IAF Pin Point Bombing

Such as not dropping bombs in the middle of the Unifil position.

Okay, anything helpful by way of "precautions"? I mean, handcuffs chafe, but we still arrest criminals.

Looking for details, not platitudes, Leif. Thanks in advance.
 
What are the odds of hitting that single ambulance right in the middle of the big red target?

Depends on whether you're doing it with a bomb from 5,000 feet or an axe from 5 feet with a digital camera at the ready, doesn't it?
 
Depends on whether you're doing it with a bomb from 5,000 feet or an axe from 5 feet with a digital camera at the ready, doesn't it?

The claim that the damage is caused by an Israeli air attack is supported by Knut Kaspersen, the Federation Representative of the International Red Cross' Beirut delegation.
 
The claim that the damage is caused by an Israeli air attack is supported by Knut Kaspersen, the Federation Representative of the International Red Cross' Beirut delegation.

Still waiting for those tactical pointers, Leif.
 
Okay, anything helpful by way of "precautions"? I mean, handcuffs chafe, but we still arrest criminals.

Looking for details, not platitudes, Leif. Thanks in advance.

I don't see how that is a platitude. Israel knew the position of the Unifil post, they knew what the post looks like and that were Unifil personell at the post. It is simply not acceptable that they then attack anything in the area without being 100% certain that their target, and the zone of effect for the payload, doesn't include the actual Unifil position. Someone ****ed up, and ****ed up big.

If there had been Hezbollah forces near the post that posed a direct, lethal and immediate threat to Israeli forces or civilians so that the IDF did not have the time necessary to make certain they didn't harm Unifil personell, then it would have been a different history. However, Hezbollah doesn't have anything that poses that kind of threat to IDF or Israel, and even if they did the length of time the Unifil position was under fire makes it clear that the Israeli attack was not the kind of hasty, no-holds barred reaction to an immediate threat that could have excused the lack of certain target identification.
 
I don't see how that is a platitude. Israel knew the position of the Unifil post, they knew what the post looks like and that were Unifil personell at the post. It is simply not acceptable that they then attack anything in the area without being 100% certain that their target, and the zone of effect for the payload, doesn't include the actual Unifil position. Someone ****ed up, and ****ed up big.

If there had been Hezbollah forces near the post that posed a direct, lethal and immediate threat to Israeli forces or civilians so that the IDF did not have the time necessary to make certain they didn't harm Unifil personell, then it would have been a different history. However, Hezbollah doesn't have anything that poses that kind of threat to IDF or Israel, and even if they did the length of time the Unifil position was under fire makes it clear that the Israeli attack was not the kind of hasty, no-holds barred reaction to an immediate threat that could have excused the lack of certain target identification.

So your problem is not with the airstrike, but with the perceived threat level? I'm still looking for some "precaution" the IAF could have taken, but there doesn't seem to be one... unless you count "become psychic" as a precaution.

There were rocket positions set up near the posts. There were rockets launched by the dozen daily into Israel. Just how psychic do you expect these pilots to be?
 
Until that point in time that Hezbollah abides the laws of war regarding distinguishing themselves from civilian populations and operating in protected spaces, those deaths are directly attributable to them.

The laws of war????

Since when did the laws of war include collective punishment?

Israeli self defence rationale: You throw stones at us, we will demolish the houses of all your relatives. You kidnap two soldiers, we will kill hundreds of lebanese civilians and destroy the infrastructure of your country.

Israel is going to hell. All that is happening right now is that Israel is creating yet another generation of people who will now dedicate their lives to destroying Israel.

Israel is a curse on humanity.
 
Last edited:
So your problem is not with the airstrike, but with the perceived threat level? I'm still looking for some "precaution" the IAF could have taken, but there doesn't seem to be one... unless you count "become psychic" as a precaution.

The precuation is to hold their fire until they know what they're shooting at. It's that simple. This isn't a fog of war situation -- IDF knew, or bloody well should have known, the exact location of the Unifil position and they had the time and control necessary to get a full situational awareness before dropping that bomb. They didn't. People died because of they didn't.

When there's a hunting accident and one hunter shoots a friend who was sitting hunched up next to the fire, you don't ask "what precaution could the hunter have taken to prevent killing his friend?" The fact is that he shouldn't have shot at anything unless he knew what he was shooting at.

There were rocket positions set up near the posts. There were rockets launched by the dozen daily into Israel. Just how psychic do you expect these pilots to be?

Those rockets don't pose the kind of immediate danger that excuses the IDF not taking the time to tell what they're shooting at. Israel has born such rocket attacks for years.
 
The laws of war????

Since when did the laws of war include collective punishment?

Israeli self defence rationale: You throw stones at us, we will demolish the houses of all your relatives. You kidnap two soldiers, we will kill hundreds of lebanese civilians and destroy the infrastructure of your country.

Israel is going to hell. All that is happening right now is that Israel is creating yet another generation of people who will now dedicate their lives to destroying Israel.

Israel is a curse on humanity.

Another political masterclass from the anti-semitic genocide advocate...

Throw stones?
 
Those rockets don't pose the kind of immediate danger that excuses the IDF not taking the time to tell what they're shooting at. Israel has born such rocket attacks for years.

So that's why they should continue to bear them forever, just so long as the launchers are positioned next to something sensitive. Great advice, Patton. :rolleyes:
 
The laws of war????

Since when did the laws of war include collective punishment?

Israeli self defence rationale: You throw stones at us, we will demolish the houses of all your relatives. You kidnap two soldiers, we will kill hundreds of lebanese civilians and destroy the infrastructure of your country.

Israel is going to hell. All that is happening right now is that Israel is creating yet another generation of people who will now dedicate their lives to destroying Israel.

Israel is a curse on humanity.

Finally, an islamist sympathizer with the cojones to come right out and say it. Take note, amateurs, for you are in the presence of greatness!
 
Finally, an islamist sympathizer with the cojones to come right out and say it. Take note, amateurs, for you are in the presence of greatness!

I am not an islamist. I merely share a pair of common enemies with Islamists. Do you have any idea how many non-muslims are as anti-american and anti-israeli as I am? Bush has done a very good job at alienating the entire world, and Israel is now following suit.
 
I am not an islamist. I merely share a pair of common enemies.

Which is why I called your statement that of an islamist sympathizer. You have sympathy for their plight against your common enemy. Not a perjorative, simply a statement of alignment.

Likewise, one might call me an Israeli sympathizer for my support of their reaction, even though I'm neither jewish nor zionist myself. I'm more interested in justice finding the killers of nearly 300 US marines a while back.
 
Which is why I called your statement that of an islamist sympathizer. You have sympathy for their plight against your common enemy. Not a perjorative, simply a statement of alignment.

In the same sense that Churchill and Eisenhower were Stalin sympathizers?
 
*sighs* Yes, of course. Roosevelt. Sorry. It's getting late here.

Well, if either of them went online and declared their support for Stalin out of a shared hatred of Hitler, then yes, to anyone oppsed to Stalin they would fulfill the characteristics of a sympathizer.

Besides, Geoff doesn't seem to have a problem with it, and I've already demonstrated my own alignment. I'm not afraid to say that Hezbollah should be eviscerated from top to bottom, not because I believe in a greater Israel, but because I happen to think terrorists deserve to die.

I think that you'll find most of the supporters of the current attacks will express similar sentiments.
 
I am not an islamist. I merely share a pair of common enemies with Islamists. Do you have any idea how many non-muslims are as anti-american and anti-israeli as I am?
Let's see, there's you, George Galloway, Robert Fiske (debatable), your sister, and... well, that's about all I can come up with without going to a neo-Nazi website and having to take a shower in boric acid afterwards. And even the neo-Nazis don't claim to be anti-American, though they share a lot more in common with your Islamist buddies than with anyone I care to associate with.

So, the answer is, "Three."
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom