Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

So, wait now. My instincts tell me to eat a lot of fatty foods, even though I'm overweight and have high cholesterol. So, I should listen to my instincts, right?

Yep, instincts are always right.

I also learned that I have no obligation to slow down if someone steps out infront of my car, after all everyone knows the roads are dangerous and have cars on them, so it is their decision to take the risk.
 
And why are we wasting all that money on anti-smoking campaigns? After all, everyone knows that cigarettes are dangerous. And we sould stop treating smokers in hospital too, 'cause it's their own fault.
 
Hell, we should abolish hospitals altogether. They are just so anti Darwin. Curing the unfit?!!
 
I think they (the radio station employees) are up s*** creek without a paddle, legally speaking. Apparently, their waiver didn't cover health or safety issues. They appear to have lacked any kind of medical advice or attention at all, and that will figure into a negligence trial heavily.

The people that run these things have some responsibility to take reasonable precautions to ensure the safety of participants. For example, having an EMT, paramedic, or other medical professional on hand to observe the contestants to pull them if they show signs of water intoxication.

There is also some legal precedent, albeit in a slightly different context: The case of Matthew Carrington.

The fact that they laughed off the very idea of water intoxication at least twice, though they were clearly aware of it, will almost certainly hurt them. The fact that the host(s) believed that you will just throw it up when you've had too much water, and that you can drink as much as you want show that they did not consult with a medical professional before hand.

By the end of the contest, Jennifer is clearly displaying signs of intoxication. She has slurred speech and reports a painful headache, both classic signs of water intoxication. She also appears somewhat confused. At that point, she needed to go immediately to an emergency room. An EMT on scene would have been trained to recognize these signs and take appropriate action. Instead they sent her home, and she died.

Although participating in this contest wasn't the smartest thing to do, I hardly can say I blame her for her own death. Water intoxication doesn't seem to be widely known. As confusion is also one of the main symptoms (as one of the organs most effected is the brain), you can't rely on the victim of water intoxication to necessarily take proper steps to ensure their own survival. She may have felt terrible, but that doesn't necessarily translate into her being fully aware of the bad shape she was in, and the need to immediately seek emergency medical attention.

Making the contestants aware of those risks, as well as managing them, is the responsibility of the people running the contest. They seemed grossly ignorant of the medical implications of their contest.

It would not surprise me if one or more of the people involved in this are convicted of some kind of criminal negligence, possibly resulting in jail time. A civil suit against the station or the employees will also almost certainly result, and will most likely be a success.

If the contestant was fully aware of all the risks and ignored all medical advice, then it would truly be her fault, and she would be an idiot. However, the attitude of the station employees I've heard audio of seems to be fairly dismissive of the real dangers of their contest, and they clearly had no medical personnel involved in the planning or running of this stupid contest.
 
By the end of the contest, Jennifer is clearly displaying signs of intoxication. She has slurred speech and reports a painful headache, both classic signs of water intoxication. She also appears somewhat confused. At that point, she needed to go immediately to an emergency room. An EMT on scene would have been trained to recognize these signs and take appropriate action. Instead they sent her home, and she died.
Not nessacarily. They never mentioned water intoxication in the EMT classes I took. But the altered mental should be a red flag to any one with medical training.
 
It would not surprise me if one or more of the people involved in this are convicted of some kind of criminal negligence, possibly resulting in jail time. A civil suit against the station or the employees will also almost certainly result, and will most likely be a success.
.


I assume that US law is not particularly different from this country, where the organisers would be looking at:

1. A potential criminal culpible homicide charge (effectively manslaughter, as opposed to murder)

2. Criminal prosecution under health & safety legislation

3. A civil case for negligence.

Aye, well up the creek.....hey, where did the paddle go?
 
Not nessacarily. They never mentioned water intoxication in the EMT classes I took. But the altered mental should be a red flag to any one with medical training.

Point taken about the EMT classes. So they probably should have found an EMT with relevant experience. I know the EMTs that work marathons are trained to recognize water intoxication, as it frequently (relatively) occurs when endurance runners drink too much water without replacing the salt their body is also losing.

That's what I mean, anyone with some medical training who knew what the contest was about and what the risks were would have noticed something. What, with the whole distended belly, massive headache, slurred speech, and confusion.

Listening the audio from right before she quits, she sounds like she's drunk.

I'm sure it wouldn't be hard to brief an unfamiliar EMT in the basics of water intoxication.

But nope, they had some intern who noted she looked sick.
 
Just to show how far health & safety responsibility goes in the UK, I'm going to give you a current construction related example.

Traditionally, in-line polycarbonate rooflights are used to provide daylighting in profiled steel clad industrial buildings. Now everyone - designers, contractors, maintenance teams - know that polycarb is non-loadbearing and can't be walked on. But every year, one or two contractors manage to do it and hurt themselves.

It is now the specifiers (ie the architects) who will be found jointly liable, even though everyone is aware of the risks.

Why? Because where health and safety is concerned we have to adopy a precautionary principal AND it was a surefired way to make sure that people stoped installing them.

Overkill (no pun intended)? Undoubtedly, in my view.

Effective? Undoubtedly.
 
I assume that US law is not particularly different from this country, where the organisers would be looking at:

1. A potential criminal culpible homicide charge (effectively manslaughter, as opposed to murder)

2. Criminal prosecution under health & safety legislation

3. A civil case for negligence.

Aye, well up the creek.....hey, where did the paddle go?

Oh, I miss those law classes I took in university. This case would probably provide a nice criminal law discussion.

IIRC, in order to prove any negligence, the prosecution has to establish that there was some duty to care involved (the hosts must have had some duty to protect the contestants/inform them of risks/whatever), and the hosts must be shown to have failed to act as a reasonable person.

They will be exposed to what we call in the US "criminally negligent homicide", which basically means they had no intention of killing the person, but failed to take reasonable precautions to prevent death. Again, the "reasonable person" standard is used. What exactly that standard means will depend on the jury, ultimately.

I don't know about health and safety legislation, because I'm not at all familiar with whatever law in California might apply. I'm not sure if they would have violated any regulations that aren't already covered by a criminally negligent homicide case.
 
Why? Because where health and safety is concerned we have to adopy a precautionary principal AND it was a surefired way to make sure that people stoped installing them.

Overkill (no pun intended)? Undoubtedly, in my view.

Effective? Undoubtedly.

That's an interesting example. Is there any difference in liability if a warning is posted? In US law, in many cases, liability in such matters can be reduced through the posting of a warning.
 
That's an interesting example. Is there any difference in liability if a warning is posted? In US law, in many cases, liability in such matters can be reduced through the posting of a warning.

Generally speaking no, not in the slightest, on the basis that it could be kids, foreigners, or signs might not be sufficiently prominent.

There's a really interesting case involving Tesco and British Rail that I have to find a link for too, which essentially says that you have to assume that the public are complete idiots. I'll have a look later on and let you know if I find it.
 
Point taken about the EMT classes. So they probably should have found an EMT with relevant experience. I know the EMTs that work marathons are trained to recognize water intoxication, as it frequently (relatively) occurs when endurance runners drink too much water without replacing the salt their body is also losing.

That's what I mean, anyone with some medical training who knew what the contest was about and what the risks were would have noticed something. What, with the whole distended belly, massive headache, slurred speech, and confusion.

My point was the the risks are not obvious even to people with some medical background, as it is rare enough that it is not a primary concern. Now mabey paramedic courses cover it, I will try to check with my brother and find out as he recently got his national medic(he was a NYS medic for at least a decade before that)

BUt the real thing that should trip anyone with medical training is the altered mental regardless of their understanding of its specific mechanism dangers in this case.
 
There's a really interesting case involving Tesco and British Rail that I have to find a link for too, which essentially says that you have to assume that the public are complete idiots. I'll have a look later on and let you know if I find it.

That would be good, thanks. I'm always up for reading interesting cases.

Here it's possible that warnings will reduce liability in certain cases. There is some idea that, after a certain point, you take your life into your own hands and are fully liable for whatever happens. As I understand it, the initially liable party (such as the property owner) has to take reasonable precautions to ensure the safety of, say, workers. In some cases having a series of prominent signs saying "this crap won't support your weight, dummy!" might be sufficient to meet that standard. It would really depend on the specifics of the case.

In the case of the contest, the organizers are the ones who have to meet the reasonableness standards. If they had done so, then the death would be totally the fault of the contestant involved. Then again, if they'd met those standards she probably wouldn't have died, because she would've most likely been taken to a hospital rather than simply going home.

Out of curiosity, the UK health/safety law you talk about: would that apply to criminal proceedings, civil proceedings, both, or something else?
 
Generally speaking no, not in the slightest, on the basis that it could be kids, foreigners, or signs might not be sufficiently prominent.

There's a really interesting case involving Tesco and British Rail that I have to find a link for too, which essentially says that you have to assume that the public are complete idiots. I'll have a look later on and let you know if I find it.

I know my dad gets frustarated dealing with people suing the company he works for blaming the company for their not useing safety equipment and getting hurt as a result. You would think providing it and telling people is enough, and it might be, but it is often cheaper to settle than to fight and win.
 
My point was the the risks are not obvious even to people with some medical background, as it is rare enough that it is not a primary concern. Now mabey paramedic courses cover it, I will try to check with my brother and find out as he recently got his national medic(he was a NYS medic for at least a decade before that)

BUt the real thing that should trip anyone with medical training is the altered mental regardless of their understanding of its specific mechanism dangers in this case.

Good point. The hosts don't seem to have demonstrated any awareness of that.
 
I think you are referring to this.


Thanks Earthborn. There was no message saying that one had to be registered in order to cut and paste, but that did make the difference. I still can't play the audio clips though…

Here's some more updates: More than one nurse warned the DJs about the lethal dangers of water intoxication and a civil lawsuit will be officially announced soon.

Judith Linder, a nurse practitioner, said she heard the Morning Rave show when she was driving into work in North Highlands on Friday morning. She found it troubling. She and two co-workers called the radio station on a speaker phone, and their comments that water intoxication can be dangerous were part of the broadcast.

A DJ retorted, asking them why they didn't join the contest. Linder said they replied: We don't want to die.

"I was thinking, 'Who else could I call?' Endangering someone's health should be against the law," Linder said.

Its really unfortunate she didn't know who else to call. I would have thought asking to speak to their manger or the owner of the station would be obvious to any adult who ever held a job, and if she couldn't get through to them then the next step would be to call the city or county's health department -- but apparently not.

At least these nurses tried, I still find it difficult to believe that no one else called in to warn that this was a dangerous stunt. I also find it difficult to believe that no one called in to criticize the DJs response to the nurses warnings. (Basically the dialogue was this: Nurses: "These people could die!" DJs: "Oh that's OK! They signed a waiver!") Perhaps the reason is that the audience thought the contenstants could hear the phone calls since they could hear the contestants?

Sacramento attorney Roger Dreyer will be announcing a wrongful death lawsuit Thursday in the death of Jennifer Strange, 28, a Rancho Cordova mother of three who died hours after a water-drinking contest at a local radio station.
The suit will be filed against The End (KDND 107.9 FM) on behalf of Strange's husband and three children, ages 11 months, 3 and 10 years, according to a Sacramento public relations firm.
…
McGeorge School of Law civil torts professor Lawrence Levine said previously that a civil suit likely would be successful, since there are indications that the disc jockeys knew of the dangers of water intoxication while they goaded competitors to keep drinking. He said the jury also will be asked to consider the social value of the contest -- which he characterized as low.

"I think a jury is going to be quite unsympathetic (to the station)," Levine said.

All emphases added to the quotes are mine.
 
Last edited:
Generally speaking no, not in the slightest, on the basis that it could be kids, foreigners, or signs might not be sufficiently prominent.
Well, safety signs have to be able to convey their message (largely) through the standardized EU pictorgrams, sign shape and colour. So they should be pretty universally understood, even by those that cannot read English.
A safety sign is a good way to reduce criminal liability (if only by avoiding prosecution under the Safety Signs and Signal regs).

There's a really interesting case involving Tesco and British Rail that I have to find a link for too, which essentially says that you have to assume that the public are complete idiots. I'll have a look later on and let you know if I find it.

I'd be interested to see that, how old is the case?
 
I'd be interested to see that, how old is the case?

Well I saw it quoted by a solicitor (dangerous building project we were working on) back around 98 or 99, but how much before that I can't recall.

The solicitor and I still speak regulary on the project, so I'll give him a call.
 
Out of curiosity, the UK health/safety law you talk about: would that apply to criminal proceedings, civil proceedings, both, or something else?

Both, the legislation is concerned (largely) with criminal matters, however the Civil courts look at what is required by law as well as what is standard industry practice when deciding on things such as determining whether a duty of care existed, and whether that duty was breached.

The whole basis of the law can be summed up in two sections from the Health and Safety at Work etc. Act 1974.

General duties of employers to their employees.
2. (1) It shall be the duty of every employer to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, the health, safety and welfare at work of all his employees.

and

General duties of employers and self-employed to persons other than their employees.
3. (1) It shall be the duty of every employer to conduct his undertaking in such a way as to ensure, so far as is reasonably practicable, that persons not in his employment who may be affected thereby are not thereby exposed to risks to their health or safety.

Thats it basically it. If you run a business (or other undertaking) don't hurt anyone who works for you, and don't hurt anyone who doesn't work for you, so far as is practicable.
Under that a number of regulations are made, requiring certain things (such as risk assessments) or proscribe certain activities.
there are also Approved Codes of Practice and then just regular guidance, which can also have some bearing on a Civil case.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom