Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

Hold the phone,...

I thought at the beginning of this thing Hulsey said he was going to ignore any and all previous work and start fresh. So why is there any comparison to NIST? Why is NIST mentioned at all?

Or am I missing something :o
 
Nobody seems to have made the obvious comment --- yet.

How come a University Professor is claiming to prove a negative?

AND

Showing ZERO respect for the "Scientific Method"?


It seems to be an endemic problem in academia - the need for publicity at any cost.

I really had little issue with much of what he said in his discussion of heat effects on steel. He later goes off the rails, especially in his conclusion that fire did not bring the structure down (more further down)

I also have little issue with his examining a single aspect of one of the several papers on the demise of the structure. Call it a peer review of that single isolated aspect. Perhaps now he will move on to the ARUP or Nordenson papers and the mode by which they describe fire bringing down the structure.

His declaration that fire did not bring down the WTC 7 is rather premature given that he has examined one aspect of collapse and in that, only one of several proposed mechanisms by which that one aspect occurred.
 
Where was the attempt to relate the observed building movements, damage, fires etc to their root causes?

Why would the examination of one node based on assumed energy inputs in isolation from the rest of the structure with much of it engorged in flames for a 7 hr period and having suffered structural damage from steel panels from 1wtc falling on it show conclusively that fire was not the cause of the collapse?

This character really revealed his confirmation bias and his real objective was a NIST hit job...

Is this the sort of investigation AE wants to see? Seems so!

Exactly. At best he has shown that in a pristine WTC 7 with only one compartment on fire, it would be unlikely that the girder would be moved far enough on it's seat on col79, due solely to beam and girder expansion, to fail. How much did the structure twist with the loss of the SW corner? Firefighters reported one elevator car out of it's shaft. That indicates core damage or at least movement. How much did fires on other floors, or the same fire earlier in other locations on the floors in question, twist or otherwise deform the structure? What of the other reports that call into the equation the action on the knife edge connections?, the movement of col 79 itself?

Hulsey has a bit more work to do before claiming, on the basis of examining the NIST scenario (which apparently is not to be considered 'previous" work on the issue), before declaring that fire did not cause WTC 7's demise.
 
ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!

All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.

There is no wiggle room.

Your admired spokesperson, Mr. SanderO, has often admitted to having very limited understanding of engineering but that does not stop him from dismissing those that do.

Regardless of where you stand on the issue of 9/11 conspiracies, if fire did not bring down WTC7, than the NIST recommendations for building safety are based on a false premise and are therefore meaningless.

It is far from the public interest to let WTC7's collapse remain a mystery.
 
Structural damage from debris strikes + sustained thermal damage from fire over seven hours + gravity = collapse.

Simple.

Steel_strength_in_fire.png
 
Last edited:
ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!

All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.

There is no wiggle room.

Your admired spokesperson, Mr. SanderO, has often admitted to having very limited understanding of engineering but that does not stop him from dismissing those that do.

Regardless of where you stand on the issue of 9/11 conspiracies, if fire did not bring down WTC7, than the NIST recommendations for building safety are based on a false premise and are therefore meaningless.

It is far from the public interest to let WTC7's collapse remain a mystery.

Let's see your fault tree or probability analysis that led to your determination of zero chance - including the probabilities you attach to each factor and your logic for each branch, and your estimates for the current states of each structural element of each building involved.
 
All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.

There is no wiggle room.

I'm not a structural engineer, but as a software engineer I'm somewhat familiar with the principles of logic, which Hulsey apparently is not. But then, neither is the target audience. It's not a cheap shot, but rather a demonstrable fact, to say that one characteristic of a "truther" is, ummm, underdeveloped reasoning skills.
 
ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!

All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.

There is no wiggle room.

Your admired spokesperson, Mr. SanderO, has often admitted to having very limited understanding of engineering but that does not stop him from dismissing those that do.

Regardless of where you stand on the issue of 9/11 conspiracies, if fire did not bring down WTC7, than the NIST recommendations for building safety are based on a false premise and are therefore meaningless.

It is far from the public interest to let WTC7's collapse remain a mystery.

Huckster fails because he limited the fluid dynamic of the fire to a simple on floor fire, not the more complex real event, that will show up when the paper is published on rolls of Charmin Toilet tissue. That's the only way this political motivated bull crap will be of use to any engineer.
 
I feel it might be constructive to revisit the beginning, the original press release regarding the objectives and intended methodology of the Hulsey Study:

Earlier this year, AE911Truth partnered with Dr. J. Leroy Hulsey, an engineering professor at the University of Alaska Fairbanks (UAF), to undertake a study, using Finite Element Modeling, of World Trade Center Building 7’s collapse. Dr. Hulsey is the chair of UAF’s Civil and Environmental Engineering Department and brings decades of experience in failure analysis and modeling of structures.

In May, Dr. Hulsey and his team of Ph.D. research assistants began a two-year process of virtually reconstructing WTC 7 — using the software programs SAP 2000 and Abaqus — and evaluating the range of possible causes of WTC 7’s collapse. By working in two separate programs, Dr. Hulsey and his team are able to crosscheck the results of the models against one another, thereby ensuring that they are error-free, accurate representations of WTC 7.

With the models now partly developed, Dr. Hulsey and his team have begun to analyze how the building responds to various conditions. Eventually they will examine the fire-based scenario put forward by NIST, which involves the thermal expansion of long-span beams near WTC 7’s column 79.

Based on his analysis, Dr. Hulsey will evaluate the probability of each hypothetical scenario being the cause of the collapse — and rule out scenarios that could not have resulted in collapse. Once the study is completed, Dr. Hulsey will submit his findings to major peer-reviewed engineering journals.

Transparency and Public Participation

Unlike NIST, which has refused to release all of its modeling data based on the untenable excuse that doing so “might jeopardize public safety,” UAF and AE911Truth will make this study completely open and transparent.

Soon, we will begin posting the process on the website WTC7Evaluation.org, where members of the architecture and engineering communities, as well as the general public, can follow and scrutinize the research as it is being conducted.

Today, we’re giving you a sneak peek by inviting you to be the first to watch the official WTC 7 Evaluation Introduction Video. This video will be featured at the top of the forthcoming website WTC7Evaluation.org to introduce visitors to Dr. Hulsey and the goals of the UAF study.

By making the study open and transparent throughout the entire process, we expect it to attract widespread attention from the engineering community and the broader public, while also enabling interested observers to provide input and feedback. To that end, we enthusiastically invite you to register to become a participant in the study. Dr. Hulsey and the review committee vetting his research greatly welcome your help.

This Is a Turning Point

We at AE911Truth believe the UAF study will be a turning point in how the destruction of WTC 7 is viewed — both within the engineering community and by the general public.
Not only will the UAF study add credible, cutting-edge research to the existing body of evidence and analysis regarding the destruction of WTC 7, it will also generate an unprecedented level of awareness and willingness to look seriously at how this building was destroyed. (Emphasis Added)

I have not watched the entire presentation yet but I am getting the impression that what we ended up with is a whole lot less than what we were told we would be getting.
 
ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!


Common sense, the laws of physics, Mr. Reality and the experts do not agree with you.


All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.


It is an accepted fact that fire, in conjunction with impact damage, brought down WTC 7 and there is nothing you say nor have you presented evidence to the contrary.


It is far from the public interest to let WTC7's collapse remain a mystery.


No mystery at all.


Did experts on the scene think WTC 7 was a controlled demolition?

"Several demolition teams had reached Ground Zero by 3:00 pm on 9/11, and these individuals witnessed the collapse of WTC 7 from within a few hundred feet of the event. We have spoken with several who possess extensive experience in explosive demolition, and all reported seeing or hearing nothing to indicate an explosive detonation precipitating the collapse.

As one eyewitness told us, "We were all standing around helpless...we knew full well it was going to collapse. Everyone there knew. You gotta remember there was a lot of confusion and we didn't know if another plane was coming...but I never heard explosions like demo charges.

https://sites.google.com/site/wtc7lies/didexpertsonthescenethinkwtc7resembledac


The Structural Engineering Community Rejects the Controlled-Demolition Conspiracy Theory

The structural engineering community rejects the controlled-demolition conspiracy theory. Its consensus is that the collapse of the World Trade Center buildings was a fire-induced, gravity-driven collapse, an explanation that does not involve the use of explosives.


Architects Shy From Truther 9/11 Conspiracy Theory

Architects didn't show up for a 9/11-architecture-conspiracy documentary screening—and the AIA doesn't want its name associated with Trutherism.

http://www.architectmagazine.com/design/architects-shy-from-trutherism_o
 
ZERO chance that the fires caused the collapse of WTC7!

All you non-engineers can continue projecting unfounded beliefs, but your arguments opposing Dr. Hulsey's findings will only land you with a fat zero on a test paper.


Let's take a closer look at Professor Hulsey and who will be supporting him.

University Of Alaska Fairbanks Professor Launches New 9/11 Research Project

Dr. J. Leroy Hulsey, of the University of Alaska Fairbanks, and two Ph.D. research assistants are partnering with the non-profit Architects and Engineers for 9/11 Truth for an engineering study known as “World Trade Center Building 7 Evaluation.” The researchers are using finite element modeling to evaluate the possible causes of World Trade Center Building 7’s collapse.

Ted Walter, Director of Strategy and Development for A&E 9/11 Truth, is in charge of working with the professor and raising money to fund the WTC7 Evaluation.


Raising money again??? Just to let you know that AE911Truth has been discredted and attacked by former workers due to that organization's questionable business practices and questionable handling of its donations
 
And for those of us who prefer the written word on grounds of ease of review and citation, is there any kind of written document we can study?

Video is great for those who want their audience to uncritically consume a pre-packaged narrative. Not so much for those who want their audience to examine the evidence and the argument for themselves and reach their own conclusions.

2 days later and still nothing new at http://www.wtc7evaluation.org/
 
2 days later and still nothing new at http://www.wtc7evaluation.org/

Okay...I downloaded all the research data from this website. The latest information is dated Nov. 24, 2015; almost 10 months ago. And unfortunately I cannot open any of the files (pdf, jpeg, tif, word, etc.), so much for transparency. I was hoping to get some of their SAP input files, so I can check their computer model. No such luck...

Let me know if anyone else has better luck. :boggled:
 
Raising money again??? Just to let you know that AE911Truth has been discredted and attacked by former workers due to that organization's questionable business practices and questionable handling of its donations

A point I have made earlier, all funding should go to and thru the University of Alaska Foundation, not AE 9/11 Truth. That a big red flag...
 
I'm curious, did anyone here attempt to register as a participant in the WTC7 Evaluation and if so, what was the result?
 
Okay...I downloaded all the research data from this website. The latest information is dated Nov. 24, 2015; almost 10 months ago. And unfortunately I cannot open any of the files (pdf, jpeg, tif, word, etc.), so much for transparency. I was hoping to get some of their SAP input files, so I can check their computer model. No such luck...

Let me know if anyone else has better luck. :boggled:

noooo, you must be doing something wrong. We were promised openness and transparency in every step. It is bigbadNIST that doesn't make available their data set.

Surely something later than Nov last year will be up and available reeeal soon.:rolleyes::cool:
 
noooo, you must be doing something wrong. We were promised openness and transparency in every step. It is bigbadNIST that doesn't make available their data set.

Surely something later than Nov last year will be up and available reeeal soon.:rolleyes::cool:

I am mostly interested to see who, if anyone who tried passed their vetting process - whatever that might be and whoever might be doing it.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom