IAF Pin Point Bombing

a mandate to defend yourself and civilians with force if necessary. And sane rules of engagement. And reasonable provisions that actually allow a peace to be kept. And a staggering reduction in bureaucracy. And less infighting. And less corruption. And less nepotism...

and American direction... :rolleyes:
 
My only question is, How long will these illogical Israeli defenders on this forum keep making up excuses for Israel?

What would Israel have to do for them to say "Oh, I see your point! Israel is using excessive force!" ?

How many more innocent people will have to die at the hands of Israel for them to say that?

Over 400 innocent civilians killed. UN peace keepers killed. Civilian redcross AID trucks bombed. Precision my ***!
 
Precision my ***!

Oh, I don't know. They seem plenty precise to me.

MIDEAST_LEBANON_ISR_430474s.jpg

(Source, Aftenposten)

Can't say I'm to thrilled about what they choose to shoot at though.
 
Oh, I don't know. They seem plenty precise to me.

Can't say I'm to thrilled about what they choose to shoot at though.



Very true. That seems like a bullseye to me! Right in the middle of that redcross symbol!




You can't have it both ways. Either Israel is unprecise in their targeting of lebanon or they are actually targeting civilians and peacekeepers. Which one is it?

If they were precise we wouldn't see the death toll this high and we wouldn't see reports of clearly marked redcross trucks or UN peacekeepers being killed.

If they aren't targeting these people we also wouldn't see the death toll this high and we wouldn't see reports of clearly marked redcross trucks or UN peacekeepers being killed.
 
Surely this is only the case if the UN post is in a civilian area?

There was a radio report (which I haven't seen online) that UN obsrevers were complaining yesterday that Hez. has been setting up rocket attacks from next to the UN observation posts.

Not sure if it is true, but sounds plausible and fits in with Hez's methods -- any return fire against the launch point kills innocents nearby, and that becomes the main news item.
 
There was a radio report (which I haven't seen online) that UN obsrevers were complaining yesterday that Hez. has been setting up rocket attacks from next to the UN observation posts.

What a surprise. :rolleyes:
 

This comment makes sense if you take for granted both that Israel did it on purpose and that it was part of a greater scheme; the scheme in this case being to make the UN go away.

You see if an ethnic group were known for forming cabals and being particularly good at plots and conspiracies, then it would follow that a nation made primarily of that ethnic group would have an ulterior motive for every action; even actions that seem like accidents, could be attributed to incompetence, or could be the doings of one rogue officer. That’s just what they want you to think.
 
This comment makes sense if you take for granted both that Israel did it on purpose and that it was part of a greater scheme; the scheme in this case being to make the UN go away.

You see if an ethnic group were known for forming cabals and being particularly good at plots and conspiracies, then it would follow that a nation made primarily of that ethnic group would have an ulterior motive for every action; even actions that seem like accidents, could be attributed to incompetence, or could be the doings of one rogue officer. That’s just what they want you to think.
Umm, okay, I guess. I'm just finding it increasingly difficult to figure out what a_u_p's trying to say lately. More and more of his posts just seem to be random neural firings. Glad you're able to puzzle out what he's talking about.
 
There was a radio report (which I haven't seen online) that UN obsrevers were complaining yesterday that Hez. has been setting up rocket attacks from next to the UN observation posts.

That's not unlikely. Hezbollah has used similar tactics in the past, and it would explain why IDF attacked near the position. It does not, in my eyes, excuse the fact that IDF did not take the necessary precautions to prevent the Unifil position itself from being hit.
 
You can't have it both ways. Either Israel is unprecise in their targeting of lebanon or they are actually targeting civilians and peacekeepers. Which one is it?

No one has claimed that there are no errors.

Imprecise? You bet.
Indiscriminate? Hell no.
Can you tell the difference? I'm not betting on it.
 
Oh, I don't know. They seem plenty precise to me.

[qimg]http://cache.aftenposten.no/multimedia/archive/00430/MIDEAST_LEBANON_ISR_430474s.jpg[/qimg]
(Source, Aftenposten)

Can't say I'm to thrilled about what they choose to shoot at though.

I'm not any kind of expert on military weapons, but I wonder what kind of weapon would make damage that looks like that.

It looks like other than the big hole, that all the other holes come from a lot of different angles, and are many different sizes which suggests (to me) a lot of different side-arms of different calibers.

Maybe if there is someone who knows more about military weaponry that knows of a weapon that does this kind of damage?
 
That's not unlikely. Hezbollah has used similar tactics in the past, and it would explain why IDF attacked near the position. It does not, in my eyes, excuse the fact that IDF did not take the necessary precautions to prevent the Unifil position itself from being hit.

What "necessary precautions" should have been taken? A little detail would be appreciated.
 
Yes, and that's what's caused all the small holes you thought looked like small arms fire.


Those holes look like they're going into the ambulance. Would the rocket have exploded above the vehicle and not inside it?
 
Those holes look like they're going into the ambulance. Would the rocket have exploded above the vehicle and not inside it?

To my eyes several of the holes are cleary made from the inside out, although the photo is so blurry and JPEG compressed that for most of the holes it's difficult to see.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom