How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
That's what I think, too, but a friend of mine says that, since "humans are not rational agents", they don't actually think that way. :boggled:

You can't do economics unless you assume people behave rationally (at least in financial matters).
 
Ok now I'm completely lost.

Because you said the feds might have an issue with a shopkeeper refusing to accept money (federal reserve notes). I believe Random thinks (correctly), you would only believe that because money has printed on it:
"this note is legal tender for all debts, public and private"

Which still doesn't mean merchants have to accept your money. Try calling the feds next time you want to use a $100 bill and the cashier won't take it.
 
"this note is legal tender for all debts, public and private"

Which still doesn't mean merchants have to accept your money. Try calling the feds next time you want to use a $100 bill and the cashier won't take it.

Does that mean that a merchant can refuse to accept any legal tender and instead only accept goats as a currency ?
 
Does that mean that a merchant can refuse to accept any legal tender and instead only accept goats as a currency ?

US federal law states that an individual or business may refuse certain forms of payment unless there is a State law prohibiting it. This means that vending machines do not have to accept pennies, the pizza delivery guy does not have to accept bills over $50, and yes, a merchant can choose to only accept goats as currency.

But there are some people who refuse to accept that and try to buy a car with a truck full of pennies, or buy a stick of gum with a thousand dollar bill and point to the "good for all debts public and private" written on the bill as justification. They then become quite indignant that the merchant is violating the law, even though no such law exists, and demand the courts intervene. That's what I thought you were referring to.
 
Rationally, based on their preferences and the information they have. Which is quite different from just "rationally".

A rational person would act based on their preferences and the information they have anyway, so I don't think you need to qualify it any further.

Except Belz is also right: if people are predictably irrational (and we are), economists need to know that also.
 
A rational person would act based on their preferences and the information they have anyway, so I don't think you need to qualify it any further.

I just thought I´d be precise, because some people here - not you - are very enthusiastic about intentionally "misunderstanding" what those they disagree with say.

Except Belz is also right: if people are predictably irrational (and we are), economists need to know that also.

I´m not so sure they are actually irrational - it´s more like their preferences and/or the information they have differ from what we think.

A guy playing the slot machines in Vegas is likely to lose money. However if his preferences place some value on the thrill of playing slot machines, he may well be coming out ahead all things considered - or he may be misinformed and expect to win money in the long run.
 
US federal law states that an individual or business may refuse certain forms of payment unless there is a State law prohibiting it. This means that vending machines do not have to accept pennies, the pizza delivery guy does not have to accept bills over $50, and yes, a merchant can choose to only accept goats as currency.

But there are some people who refuse to accept that and try to buy a car with a truck full of pennies, or buy a stick of gum with a thousand dollar bill and point to the "good for all debts public and private" written on the bill as justification. They then become quite indignant that the merchant is violating the law, even though no such law exists, and demand the courts intervene. That's what I thought you were referring to.

Well, thanks for clearing that up.
 
I just thought I´d be precise, because some people here - not you - are very enthusiastic about intentionally "misunderstanding" what those they disagree with say.



I´m not so sure they are actually irrational - it´s more like their preferences and/or the information they have differ from what we think.

A guy playing the slot machines in Vegas is likely to lose money. However if his preferences place some value on the thrill of playing slot machines, he may well be coming out ahead all things considered - or he may be misinformed and expect to win money in the long run.

I'm thinking more about how many people fall for the Gambler's Fallacy, all the different ways we fall prey to manipulations (check out the science behind a grocery store layout for example), that kind of thing.
 
Wow, back around July/Aug '11 I mined for a few hours or so for fun, mined a few bitcoin cents, and after reading this thread figured it wasn't worth it.

Boy do I regret that now that one bitcoin cent is $1.61 USD. :D
 
Wow, back around July/Aug '11 I mined for a few hours or so for fun, mined a few bitcoin cents, and after reading this thread figured it wasn't worth it.

Boy do I regret that now that one bitcoin cent is $1.61 USD. :D

The problem is that it might not be representative of the value of bitcoins in the far or near future. Things could go sour in a day or so because of some hacked transaction again, or because the founding fathers of BTC decide to cash in on their investment, etc. Assuming it isn't a scam and that the thing can work, I could only recommend waiting for the thing to stabilise before 'investing'.
 
The problem is that it might not be representative of the value of bitcoins in the far or near future. Things could go sour in a day or so because of some hacked transaction again, or because the founding fathers of BTC decide to cash in on their investment, etc. Assuming it isn't a scam and that the thing can work, I could only recommend waiting for the thing to stabilise before 'investing'.

Very true, that you never know, and I probably would have ended up cashing out when it hit $40. On the other hand, people have been saying it's about to crash for two years now ;).
If it does crash at this point, I don't think it would crash completely, though. Bitcoin is an easy (and cheap) way of exchanging foreign money, is useful for people in groups like Anonymous to be able to compensate each other without "doxing" themselves, and anyone who'd rather pay or donate to things anonymously (including drug/contraband sales).
Privacy is kind of a "hot" concern on the internet these days, with people concerned about Google, Patriot Act, Facebook, etc.

And just to clarify, when I said "after reading this thread" in my last post I didn't mean that as blaming anyone other than myself ;).
 
If I go down to the store with my car and say, "This metal box on wheels can take me places faster than I can go on my own two feet", and the shopkeeper says "No it can't", I can still drive away faster than I can run. What the shopkeeper believes is irrelevant.
And if people in my country or community say that money makes thinks work easier, we can still use it even if you disagree, and we will outperform your barter-based society. People who use money between them benefit. Those who are delusional or claim it isn't will have a much lower quality of life. This example takes the exact form of what you're trying to say about cars.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom