IAF Pin Point Bombing

In breakinmg news it is reported that 4 unarmed UN military observers have been killed by an Israeli bomb. Initial report with numbers of dead in http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1153291996858&pagename=JPost/JPArticle/ShowFull

A pin point strike by the IAF on unarmed UN observers plus 14 other incidents? How can this be a mistake? And if isn't a mistake what is it?

Do you think that people never make mistakes, especially in stressful situations? Do you think that the dozen or so UK soldiers killed by US friendly fire in the first Gulf War were intentionally hunted down by the American pilots?

Concept of Human Error calling EJ Armstrong. Care to pick up?
 
Do you think that people never make mistakes, especially in stressful situations? Do you think that the dozen or so UK soldiers killed by US friendly fire in the first Gulf War were intentionally hunted down by the American pilots?

Concept of Human Error calling EJ Armstrong. Care to pick up?
So this wasn't a 'pin point' attack. Fine. What is the true level of 'error' being made by the IDF in the Lebanon? How many dead Lebanese civilians can be ascribed to error now that we know some level of error is being made?

Kofi Annan has stated that ""The firing continued even during the rescue operation," Annan said." from http://www.theage.com.au/news/World...by-Israeli-bomb/2006/07/26/1153816214206.html

This seems like a very prolonged 'error'. Is this level of 'error' acceptable?
 
Last edited:
Until that point in time that Hezbollah abides the laws of war regarding distinguishing themselves from civilian populations and operating in protected spaces, those deaths are directly attributable to them.

Terrorists in the media age depend on sympathy from those who overlook their methods.
 
Until that point in time that Hezbollah abides the laws of war regarding distinguishing themselves from civilian populations and operating in protected spaces, those deaths are directly attributable to them.

Terrorists in the media age depend on sympathy from those who overlook their methods.

Surely this is only the case if the UN post is in a civilian area?
 
Surely this is only the case if the UN post is in a civilian area?

Sorry - I was responding to the question of civilian casualties. The UN observers are a stickier wicket. I'd want to know if the outpost was clearly marked and if it was being also being used by Hezbollah an observation point.
 
Until that point in time that Hezbollah abides the laws of war regarding distinguishing themselves from civilian populations and operating in protected spaces, those deaths are directly attributable to them.

Terrorists in the media age depend on sympathy from those who overlook their methods.

Doyou believe that the IDF has no responsibility for any civilian deaths howso ever caused? If yes - is it your contention therefore that every single death of civilians and UN observers is attributable to IDF 'error'? If not - what is the rate of 'error' and why does the IDF not have responsibility for killing unarmed men and children?

Do you deny that the IDF has committed any war crimes whatsoever to date?

And what about those who overlook both Hezbollah and IDF terror?
 
Sorry - I was responding to the question of civilian casualties. The UN observers are a stickier wicket. I'd want to know if the outpost was clearly marked and if it was being also being used by Hezbollah an observation point.

How many UN observation posts are being used by Hezbollah?
 
Doyou believe that the IDF has no responsibility for any civilian deaths howso ever caused?

From what I have seen so far, I cannot assess any blame on the IDF. Certainly if their intent was to kill civilians, they are doing a piss-poor job of it.

If yes - is it your contention therefore that every single death of civilians and UN observers is attributable to IDF 'error'? If not - what is the rate of 'error' and why does the IDF not have responsibility for killing unarmed men and children?

The error rate (accepting your term for the purpose of this discussion) is actually quantifiable. The IAF had completed ~2500 strike missions this weekend with ~250 civilian deaths being reported by the government. Even if you spread these deaths evenly, you are talking about a 10% error rate. In fact, the per mission error is probably much lower, since the media reports indicate many civilian deaths occurred at single targets.

Do you deny that the IDF has committed any war crimes whatsoever to date?

I don't have any evidence of war crimes. Remember that combatants operating in protected areas remove the protected status of that area.
 
What's the basis of the claim that it was an IAF strike? Does the UNIFIL have radar? How can they tell the difference between a bomb and a katusha?
Mr Strugar said attacks had continued in the area as rescuers attempted to reach the wounded.
It's got to take a few minutes for rescuers to get there. A fighter is not going to hang around that long. And a katusha magazine is not going to take that long to empty either. I would like to hear a little more from these rescuers since the story Strugar tells doesn't sound like a rocket or bomb attack.

Also it seems like the border monitoring force is a bit of an anachronism in the middle of open war. Those guys should all have been evacuated July 12th.
 
Kofi Annan has stated that ""The firing continued even during the rescue operation," Annan said."

Of course, Kofi Annan also said that "Mr. Nasrallah" will be a force for stability and peace in Lebanon. Annan also says that israel fighting against Palestinian terorrists is just a "cycle of violence".

If Annan says something about the middle east, there's about a 90% chance that it's inaccurate, and a 99.5% that it's against israel.
 
What's the basis of the claim that it was an IAF strike? Does the UNIFIL have radar?

UNIFIL and Kofi Annan both believe it's Israel. Do you know better?

from cbc.ca:

"Alan Baker, Israel's ambassador to Canada, said from Ottawa he was aware of an air strike, but couldn't confirm reports that a Canadian was among the casualties."

Even Israel seems to know better than you.

Also it seems like the border monitoring force is a bit of an anachronism in the middle of open war. Those guys should all have been evacuated July 12th.

Israel is not at war with Lebanon.

Regardless...

Even if Hezbollah was at fault, I'm shocked at the reaction. You'd think that Israel (ostensibly one of the great western democracies) would be falling all over themselves to launch a full investigation and take excruciating pains to avoid U.N. posts. If they genuinely suspected Hezbollah, they should be offering all resources for the U.N. to investigate. Their innocence would be made manifest.

I have no love for Hamas and Hezbollah, but I'm not amenable to any false dichotomy. Israel is just as capable of reprehensible acts.
 
UNIFIL and Kofi Annan both believe it's Israel. Do you know better?

from cbc.ca:

"Alan Baker, Israel's ambassador to Canada, said from Ottawa he was aware of an air strike, but couldn't confirm reports that a Canadian was among the casualties."

Even Israel seems to know better than you.



Israel is not at war with Lebanon.

Regardless...

Even if Hezbollah was at fault, I'm shocked at the reaction. You'd think that Israel (ostensibly one of the great western democracies) would be falling all over themselves to launch a full investigation and take excruciating pains to avoid U.N. posts. If they genuinely suspected Hezbollah, they should be offering all resources for the U.N. to investigate. Their innocence would be made manifest.

I have no love for Hamas and Hezbollah, but I'm not amenable to any false dichotomy. Israel is just as capable of reprehensible acts.

I am not sure why cbc.ca does not mention it, but there seems to be an investigation underway.

Sources:
Guardian and Sydney Morning Herald
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom