Idiot Drinks So Much Water She Dies

Well I saw it quoted by a solicitor (dangerous building project we were working on) back around 98 or 99, but how much before that I can't recall.

The solicitor and I still speak regulary on the project, so I'll give him a call.

I'll have a look myself. I left the HSE in 2003, but I have notes on landmark cases before that, I'll see if I can find a reference to the case you're talking about.
 
Thats it basically it. If you run a business (or other undertaking) don't hurt anyone who works for you, and don't hurt anyone who doesn't work for you, so far as is practicable.
Under that a number of regulations are made, requiring certain things (such as risk assessments) or proscribe certain activities.
there are also Approved Codes of Practice and then just regular guidance, which can also have some bearing on a Civil case.

Sounds like, in practical terms, it's pretty similar to US law. We get some silly cases, but generally speaking avoiding liability is about taking reasonable precautions to avoid hurting your employees or others.

Anyhow, it's all beyond the scope of this particular case. They were way out of line by not even informing the contestants of the potential risk and consulting with medical professionals (or not listening to them, if they did). I just don't see that reasonableness standard being met here.
 
Sounds like, in practical terms, it's pretty similar to US law. We get some silly cases, but generally speaking avoiding liability is about taking reasonable precautions to avoid hurting your employees or others.

Anyhow, it's all beyond the scope of this particular case. They were way out of line by not even informing the contestants of the potential risk and consulting with medical professionals (or not listening to them, if they did). I just don't see that reasonableness standard being met here.

Well in a UK case the first thing that investigators (and lawyers for the deceased's family) would ask to see would be the risk assessment for the contest. If they didn't do one, they then will have pretty much lost- both criminally and in civil court. If they did do one but didn't follow it- ditto.
If they did do one,a nd followed it- it could not have been done very well, but the may possibly have some sort of defense ( but I doubt it).
 
Well in a UK case the first thing that investigators (and lawyers for the deceased's family) would ask to see would be the risk assessment for the contest. If they didn't do one, they then will have pretty much lost- both criminally and in civil court. If they did do one but didn't follow it- ditto.
If they did do one,a nd followed it- it could not have been done very well, but the may possibly have some sort of defense ( but I doubt it).

That's not something that I've heard of in US cases before. I might be misinformed, but I'm pretty sure that a risk assessment wouldn't be present with a US case.

Tell me, does the UK system also involve the concept of the "reasonable person" with negligence cases?

In the US, that's the golden ticket when it comes to negligence, either by a person or by an organization.
 
That's not something that I've heard of in US cases before. I might be misinformed, but I'm pretty sure that a risk assessment wouldn't be present with a US case.
In the Uk not carrying out a risk assessment (except for small undertakings) is a criminal offense, regardless of whether anyone was injured or not.

Tell me, does the UK system also involve the concept of the "reasonable person" with negligence cases?

In the US, that's the golden ticket when it comes to negligence, either by a person or by an organization.

I don't know. As I said most of my knowledge is on the criminal aspects rather than civil. What i would say though is that (much like in the US) the perception of the number of stupid cases which actually win (the apocryphal woman in a shop tripping over her own unruly kids and then suing etc) is much, much lower than the reality.
The trouble is, this perception- and the willingness of insurance companies to settle out of court rather than face large legal bills, means that many businesses act as if they do have to protect people to a ridicules degree, no matter how irresponsible the person- which means that many perfectly safe activities are prohibited by the businesses own health and safety policy, or by constraints put on them in insurance polices.
 
I have a question - could the Nintendo corporation sue over this matter?

The reason I bring this up is something I notice in the gaming blog Shera had linked to in her post yesterday where it mentioned the FCC problems the radio station was having before this debacle. I remember the last line of the item stating that they will continue to follow FCC story, or "if Nintendo gets involved..." (this may not be the exact quote, but since I am at work I doubt I could access the blog to get the correct wording.)
 
In the Uk not carrying out a risk assessment (except for small undertakings) is a criminal offense, regardless of whether anyone was injured or not.

Gotcha. We've got nothing generally comparable in the US, as far as I know.

I don't know. As I said most of my knowledge is on the criminal aspects rather than civil. What i would say though is that (much like in the US) the perception of the number of stupid cases which actually win (the apocryphal woman in a shop tripping over her own unruly kids and then suing etc) is much, much lower than the reality.
The trouble is, this perception- and the willingness of insurance companies to settle out of court rather than face large legal bills, means that many businesses act as if they do have to protect people to a ridicules degree, no matter how irresponsible the person- which means that many perfectly safe activities are prohibited by the businesses own health and safety policy, or by constraints put on them in insurance polices.

The high legal cost and settlements can be a massive cost as well. Even though the suit might be ridiculous, the company or individual being sued has to pay to defend themselves or settle the case. Even if the case is tossed out, the lawyers' fees can be considerable.

Of course, this can have an impact on the cost of everything, as the company needs to pay for those lawyers somehow.
 
I heard the audio from this contest played at length today on another radio program. It was pretty freaky. A caller called in during the contest and specifically warned that the contest will probably kill a contestant due to water intoxication. The radio jocks said (sarcastically) "yeah we know. That's why we had them all sign waivers. Haha. Hey, are any of our contestants dead yet?" Then, near the end of the contest when the (soon to die) contestant dropped out, she was speaking in a pained voice and complaining about headaches. The DJ's did nothing to suggest she seek any medical help or evaluation. They just sent her home. They said an intern told her he body would naturally make her throw up if she needed to.

The negligence seems so high that I think the radio dj's and management face potential criminal liability.
 
I heard the audio from this contest played at length today on another radio program. It was pretty freaky. A caller called in during the contest and specifically warned that the contest will probably kill a contestant due to water intoxication. The radio jocks said (sarcastically) "yeah we know. That's why we had them all sign waivers. Haha. Hey, are any of our contestants dead yet?" Then, near the end of the contest when the (soon to die) contestant dropped out, she was speaking in a pained voice and complaining about headaches. The DJ's did nothing to suggest she seek any medical help or evaluation. They just sent her home. They said an intern told her he body would naturally make her throw up if she needed to.

The negligence seems so high that I think the radio dj's and management face potential criminal liability.


OK Dave! We get the point! ;)

I'm sure most people know this, but I've seen it mentioned, and heard it in the audio of the broadcast, and feel compelled to make mention of the fact that in pretty much all cases when a DJ talks about an intern in the studio, they are referring to a Radio Intern. Not a Doctor doing his/her stint at a local university hospital to finish their education. So, I think it's safe to say that the intern in this case is just someone trying to break into the radio industry (as a DJ I suppose, but don't know).

Again, I don't think that's new news to many, but wanted to clarify in case :)
 
OK Dave! We get the point! ;)

I'm sure most people know this, but I've seen it mentioned, and heard it in the audio of the broadcast, and feel compelled to make mention of the fact that in pretty much all cases when a DJ talks about an intern in the studio, they are referring to a Radio Intern. Not a Doctor doing his/her stint at a local university hospital to finish their education. So, I think it's safe to say that the intern in this case is just someone trying to break into the radio industry (as a DJ I suppose, but don't know).

Again, I don't think that's new news to many, but wanted to clarify in case :)

Good point. Intern could be misconstrued as medical doctor, but I don't think it's commonly used that way by lay people in the U.S. I think most Americans understood it to mean Radio Intern, as you say.
 
Good point. Intern could be misconstrued as medical doctor, but I don't think it's commonly used that way by lay people in the U.S. I think most Americans understood it to mean Radio Intern, as you say.

I was afraid you were gonna yell at me about the OK Dave we get the point thing!

Doesn't make as much sense without the triple post being there:)
 
I have a question - could the Nintendo corporation sue over this matter?

Well, they could sue. After all, I could sue you for looking at me funny. The real question is whether or not they could win anything.

I would think not. A negligence judgment (or any civil judgment, really) requires that some quantifiable damage be shown. I doubt very much that Nintendo could make a convincing case that their business or reputation was materially impacted by this.
 
Well, they could sue. After all, I could sue you for looking at me funny. The real question is whether or not they could win anything.

I would think not. A negligence judgment (or any civil judgment, really) requires that some quantifiable damage be shown. I doubt very much that Nintendo could make a convincing case that their business or reputation was materially impacted by this.

I think Nintendo's chances for a successful lawsuit would depend on the wording of any agreements included in the package (those "the user agrees to these terms and conditions" things that most software includes).

I have no idea if Nintendo includes such conditions of use. But if they do, and if those conditions limit or forbid using their product for promotions (or stupid contest that kill people;)) then there could be a case.

The wording of those terms/conditions would, I think, determine the grounds and chances of success.
 
I think Nintendo's chances for a successful lawsuit would depend on the wording of any agreements included in the package (those "the user agrees to these terms and conditions" things that most software includes).

I have no idea if Nintendo includes such conditions of use. But if they do, and if those conditions limit or forbid using their product for promotions (or stupid contest that kill people;)) then there could be a case.

The wording of those terms/conditions would, I think, determine the grounds and chances of success.

Unless Nintendo has included a very bizarre provision that you cannot sell their hardware or the included software, then I don't think there would be an issue here. Not only that, but I would think there would be legal issues if they tried to tell people that you couldn't resell the hardware.

Even if it covered software as well, the only included software is that Wii Sports game, and possibly whatever software is loaded onto the console's built-in memory (i.e. the console's "operating system").

Once you own the hardware, you can sell it, give it away, or throw it off a bridge (barring state dumping laws ;) ) if you want. If Nintendo tried to restrict the rights of an individual to transfer their private non-software property in such a way (even software transfer restriction would be a sticky issue), it would be without any legal precedent, and would probably result in legal troubles for Nintendo more than anyone else.
 
I think whether Nintendo can sue depends on how the radio station got the console. If Nintendo has been giving away consoles to media in order to have them promoted on air, then they may be able to sue because it reflects badly on them and they may have reasonably expected that a radio show would have plugged their product in a less distasteful and less deadly way.

On the other hand, if the radio station bought the console itself and did not intend the stunt as promotion of it, Nintendo will have a more difficult case. Perhaps it is still possible if they argue that listeners may have mistaken it for marketing by Nintendo and it reflects badly on them.
 
I think whether Nintendo can sue depends on how the radio station got the console. If Nintendo has been giving away consoles to media in order to have them promoted on air, then they may be able to sue because it reflects badly on them and they may have reasonably expected that a radio show would have plugged their product in a less distasteful and less deadly way.

On the other hand, if the radio station bought the console itself and did not intend the stunt as promotion of it, Nintendo will have a more difficult case. Perhaps it is still possible if they argue that listeners may have mistaken it for marketing by Nintendo and it reflects badly on them.

Again, I think the thrust of it is whether or not there were measurable damages to Nintendo.

I have a feeling they won't bother to get involved with it. They have to pay their lawyers too, after all.
 
It appears that the attorneys for Jennifer Strange's family intends to sue Nintendo and the promoters for Justin Timberlake.

I don't know how Justin Timberlake was involved in this promotion so I can't speak about that.

In cable television ts common for corporations to do joint marketing. I assume that the same is true in radio. Also, American Radio also has the reputation of having slim profit margins (or at least they did when I last checked this out about 10 years ago, I doubt that has changed). Based on those two things -- its unlikely that the radio station bought the prize (the Wii) on their own to give away. Its much more likely that Nintendo and the radio station, or the parent company of the radio station, signed a contract to do joint marketing and that Nintendo either supplied the Wii or at least paid for part of it, and also helped pay for much of the marketing.

Usually the company paying for the marketing attaches samples of what was produced when they bill their partner company for their share of the "marketing campaign". So it will be difficult for Nintendo to prove that they did not know what the contest involved. Their contract most likely got fairly specific as to what the marketing would cover, and there was probably printed materials promoting the contest also. Again, I'm going based on my experience in cable television -- but I really doubt that they handle marketing that differently in radio.

Its business, and unless radio is completely different than cable, companies are not going to give each other that much publicity without any discussion as to who will do what, and what the advertising will involve, and then signing contracts that summarize their intent.

Without looking into this specifically but relying on generalities -- Nintendo would be an attractive target for a civil lawsuit and is more likely to have deeper pockets than the company owning the radio station. Particularly a radio station that may lose its license from the FCC (posted earlier in the thread the other day).


http://www.tssznews.com/
TSSZ has learned this evening through the way of KCRA-TV that the attorney for the family of Jennifer Strange may expand a pending civil suit to include Nintendo as a named defendant.

Ms. Strange died of water intoxication after participating in KDND-FM’s Hold Your Wee for a Wii contest. She drank over a gallon of water and won a Wii for her children.​


The Strange family attorney also intends to sue promoters for Justin Timberlake–their connection to the contest is unclear at this time.​
 
Last edited:
Well that one came out of left field. I think you're right about the deep pockets thing.

In this case, they'll have to show Nintendo (or Justin Timberlake's promoters) had some kind of responsibility. If they officially endorsed the contest, that might be a valid point. If not, I fail to see how Nintendo could be held liable for the woman's death. If they had no involvement with the contest, it would be akin to me killing someone over their TV and the family suing the television manufacturer.

As they used the Timberlake tickets to try and get her to stop, perhaps the promoters could claim they were actually trying to help save this woman.
 
It appears that the attorneys for Jennifer Strange's family intends to sue Nintendo and the promoters for Justin Timberlake.

I don't know how Justin Timberlake was involved in this promotion so I can't speak about that.

In cable television ts common for corporations to do joint marketing. I assume that the same is true in radio. Also, American Radio also has the reputation of having slim profit margins (or at least they did when I last checked this out about 10 years ago, I doubt that has changed). Based on those two things -- its unlikely that the radio station bought the prize (the Wii) on their own to give away. Its much more likely that Nintendo and the radio station, or the parent company of the radio station, signed a contract to do joint marketing and that Nintendo either supplied the Wii or at least paid for part of it, and also helped pay for much of the marketing.

I am not sure about the profit margions, but with all the consolidation going on in the radio market, there is a likelyhood that the station is owned by a large enough company to have real assets to go after.

How culpable nintendo is, well as you pointed out that depends on their connection to the event.
 
The Central Scrutinizer, FarmallMTA & DanishDynamite have left the building!
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom