely to tune in.
 
So just to summarise, the entire liability system of the western world, from Donoghue vs Stevenson onwards, is wrong but FarmallMTA is right.

Erm, no, sorry Farmall. I'm sticking with 100+ years of case law and common sense.
 
Jennifer Lea Strange died after drinking well over a half gallon of water Friday during the "Morning Rave" program on The End (KDND, 107.9 FM).
Is it just me or does this not seem like it's an insane amount of water.

It's not just you. Half a U.S. gallon is only 1.89 litres which is under 4 small bottles of water (Unless my conversion is wrong).
I've drunk well over that on several occasions - granted i used the toilet, but, although aware of water intoxication, i had no idea i may die if i was stuck in a traffic jam for 4 hours.

Maybe the women had a low sodium count.
 
So, if I get your drift, Dimbulb is absolved because she doesn't have a medical degree. But the Q-Morning Zoo Crew, who ALSO doesn't have a medical degree IS responsible? Shucks. I must have missed the part where they went to Dimbulb's house, kidnapped her, dragged her to the radio station, forced her to drink the Ogallala Aquifer with a gun to her head, then laughed callously as she didn't pee her panties. LOL. Better check that again.

It has been suggested that the patrons of a restaurant are not responsible for ensuring that the food they are served and will eat is not poisonous.

May I also suggest that if I get in my car and drive along a road it is not my responsibility to check if any bridges will hold the weight of my car?

Since Germany did host the last soccer world cup - do you think it was the responsibility of the teams or even individual players to ensure the arenas wouldn't collapse or cave in during a game - or do you think that the organizers, builders and architects would have been the ones to ensure the buildings stood as they were supposed to?
 
Maybe the women had a low sodium count.

Yes, there are a number of medical conditions I'd want to run by a doctor before organising a competition like that. Diabeties, for example. Or kidney problems. Or stomach ulcers. Or gallstones. I've no idea whether any of these conditions is relevant to the task set for the competition, but as I don't know for a fact they're not relevant, I'd want to go through them with a doctor. At which point, of course, the water toxification stuff would've been brought to my attention.

Even if we can't expect the organisers to know about water toxification themselves, it seems alarming they didn't find out via this route.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom