How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
And no one has denied that. I think you are rather confused about what money actually is in our modern societies.
You are the one that is confused.

"Money" is an emergent property of social interactions that is often mapped onto tokens. The tokens themselves are irrelevant to that property,
Really? So why does nearly every society in history that has developed an economy and had access to gold and/or silver ended up using them as money? We have thousands of years of data. Wagon wheels, teeth, wampum, none of them last in the role except gold and silver. If the token itself is irrelevant, then what becomes money over time should be have no consistent result.

you seem to have confused the token with the property that is mapped onto it. And the mapping is simply what we "agree" it to be or rather what we accept it to be. It matters not one what the token itself actually is.
So you claim then that you can use anything you want as money and it will work equally well? Stake your ground.
 
And if people in my country or community say that money makes thinks work easier, we can still use it even if you disagree, and we will outperform your barter-based society. People who use money between them benefit. Those who are delusional or claim it isn't will have a much lower quality of life. This example takes the exact form of what you're trying to say about cars.

I'm not saying that money is a bad thing, or that societies that use it are not better off, I'm just saying that money isn't worth anything if people do not believe it is worth anything.

The car that I take to go have lunch with my parents gets me there faster than walking, regardless of my parent's beliefs. The ability of the restaurant napkin that I hastily scrawled "100" on to pay for the meal is completely dependent on the restaurant owner's beliefs.
 
That's circular reasoning.
No, because monetary value and utility are different things. Utility causes monetary value, and not vice versa. I'm telling you that the monetary value of gold and any other form of money comes from its utility in enabling non-barter trades. And in fact, as any form of money loses utility, say, through becoming non-scarce due to inflation or losing recognizability due to the CIA air-dropping counterfeit notes that are indistinguishable from the actual money (as the CIA has done as a war tactic in the past)...that form of money loses its monetary value in relation to other forms of money and the goods for which it can be exchanged. That's why the value of gold and currencies fluctuate in relation to each other.

Anything can be used as a token for the property of social interactions we label "money", which is why paper notes exist, why some people will exchange and use tokens such as diamond for "money". It's simply whatever your society "agrees" on.
Really? So why don't societies use leaves as money? And that's not a rhetorical question.
 
I'm not saying that money is a bad thing, or that societies that use it are not better off, I'm just saying that money isn't worth anything if people do not believe it is worth anything.

The car that I take to go have lunch with my parents gets me there faster than walking, regardless of my parent's beliefs. The ability of the restaurant napkin that I hastily scrawled "100" on to pay for the meal is completely dependent on the restaurant owner's beliefs.
...and that restaurant owner will suffer by pretending there is no value to him in accepting money. But the people who do recognize the value of using money will be better off. Just like you will be better off if you use a car, it makes no difference if it's useful to an individual or to people functioning as a group.

Let me try putting this another way. Can you see that language is valuable to people? Even if you refuse to talk to someone...another group of people can speak to each other...thus the idea of language has value even if one person ignores it.
 
By the way Random, I think you're also confusing monetary value with utility. The monetary value of the things we use as money comes from their utility in enabling trades without barter, not from thin air. That's why currencies fluctuate in relation to each other...it depends on the various factors that make one more useful than the other (like the government inflating them).

Assuming that the restaurant understands how money functions (just like we assume you know how to drive the car that gives you the valuable use of being transportation), the restaurant owner will NOT accept your napkin with "100" scrawled on it because that does not have the properties that would make it useful money. For one reason, it is not scarce, since you can grab any number of napkins and write any amount on them that you want.

However, if you found something that was scarce, recognizable, didn't rot or spoil, was evenly divisible into smaller equal parts that could represent small enough amounts and was difficult to counterfeit, the restaurant owner WOULD accept that. You also would be handing him gold, silver, platinum, another precious metal, or sending him Bitcoins, since those are among the very few things that have all those properties and thus the utility of being able to enable those trades.
 
Let me try putting this another way. Can you see that language is valuable to people? Even if you refuse to talk to someone...another group of people can speak to each other...thus the idea of language has value even if one person ignores it.
But people who use language have to agree to use language. Otherwise language doesn't work.
 
What does that have to do with language being valuable?

If you have an eloquent language, and no one else speaks it or cares to learn, it is useless. If no one else will accept gold as a form of payment, it is worthless as a form of payment. In order for any form or money to function, other people have to be willing to accept it. If no one is willing to accept it, it has no value as money, no matter how well it might function as currency.

Again, once people decide to go along with the concept of money, gold and silver have definite advantages to them, but they are not strictly necessary. People once used ownership of a giant stone disc at the bottom of the ocean for money.
 
In light of the recent explosive growth of the bitcoin price ($180 per BTC as I'm typing this, compared to $100 a week ago), I wonder if people would be willing to take wild, non-binding guesses at how high the price is going to climb before there is a major drop. (For reference, you can check past prices here.)

And yes, obviously nobody can know how high it will climb, so please don't respond merely to point that out. Just take a guess. This is not a test of your psychic powers, and nobody is asking you to put any money on it. It's not a problem to guess wrong, in fact that would be expected. I'm just interested in what people's guesses will be at this point in time, as well as in retrospect, and how wildly they'll vary. - It'll be too late to ask this after the bubble is over.

(It is also valid to guess that there'll be no major drop at all, i.e. that the price will rise to some steady level and remain there, or keep growing more slowly but indefinitely.)

Thank any of you guys for your responses, should you decide to take part in this little research thingy. :)
 
If it properly takes off I could easily envisage 10x from here, but not without pullbacks along the way.

these vertical spikes dont very often go forever.
 
You are the one that is confused.

Really? So why does nearly every society in history that has developed an economy and had access to gold and/or silver ended up using them as money? We have thousands of years of data. Wagon wheels, teeth, wampum, none of them last in the role except gold and silver.

And fiat money. So far, anyway.
 
If you have an eloquent language, and no one else speaks it or cares to learn, it is useless.
And how does that mean that the entire concept language is completely useless or has fictional value? You know that the internet is useless if no one else on the planet chooses to create a website or go to forums and so on, right? So therefore all websites are actually fictional and useless as well, right?

If no one else will accept gold as a form of payment, it is worthless as a form of payment.
Just to note, you've now slipped from "if one person doesn't take it" to "if everyone doesn't take it." And your argument still isn't going anywhere.

In order for any form or money to function, other people have to be willing to accept it.
In order for language to function, and for the internet to function, and for your eyes to function, and money to function, you must have external sources to send you information or interact with you, therefore they're all actually useless?

If no one is willing to accept it, it has no value as money, no matter how well it might function as currency.

Again, once people decide to go along with the concept of money, gold and silver have definite advantages to them, but they are not strictly necessary. People once used ownership of a giant stone disc at the bottom of the ocean for money.
People once tried to use a flat-earth model as well. It didn't last. Because the round-earth works better.
 
And fiat money. So far, anyway.
Actually, the most widespread fiat money in the world is rapidly degenerating in value, so it lasting a few more millennia is highly unlikely. That's because it has the crucial flaw of having unreliable scarcity, thus limiting its usefulness as money. Again, scarcity is a property that actually controls the monetary value of a currency, and explains why currency values fluctuate as opposed to the mythical belief that it has no basis.
 
Last edited:
Er... because they didn't agree to that.
Go on. Why didn't they? Why don't we use wampum, or teeth, or wagon wheels? Why does every modern society consistently treat gold and silver as valuable? Even the U.S. government which has the power of fiat still holds hundreds of billions of dollars worth of gold. Why don't they just decree that gold is worthless? Answer.
 
In order for language to function, and for the internet to function, and for your eyes to function, and money to function, you must have external sources to send you information or interact with you, therefore they're all actually useless?

Well, sort of (I don’t know where you are trying to go with the eyes thing). I’m not saying that language, the internet, and money all have no value, but that their value is entirely dependent on other people going along with it. If everyone agrees that money has value, then it does. If no one thinks money has value, then it doesn’t.

A $100 bill would be worthless to cavemen, and it may be worthless to people in a post-scarcity economy, but I would certainly pick one up if I saw it on the street because civilization uses money right now.
 
Go on. Why didn't they? Why don't we use wampum, or teeth, or wagon wheels? Why does every modern society consistently treat gold and silver as valuable? Even the U.S. government which has the power of fiat still holds hundreds of billions of dollars worth of gold. Why don't they just decree that gold is worthless? Answer.
Wampum, teeth and wagon wheels also have value. They were never declared worthless by fiat either.

Therefore I support a return to the wampum standard! If it was good enough to buy America, it's good for America!
 
In light of the recent explosive growth of the bitcoin price ($180 per BTC as I'm typing this, compared to $100 a week ago), I wonder if people would be willing to take wild, non-binding guesses at how high the price is going to climb before there is a major drop. (For reference, you can check past prices here.)

And yes, obviously nobody can know how high it will climb, so please don't respond merely to point that out. Just take a guess. This is not a test of your psychic powers, and nobody is asking you to put any money on it. It's not a problem to guess wrong, in fact that would be expected. I'm just interested in what people's guesses will be at this point in time, as well as in retrospect, and how wildly they'll vary. - It'll be too late to ask this after the bubble is over.

(It is also valid to guess that there'll be no major drop at all, i.e. that the price will rise to some steady level and remain there, or keep growing more slowly but indefinitely.)

Thank any of you guys for your responses, should you decide to take part in this little research thingy. :)

Earlier today when I looked it was $170. Now it's about 10 hours later and it's $194. It seems like a no brainer that it'll be over $200 when I wake up tomorrow.

I'll guess a peak at $250, but I readily admit that I have no basis for that number. It just seems like a nice round number that's as good as any other and within reach.
 
It will go up until someone holding a fair ammount blinks and decides to get out while it is high. Like always happens with bubbles. First in first out makes the money.
 
Go on. Why didn't they? Why don't we use wampum, or teeth, or wagon wheels? Why does every modern society consistently treat gold and silver as valuable? Even the U.S. government which has the power of fiat still holds hundreds of billions of dollars worth of gold.
Not sure what you are getting at. Historically, gold was used as money because it was the best choice of a medium. I doubt that a modern society would want to go back to lugging gold coins around to pay for things nowadays.

Of course, gold is still considered a valuable commodity and I doubt that you would get too many knock backs if you offered to pay for something with gold but unless the world loses confidence in fiat money, fiat is here to stay.

Why don't they just decree that gold is worthless? Answer.
Governments can't decree anything worthless. They can try to make it illegal but that usually has the opposite effect (eg drugs).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom