IAF Pin Point Bombing

From what I have seen so far, I cannot assess any blame on the IDF. Certainly if their intent was to kill civilians, they are doing a piss-poor job of it.

One could argue they're doing an even worse job of killing Hezbollah: "More than 380 Lebanese and 42 Israelis have died in nearly two weeks of conflict in Lebanon [...] Hezbollah said 27 of its fighters had been killed as of Monday, but the Israeli military said it had killed "some dozens"." (BBC News)
 
Israel chose it as a target, the BBC link in my sig says the UN post was under attack for a sustained period: 14 artillery attacks (causing the French general who commands Unifil to call Israel's military asking them to desist) and a heavy bomb which took out the bunker where they were hiding.

Human error... Move along.

No. Negligence is not human error.
(For either side -- that has to be said in every post)
 
Last edited:
An error.

Interview with UN representative, (transcript available tomorrow), this was not an error. There was an artillery bombardment aimed at the post for the best part of a day. The post is clearly marked, and well know, and prominent.

The arial bomb was what killed them. They were in regular contact with the outside, and there messages to stop the attack were passed on to the Isreali authorities.
 
Of course, Kofi Annan also said that "Mr. Nasrallah" will be a force for stability and peace in Lebanon. Annan also says that israel fighting against Palestinian terorrists is just a "cycle of violence".

If Annan says something about the middle east, there's about a 90% chance that it's inaccurate, and a 99.5% that it's against israel.

It's not just annan, and the evidence is available on the news reports. He is apparenlty commenting on the evidence passed on to him. To attack Annan is just a diversion.
 
"This coordinated artillery and aerial attack on a long-established and clearly marked U.N. post at Khiyam occurred despite personal assurances given to me by Prime Minister Ehud Olmert that U.N. positions would be spared Israeli fire," he said in a statement.
"Furthermore, General Alain Pelligrini, the U.N. force commander in south Lebanon, had been in repeated contact with Israeli officers throughout the day on Tuesday, stressing the need to protect that particular U.N. position from attack." (Full story)
The airstrike came as Israeli forces continued to battle Hezbollah militants in southern Lebanon, seeking to end the Islamic militia's rocket attacks on northern Israel.



http://edition.cnn.com/2006/WORLD/meast/07/26/mideast.main/index.html
 
Why were these UN people there?

I mean, what function were they supposed to serve? Everyone calls them "peacekeepers," but come on...

E.J. calls them "UN military observers." What does that mean?

"Look Tovar, there goes a Hezbollah rocket."
"I see it, Carlos. Hey, did you see that IAF air strike this morning?"
"No, but I think Parvit did, didn't you, Parvit?"
"Yes, I did. Oh, look, there goes an IDF tank column."
"Hm. Third one today. Tovar, the bet's up to you. You going to see it, or do you fold?"
"Fold? I have two jacks showing and you want me to fold?"

Annan took all the UN personnel out of Iraq when things got too rough there. Why are they in Lebanon, if their only purpose is to get shot at by accident?
 
Of course, Kofi Annan also said that "Mr. Nasrallah" will be a force for stability and peace in Lebanon. Annan also says that israel fighting against Palestinian terorrists is just a "cycle of violence".

If Annan says something about the middle east, there's about a 90% chance that it's inaccurate, and a 99.5% that it's against israel.

So, so true (that last line).
 
Human error... Move along.

No. Negligence is not human error.
(For either side -- that has to be said in every post)

Oh, it was probably a human error of some kind -- I can't see that Israel should have anything to gain by bombing a Unifil position. Of course, there are two types of human errors: excusable and inexcusable. Which one are we dealing with here, now that's the central question.
 
A pin point strike by the IAF on unarmed UN observers plus 14 other incidents? How can this be a mistake? And if isn't a mistake what is it?

See also: French embassy in Tripoli, April 14, 1986. These errors DO happen.
 
Well, that's one difference between a NATO-style force and useless blue helmets counting rockets. Another difference can be found just beneath the beltline.

Over the years, a large portion of the Unifil personell have been NATO soldiers.
 
Over the years, a large portion of the Unifil personell have been NATO soldiers.

BFD. Who do they take orders from? Whose rules of engagement? Who sets the mission objectives?

Soldiers from NATO countries != NATO mission. Not even close.
 
BFD. Who do they take orders from? Whose rules of engagement? Who sets the mission objectives?

Soldiers from NATO countries != NATO mission. Not even close.
Exactly! When Bob wears a blue hat he is a useless UN soldier hellbent on destroying the free world by getting killed by the good guys. However, when Bob goes home, has a few weeks off, and then comes back wearing a green hat, he is a freedom lovin', democracy spreadin' soldier of NATO. One would do good to learn the difference.
 
Exactly! When Bob wears a blue hat he is a useless UN soldier hellbent on destroying the free world by getting killed by the good guys. However, when Bob goes home, has a few weeks off, and then comes back wearing a green hat, he is a freedom lovin', democracy spreadin' soldier of NATO. One would do good to learn the difference.

Yes, it's the hat. Precisely. And the idea that they'd actually be armed. And a mandate to defend yourself and civilians with force if necessary. And sane rules of engagement. And reasonable provisions that actually allow a peace to be kept. And a staggering reduction in bureaucracy. And less infighting. And less corruption. And less nepotism...

Am I getting the point across here, or shall I carry on?

EDITED TO ADD: And of course less gang rape. Can't forget about the gang rape.
 
Last edited:

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom