Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

I noticed that sometime earlier - around the time that it came out that the studio had been warned but the contestants weren't to be exact. Not as honorable as apologising - but then given some of two of their posts on other threads, not surprising.
 
In case people missed it, there where no criminal charges in this case.

This would seem to be good news for reality shows they can be potentialy deadly in obvious ways to profeshionals and still be not liable.
 
I knew of a young lady who did the exact same thing.


This unfortunant lady may have had obsessive compulsive disorder. There was a young college girl at Emory University here in Atlanta who drank hugh amounts of water, often looking like she was pregnant. This doisorder began after her mother died of cancer and she was obsessed with the idea that water would flush the toxins out of own body. She contracted pneumonia and died in a hospital.
 
Hell, got a link? I can't believe they got away with it. :(

Dirrectly to a news source no. It was not such news that it seems to have been preserved well. I have wikipedia and blog sources

here this looks like a news source.

"She knew what the contest involved when she entered it and had the option to stop or discontinue her participation in the contest at any time," said Scully, outlining how prosecutors contemplated -- and ultimately decided against -- filing charges of involuntary manslaughter.

"There were no observable indications or symptoms that Jennifer Strange was experiencing a serious medical emergency which would have required station employees to seek or administer medical aid to her," Scully said.

It would seem that being drunk from water is not enough of a clue, unlike this where the frat brothers where convicted in responce to killing someone by having them drink too much water.
 
The family of a US woman who drank so much water in a contest run by a radio station that she died has received $16m (£9.7m) in compensation.

A California court found Sacramento radio station KDND-FM and its owner liable for the death in January 2007 of mother-of-three Jennifer Strange, 28.

She had taken part in a contest to see who could drink the most without going to the toilet, to win a Nintendo Wii.

She lost, and a few hours later died of acute water intoxication.

Story at BBC News
 
Well, now her family can buy a whole bunch of Wiis!

#1 Story here in Sacramento for 2 days.
The woman was stupid, but I think the radio station deserves a smack down for being stupid enough to let a shock jock sponser a contest that had "lawsuit "written all over it. Frankly, a lot of these Shock Jocks seem to think the First Admendment gives them a licence to do just about anything, no matter how dangerous it might be. Say just about anything as long it is not one of the Seven words, yes, but do anything, no. If you do something as a Radio show Host that endangers other people or breaks Civil Law (diferent then FCC Regs) you have just jumped out from under the 1st Admendment cover.
 
Last edited:
#1 Story here in Sacramento for 2 days.
The woman was stupid, but I think the radio station deserves a smack down for being stupid enough to let a shock jock sponser a contest that had "lawsuit "written all over it. Frankly, a lot of these Shock Jocks seem to think the First Admendment gives them a licence to do just about anything, no matter how dangerous it might be. Say just about anything as long it is not one of the Seven words, yes, but do anything, no. If you do something as a Radio show Host that endangers other people or breaks Civil Law (diferent then FCC Regs) you have just jumped out from under the 1st Admendment cover.

Everybody in this case showed incredible stupidity.
 
Well, looking deeper into the story, the original contest was not supposed to be a drinking contest. They were supposed to only drink a liter of water each. When it was perceived that the contest would take too long, they started incrementing the amounts.

The woman who died was not necessarily stupid, if she knew how much water was going to be involved (no indication of a large amount from the original contest rules) she may have backed out. In the situation the way it presented itself, she was already vested in the contest, and was not made aware of any safety issues.
 
Everybody in this case showed incredible stupidity.

I won't debate that.
What irritated me in this thread is those who while blasting the participant tried to let the radio station off the hook completly. I notice they left after the transcripts were posted showing how totally irresponsible the radio station was, laughing off a couple of callers, including a RN, who tried to warn them about the dangers.
The station deserved to get nailed.
 
I won't debate that.
What irritated me in this thread is those who while blasting the participant tried to let the radio station off the hook completly. I notice they left after the transcripts were posted showing how totally irresponsible the radio station was, laughing off a couple of callers, including a RN, who tried to warn them about the dangers.
The station deserved to get nailed.

I agree completely. At first I didn't have much sympathy, as I still remember going over hyposalination in Health class in 6th grade, 9th grade, AND 11th grade, including reviewing cases of it happening, etc., and figured anyone willing to enter a dangerous contest deserves what they get, but the transcripts tells a very different story, including callous and ignorant DJ's misleading their listeners about the safety of the event.
 
#1 Story here in Sacramento for 2 days.
The woman was stupid, but I think the radio station deserves a smack down for being stupid enough to let a shock jock sponser a contest that had "lawsuit "written all over it. Frankly, a lot of these Shock Jocks seem to think the First Admendment gives them a licence to do just about anything, no matter how dangerous it might be. Say just about anything as long it is not one of the Seven words, yes, but do anything, no. If you do something as a Radio show Host that endangers other people or breaks Civil Law (diferent then FCC Regs) you have just jumped out from under the 1st Admendment cover.

Why was she stupid? It seems very few people understand the dangers of Hyponatremia, and the people who saw that she had altered mental status from water, deciding not to do anything about it is worse. Altered mental status is always dangerous unless you have a clear cause.

I am annoyed at the lack of criminal charges.
 
She may have had obsessive compulsive disorder. A woman at Emory University here in georgia USA started drinking water after her mother died of cancer and eventually died of pneumonia even though the doctors frantically tried to save her. She had so much water in her tissues that she looked obese.

Obsessive compulsive disorder? She was trying to win a Wii. OCD had nothing to do with it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom