Merged Hulsey presents research arguing WTC7 not brought down by fires/University of Alaska

The funny part about this "pamphlet" thing is none of the engineers they send it to will likely read it.

It's junk mail. When was the last time anyone actually looked at any of this crap we get everyday?
This morning.


For historic reasons I operate my own email server. So I am out there on the inter-webs without any ISP spam filtering. Need to check that my own spam filters are doing a good job.

ozrco43 had a string of identical spams get through to her mail box a few days back. Promising larger penis and longer erections or some such thing.

I suggested that she take up the offer and sue them when the product failed. My suggesting was not taken up. :mad:
 
...
ozrco43 had a string of identical spams get through to her mail box a few days back. Promising larger penis and longer erections or some such thing.

I suggested that she take up the offer and sue them when the product failed. My suggesting was not taken up. :mad:

Send me AU$ 111.11, and I promise to double length, girth and number of your wife's penises. And teach all of them to chisel Sumerian cuneiform script.
:D
 
​
Your opinion about CD detonations is refuted by eyewitnesses...


Let's take a look to see if you are correct.


An interview with explosives expert Brent Blanchard

Undicisettembre: What do you think about World Trade Center 7? Was its collapse a controlled demolition, in your opinion?

Brent Blanchard: No. Absolutely not. I know people who were on the site and they told me first hand they knew the building was about to collapse.

http://undicisettembre.blogspot.com/2014/10/an-interview-with-explosive-expert.html

That's Strike 1.


...and recordings.


Then, you should have no problem pointing out to us, the time line where CD explosions are heard in the following video.


WTC 7 Collapse Video

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LD06SAf0p9A


No explosions evident in that video, so that's Strike 2.


I have yet to see usable seismic data supporting either side of that argument.


Let's take a look here.


9/11 Seismic Recordings

Brent Blanchard devotes section 4 of his paper to the issue of seismic recordings on 9/11. Blanchard is Senior Editor of ImplosionWorld, a website which posts details of explosive demolitions, and also Director of Field Operations at Protec Documentation Services, Inc. Protec works in the field of vibration monitoring and structure inspection, a key service to both the construction and demolition industries.

The field seismographs used by Protec and others provide the key scientific evidence for disturbances that may have caused damage, and there were a number of such seismographs operated by Protec on 9/11 in the vicinity of Ground Zero, for monitoring construction sites. Blanchard tells us that data from these machines, and seismographs operated elsewhere, all confirm single vibration events recording the collapse. None of them record the tell-tale 'spikes' that would indicate explosive detonations prior to collapse.

This evidence makes a compelling argument against explosive demolition.


Seismographs at Columbia University's Lamont-Doherty Earth Observatory

"There is no scientific basis for the conclusion that explosions brought down the towers," Lerner-Lam tells PM. "That representation of our work is categorically incorrect and not in context."

http://www.911myths.com/html/seismic_record.html


That's Strike 3 and you know what that means.

.
Beyond audibility evaluations, the NIST never performed a forensic analysis on WTC7. Their focus was structural engineering.


Why waste time and money checking for something for which no evidence existed on video, audio, seismic data or within the WTC rubble?


If WTC7 south side damage was as low, deep, and extensive as you promote, global building collapse should have highly favoured a southward topple through the most weakened part of the structure.


That is EXACTLY what happened in the final seconds as WTC 7 collapsed and you can see the southward tilt of WTC 7 in the following video from time line 0:12 to 0:15.



WTC 7 Southern Tilt Collapse


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Mamvq7LWqRU


The heavy east penthouse folded inward at its middle indicating a straight down collapse pattern.


The east side of the Penthouse collapsed first and then the western section, and it's all on video as well.


A covert CD is designed in a way that maximizes the amount of flying debris but minimizes sound carry and hard surface reflection.


You are kidding me, right?!

Just to let you know that the detonation of explosives make a lot of noise that can be heard many miles away and I know that from experience.
 
Last edited:
​
NIST FAQ:“The analyses of the video (both the estimation of the instant the roofline began to descend [GLOBAL COLLAPSE INITIATION] and the calculated velocity and acceleration of a point on the roofline) revealed three distinct stages characterizing the 5.4 seconds of collapse."

Stage 2 was the most revealing.

Tony was referring to this 2.25 seconds from the video record of WTC7's global collapse.

NIST FAQ:"Stage 2 (1.75 to 4.0 seconds): gravitational acceleration (free fall)"


Nothing to do with explosives, especially since WTC 7 was gutted on its south wall and its steel structure exposed to the effects of fire for hours as its steel structure struggled to redistributed structural loads until it had nothing left.

Now, let's take a look at this video and tell us, how long it took for WTC 7 to collapse?


WTC 7 Collapse Time

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=yrIBOTfRFXo
 
Last edited:
Fine.
After losing the debate about certain third-party analyses of the WTC7 collapse, you resort to the old old Twoofer mantras (yes, Twoofer, to point out my opinion that the entire "movement" believes in nothing but woo):
  • "Freefall" you ought to know that "freefall" is neither a sufficient nor a necessary condition to prove CD or disprove fire-induced collapse - it is an irrelevant, colateral circumstance.
  • None of you Twoofers have shown that the "symmetry" you allude to - the claimed simultaneousness of the descent of the various parts of the outer skin - actually exists, and is indicative of any particular collapse initiation mechanism. Now, you are one of the few Twoofers who have understood that the collapse, obviously, originated "somewhere" in the core (you must know, but can't make yourself admit that this can be, almost trivially, be localized to the neighborhood of column 79), and that any demolition devices on the periphery were not nexessary nor present nor even possible, and certainly without any evidence whatsoever. So with a collapse obviously, and agreed by you, originating in the core, why should the periphery collapse "symmetrically" in the first place - if not, in appearance, by pure and simple and meaningless chance?

I should have copy written that word (Twoofer). I would be rich now.
Think how many times it has been used since I first posted in 2005?

Also think of this, Banzant limited case, stated as limited case.

Szambboti Limited case, stated as physical proof, and fact.

Oh the hypocrisy in that.
 
​

NIST FAQ:“The analyses of the video (both the estimation of the instant the roofline began to descend [GLOBAL COLLAPSE INITIATION] and the calculated velocity and acceleration of a point on the roofline) revealed three distinct stages characterizing the 5.4 seconds of collapse."

Here we go again. You really should read all of NCSTAR 1-9 (or at least the sections dealing with the collapse.) I previously posted the timeline of the collapse published in NCSTAR 1-9. I can't remember whether it was in response to something that you wrote, or something FF wrote. Reposted at the bottom.

Your opinion about CD detonations is refuted by eyewitnesses and recordings.

Tell us what you think is the most persuasive, and provide a link, please.

Beyond audibility evaluations, the NIST never performed a forensic analysis on WTC7. Their focus was structural engineering.

A structural engineering analysis of structural failure IS forensic analysis. :rolleyes:

If WTC7 south side damage was as low, deep, and extensive as you promote, global building collapse should have highly favoured a southward topple through the most weakened part of the structure.

It did lean south.


The heavy east penthouse folded inward at its middle indicating a straight down collapse pattern.

What it indicated was that the support columns underneath it had failed, which were of course positioned under its middle. It also pitched to the north, indicating that column 79 was the first column to fail.

An east to west failure should have created an east to west collapse pattern.

Which is what happened. Watch the iconic video and read NCSTAR 1-9, Table 5-3.

The biggest problem with arguing against CD, and the NIST engineering staff proved this over 7+ years, is that nothing else makes any scientific sense.

Sez who?

A covert CD is designed in a way that maximizes the amount of flying debris but minimizes sound carry and hard surface reflection.

What's the most famous case of a covert CD that was uncovered that you could compare to the collapse of any of the WTC buildings? Surely, it must be a famous case! Or was this "the first time in history" for a surreptitious demolition? :rolleyes:
 

Attachments

  • NCSTAR 1-9 Table 5-3.jpg
    NCSTAR 1-9 Table 5-3.jpg
    32 KB · Views: 6
The same could be asked of the government. The NIST theory has been shown to be incoherent. This is why a new investigation is necessary - to get a coherent theory.

This is not a job for private citizens who have no subpoena authority or resources to do a comprehensive investigation and anyone who would expect individuals to do that exposes themselves as a disingenuous fraud.

What use of subpoena power did NIST make use of in order to prepare it's structural response reports?

How did subpoena power figure into the Nordenson or ARUP studies? How much did they cost?
Now tell us again that only an entity with subpoena power and very deep pockets can produce a technical report.
 
I Support A "New Investigation" with subpoena powers.

With T Szamboti, D Chandler, R Gage as witnesses called under oath and subjected to cross examination.

It would NOT be a pretty sight. Or a comfortable experience for those witnesses.

As always I recommend that folks read the transcript of the cross-exam of Michael Behe who was witness for the creationists and chose to lie for his version of God in Kitzmiller v Dover.

Not a pretty sight.

So that is why I support a "New Investigation" ;)
 
I Support A "New Investigation" with subpoena powers.

With T Szamboti, D Chandler, R Gage as witnesses called under oath and subjected to cross examination.

It would NOT be a pretty sight. Or a comfortable experience for those witnesses.

As always I recommend that folks read the transcript of the cross-exam of Michael Behe who was witness for the creationists and chose to lie for his version of God in Kitzmiller v Dover.

Not a pretty sight.

So that is why I support a "New Investigation" ;)

Get talking about the impossibility of Noah's flood with a creationist and they might well tell you about the (very real) evidence for an ancient, massive flood event at the entrance to The Black Sea. But that deluge's depth would have been measured in metres, not kilometres as in the case of Noah's flood.

But it comforts them to say such things, just as it comforts Criteria and others to mention witnesses to 'explosions' prior to WTC7's collapse when what's being described is on a par with the Black Sea flood.

People will talk any old crap to protect their pet delusions.
 
Get talking about the impossibility of Noah's flood with a creationist and they might well tell you about the (very real) evidence for an ancient, massive flood event at the entrance to The Black Sea. But that deluge's depth would have been measured in metres, not kilometres as in the case of Noah's flood.

But it comforts them to say such things, just as it comforts Criteria and others to mention witnesses to 'explosions' prior to WTC7's collapse when what's being described is on a par with the Black Sea flood.

People will talk any old crap to protect their pet delusions.
I think you may know that I served my apprenticeship moderating on the Richard Dawkins Forum.

The analogy "Creationists v evolutionary biologists" to "truthers v debunkers" is exact IMNSHO.

And the truthers who ask for a New Investigation with para-judicial powers are deluding themselves. NONE of the debating tricks they play on forums would last minutes in the face of competent cross-examination.

So "Bring it on!!" :)
 
It also explains why they studiously avoid doing a damn thing to make it happen.
 
Get talking about the impossibility of Noah's flood with a creationist and....
...and my real life career was managing some of the larger dams - including one which had (at that time - since fixed) massive flood risk. Where failure could have flooded a large proportion of the lower cost housing of the western outskirts of Sydney. (it is a landlocked flood plain with limited exits to the ocean.)

So I never had much of a problem switching from explaining WTC collapses to truthers to then explain floods to creationists. Same CT mindset. Different details in the topic technology. Same "faith based reasoning" if you excuse the oxymoron ;)

It also explains why they studiously avoid doing a damn thing to make it happen.
:thumbsup:
 
I would like to see Cole, and Harret testifying under oath as well.

Who else would you like to see testifying under oath?
 
I would like to see Cole, and Harret testifying under oath as well.

Who else would you like to see testifying under oath?

Farrer, Basile - for they will answer truthfully when pressed.

Then confront SE Jones and Harrit with their testimony.

And then Kevin Ryan.


ETA - Splitt off to new thread?
 
Farrer, Basile - for they will answer truthfully when pressed.

Then confront SE Jones and Harrit with their testimony.

And then Kevin Ryan.


ETA - Splitt off to new thread?

That's a great Idea, splitt this to a new thread, and people can help come up with a list of
Witnesses that could be called under oath in a new investigation.
 
Is this your enemies list?

That is the list of 9/11 truth loons. Idiots on 9/11, who fool gullible people.

15 years and 9/11 truth loons have nothing but BS. People with critical thinking skills are able to figure out 9/11 in days or weeks.

Hulsey appears to be another loon, he uses standard 9/11 truth tag lines; which are used to fool those who can't do science, those void of critical thinking skills.
 

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom