Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

No distinction whatsoever. Both require overriding natural basic instincts, inherent bodily knowledge, when done voluntarily. Black still isn't white. Boohoo about something else.


No distinction between drinking water and breathing it?

Let's try an experiment, Farmal. Go get a glass of water. Drink the first half of it. Any trouble? Now try breathing the second half of it and see what happens.

Come back and let me know if you detect a distinction.
 
May I also suggest that if I get in my car and drive along a road it is not my responsibility to check if any bridges will hold the weight of my car?
Why bother, Rasmus? You already know the answer:
No distinction whatsoever. Both require overriding natural basic instincts, inherent bodily knowledge, when done voluntarily. Black still isn't white. Boohoo about something else.
 
It's not just you. Half a U.S. gallon is only 1.89 litres which is under 4 small bottles of water (Unless my conversion is wrong).
I've drunk well over that on several occasions - granted i used the toilet, but, although aware of water intoxication, i had no idea i may die if i was stuck in a traffic jam for 4 hours.

Maybe the women had a low sodium count.
It wasn't "half a gallon". It was "well over half a gallon". Note that one participant stopped after half a gallon, but she continued on, and at some point they switched to bigger bottles of water. I suspect the person quoted was being very careful in his speech; he knew he stopped at 1/2G, he didn't know exactly how much she drank, except it was a lot more than he had drank.
 
Even if we can't expect the organisers to know about water toxification themselves, it seems alarming they didn't find out via this route.

The cheerleaders for this woman's death actually seem to want situation where the radio station would be actively discouraged from seeking medical advice. If "we didn't know it was dangerous" was an acceptable defence, then any smart event organiser (or product maufactuere0 would go out of their way to make sure that they remained completely ignorant of the dangers involved in their business.
Now, I don't know about US occupational health and safety legislation (and I suspect it varies from state to state), but in the UK undertakings are required to carry out a full risk assessment before carrying out their business activities. Any half competent risk assessment would have picked up on the dangers.
 
So you already know you're wrong but don't care? Well, at least you're forthright about it.

A contest to see how much water one can drink is not as inherently dangerous as, say, a contest to see who can jump off the highest bridge. Water is good for you. It makes up better than nine tenths of your body mass. You need lots of it every day. In fact, most could really use more than what they actually drink. People die left and right from dehydration. So the fact that you can drink too much of it is, though true, highly counterintuitive - and that's being modest.

This death was senseless and preventable, but that's the worst that can fairly be said about it.


And this attitude is part of the problem. Most people are not that dehydrated and telling people to drink water when they are not thirsty is one of the more dangerous modern exercise myths. It has lead to people doing what this person did because they thought it was good for them.

Hearing this, it makes most people think that it is even less likely to be dangerous.
 
No distinction whatsoever. Both require overriding natural basic instincts, inherent bodily knowledge, when done voluntarily. Black still isn't white. Boohoo about something else.

Got it, fighting instint is bad, so you should to what ever you feel might feel good at the time?

You are repeadedly ignoreing that there is a clear mechanism to most people for why drowning can kill you, the mechanism here is not obvious to people with out a good chemistry background.
 
Got it, fighting instint is bad, so you should to what ever you feel might feel good at the time?

You are repeadedly ignoreing that there is a clear mechanism to most people for why drowning can kill you, the mechanism here is not obvious to people with out a good chemistry background.

Not ignoring it at all. In fact in at least 20 posts I've NOT been ignoring it. Quite to the contrary, I keep harping on it. Get a clue, already wouldya? It's getting boring repeating the same old thing over and over!

Let's try it again. One last time. Grok it, already!

The body tells you to STOP DRINKING WATER! It's called the satiation feedback. The ONLY way you can drink too much water is to affirmatively OVERRIDE the feedback mechanism, unless coercion is involved (even you seem to agree her participation was voluntary).

She, without coercion, affirmatively overrode her own feedback mechanism telling her to "STOP DRINKING WATER, DIMBULB BABE!" She ignored it and CHOOSE to keep drinking. She did it by herself to herself of her own volition.

She was a living dumbass. Now she's a dead dumbass. I nominate her for the Darwin Extra Effort Award!
 
Not ignoring it at all. In fact in at least 20 posts I've NOT been ignoring it. Quite to the contrary, I keep harping on it. Get a clue, already wouldya? It's getting boring repeating the same old thing over and over!

Let's try it again. One last time. Grok it, already!

The body tells you to STOP DRINKING WATER! It's called the satiation feedback. The ONLY way you can drink too much water is to affirmatively OVERRIDE the feedback mechanism, unless coercion is involved (even you seem to agree her participation was voluntary).

She, without coercion, affirmatively overrode her own feedback mechanism telling her to "STOP DRINKING WATER, DIMBULB BABE!" She ignored it and CHOOSE to keep drinking. She did it by herself to herself of her own volition.

She was a living dumbass. Now she's a dead dumbass. I nominate her for the Darwin Extra Effort Award!
Every time I get on a plane, my whole body screams at me that flying isn't natural, that there is no way so much metal should be able to stay in the air- it's not safe. The only way for me o board a plane is to override my bodies natural defence mechanism.
Now, if I where to board a plane which disintegrated in mid flight, because the airline decided not to check its airworthiness because they "didn't know it wasn't safe", would I also be eligible for your extra super special Darwin grave pissing award?

Or should I be able to presume that taking a flight is a relatively safe thing to do?
 
Does anyone know what audience the station appeals to? It could be that it's a downmarket audio equivalent of The Sun (UK tabloid for idiots), and healthcare professionals were unlikely to tune in.

Good question. Here's the radio station's morning show's web site:
http://www.endonline.com/jocks_content/morningrave/index.php

I'm very hard of hearing and don't usually wear my hearing aids at home. And when I do listen to music, I usually listen to my CDs, not the radio (I really hate the commercials) so I can't judge the demographics based on the station's line up -- someone else will have to jump in here. However, their ads seem targetted to the middle class: a Chevy car dealership, an online university and a search engine's web site (Ask Jeeves). The talk shows topics they had coming up included the California governor and various health related areas: laser vision correction, plastic surgery and a psychologist. So I would say that their audience demographics seems educated enough that I'm still amazed that only one nurse called in to tell the DJs that their water drinking contest was dangerous. (BTW, eating contests are not unusual in the US. This is another reason why I'm not surprised that no lawyers or physicians were consulted about the water drinking contest. Intuitively over-drinking does not seem that much different than over-eating.)

BTW, that morning show is temporarily off the air - - here's the stations' announcement:

All of you are probably aware of the tragic death of a contestant, Jennifer Strange, following her participation in a contest on the Morning Rave last Friday.

First and foremost, our thoughts and sympathies go out to Jennifer's family and loved ones.

I also want to assure you that the circumstances regarding this matter are being examined as thoroughly as possible. We are doing everything we can to deal with this difficult situation in a manner that is both respectful and responsible. In the interim, the Morning Rave is off the air indefinitely.

Thank you.

John Geary
Vice-President & General Manager
107.9 THE END
 
Last edited:
The body tells you to STOP DRINKING WATER! It's called the satiation feedback. The ONLY way you can drink too much water is to affirmatively OVERRIDE the feedback mechanism, unless coercion is involved (even you seem to agree her participation was voluntary).

She, without coercion, affirmatively overrode her own feedback mechanism telling her to "STOP DRINKING WATER, DIMBULB BABE!" She ignored it and CHOOSE to keep drinking. She did it by herself to herself of her own volition.

She was a living dumbass. Now she's a dead dumbass. I nominate her for the Darwin Extra Effort Award!

I know this will be lost on you, but there is a vast difference in overriding a normal, every-day instinct and something lethal.

I get up in the morning, even trhough instinct tells me that sleep is more important than keeping a job that expects me to show up at work before 2pm. Yet, quite regularily, there I am in the office, fighting back my urge to sleep just another 5 minutes. I severly doubt I am risking my life.

Jogging. I have - on more than one occasion - done more than what my instincts were telling me to do. More often than not, my instincts tell me to simply not go jogging at all, period. Yet, there I am, running (or trampling as the case may be) through a forrest. And very often I decide to keep running even though I may be tired and exhausted. (My house isn't very accomodating and just stays put wherever it's been built. Never comes to pick even if it's just a quarter mile - so I keep running the lasst bit.)

Do I realize that what I do is unhealthy? Not even that. I know my muscles will be aching the next day, but that should be it. I have on occasion taken the bus or asked people to pick me up for the last couple of miles when the house was just too far away. Did I think I would kill myself if I kept on running? No! I was just too exhausted to keep running, a walk would have made me terribly late and I might have gotten a cold or something.

Need I point out that I have overeaten and poured myself a drink too much more than once, too? And don't get me started on not getting enough sleep....
 
I know this will be lost on you, but there is a vast difference in overriding a normal, every-day instinct and something lethal.

I get up in the morning, even trhough instinct tells me that sleep is more important than keeping a job that expects me to show up at work before 2pm. Yet, quite regularily, there I am in the office, fighting back my urge to sleep just another 5 minutes. I severly doubt I am risking my life.

Jogging. I have - on more than one occasion - done more than what my instincts were telling me to do. More often than not, my instincts tell me to simply not go jogging at all, period. Yet, there I am, running (or trampling as the case may be) through a forrest. And very often I decide to keep running even though I may be tired and exhausted. (My house isn't very accomodating and just stays put wherever it's been built. Never comes to pick even if it's just a quarter mile - so I keep running the lasst bit.)

Do I realize that what I do is unhealthy? Not even that. I know my muscles will be aching the next day, but that should be it. I have on occasion taken the bus or asked people to pick me up for the last couple of miles when the house was just too far away. Did I think I would kill myself if I kept on running? No! I was just too exhausted to keep running, a walk would have made me terribly late and I might have gotten a cold or something.

Need I point out that I have overeaten and poured myself a drink too much more than once, too? And don't get me started on not getting enough sleep....

Not lost on me at all. And the things you point out are perfectly normal everyday overrides with rather little chance of fatality resulting.

Here'd be a non-normal override. You're 2 miles from your home which is at the bottom of a canyon. Your run uphill takes you to the top of the ledge which, if you'd just jump off, would peel 1.85 miles off your trip back.

If you choose to jump, you'd do a stupid thing. You'd override a basic life instinct. Please don't try it. We need you here. :)

The woman CHOSE to override a basic life instinct and paid the price. No need to feel sorry for her one whit.
 
You're right. Completely and totally right. Let's move on.










They just want stroking is all. Egos are so cute when they're huge.
 
I've had to move posts to AAH twice, if I have to do it again I'll take further action which may include suspensions.

Attack the argument not the arguer.
Replying to this modbox in thread will be off topic  Posted By: Darat
 
do you feel sympathy for people that die as a result of car accidents?

after all, that's a common occurrence and you should expect it to happen. and you are an obvious idiot who deserves a 'darwin award' if you die that way. after all, we all know it's dangerous.

:)
This is a faulty analogy. People usually need to use a car to get somewhere in every day life. If the person drove recklessly, I would feel little sympathy if she died. If she was excercising typical caution and just got unlucky, it'd be a different story.

This woman put her health at risk. No, I don't blame her for not knowing it'd get her killed, but surely she could have figured out she was putting her health at risk. As I said, it's common sense that ingesting too much of something, anything, especially without excreting it, can't be good for your body.
 
I once had a sodium imbalance after working out and running in 100 degree heat, and drinking nothing but water. My calves and all the muscles in my forearms locked up, my heart was at times just sort of randomly fluttering, and I had the general sense that I was about to die. I had no headache and I suppose no brain swelling though, probably because I was still somewhat dehydrated. It's hard to know how much water I had, but I'm sure it was less than a gallon. The problem was more loss of sodium through sweat than excess of water. In my defense, I was 16 years old and this was in the time before sports drinks were popular.
 
As I said, it's common sense that ingesting too much of something, anything, especially without excreting it, can't be good for your body.

Not necessarily. If it was a barstool bet you'd expect alarm bells to start ringing, but a competition organised by a respectable radio station should be safe.
 
The woman CHOSE to override a basic life instinct and paid the price. No need to feel sorry for her one whit.
Except she, nor the other contestants, nor the organizers, seems to have recognized it as a basic life instinct. If I hadn't heard of water poisoning I'm not sure I would have, either. It doesn't seem intuitive to me. The example you give about jumping, on the other hand, is very intuitive.

I suppose this has to do with what we learn as a child. Everyone knows falling can hurt. We've experienced it many times in our childhood, from the moment we learn to stand. On the other hand, few of us have ever held our wee beyond mild discomfort, so how are we to know it can be dangerous? It's non-intuitive.

I must admit your lack of sympathy for this woman does leave me puzzled somewhat - in fact it seems almost like an alien mindset. Hypothetically speaking, do you suppose you could ever feel sympathy for someone who was hurt as a result of their own actions, whether due to lack of knowledge or cognitive abilities? Is it conceivable that you yourself might ever get hurt as a result of your own actions, due to a lack of knowledge or cognitive abilities?
 
FarmallMTA said:
The woman CHOSE to override a basic life instinct and paid the price. No need to feel sorry for her one whit.

Perforatu said:
I must admit your lack of sympathy for this woman does leave me puzzled somewhat - in fact it seems almost like an alien mindset.

I don't know about alien. Nelson Muntz is the character that springs to mind :D
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom