How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
"Lie" isn't really the right word, except in a very figurative way. Like parking lots are a lie, because a car could theoretically be parked anywhere, and crimes are a lie, because they're just things outlawed by government. National borders are a lie, the lines drawn between breeds of dog are a lie, etc. etc.
I wouldn't consider something a "lie," just because it's a human construct.

Money is not just any old lie like crimes or justice or parking lots. Money is a self-effecting lie. If we all lie about a $1 bill being able to buy X amount of goods and services, suddenly, it's not a lie anymore. That $1 bill is exchangeable for X amount of goods and services. As soon as we believe the lie, it becomes objectively true. Our belief that money has value is what gives it its value, and that money's value reinforces our belief in it. It is almost beautiful in it's paradoxical nature.

Of course, once people stop believing in it, it falls apart fast. As I write this, two 100,000 Mark notes from 1923 Germany are selling on E-Bay for less than a Whopper value meal, and nobody is buying.
 
Nope - his comments are true; money is in fact an emergent property of society. So it does exist but what actually exists is not the lie/fiction that we bandy about i.e. currency itself has some magical intrinsic innate value.
I disagree. There is no substance called "money". It is just an abstract concept (like a corporation) which people use to assign relative values to things (there is no such thing as inherent value since if there are no people there is no value).

Since money does not exist, it has to be represented through the use of tokens. This could take the form of a commodity like gold (or bitcoins) or some popular product like tobacco or alcohol. It could also be represented through an accounting method like a bank account or IOU. The main criteria for a token is that it should not be readily manufacturable without giving up something of "value" for it.
 
Last edited:
Bitcoins are very interesting but I can't stand bitcoin evangelists who think they are always right. Any criticism is meet with an insult about how the person making the criticism knows nothing about currency or money markets.

I just read an interesting article on Medium about bitcoins and here are a few bits we can discuss:
If millions of people started using bitcoins on a regular basis, the soaring value of bitcoins would actually be disastrous. You’ve heard of hyperinflation: this would be hyperdeflation. Take a gold bar valued at $600,000. At $60 per bitcoin, the value of that bar is 10,000 BTC. But then assume that bitcoins rise in value to $600 apiece, and then to $6,000, and then to $60,000 — as would have to happen if the fixed number of bitcoins was being used to store hundreds of billions of dollars in value. Then the value of the gold bar would plunge, in bitcoin terms — to 1,000 BTC and then 100 BTC and finally just 10 BTC. The same thing would happen to all other goods and services in the world, including your own salary. Everything would be constantly going down in price, if you thought in bitcoin terms.

Inflation is bad, but deflation is worse. The reason is that in a deflationary environment, no one spends money — because whatever you want to buy is sure to become cheaper in a few days or weeks. People hoard their cash, and spend it only begrudgingly, on absolute necessities. And they certainly don’t spend it on hiring people — no matter how productive their employees might be, they’d still be better off just holding on to that money and not paying anybody anything.

The result is an economy which would simply grind to a halt, with massive unemployment and almost no economic activity. In a word, it would be a Depression. In order to have economic growth, you need monetary growth as well — and that’s something which is impossible to achieve in a bitcoin-based system. Currencies such as the dollar, with a central bank which can print money at will, have succeeded for a reason. As economies grow, the money supply has to be able to grow with them. And that’s why bitcoin can never really succeed over the long term....

...It’s because we place so much trust in banks, after all, that they are forced to take on a great deal of responsibility. Banks and central banks are given an important job to do, are regulated and scrutinized, and can be held responsible for their actions. The population of the entire country, as represented by the government, stands behind bank deposits and promises to honor them even if the bank goes bust. Money, in other words, is a key ingredient in the glue which keeps the social compact together. (What we’re seeing in Cyprus is in large part a demonstration of what happens when that compact starts becoming unglued.)

Bitcoin, in that sense, is anti democratic. It’s based on mistrust rather than trust, it refuses to take any responsibility onto itself – indeed, it doesn’t even have a self to take responsibility onto. It’s nihilistic, and an attractive alternative only to things which are downright bad.
 
Last edited:
Bitcoins are very interesting but I can't stand bitcoin evangelists who think they are always right. Any criticism is meet with an insult about how the person making the criticism knows nothing about currency or money markets.

I just read an interesting article on Medium about bitcoins and here are a few bits we can discuss:
The deflationary aspect of bitcoin has been discussed at length in this thread (this is a looong thread). For that reason, bitcoin won't replace other currencies.

However, (regardless of your article's criticism of those who mistrust banks and governments), the bitcoin algorithm could result in a currency that is suitable for bypassing banks.

As recently as post #1582 I pointed out:
I suspect that if the technology continues to prove to be tamper resistant, a bit-currency will evolve that overcomes these limitations. In order to make banks redundant for money transfers, bit currency would need two features:
- perpetual growth (say 2% - 3% per year)
- some form of lottery to replace the mining algorithm.
Of course, governments could use the same algorithm for national currencies (if the banks don't object).
 
Last edited:
If your pre-industrial society has decided to have money, than gold is a pretty good choice for all of the reasons that you have mentioned. But if you have decided to have money, you have jumped down the rabbit hole already.

Money is the most spectacularly useful lie in the history of civilization, an item whose sole purpose is to be traded for other items. A lie that is so successful that pretty much everyone goes along with it, even people who will freely admit that it is a lie. It has enabled capitalism to thrive around the world and allowed people with completely mismatched skills, needs and wants to profitably trade with each other. But it’s still a lie.

If no one wants to trade with you for your gold coin for whatever reason, your gold coin will be worthless (unless you want to electroplate something). The pressures that may change the amount of goods a gold coin can buy are different than the pressures that would affect the purchasing power of government backed currency, but the basic lie behind both (and bitcoin as well for that matter) is the same.

Now modern society needs money, but modern society is a construct as well… which takes you into a much deeper swamp of thought.

Short version: Gold is a very useful form of currency, but the idea of currency itself only has the value we assign to it.
"Cars are the most spectacularly useful lie in modern civilization. An item whose sole purpose is to take you somewhere you could walk on your own two feet."

Maybe if you view this statement and compare it to your own, you'll realize that value can and does come from making something easier and faster to do. Cars take you places where you could walk, but CARS DO IT FASTER and let you carry large amounts of things as you go. Because of this, a society that has cars (or other automobiles) will be so much more efficient in nearly everything it does then a society without them that the car society will greatly outperform the society of people who walk, or pretend that cars have no value. Thus, it doesn't matter if some delusion person tries to turn their back on it, cars have value. Period.

The same is true of money. It allows you to trade for items that you could acquire through bartering, but money lets you do it MUCH FASTER and more conveniently. Because of this, a society or group of people that uses money will greatly outperform the society or person who pretends money has no value. It doesn't matter if some random person or persons is delusional about it or tries to turn their back on it, money has value. Period.

I hope you actually read this.
 
Last edited:
:confused: The post you link to supports Random's comments.
:confused:

Value comes from being useful for a purpose. If you need to breathe and you're underwater, a scuba suit and tank would be a valuable thing to you. It's not fictional or a lie, it would improve your quality of life, in this case allowing you to not die.

Our modern society needs money. The purpose it serves, the difference in convenience it offers over a barter system, is not fictional or a lie. It actually improves our quality of life.

I have no clue how this could be unclear.
 
Nope - his comments are true; money is in fact an emergent property of society. So it does exist but what actually exists is not the lie/fiction that we bandy about i.e. currency itself has some magical intrinsic innate value.
My post on the value of money has nothing to do with it having "magic intrinsic value," and in fact, I took the time to clarify exactly that yesterday in post 1645...and I will now copy/paste that as well.

"Peter Schiff is big on that concept of "inherent value" (or "intrinsic value") also, which is one area where I think he's wrong. He claims that the gold represents the effort it takes to mine it. That is true, however, that doesn't make gold valuable. Something is only valuable if it can be used for something, not because it took effort to acquire. For example, I could drive my car all around the country, and after weeks and thousands of dollars, try to sell my tires for a fortune. It took a ton of effort, but in all likelihood no one will care.

The value comes from usefulness, and gold's value comes from it being useful as money. That's why Bitcoins are useful also. The mining requirement doesn't give it intrinsic or inherent value (I may have mis-stated this several years ago in this thread btw, I've since understood the issue better), the mining requirement gives it scarcity, which is one of several properties that makes it useful as money. That is why gold (and also other precious metals like silver, and Bitcoins) have real, reliable value in our society."
 
Bitcoins are very interesting but I can't stand bitcoin evangelists who think they are always right. Any criticism is meet with an insult about how the person making the criticism knows nothing about currency or money markets.
Don't be so quick to dismiss or distort other people's actions as being unreasonable. It may very well be that your behavior plays a role in the way people react to you, and in fact I'd estimate that in 90% of cases in life, that is true. The people you're speaking to may very well be frustrated or angered by people who approach them without knowing basic things about the topic, as I've observed that and it's very, very, very common when having open discussions on Bitcoin and economics.

It always helps to ask questions or do some reading before you make declarative statements about something. I've read and studied a lot about fundamental economics and Bitcoin itself...and even did a radio feature story on it last year...and I've said things that weren't 100% correct about it as recently as a conversation yesterday. I even said things originally in this thread that I realized now, several years later, weren't totally accurate and have pointed out. If you aren't doing the same, perhaps you can imagine how many errors you may also have committed without having nearly the same amount of interest in Bitcoin as I have had.
 
"Cars are the most spectacularly useful lie in modern civilization. An item whose sole purpose is to take you somewhere you could walk on your own two feet."

Maybe if you view this statement and compare it to your own, you'll realize that value can and does come from making something easier and faster to do. Cars take you places where you could walk, but CARS DO IT FASTER and let you carry large amounts of things as you go. Because of this, a society that has cars (or other automobiles) will be so much more efficient in nearly everything it does then a society without them that the car society will greatly outperform the society of people who walk, or pretend that cars have no value. Thus, it doesn't matter if some delusion person tries to turn their back on it, cars have value. Period.

The same is true of money. It allows you to trade for items that you could acquire through bartering, but money lets you do it MUCH FASTER and more conveniently. Because of this, a society or group of people that uses money will greatly outperform the society or person who pretends money has no value. It doesn't matter if some random person or persons is delusional about it or tries to turn their back on it, money has value. Period.

I hope you actually read this.

If I go down to the store with my car and say, "This metal box on wheels can take me places faster than I can go on my own two feet", and the shopkeeper says "No it can't", I can still drive away faster than I can run. What the shopkeeper believes is irrelevant.

If I go down to the store with my cash and say, " These green pieces of paper are exchangeable for goods and services", and the shopkeeper says "No they are not", the shopkeeper is right. The value of my green pieces of paper is contingent on the other person believing that they are worth something.

The concept of money is indeed very useful and make economies more efficient, but money itself only has value if people believe it has value. If people don't believe your green pieces of paper are worth anything, then they are right. A green piece of paper with $10 printed on it is not worth more than a green piece of paper with $1 printed on it, unless people agree that it is.
 
I believe the federal government might have issue with that. ;)
If people with guns need to come by to force you to believe that little green pieces of paper are worth goods and services, this raises the question of how valuable the pieces of paper really are.
 
:confused:

Value comes from being useful for a purpose. If you need to breathe and you're underwater, a scuba suit and tank would be a valuable thing to you. It's not fictional or a lie, it would improve your quality of life, in this case allowing you to not die.

Our modern society needs money. The purpose it serves, the difference in convenience it offers over a barter system, is not fictional or a lie. It actually improves our quality of life.
I have no clue how this could be unclear.

And no one has denied that. I think you are rather confused about what money actually is in our modern societies. "Money" is an emergent property of social interactions that is often mapped onto tokens. The tokens themselves are irrelevant to that property, you seem to have confused the token with the property that is mapped onto it. And the mapping is simply what we "agree" it to be or rather what we accept it to be. It matters not one what the token itself actually is.
 
...snip...

The value comes from usefulness, and gold's value comes from it being useful as money. That's why Bitcoins are useful also. The mining requirement doesn't give it intrinsic or inherent value (I may have mis-stated this several years ago in this thread btw, I've since understood the issue better), the mining requirement gives it scarcity, which is one of several properties that makes it useful as money.


That's circular reasoning.


.
That is why gold (and also other precious metals like silver, and Bitcoins) have real, reliable value in our society."[/i]

Anything can be used as a token for the property of social interactions we label "money", which is why paper notes exist, why some people will exchange and use tokens such as diamond for "money". It's simply whatever your society "agrees" on.
 
If people with guns need to come by to force you to believe that little green pieces of paper are worth goods and services, this raises the question of how valuable the pieces of paper really are.

If people with guns need to come by to force you to not kill other people, this raises the question of how valuable the idea of not killing really is.

I'm having a hard time following your logic.
 
If people with guns need to come by to force you to not kill other people, this raises the question of how valuable the idea of not killing really is.

I'm having a hard time following your logic.

I assumed that you were refering to the "all debts public and private" thing.
 
Perhaps he is. There are certainly plenty of people who are smarter than me with money. Is he locking in any of the profits yet, or letting it all ride?

There's a guy that just won $338 million from the powerball lottery but I wouldn't say that makes him smart.

By cashing in now he could reinvest it in something less volatile, even gold. He might miss more upside, but I think there's going to be a correction after such a rapid rise as the last couple months.

yea, there will be, at some point, for sure.

but this is not how the smart money, which in this instance he is, work.

he got in at like $11 or something? so hes (edit lol, just checked price $140 wow) into the 000's of % up, does he care if it retraces technically even 60 % when it could potentially run many more thousands of percent to the upside over time?

your approach is more trading based in this instance, I suspect this guy will only be selling if/when your Auntie Ethel is getting in.

he may also be trading it for all I know, but time has proven him a smarter than your average cookie thus far.

it could well be a massive bubble, but if you got in somewhere the bottom, thats just perfect isn't it. the bigger the better, because they nearly always run so much further than anyone thinks possible.

EDIT from my trading perspective, its firmly in BTFD (Buy The ****** Dip) mode at this point, because breakout trading is dangerous with no long term real history, it worked for him but I wouldnt be able to bring myself to buy this at the top in expectation of more right now.
 
Last edited:
Money is not just any old lie like crimes or justice or parking lots. Money is a self-effecting lie. If we all lie about a $1 bill being able to buy X amount of goods and services, suddenly, it's not a lie anymore. That $1 bill is exchangeable for X amount of goods and services. As soon as we believe the lie, it becomes objectively true. Our belief that money has value is what gives it its value, and that money's value reinforces our belief in it. It is almost beautiful in it's paradoxical nature.

Of course, once people stop believing in it, it falls apart fast. As I write this, two 100,000 Mark notes from 1923 Germany are selling on E-Bay for less than a Whopper value meal, and nobody is buying.

Very well put. Almost philosophical...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom