How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
One day we will have awesome slave robots who DO OUR BIDDING!

I'll be dead by then though.....
 
I'm not talking about gold..... I'm talking about paper currency. Gold has inherent value (though I'm not a gold bug as it presents the problem of imminent stabilization and zero growth eventually).

I just find the concept of currency and growth as interesting and precarious due to speculation ....
I addressed this in the post where I said that paper currencies are backed by governments who force us by law to honor the currency and pay our taxes with it.

(note: I am not endorsing this idea, just pointing out that that is why we can use the paper currency, rather than it being due to opinion or trend.)

By the way, in regards to zero growth...you know that when there's more goods than there is money, the goods just become cheaper, right? You don't necessarily need to increase the money supply as the number of available products grows. In fact, one of the necessary characteristics for a useful form of money is that it be easily divisible into equally valuable parts. That's also why Bitcoins can be divided into millionths of a coin.
 
Last edited:
bitcoin is going to crash and burn so hard, some people are going to make a bundle while others are left holding the bag, Just like that last person left to turn off the lights at Amway
 
I'm not talking about gold..... I'm talking about paper currency. Gold has inherent value (though I'm not a gold bug as it presents the problem of imminent stabilization and zero growth eventually).
Can you explain this concept of "inherent value" to me? AFAIK something is only worth what it could be traded for.

bitcoin is going to crash and burn so hard, some people are going to make a bundle while others are left holding the bag, Just like that last person left to turn off the lights at Amway
I sounds like you could make a fortune by shorting bitcoins then. Are you game?
 
Peter Schiff is big on that concept of "inherent value" (or "intrinsic value") also, which is one area where I think he's wrong. He claims that the gold represents the effort it takes to mine it. That is true, however, that doesn't make gold valuable. Something is only valuable if it can be used for something, not because it took effort to acquire. For example, I could drive my car all around the country, and after weeks and thousands of dollars, try to sell my tires for a fortune. It took a ton of effort, but in all likelihood no one will care.

The value comes from usefulness, and gold's value comes from it being useful as money. That's why Bitcoins are useful also. The mining requirement doesn't give it intrinsic or inherent value (I may have mis-stated this several years ago in this thread btw, I've since understood the issue better), the mining requirement gives it scarcity, which is one of several properties that makes it useful as money. That is why gold (and also other precious metals like silver, and Bitcoins) have real, reliable value in our society.
 
By the way, in the process of looking for my own post about Bitcoin mining to see if I mis-stated it, I've come across some truly amusing ones.

Post #262 in this thread is exquisitely awful in its combination of ignorance and rudeness.
 
Whether backed by detergent, faith in politicians, shiny yellow rocks, or obscure mathematical formulas, money is only worth what other people believe it is worth. It’s all fiat currency. Once you realize that, you can move on with your life.
 
BTW, I skipped over StankApe's first comment, where he says that earning more money is not economic growth.

This is actually true, and I don't know if he intended this, but this demonstrates exactly why printing money does not actually create wealth or improve the economy. You must create more and better products and services. As technology improves and production becomes more understood and more efficient, and the market continues to function to reward that improvement and encourage innovation, THAT is where the improvement in our quality of life (and our economy) is generated.

In fact, debasing money leads to mal-investment and corruption, taking capital out of productive and innovative hands and destroying it. This of course reduces the quality of life for those who aren't privileged enough to get the new money, or to get it at the same terms as the insiders.
 
Can you explain this concept of "inherent value" to me? AFAIK something is only worth what it could be traded for.

I sounds like you could make a fortune by shorting bitcoins then. Are you game?

I mean it has a function, it's a conductor, people use it to make jewelry....etc

If I had any money I'd be thinking about doing that very thing. Bitcoin has 'bubble gonna 'splode" written all over it.
 
Whether backed by detergent, faith in politicians, shiny yellow rocks, or obscure mathematical formulas, money is only worth what other people believe it is worth. It’s all fiat currency. Once you realize that, you can move on with your life.
This is completely untrue. Please see this post.
 
I'm not talking about gold..... I'm talking about paper currency. Gold has inherent value (though I'm not a gold bug as it presents the problem of imminent stabilization and zero growth eventually).
You said "Money only has value if you think it does."

That is completely untrue and neither government paper money nor gold nor bitcoins draw their value from people "thinking it's valuable." I explained where the value of all those forms of money came from, please read the post.
 
This is completely untrue. Please see this post.

If your pre-industrial society has decided to have money, than gold is a pretty good choice for all of the reasons that you have mentioned. But if you have decided to have money, you have jumped down the rabbit hole already.

Money is the most spectacularly useful lie in the history of civilization, an item whose sole purpose is to be traded for other items. A lie that is so successful that pretty much everyone goes along with it, even people who will freely admit that it is a lie. It has enabled capitalism to thrive around the world and allowed people with completely mismatched skills, needs and wants to profitably trade with each other. But it’s still a lie.

If no one wants to trade with you for your gold coin for whatever reason, your gold coin will be worthless (unless you want to electroplate something). The pressures that may change the amount of goods a gold coin can buy are different than the pressures that would affect the purchasing power of government backed currency, but the basic lie behind both (and bitcoin as well for that matter) is the same.

Now modern society needs money, but modern society is a construct as well… which takes you into a much deeper swamp of thought.

Short version: Gold is a very useful form of currency, but the idea of currency itself only has the value we assign to it.
 
If your pre-industrial society has decided to have money, than gold is a pretty good choice for all of the reasons that you have mentioned. But if you have decided to have money, you have jumped down the rabbit hole already.

Money is the most spectacularly useful lie in the history of civilization, an item whose sole purpose is to be traded for other items. A lie that is so successful that pretty much everyone goes along with it, even people who will freely admit that it is a lie. It has enabled capitalism to thrive around the world and allowed people with completely mismatched skills, needs and wants to profitably trade with each other. But it’s still a lie.

Sorry, how is it a lie if it works ? Because it has not inherent value ? Well, nothing else does, either. Maybe you're just being hyperbolic.
 
Sorry, how is it a lie if it works ? Because it has not inherent value ? Well, nothing else does, either. Maybe you're just being hyperbolic.

People have been telling themselves the lie for so long it has become the truth. It is kinda awesome if you think about it.
 
Sorry, how is it a lie if it works ? Because it has not inherent value ? Well, nothing else does, either. Maybe you're just being hyperbolic.

Nope - his comments are true; money is in fact an emergent property of society. So it does exist but what actually exists is not the lie/fiction that we bandy about i.e. currency itself has some magical intrinsic innate value.
 
Nope - his comments are true; money is in fact an emergent property of society. So it does exist but what actually exists is not the lie/fiction that we bandy about i.e. currency itself has some magical intrinsic innate value.

Yeah sure but who says it has any inherent value ?

Come to think of it, goats and couches also have no intrinsic value. Again, I don't think it's quite right to call it a lie. It's a system.
 
"Lie" isn't really the right word, except in a very figurative way. Like parking lots are a lie, because a car could theoretically be parked anywhere, and crimes are a lie, because they're just things outlawed by government. National borders are a lie, the lines drawn between breeds of dog are a lie, etc. etc.
I wouldn't consider something a "lie," just because it's a human construct.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom