How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I have read his posts, and in all honesty I have to say your responses to him have tended to avoid his actual arguments and positions in favour of attacking tangential points and outright straw-men.
That's like saying that John Albert has proven his ridiculous claim that bitcoin is a scam.

So, once again, I have to ask: what, exactly, is establishing "that bitcoin is definitely not 'nothing'" supposed to be sufficient for? Do you even know yourself at this point?
You obviously missed the posts that are rebutted by establishing that bitcoin is not nothing.
 
It is sufficient to have established that bitcoin is definitely not "nothing".


I never said Bitcoin is "nothing." You're misrepresenting me again.

What I said was that bitcoins are backed by nothing. They purport to be units of something, but there is no stable foundation beneath them. There is no real-world economy, no authority, or even any legal system in place to ensure their value. Bitcoins represent nothing more than whatever some small community of people are willing to pay for them, and that price fluctuates crazily because there's no intrinsic value on which to stabilize the system; all value comes from whatever price the "greater fools" are willing to pay from one moment to another, in hopes of sharing in the fantasy, making a killing, or recouping their earlier losses.

The only mechanism that even ensures the existence of bitcoins is an arcane cryptographic protocol, which is a really lousy basis for an economy because cryptography has a long history of being broken. Anybody with even a basic understanding of cryptographic systems should realize that it's only a matter of time before this thing gets cracked. There's money wrapped up in Bitcoin, so the stakes are high. You can bet that lots of very smart people are busy picking apart the code at this very moment. Sooner or later a fatal flaw will be discovered, the crypto will get broken and the entire house of cards will come crashing down. Woe be to the poor fools who wasted their money on bitcoins whenever that happens.

Even beyond the risk of the crypto being cracked, there's the problem that the security of the entire system is predicated on the leverage of computational power against outside attack. For that model to succeed, the computational power would need to be decentralized and evenly distributed among many hosts. But what we're seeing with Bitcoin is an increasing aggregation of computational power among large "mining pools," one of which currently handles over a third of all transactions on the "blockchain." As the "mining difficulty" ramps upward, the economics will force smaller mining interests out of the game, further consolidating computational power into a single, monopolistic concern. That imbalance has the potential to topple the entire economy even without the vaunted "cryptographic algorithm" being broken.

In addition to the inherent problems of predicating an imaginary economy upon a computationally expensive cipher, you have the significant problem of interfacing that imaginary economy with the real world. Lacking any means of transferring value between Bitcoins and other currencies, the entire Bitcoin system would operate in a vacuum, no more "real" than a video game. So that's where the "exchanges" come in. They're a business-critical part of Bitcoin, so the safety and stability of the entire economy relies upon them, yet in only 3 years of operation they've already proven notoriously insecure and unreliable.

The entire Bitcoin economy is a shaky structure built on a fiction.

I cannot prove the intentions of the Bitcoin creators one way or another, so I can't say for certain that it was deliberately engineered to rip people off. But judging by the way it operates, it certainly appears that Bitcoin is a financial scam that harbors and facilitates a variety of subsidiary scams.
 
Last edited:
That's like saying that John Albert has proven his ridiculous claim that bitcoin is a scam.

No, it's like saying that your responses to him have tended to avoid his actual arguments and positions in favour of attacking tangential points and outright straw-men.

You obviously missed the posts that are rebutted by establishing that bitcoin is not nothing.

That's a possibility, but I think the alternative that you've misread him or are quibbling on some semantic point tangential to his arguments is more likely.
 
I have read his posts, and in all honesty I have to say your responses to him have tended to avoid his actual arguments and positions in favour of attacking tangential points and outright straw-men.

That's like saying that John Albert has proven his ridiculous claim that bitcoin is a scam.


Actually, no. He isn't saying that at all. As far as I've seen, he hasn't passed judgment one way or another on whether it's a scam. All he's saying is that you're not doing a very good job at arguing your case.
 
Oh, certainly. Practically you're likely to be sol because of lack of evidence, but in principle the law applies and you could take the culprit to court for theft or embezzlement.


Actually, I'd think a prosecutor (an American one, anyway ;)) would have a much easier go at establishing a violation of the Computer Fraud and Abuse Act of 1986 (a.k.a. the "Anti-hacking Law"), if the attacker did indeed obtain unauthorized access to the victim's computer system.

But it's doubtful that an American prosecutor would (or could) prosecute the offender on theft charges because unlike some other countries (like Australia and South Korea, for example) the USA's criminal justice system does not recognize "virtual assets" as real property. Of course different countries have different laws, so YMMV.

There's also the possibility that a court case involving bitcoin theft could change all that.
 
Last edited:
I never said Bitcoin is "nothing." You're misrepresenting me again.

What I said was that bitcoins are backed by nothing. They purport to be units of something, but there is no stable foundation beneath them.
That's not what you were saying in post #1319. If what you mean is that bitcoin is backed by nothing of value then that is a bit of a non-statement. There was never any intention for that to happen. Bitcoin stands or falls on its own.

There is no real-world economy, no authority, or even any legal system in place to ensure their value.
Who said there has to be? The test is whether the bitcoin network (not the exchanges) is secure enough to work without resorting to external authorities. So far this is the case.

Bitcoins represent nothing more than whatever some small community of people are willing to pay for them, and that price fluctuates crazily because there's no intrinsic value on which to stabilize the system; all value comes from whatever price the "greater fools" are willing to pay from one moment to another, in hopes of sharing in the fantasy, making a killing, or recouping their earlier losses.
In spite of your "greater fool" references (and this is a prediction not a fact), you are just pointing out that bitcoins are worth whatever somebody is willing to pay for them. This is as it should be. This is the way commerce has worked for thousands of years.

Why should bitcoin be any different? I don't recall a rule saying that something must exist independently of electronic media before it can be marketed. I don't recall a rule saying that something has to have a utility beyond pure existence before it can be marketed. I don't see what business it is of yours if somebody else wants to buy them - even if they are just gambling. It is just the old case of caveat emptor/caveat venditor.

And if the only use made of bitcoin is for gambling, are you really going to say that shouldn't be allowed? That is unbelievably oppressive. If the worst of the worst is true, all you can say is that the founders might have made a fortune in bitcoins. When did making money out of an idea become a bad thing? Maybe you think they should be open about how much they are making but that is an issue for the buyers of bitcoins - not bystanders.

The only mechanism that even ensures the existence of bitcoins is an arcane cryptographic protocol, which is a really lousy basis for an economy because cryptography has a long history of being broken. Anybody with even a basic understanding of cryptographic systems should realize that it's only a matter of time before this thing gets cracked. There's money wrapped up in Bitcoin, so the stakes are high. You can bet that lots of very smart people are busy picking apart the code at this very moment. Sooner or later a fatal flaw will be discovered, the crypto will get broken and the entire house of cards will come crashing down. Woe be to the poor fools who wasted their money on bitcoins whenever that happens.
Another prediction. If it comes to pass and the algorithm gets broken then it's game over. All the gamblers who didn't get out in time lose and no spin-off technology would be likely.

In addition to the inherent problems of predicating an imaginary economy upon a computationally expensive cipher, you have the significant problem of interfacing that imaginary economy with the real world. Lacking any means of transferring value between Bitcoins and other currencies, the entire Bitcoin system would operate in a vacuum, no more "real" than a video game.
Again, that is not anybody's problem. If lots of people want to buy and sell bitcoins then exchanges will spring up to accommodate them but that is not a function of bitcoin itself.

So that's where the "exchanges" come in. They're a business-critical part of Bitcoin, so the safety and stability of the entire economy relies upon them, yet in only 3 years of operation they've already proven notoriously insecure and unreliable.
The exchanges have nothing to do with the operation of bitcoin - only buying and selling. Exchange security is mostly about taking proper security measures. It seems almost unamerican to suggest that exchange security won't improve without government involvement but that is a separate issue altogether.

The entire Bitcoin economy is a shaky structure built on a fiction.
ftfy. There is NO bitcoin economy. Just bitcoins.

I cannot prove the intentions of the Bitcoin creators one way or another, so I can't say for certain that it was deliberately engineered to rip people off.
But that hasn't stopped you from claiming so anyway.

But judging by the way it operates, it certainly appears that Bitcoin is a financial scam that harbors and facilitates a variety of subsidiary scams.
Pure non-sequitur. There is no bitcoin economy to "scam" anybody. There are just scams that bitcoin holders (like anybody else) can be victims of. There is no "system" designed to lure in the suckers. Just something to buy or sell.
 
Bitcoin stands or falls on its own.

Frequently.

Who said there has to be? The test is whether the bitcoin network (not the exchanges) is secure enough to work without resorting to external authorities.

You seem to be implying that this is the purpose of BTC, but I see no evidence of this. How do you know ?

Pure non-sequitur. There is no bitcoin economy to "scam" anybody.

Again, for someone who thinks other posters shouldn't say they know the mind of the people who made bitcoin, you seem to claim quite a bit of said knowledge yourself.
 
I never said Bitcoin is "nothing." You're misrepresenting me again.

What I said was that bitcoins are backed by nothing. They purport to be units of something, but there is no stable foundation beneath them.
That's not what you were saying in post #1319.


This is what I said in post #1319:

So you're saying that the value of bitcoins is due to the "greater fool" theory? How comforting.


Exactly.

He's arguing that there will always be some supply of suckers who are willing to pay a dollar amount for nothing, on the amoral pipe-dream of scamming some other future sucker at a later date.

It can't continue forever. Sooner or later the thing will run out of steam, and/or its security will be compromised. The law of averages demands it.

See?

Why do you feel the need to constantly misrepresent the things I say? Can't you just honestly address my statements without these transparent attempts at subterfuge?

Or do you really, honestly not understand the difference between saying "Bitcoin is nothing" and saying "bitcoins represent nothing of value"?


If what you mean is that bitcoin is backed by nothing of value then that is a bit of a non-statement.


Um, no, I'm pretty sure it's actually a statement.


Bitcoin stands or falls on its own.


:confused:

It's fallen repeatedly over the past 2 years, and each and every time, lots of people have lost a lot of money while others have gotten rich directly at their expense.


There is no real-world economy, no authority, or even any legal system in place to ensure their value.


Who said there has to be?


The fact that there's nothing behind it except a bunch of people taking free money directly out of the pockets of investors is what makes it a scam.

My mind boggles at how steadfastly resistant you are to even trying to comprehend that obvious fact.


The test is whether the bitcoin network (not the exchanges) is secure enough to work without resorting to external authorities. So far this is the case.


What "test"?

Is there some kind of "test" to see how many people can get scammed on their foolish investments before the entire thing collapses under its own inertia?

Who is in charge of proctoring this "test"?

I'd say that person, whomever they are, should be a prime candidate for a stint in Federal "PMITA" Prison.


In spite of your "greater fool" references (and this is a prediction not a fact), you are just pointing out that bitcoins are worth whatever somebody is willing to pay for them. This is as it should be. This is the way commerce has worked for thousands of years.


Appeal to tradition. You must be referring to the thousands of years prior to the advent of Federal laws against the sale of false and misleading securities.


Why should bitcoin be any different? I don't recall a rule saying that something must exist independently of electronic media before it can be marketed. I don't recall a rule saying that something has to have a utility beyond pure existence before it can be marketed.


Here are a few Federal laws that Bitcoin and its exchanges appear to violate:

Securities Act of 1933

Often referred to as the "truth in securities" law, the Securities Act of 1933 has two basic objectives:

  • require that investors receive financial and other significant information concerning securities being offered for public sale; and
  • prohibit deceit, misrepresentations, and other fraud in the sale of securities.

The full text of this Act is available at: http://www.sec.gov/about/laws/sa33.pdf.

Purpose of Registration

A primary means of accomplishing these goals is the disclosure of important financial information through the registration of securities. This information enables investors, not the government, to make informed judgments about whether to purchase a company's securities. While the SEC requires that the information provided be accurate, it does not guarantee it. Investors who purchase securities and suffer losses have important recovery rights if they can prove that there was incomplete or inaccurate disclosure of important information.

The Registration Process

In general, securities sold in the U.S. must be registered. The registration forms companies file provide essential facts while minimizing the burden and expense of complying with the law. In general, registration forms call for:

  • a description of the company's properties and business;
  • a description of the security to be offered for sale;
  • information about the management of the company; and
  • financial statements certified by independent accountants.
http://www.sec.gov/about/laws.shtml#secact1933


Securities Exchange Act of 1934

With this Act, Congress created the Securities and Exchange Commission. The Act empowers the SEC with broad authority over all aspects of the securities industry. This includes the power to register, regulate, and oversee brokerage firms, transfer agents, and clearing agencies as well as the nation's securities self regulatory organizations (SROs). The various securities exchanges, such as the New York Stock Exchange, the NASDAQ Stock Market, and the Chicago Board of Options are SROs. The Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) is also an SRO.

The Act also identifies and prohibits certain types of conduct in the markets and provides the Commission with disciplinary powers over regulated entities and persons associated with them.

The Act also empowers the SEC to require periodic reporting of information by companies with publicly traded securities.

The full text of this Act can be read at: http://www.sec.gov/about/laws/sea34.pdf.

...

Corporate Reporting

Companies with more than $10 million in assets whose securities are held by more than 500 owners must file annual and other periodic reports. These reports are available to the public through the SEC's EDGAR database.

Insider Trading

The securities laws broadly prohibit fraudulent activities of any kind in connection with the offer, purchase, or sale of securities. These provisions are the basis for many types of disciplinary actions, including actions against fraudulent insider trading. Insider trading is illegal when a person trades a security while in possession of material nonpublic information in violation of a duty to withhold the information or refrain from trading.

Registration of Exchanges, Associations, and Others

The Act requires a variety of market participants to register with the Commission, including exchanges, brokers and dealers, transfer agents, and clearing agencies. Registration for these organizations involves filing disclosure documents that are updated on a regular basis.

The exchanges and the Financial Industry Regulatory Authority (FINRA) are identified as self-regulatory organizations (SRO). SROs must create rules that allow for disciplining members for improper conduct and for establishing measures to ensure market integrity and investor protection. SRO proposed rules are subject to SEC review and published to solicit public comment. While many SRO proposed rules are effective upon filing, some are subject to SEC approval before they can go into effect.
http://www.sec.gov/about/laws.shtml#secexact1934


Investment Company Act of 1940

This Act regulates the organization of companies, including mutual funds, that engage primarily in investing, reinvesting, and trading in securities, and whose own securities are offered to the investing public. The regulation is designed to minimize conflicts of interest that arise in these complex operations. The Act requires these companies to disclose their financial condition and investment policies to investors when stock is initially sold and, subsequently, on a regular basis. The focus of this Act is on disclosure to the investing public of information about the fund and its investment objectives, as well as on investment company structure and operations. It is important to remember that the Act does not permit the SEC to directly supervise the investment decisions or activities of these companies or judge the merits of their investments.

The full text of this Act is available at: http://www.sec.gov/about/laws/ica40.pdf.
http://www.sec.gov/about/laws.shtml#invcoact1940​


I'm sure there are others.


I don't see what business it is of yours if somebody else wants to buy them - even if they are just gambling. It is just the old case of caveat emptor/caveat venditor.


Ah, the old "Some of us got a good thing going here, why don't you butt out" argument. How charming.

Well, I have a right to warn people about dangerous scams. That's a major part of what the so-called "skeptics movement" is about, in case you didn't notice.


And if the only use made of bitcoin is for gambling, are you really going to say that shouldn't be allowed?


Yes, because it's fundamentally unfair and manipulative, and people ought to be made aware of that.


That is unbelievably oppressive.


:cry1

Cry me a river.


If the worst of the worst is true, all you can say is that the founders might have made a fortune in bitcoins.


...at the direct expense of a lot of innocent people who got swindled.


When did making money out of an idea become a bad thing?


It's a bad thing when the "idea" is specifically engineered to siphon funds directly from later investors into the pockets of the early adopters.


The exchanges have nothing to do with the operation of bitcoin - only buying and selling. Exchange security is mostly about taking proper security measures.


This is the same logical fallacy you've been called on numerous times already, yet you still can't seem to wrap your mind around it.

The exchanges have everything to do with the operation of Bitcoin. If there were no exchanges, there would be no Bitcoin trading or commerce at all.


It seems almost unamerican


Gimme a break :rolleyes:

"Last refuge of a scoundrel."


There is NO bitcoin economy. Just bitcoins.
Pure non-sequitur. There is no bitcoin economy to "scam" anybody. There are just scams that bitcoin holders (like anybody else) can be victims of. There is no "system" designed to lure in the suckers. Just something to buy or sell.


:crazy:
 
Last edited:
I cannot prove the intentions of the Bitcoin creators one way or another, so I can't say for certain that it was deliberately engineered to rip people off.


But that hasn't stopped you from claiming so anyway.


Um, no, that's another lie, another blatant misrepresentation of what I've said.

I have repeatedly stated that I don't claim to know the minds of the Bitcoin creators, and have explained that my entire assessment of Bitcoin has come solely from a dispassionate, critical analysis of its design and operation, and the manner in which it has been implemented.

And hey, guess what... my very next sentence in my post, I clarified that position yet again:


But judging by the way it operates, it certainly appears that Bitcoin is a financial scam that harbors and facilitates a variety of subsidiary scams.


You handwaved it as a "non sequitur," but that accusation doesn't even make sense. Do you even know what a non sequitur is?
 
Last edited:
This is what I said in post #1319:

See?

Why do you feel the need to constantly misrepresent the things I say? Can't you just honestly address my statements without these transparent attempts at subterfuge?

Or do you really, honestly not understand the difference between saying "Bitcoin is nothing" and saying "bitcoins represent nothing of value"?
LOL It says in black and white "pay a dollar amount for nothing" and you still deny it.

Of course, bitcoins aren't supposed to represent anything of value. They just exist.

It's fallen repeatedly over the past 2 years, and each and every time, lots of people have lost a lot of money while others have gotten rich directly at their expense.
This is just a colossal LIE. Apart from the loss of value between July and November 2011, the price of bitcoin has risen constantly with few hiccups on the way.

The fact that there's nothing behind it except a bunch of people taking free money directly out of the pockets of investors is what makes it a scam.

My mind boggles at how steadfastly resistant you are to even trying to comprehend that obvious fact.
This is why everything you post about bitcoin is nonsense.

There are no people running around picking pockets (or whatever other imagery you are trying to conjure up). Nobody is demanding money and nobody is being coerced into buying bitcoins. No promises or representations are made to potential bitcoin buyers.

All these words like "scam", "pyramid" exist only inside your head. The only scamming going on is in your head. You have to invent an entire "system" to try and make your objections sound plausible but that system also exists only inside of your head.

What "test"?
The bitcoin algorithm test.

Is there some kind of "test" to see how many people can get scammed on their foolish investments before the entire thing collapses under its own inertia?
No.

Who is in charge of proctoring this "test"?

I'd say that person, whomever they are, should be a prime candidate for a stint in Federal "PMITA" Prison.
Releasing bitcoin onto the internet without getting prior permission from the government must be a shocking crime.

Appeal to tradition. You must be referring to the thousands of years prior to the advent of Federal laws against the sale of false and misleading securities.
Don't we allow things to be sold at whatever price someone is willing to pay anymore?

Here are a few Federal laws that Bitcoin and its exchanges appear to violate:



I'm sure there are others.
If you want to make the argument that bitcoin exchanges are violating the security acts that's fine but it has got absolutely nothing to do with bitcoin itself

Ah, the old "Some of us got a good thing going here, why don't you butt out" argument. How charming.
I couldn't have put it better myself. ;)

Well, I have a right to warn people about dangerous scams. That's a major part of what the so-called "skeptics movement" is about, in case you didn't notice.
That's why your time is wasted here. Bitcoin is not a "dangerous scam" (when did you upgrade the description from plain old scam?)

Readers have the right to know that you are desperately trying to make them believe that bitcoin is a scam because you want it banned and moral arguments are not enough.

Yes, because it's fundamentally unfair and manipulative, and people ought to be made aware of that.

:cry1

Cry me a river.
So bitcoin is bad because people gamble with it? That must mean that you are opposed to all forms of gambling. Or is gambling bad only when it involves bitcoin?

What is "fundamentally unfair" about buying bitcoins? How are people being "manipulated" into buying bitcoins. This is just more words you are throwing around like mud and hoping something sticks.

This is what it is all about for you. Imposing your moral values on the rest of society.

...at the direct expense of a lot of innocent people who got swindled.
Bitcoin buyers are now "innocent people"? How did these "innocent people" get swindled? Didn't they get the bitcoins they bought?

How many other negative ways can buying something be presented?

It's a bad thing when the "idea" is specifically engineered to siphon funds directly from later investors into the pockets of the early adopters.
So now they have a hose in their pockets? The hyperbole never ceases!

Of course bitcoin wasn't "engineered" to do any such thing. It just exists. If bitcoin was "engineered" to do anything, it is to be transferred over the internet without requiring a third party.

It's ridiculous to suggest that the whole reason for eliminating the third party was to make bitcoin a "scam".

This is the same logical fallacy you've been called on numerous times already, yet you still can't seem to wrap your mind around it.

The exchanges have everything to do with the operation of Bitcoin. If there were no exchanges, there would be no Bitcoin trading or commerce at all.
That is because the bitcoin exchanges are completely and utterly irrelevant to bitcoin itself.

Nothing about the bitcoin algorithm requires the establishment of exchanges. Without them, only a bit of private trading would be possible and bitcoins would probably cost a lot less. There is no rule that says that the value of bitcoin has to be enhanced in any way.

The only reason the exchanges exist is because bitcoin has proved immensely popular and a demand for them sprung up. Do you think that is evil?

Gimme a break :rolleyes:

"Last refuge of a scoundrel."

:crazy:
Yes, it bears repeating over and over until the message sinks in:
There is NO scheme, scam, system, economy, pyramid or anything else. There is only bitcoins.
 
Would it be a good idea to agree to restrict the discussion to either:

a. Bitcoin the protocol.

b. This particular instance of bitcoin. Aren't there others (litecoin)? But no exchanges, no transfering into dollars. Is this what psionIO wants?

c. The Bitcoin system as a whole, including the exchanges, the users, etc...

It just seems to me that a lot of the time the conversation is John Albert saying "c. operates as a scam" and psionIO saying "no, b. does not operate as a scam".
 
LOL It says in black and white "pay a dollar amount for nothing" and you still deny it.


Bitcoin investors are paying a dollar amount to buy into a fantasy. Bitcoins represent no real world thing.


Of course, bitcoins aren't supposed to represent anything of value. They just exist.


Just like the tickets on the "Airplane Game." They're immaterial placeholders for wealth that serve to facilitate the logical breakdown and redistribution of wealth into the hands of the majority bitcoin holders.

To help you understand what I'm talking about, please try answering these questions:

For what reason was Bitcoin created in the first place?

What benefits does Bitcoin bring to the table that make it better suited to that purpose than previously existing solutions?

Why go through the trouble of implementing all this advanced cryptography and resource-hogging software to support a fake currency, when the problem could be more easily solved by creating a distributed, peer-to-peer payment transfer system using existing currencies?


It's fallen repeatedly over the past 2 years, and each and every time, lots of people have lost a lot of money while others have gotten rich directly at their expense.
This is just a colossal LIE. Apart from the loss of value between July and November 2011, the price of bitcoin has risen constantly with few hiccups on the way.


Quite a few "hiccups" indeed.

The chart you've posted looks pretty good from the long-range perspective. But zooming in to view the day-to-day activity of this market tells a different story entirely.

Look at the large number of precipitous drop-offs where the share price has fallen drastically, often losing a major percentage of its total value. The reason the Bitcoin economy is so unstable is because it's a small and very slanted playing field that can be easily gamed by a tiny fraction of outrageously powerful players. Do you realize what happens every time one of the major players cashes in a huge load of BTC? Lots of people who are in the process of selling their coins (and even people just using Bitcoin for its ostensible purpose as a currency) are effectively getting screwed. The market drops so fast that you can't transact the exchange fast enough to avoid a huge loss in value. And there's no telling when such a drop is going to occur. You can get screwed out of your money at any moment of any day.

Just because a lot of people are jumping on board and buying into this craze is no indication that it isn't a scam. My advice to you is to do a bit of reading on speculative bubble scams. This would be a good place to start.


There are no people running around picking pockets (or whatever other imagery you are trying to conjure up). Nobody is demanding money and nobody is being coerced into buying bitcoins. No promises or representations are made to potential bitcoin buyers.


Nobody coerced or forced investors to sink their money into Madoff Securities or the various pyramid or Ponzi schemes either, but you'd be a fool to defend that those kinds of practices as not being scams (as you've already tried to argue at least once). The whole premise of a scam is to beguile somebody into giving up their money freely, by raising false hopes by means of a compelling story (like a "revolutionary digital cryptocurrency that will revolutionize the world").

The entire premise of Bitcoin being a currency is fraudulent to start with. Bitcoin is aggressively promoted as a general-use currency, but it's not a currency. It lacks most of the fundamental elements that define a currency. That fact ought to raise some red flags right away.

What it really amounts to is a crooked investment scam based on a fraudulent "virtual commodity" that represents nothing real. You'd have to look pretty damn hard to find an investment more foolish than just throwing your money away at nothing.


All these words like "scam", "pyramid" exist only inside your head. The only scamming going on is in your head.


I've backed up my position with facts, sound reasoning and decent ethical principles. You have yet to rebut any of my arguments with anything substantial. Your ad hominem attacks amount to nothing.


You have to invent an entire "system" to try and make your objections sound plausible but that system also exists only inside of your head.


I haven't "invented" anything. The "system" I've described is the actual operation of the Bitcoin protocol, the software that implements that protocol, and the various financial services that support that protocol being used as a means for exchange.

That you deny the existence of a "system" speaks volumes about your own closed-minded, willful ignorance about this cockamamie "investment opportunity" you've decided to involve yourself with.


The bitcoin algorithm test.


I've never heard of this "Bitcoin algorithm test" before. Please link to somewhere I can read about it.


Releasing bitcoin onto the internet without getting prior permission from the government must be a shocking crime.


:confused:

I was referring to the scam in which some programmers created a fake, pre-cornered economy for themselves wherein they could feed off the monetary investments of credulous rubes. It's most certainly a crime under several US Federal codes, but not really all that shocking to be honest.


Appeal to tradition. You must be referring to the thousands of years prior to the advent of Federal laws against the sale of false and misleading securities.
Don't we allow things to be sold at whatever price someone is willing to pay anymore?


Not when those "things" are false investment securities peddled through unlicensed, unregistered financial institutions that operate outside the law and regularly lose millions of dollars of their customers' money.

(Why do I really need to explain this over and over again?)


If you want to make the argument that bitcoin exchanges are violating the security acts that's fine but it has got absolutely nothing to do with bitcoin itself


The above statement makes absolutely no sense. You said:

I don't recall a rule saying that something must exist independently of electronic media before it can be marketed. I don't recall a rule saying that something has to have a utility beyond pure existence before it can be marketed.


So I pointed out that yes, in fact there are several "rules" (Federal criminal codes, in fact) governing the industry of marketing financial instruments, and that Bitcoin violates a number of them.

Now you're turning that around and saying "it's got nothing to do with Bitcoin"?!?

Please try for once to make an honest effort at a conversation instead of just omnislashing my posts with snarky replies.


Ah, the old "Some of us got a good thing going here, why don't you butt out" argument. How charming.
I couldn't have put it better myself. ;)


I was actually criticizing your unprincipled sense of ethics. Your impertinent brush-off speaks volumes about your true character.


That's why your time is wasted here.


My time is most assuredly not wasted here.


Readers have the right to know that you are desperately trying to make them believe that bitcoin is a scam because you want it banned and moral arguments are not enough.


Quite putting words into my mouth. I never said any of that.


So bitcoin is bad because people gamble with it?


It's bad because it's a contrived, crooked economy that operates as an investment scam.


That must mean that you are opposed to all forms of gambling.


No, but I am certainly opposed to crooked gambling that is unfairly rigged against the interest of the players.


Or is gambling bad only when it involves bitcoin?


Bitcoin is bad, yes, just like any other investment scam. Not quite as bad as some others, but far worse than most just on the basis of its sheer scale.


What is "fundamentally unfair" about buying bitcoins?


Bitcoin is fundamentally unfair because it's a crooked market wherein all the monetary value comes from new investors paying money in but the majority of the capital is owned by only 1% of the players who initially paid nothing yet who control well over half the resources, and who regularly exploit that advantage to manipulate the market.

There, I managed to cram most of the meat of it into one single run-on sentence.

*whew*


How are people being "manipulated" into buying bitcoins.


I never said people are being "manipulated" into buying bitcoins.

What I said was, Bitcoin is a manipulative system.

It's manipulative in that its promoters falsely advertise it as a general-use currency, it is marketed towards political radicals whose ideology clouds their financial judgment; it hides critical details about its design beneath layers of complexity, it relies on disingenuous metaphors such as "mining" to justify creating a clearly rigged system intended to disproportionately benefit its creators, and its market is unfairly manipulated by a small cartel of users who are anonymous.


This is what it is all about for you. Imposing your moral values on the rest of society.


You really need to check your attitude there. You're betraying the weakness of your position by relying on all these tiresome ad hominem attacks. Raising awareness about a financial scam does not constitute "imposing moral values."


Bitcoin buyers are now "innocent people"?


Good point. I'm probably wrong about that point. In fact there's pretty good evidence in this thread and elsewhere that at least a large number of them are total douchebags.


How did these "innocent people" get swindled? Didn't they get the bitcoins they bought?


List of events in rough chronological order

~Stone Man Loss
Time: 2010-08-09T23:35 ± 600 s
Victim: Stone Man @BitcoinTalk
Status: Coins lost, effectively destroyed
Amount: Exactly 8999.00000000 BTC
Transaction of interest: eb5b761c7380ed4c6adf688f9e5ab94953dcabeda47d9eeabd77261902fccccf
Due to not keeping proper wallet backups, 8999 BTC sent as change were effectively destroyed when the private key controlling them was lost. Because this theft is from 2010, it is not included in severity lists.


~Ubitex Scam
Time: April 2011 to July 2011
Victim: Investors on GLBSE of Ubitex
Status: Ubitex founder known, but nothing returned
Amount: About 1138.98 BTC (amount "invested" into Ubitex)
Equivalent USD: 11668.70 $ (wt. avg)
A GLBSE investment run by a minor, around 1000 BTC of the missing investments are said to have been "spent", many of which were further scammed, or converted into USD without follow-up.


~Stefan Thomas Loss
Time: June 2011
Victim: Stefan Thomas
Status: Coins destroyed (no thief)
Amount: Estimate 7000 BTC (estimate)
Equivalent USD: 128000 $ (wt. avg, rounded to nearest thousand)


~Allinvain Theft
Time: 2011-06-13T17:52 (UTC) ± 600 s [satoshi estimated block transmission time]
Victim: Bitcointalk.org user "allinvain"
Status: Thief uncaught
Amount: Exactly 25000.01000000 BTC
Equivalent USD: 502750.20 $
Chief transaction of interest: 4885ddf124a0f97b5a3775a12de0274d342d12842ebe59520359f976721ac8c3
Perhaps the most famous bitcoin heist of all time, there has been some dispute about its genuineness, with some believing that it was set up as a ploy for donations. Allinvain was an early adopter, and most of his coins were mined, so there is little reason for him to sabotage Bitcoin's image for donations. The hack ended up redistributing some early-adopter coins, and the presence of these coins in nearly every user's wallet is cited as a reason that a tainted coin system would definitely fail. Although not as important as it once was, being dwarfed by the MyBitcoin Theft not too much later, this heist will likely remain the most famous for some time.


~June 2011 Mt. Gox Incident
Time: 2011-06-19T18:00 ± 1 h (theft), days ensuing (hacks & withdrawals)
Victim: Mt. Gox (some claim also customers)
Status: Thief uncaught
Amount:
Stolen by thief: 2000 BTC (official estimate)
Additional withdrawn from Mt. Gox: 643.27 BTC (lower bound)
Total: Lower bound 2643.27 BTC
Equivalent USD: 46970.91 $ (used last trade value; actual price at the time was not reliable)
Transactions: none released officially
The event's scale was widely disputed; some report a theft of almost 500000 BTC due to related account hacking. At this time, these reports seem to be unfounded and closer inspection puts the losses at closer to 2500 BTC. Some additional money was stolen by traders capitalizing on the dropping price and withdrawing in time, including toasty of the bitcointalk.org forums. Mt. Gox claims it has reimbursed customers for this theft.


~MyBitcoin Theft
Time: Unknown time in July 2011 (claimed it was a process)
Victim: MyBitcoin & customers
Status: Thief unknown, planned shutdown suspected (disputed theft)
Suspects: "Tom Williams", likely pseudonym (founder of MyBitcoin)
Amount: Exactly 78739.58205388 BTC
Equivalent USD: 1110544 $ (wt. avg, definitely >$1M, rounded to nearest $)
Transaction information: none
Little information was released about the MyBitcoin theft, however, many argue that Tom Williams ran it as a scam (and was not a theft per se). In terms of both dollars and bitcoins, this was by far the largest theft, however, it is possible it was simply a scam. Although MyBitcoin offered to release its code as a gift to the community, it failed to follow through on that promise. In the months ensuing, some evidence has been uncovered supporting mortgage broker Bruce Wagner; however, any evidence is inconclusive.


~Bitomat.pl Loss
Time: 2011-07-26
Victim: Bitomat.pl
Status: Coins destroyed (no thief)
Amount: Estimate 17000 BTC (likely estimate/lower bound, no tx due to technical reason)
Equivalent USD: 236000 $ (rounded to nearest thousand)
Bitomat.pl, during a server restart, had its remote Amazon service that housed the wallet wiped. No backups were kept. Mt. Gox later bailed bitomat.pl out, and neither customers nor original owners suffered any loss from the incident.


~Mooncoin Theft
Time: 2011-09-11
Victim: Mr. Moon, Mooncoin, & Customers
Status: Unknown (Federal intervention suspected)
Amount: Estimate 4000 BTC (conservative estimate based on SC values)
Equivalent USD: 24000 $ (rounded to nearest thousand)
Transactions: numerous
Moonco.in's hack has been compared to the MyBitcoin of SolidCoin, back when it remained a powerful cryptocurrency. Over 800000 SC have been removed from circulation, only to have been put back through SolidCoin 2.0. The effects on Bitcoin were also substantial, and the effect on Namecoin was not negligible. In total, this may have been the worst cross-currency hack in cryptocurrency history.


~Bitcoin7 Hack
Time: 2011-10-05 (UTC)
Victim: Bitcoin7 & Customers
Status: Hacker unknown (officially from Eastern Europe or Russia), scam suspected, some returned
Amount: Estimate 11000 BTC*
Based on size of order books at that time, ~15000.
A quarter supposedly not stolen (3 of 4 wallets compromised).
Rounded to 11000 BTC
* Bitcoin7 may have disappeared with more (u.b. 15000 BTC).
Equivalent USD: 50000 $ (rounded to nearest ten thousand)
Bitcoin7 later shut down because of this hack. The magnitude served as a reminder to the Bitcoin community to stop trusting new exchanges without identification.


~October 2011 Mt. Gox Loss
Time: 2011-10-28T21:11 (UTC) [blockchain time, off by up to three hours]
Victim: Mt. Gox
Status: Coins destroyed (no thief)
Amount: Exactly 2609.36304319 BTC
Equivalent USD: 8115.12 $ (wt. avg price)
Transactions: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. Gox fully reimbursed customers after this incident.


~Bitscalper Scam
Time: January 2012 to March/April 2012
Suspects:
Alberto Armandi
bitdaytrade @BitcoinTalk
bitscalper @BitcoinTalk
jjfarren @BitcoinTalk
Victim: Users of Bitscalper
Status: MiningBuddy (bitcointalk.org user) attempted to reorganize bitscalper, but failed. No coins have been returned at all.
Amount: Estimate 1000 BTC (official estimate)
Equivalent USD: 5000 $ (wt. avg, rounded to nearest thousand)
Bitscalper was founded as an "arbitrage engine", and users were invited to deposit money. It was promising extremely high and unrealistic returns. As a result, it was suspected of being a scam from the beginning, fears that were compounded due to a shady and anonymous management. After Bitscalper shut down without returning user funds, BitcoinTalk user MiningBuddy attempted to reform Bitscalper using the remnants of the engine. However, no success was found and the coins could not be returned.


~Bitcoin Savings and Trust
Time: 2011–2012
Victim: Creditors of First Pirate Savings and Trust, later Bitcoin Savings and Trust
Status: Trendon Shavers (perpetrator) may still repay
Amount: Estimated 200000 BTC; Upper bound 500000 BTC
References:
Blockchain Analysis used for 200000 BTC estimate
DailyTech article used for upper bound


~Andrew Nollan Scam
Time: February 2012
Victim: Investors of Shades Minoco, creditors of bitcointalk.org user "shakaru", investors of BitArb
Status: Andrew Nollan (a.k.a. shakaru[2])(thief) known but disappeared, repaid some (not included in amount)
Amount: Lower bound 2211.07786728 BTC, possibly more [1]
Equivalent USD: 10978 $ (wt. avg price, rounded to nearest $)
References:
[1]
[2]


~February 2012 Bitcoinica Theft
Time: February 2012 (also possibly prior)
Victim: Bitcoinica, LLC.
Status: Various thieves possible, untraceable exploit
Amount: unknown, est. 3000 BTC
Equivalent USD: 15000 $ (rounded to nearest thousand)


~Linode Hacks
Time: Late 2012-03-01, Early 2012-03-02
Victim: Bitcoinica, Bitcoin.cx mining pool (Marek Palatinus), Bitcoin Faucet, possible others
Status: Thief unknown, not caught. Linode employee suspected.
Amount:
Bitcoinica: 43554.02005417 BTC
Bitcoin.cx: 3094.45825078 BTC
Bitcoin faucet: 5 BTC (estimated, no tx)
Total: About 46653.47830495 BTC
Equivalent USD: 230468 $ (rounded to nearest $)
Transactions of interest: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 early March 2012, the New Jersey-based web and cloud hosting company Linode was suspected of robbing many popular Bitcoin services. A vulnerability in the customer support system was used to obtain administrator access to the servers. Once the Linode servers were compromised, eight accounts dealing with bitcoins were targeted. The hardest hit was the bitcoin trading platform, Bitcoinica. This resulted in the unauthorized transfer of BTC from the "hot wallets", a term used to describe operational withdrawal wallets, of the services affected. A severe bitcoin-denominated theft, the Linode theft also affected Tradehill, but no coins were stolen from them; instead, Tradehill had a short downtime because of the incident. In the aftermath of this theft, all the services migrated to other platforms and Linode remains with a negative connotation to this date.


~Betcoin Theft
Time:
Event Time
Theft Commences
Transaction: #1, #2 2012-04-11T10:55:54
Theft Continues
Transaction: #3 2012-04-11T12:15:49
Theft Culminates
Transaction: #4 2012-04-11T12:43:14
All times are blockchain time, and have possible error of up to 3 hours.
Victims: Betco.in, creditors
Status: Hacker not known. Some of creditors' deposits were repaid, around 2900 BTC outstanding.
Amount: Exactly 3171.50195016 BTC
Equivalent USD: 15509 $ (rounded to nearest $)
Transactions of interest:
266e4682abdf4932c4c271872ca9ba6bfdbe75941eb9ba4c4d81e4d3c7364e4b
40fc8f6b2f222fb2871a38a245132ed1eada9ff6aec8d46ebe74b29c64fd82a7
bf70ac1d2b702dbe0e14fbefb3a0cb2ff5ee5aa425cfe4249f16d6ede7b3ff14
92968a2331a02a3128460a64ba16fbf8d3a2fc79ebc8882300015d3ca0e4fb17
References:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=68066.msg848855#msg848855
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=82100.0
Similar to the Mooncoin Theft a year ago, and just as devastating, a gambling website's customers lost a large amount of money. This time, the owner took just as large a hit: all the deposits, plus non-live storage, were stolen. 2900 BTC remains to be refunded to creditors today.


~Tony Silk Road Scam
Time: 2012-04-20
Victim: Buyers on Silk Road
Status: Hacker's name (possibly pseudonym) determined to be "Tony"
Amount: Estimate 20000 BTC (estimate from Silk Road users)
Equivalent USD: 100000 $ (wt. avg price, rounded to nearest thousand)


~May 2012 Bitcoinica Hack
Time: 2012-05-12T11:19 (UTC) [blockchain time, off by up to three hours]
Victim: Bitcoinica, LLC
Status:
Hacker unknown, minimal coins were returned.
Venture capital group Wendon Group threatened legal action against Bitcoinica Consultancy.
Receivership in New Zealand ongoing.
Amount: Exactly 18547.66867623 BTC
Equivalent USD: 91306.46 $ (last Mt. Gox price)
Chief transaction of interest: 7a22917744aa9ed740faf3068a2f895424ed816ed1a04012b47df7a493f056e8
Zhou Tong, former founder of Bitcoinica, discovered an entry into Bitcoinica's Rackspace server through an excessively privileged compromised email address. This caused the theft of the entire "hot wallet", funds stored on-site, as well as the loss of the main database. No backups were kept. Bitcoinica shut down because of this incident. The claims process is still ongoing; however, Bitcoinica is now entering receivership.


~Bitcoin Syndicate Theft
Time: 2012-07-04T14:34:19 (Mt. Gox time)
Victims:
Bitcoin Syndicate
Paul Mumby
Shareholders on GLBSE
Suspect: IP 130.83.54.115
Status: Pending
Amount: Exactly 1852.61553553 BTC
Equivalent USD: 12134.61 $
Medium of theft: Mt. Gox
Transactions of interest: On Mt. Gox. Withdrawal transaction was 4c61d3639f010e30ad305b294cd128f381f58fc161d0badda1f39807dc2f12f7.
A hacker infiltrated the Mt. Gox account used by Bitcoin Syndicate, sold off the USD owned, and withdrew all balances.


~July 2012 Bitcoinica Theft
Time: 2012-07-13 (UTC)
Victims:
Bitcoinica, LLC
Creditors of Bitcoinica (former users of Bitcoinica)
Suspects:
Suspect Accused by Defended by Additional evidence
Zhou Tong AurumXChange
Mt. Gox Tihan Seale Selling bitcoins after event
Chen Jinghai Zhou Tong
Status: All funds returned
Amount: Exactly 40000.00000000 BTC (Mt. Gox Daily Limit)
Equivalent USD: 305200 $ (wt. avg, rounded to nearest $)
Medium of theft: On MtGox.
On July 13, 2012, a thief compromised the Bitcoinica Mt. Gox account. The thief made off with around 30% of Bitcoinica's bitcoin assets, which are likely to cost claimants of Bitcoinica debt. Additionally, 40000 USD was also reported to be stolen. The thief is still unknown at this point, but the theft has supposedly been entirely returned. This theft further complicated the May 2012 Bitcoinica Hack.


~BTC-E Hack
Time:
Event Time
Commencing 2012-07-31 00:07 (UTC)
Action taken 2012-07-31 06:30 (UTC)
Victim: btc-e.com
Suspects: BTC-E chat user MrWubbles
Status: Pending
Amount: Estimate 4500 BTC (Official estimate)
Equivalent USD: 42000 $ (rounded to nearest thousand)
Medium of theft: On BTC-E.
On July 31, 2012, the BTC-E Liberty Reserve API secret key was broken. This key was shorter than it needed to be at only 16 characters long. The attacker initiated many Liberty Reserve deposits and injected large amounts of USD into the system, which were quickly sold for BTC. Not all BTC was withdrawn; official estimates state that the scope was limited to 4500 BTC. Similar to the June 2011 Mt. Gox Incident, the BTC-E market was disturbed during the duration of the hack. The handling of this hack was widely applauded after BTC-E revealed they would cover the losses and revert to a backup made just before the hack.


~Bitfloor Theft
Time:
Event Time
Theft Commences
Transaction: #1 2012-09-04T03:07:39
Theft Continues
Transaction: #2, #3 2012-09-04T03:12:52
Theft Culminates
Transaction: #4, #5 2012-09-04T03:43:33
All times are blockchain time, and have possible error of up to 3 hours.
Victims: Bitfloor, creditors
Status: Hacker not known, but IP is 178.176.218.157.
Amount: Upper Bound 24086.17219307 BTC
Equivalent USD: 248088 $ (rounded to nearest)
Transactions of interest:
83f3c30dc4fa25afe57b85651b9bbc372e8789d81b08d6966ea81f524e0a02be
d5d23a05858236c379d2aa30886b97600506933bc46c6f2aab2e05da85e61ad2
358c873892016649ace8e9db4c59f98a6ca8165287ac80e80c52e621f5a26e46
f9d55dc4b8af65e15f856496335a29e2be40f128a7374c75b75529e864579f93
42ea472060118ee5aee801cdedbc4a3403f3708a87340660f766e2669f0afeb0
References:
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=105819.msg1159518#msg1159518
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=105818.0
Although the keys to the hot wallet of Bitfloor was secured, an unencrypted backup was mistakenly stored on some of the servers. After a hacker gained entry, most of not only the hot wallet but also the cold wallet was stolen. To this date, none of the coins have been returned by either the hacker to Bitfloor or Bitfloor to its creditors.

Limbo

~Kronos Hack
Time: ?
Suspects:
Alberto Armandi
bitdaytrade @BitcoinTalk
bitscalper @BitcoinTalk
jjfarren @BitcoinTalk
Victim: Kronos.io, liability onto:
Jonathon Ryan Owens
Matthew Neal Wright
Status: Legal action possibly pending
Amount: Estimate 4000 BTC (official estimate)
A serial scammer, Alberto Armandi reportedly hacked into a website he himself coded. The vulnerability was in the withdrawal script that Alberto coded, reportedly intentionally as a backdoor. Information about Kronos is highly uncertain, due to a lack of communication. Neither Jonathon Ryan Owens nor Matthew Neal Wright were responsive to demands for information.


Thefts not included

Some thefts in Bitcoin's history, although severe and damaging to Bitcoin users, did not involve the theft of over one thousand bitcoins. These thefts are listed below.
World Bitcoin Exchange, due to fraudulent activity, stole over 5000 BTC worth at the time in AUD. The total amount stolen was 25779.49 AUD. More information: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=65867.msg923845#msg923845
Tradehill was repeatedly hassled by Dwolla, and eventually dropped support after being scammed off 17000 USD. Later fraudulent transactions ended up costing the exchange even more, and after the March 2012 Linode Hacks they shut down, citing 100000 USD stolen or scammed through fraud.


Minor but notable thefts

Other thefts are minor, but are unique in some manner (for example, interesting methods or a first of its kind).
First recorded physical theft of bitcoins: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=52206.0
Coordinated hacking of BitcoinTalk accounts allowed theft of many "loaned" bitcoins: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=61500.0
Bitcointalk.org user "Goat" lost 400 BTC through sending to a wrong address. These bitcoins were later recovered: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=82600.0
On watch
This section is reserved for possible thefts and scams that bear mentioning. It is not an endorsement, and the presence on this list does not imply a scam. At the moment, no thefts are listed here.


Pirate default

It's over. I personally will offer sympathy to those who may have lost.

I'm at odds about what to do about this. On one side, the implications are clear: Pirate@40 willingly scammed hundreds off their money, which best estimates put at around 500000 BTC. Such an amount, making up more than 5% of all BTC in circulation, in unprecedented in the history of Bitcoin. It is my duty to include it in this list, as not doing so would be dishonest. However, by doing so, the complexity of this situation requires restructuring at the least.

I am looking for community input into this issue. There are missing data which I deem important, and I welcome any estimates for the values I list below.
Total BTC defaulted on
Total investors directly with Pirate
Total investors exposed through defaulting passthroughs
Total investors exposed through all passthroughs, including ones that compensated partially or fully
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=83794.0​

That's not to even count the untraceable losses due to market manipulations.


If bitcoin was "engineered" to do anything, it is to be transferred over the internet without requiring a third party.


It's also engineered to appreciate artificially on an asymptotic scale after allowing the creators to mine huge fortunes of bitcoins at little computational cost.


This is the same logical fallacy you've been called on numerous times already, yet you still can't seem to wrap your mind around it.

The exchanges have everything to do with the operation of Bitcoin. If there were no exchanges, there would be no Bitcoin trading or commerce at all.


That is because the bitcoin exchanges are completely and utterly irrelevant to bitcoin itself.

Nothing about the bitcoin algorithm requires the establishment of exchanges.


You keep on repeating that same compositional fallacy. Why is it so difficult for you to understand this?

There's more to that economy than just the Bitcoin software that people run on their computers. If the entirety of Bitcoin was just the software, it would amount to nothing but a computer game with absolutely no purpose in the real world. Without exchanges, bitcoins would be completely infungible with other currencies, hence completely useless. So the exchanges are 100% mission critical services to the operation of this economy. If we're discussing the situation of bitcoins as a "currency" or a "commodity" exchangeable in the marketplace, then you must consider the entirety of the system including the exchanges.

Arguing that the exchange security is irrelevant is like arguing that car crashes are irrelevant to the safety of automobiles because of the reliability of the internal combustion engine.


Without them, only a bit of private trading would be possible and bitcoins would probably cost a lot less. There is no rule that says that the value of bitcoin has to be enhanced in any way.


But that's not how Bitcoin works, is it? Bitcoin has exchanges. Why do you think that is?

Despite your own musings about what may or may not be "irrelevant to the bitcoin algorithm," the fact is that Bitcoin is what it is, and that includes the exchanges that allow it to be fungible with other currencies. I'm not going to let you evade discussing the reality of the situation by venturing into rhetorical questions.


The only reason the exchanges exist is because bitcoin has proved immensely popular and a demand for them sprung up.


The exchanges exist because Bitcoin could not be monetized without them. Without the exchanges, Bitcoin would be completely worthless to anyone except a minuscule community of hobbyists.

Most importantly, you cannot deny that the exchanges exist and are essential to Bitcoin's current model of operation, so you cannot just handwave them away.


Yes, it bears repeating over and over until the message sinks in:
There is NO scheme, scam, system, economy, pyramid or anything else. There is only bitcoins.

:crazy:

You sound like a cult member or religious nut spouting doctrine.

Bitcoin is a system just as much any other computer program is a system, just as the US Federal Reserve System is a system, just like even the Internet itself is a system.

Bitcoin also has an economy around it. The movements of monetary value within that economy can be measured and observed over time, just as in any other economy. The "Bitcoin charts" are rather obvious evidence of that.

I already explained how Bitcoin takes in money among a large base of investors, and redistributes those funds according to a structure wherein a small portion of the early adopters hold the largest share of monetary value. By taking in money from many and redistributing it to a few, Bitcoin operates in the manner of a pyramid scheme.
 
Last edited:
John Albert said:
Today, 10:56 AM
Today, 01:17 PM
Today, 01:18 PM
Whenever I fail to get a post confirmed or a JREF page takes excessively long to load up, the culprits invariably turn out to be "burstnet" or "pagead".

I have now installed "Simple Adblock" and all of the JREF pages now load up almost instantly. (I hope this doesn't cost JREF too much money :D).


Bitcoin investors are paying a dollar amount to buy into a fantasy. Bitcoins represent no real world thing.
It is not possible to tell anymore whether you are referring to bitcoin's lack of physical existence or its lack of "intrinsic" value. Ever ytime you are challenged on the "bitcoin is nothing" mantra, you change tack.

I suspect that it is no coincidence that "fantasy" could be interpreted either way.

Just like the tickets on the "Airplane Game."
I would never have mentioned the airplane game if I knew you had such a complicated code of values regarding gambling.

The irony is that most "legitimate" forms of gambling are "unfair" meaning that the punters will lose their money if they keep playing the game long enough. Where does that fit into your gambling code?

For what reason was Bitcoin created in the first place?

What benefits does Bitcoin bring to the table that make it better suited to that purpose than previously existing solutions?

Why go through the trouble of implementing a fake currency when the problem could be more easily solved by creating a distributed, peer-to-peer payment system for existing currencies?
Why does there have to be a "big problem" for bitcoin to solve?

Obviously, somebody had an idea for a peerless currency transfer mechanism and wanted to give it a "soak test". If the algorithm holds up in the hostile environment of the internet then any number of useful spin-off technologies could evolve.

I'm not going to speculate about the motives of the designers nor the people who spend money on bitcoin. It is totally irrelevant.

The chart you've posted looks pretty good from the long-range perspective. But zooming in to view the day-to-day activity of this market tells a different story entirely.

Look at the large number of precipitous drop-offs where the share price has fallen drastically, often losing a major percentage of its total value. The reason the Bitcoin economy is so unstable is because it's a small and very slanted playing field that can be easily gamed by a tiny fraction of outrageously powerful players. Do you realize what happens every time one of the major players cashes in a huge load of BTC? Lots of people who are in the process of selling their coins (and even people just using Bitcoin for its ostensible purpose as a currency) are effectively getting screwed. The market drops so fast that you can't transact the exchange fast enough to avoid a huge loss in value. And there's no telling when such a drop is going to occur. You can get screwed out of your money at any moment of any day.
There is no denying the long term trend. You can find days where the bitcoin price fell "significantly" but the price would recover again.

. . . craze . . . scam . . . economic bubble . . . Madoff Securities . . . pyramid . . . Ponzi schemes . . . etc
This is just pure attempted word association. Bitcoin isn't associated with any of those words.

The whole premise of a scam is to beguile somebody into giving up their money freely, by raising false hopes by means of a compelling story (like a "revolutionary digital cryptocurrency that will revolutionize the world").
That doesn't apply to bitcoin. The only hopes being raised come from the information you see on the price charts.

The entire premise of Bitcoin being a currency is fraudulent to start with. Bitcoin is aggressively promoted as a general-use currency, but it's not a currency. It lacks most of the fundamental elements that define a currency. That fact ought to raise some red flags right away.
You are just splitting hairs on the definition of "currency". It is not government sanctioned legal tender but you are trying to imply that it can't even perform the function of "medium of exchange".

What it really amounts to is a crooked investment scam based on a fraudulent "virtual commodity" that represents nothing real. You'd have to look pretty damn hard to find an investment more foolish than just throwing your money away at nothing.
When you say "nothing real" are you referring to the lack of physical substance or lack of "intrinsic value"? :rolleyes:

I've backed up my position with facts, logical reasoning and sound ethical principles. You have yet to rebut any of my arguments with anything substantial.
I've backed up my position with facts, logical reasoning and sound ethical principles. You have yet to rebut any of my arguments with anything substantial. :D

Your entire case consists of "begging the question". You have assumed that bitcoin is a fraudulent rip off and used that to prove that bitcoin is a fraudulent rip off.

I haven't "invented" anything. The "system" I've described is the actual operation of the Bitcoin protocol, the software that implements that protocol, and the various financial services that support that protocol being used as a means for exchange, and the market that has developed around all those things.

That you deny the existence of any form of "system" speaks volumes about your own closed-minded, willful ignorance about this cockamamie "investment opportunity" you're become involved with.
Bitcoin was released onto the internet and a gambling industry soon formed around it.

Can you prove it is anything more than that?

I've never heard of this "Bitcoin algorithm test" before. Please link to somewhere I can read about it.

:confused:
:rolleyes:

I was referring to the scam in which some programmers created a fake, pre-cornered economy for themselves wherein they could feed off the monetary investments of credulous rubes. It's most certainly a crime under several US Federal codes, but not really all that shocking to be honest.
I thought this was about bitcoin.

Not when those "things" are false investment securities . . .
. . . <snip> . . .
. . . So I pointed out that yes, in fact there are several "rules" (Federal criminal codes, in fact) governing the industry of marketing financial instruments, and that Bitcoin violates a number of them.

Now you're turning that around and saying "it's got nothing to do with Bitcoin"?!?
I'll admit I missed the point of the quoted legislation. It appeared to be showing that there are laws to be complied with when setting up a company.

What you are actually trying to show is that there are laws associated with the trade of securities. This is hardly surprising. A security is a claim on ones future income or assets. It is a debt instrument. It would not do to have the securities industry run by cowboys. If a bunch of securities turn bad then it doesn't just affect the people trading in them. It can threaten the entire economy (subprime crisis).

The problem is that bitcoin is not a security. No matter how many of the bitcoins you have in your possession, you don't have one iota of a claim on anything. If the price of bitcoins crashed permanently for any reason, the only people who would get hurt would be the people who traded in bitcoin so the securities act doesn't apply.

I was actually criticizing your unprincipled sense of ethics. Your impertinent brush-off speaks volumes about your true character.
Do your really think your character is suprerior to mine just because of your views on gambling? (You can start a thread about it but your views on the subject are all over the place).

Bitcoin is fundamentally unfair because it's a crooked market wherein all the monetary value comes from new investors paying money in but the majority of the capital is owned by only 1% of the players who initially paid nothing yet who control well over half the resources, and who regularly exploit that advantage to manipulate the market.

There, I managed to cram most of the meat of it into one single run-on sentence. *whew*
You have no basis whatsoever to claim that the top 1% of bitcoin holders paid "nothing" for their bitcoins. Whethere any of them did or not is totally irrelevant.

I never said people are being "manipulated" into buying bitcoins.

What I actually said was, Bitcoin is a manipulative system.
A "manipulative system" that doesn't manipulate people into buying bitcoins isn't very manuipulative.

It's manipulative in that its promoters falsely advertise it as a general-use currency,
That part is true (depending on what precisely you mean by "currency").
it is marketed towards political radicals whose ideology clouds their financial judgment;
"political radicals whose ideology clouds their financial judgment" have discussed how bitcoin fits in with their ideology. That is a very different thing. In any case, these aren't the people who are buying bitcoins. The gamblers are.
it hides critical details about its design beneath layers of complexity, it relies on disingenuous metaphors such as "mining"
That one never occurred to me. Deliberately employing poor technical writers to obfuscate the technical details of bitcoin is a devilishly clever plot.
to justify creating a clearly rigged system intended to disproportionately benefit its creators, and its market is unfairly manipulated by a small cartel of users who are anonymous.
You need to make up some more details if you are going to sell this.

You really need to check your attitude there. You're betraying the weakness of your position by relying on all these tiresome ad hominem attacks. Raising awareness about a financial scam does not constitute "imposing moral values."
But falsely calling something a "scam" and inventing all sorts of stories about how this evil thing was plotted and hatched is.

Good point. I'm probably wrong about that point. In fact there's pretty good evidence in this thread and elsewhere that at least some of them are total douchebags with no qualms about entering into a fraudulent enterprise, so long as they end up on the receiving end of somebody else getting swindled.
Some gamblers win and some gamblers lose. Or to put it in your more moralistic manner, some gamblers are "on the receiving end of somebody else getting swindled". (Except when it is "legitimate" gambling of course).


That's not to even count any untraceable losses due to deliberate market manipulations.
Yes, if you fail to take proper security measures or if you store your bitcoins at an exchange centre that has inadequate security then your bitcoins are at risk of being stolen. Is somebody else supposed to be responsible for what security measures you take?

It's also specifically engineered to appreciate artificially on an asymptotic scale, after allowing the creators to mine huge fortunes of bitcoins at little computational cost. You still haven't given a single good reason why on Earth they should have set up their "currency" to behave in such a way, if not for the explicit purpose of enriching themselves for free on the money invested by others.
I gather you are talking about the 21M limit again. Nobody can "inflate" bitcoin away. Some might say this is necessary with a deregulated currency and some would say it is not a good idea. Not you however. For you it is proof to a mathematical certainly that the originators intended bitcoin to be a scam.

You keep on repeating that same compositional fallacy. Why is it so difficult for you to understand this?
Actually you are continuously repeating the fallacy of division.You assume that the problems of bitcoin exchanges is a problem of bitcoin itself.

No doubt, you believe that the designers were in cahoots with gambling operators to set up a sting operation.

Without exchanges, bitcoins would be completely infungible with other currencies, hence completely useless.
. . . . .
Why are you arguing how Bitcoin might work if there are no exchanges, instead of addressing the way it actually works, exchanges and all?
Aren't you being a bit hypoctritical?

You could regulate exchanges if you wanted (tax them even) or abolish them entirely and drive the whole thing underground. But nothing you do to the exchanges or the associated gambling industry will change anything about bitcoin itself (except perhaps the price you could get for it).

:crazy:

You sound like a cult member or religious nut spouting doctrine.
Just a word of advice: constantly putting up the "crazy" symbol make you look like an angry loser.

I already explained how Bitcoin takes in money among a large base of investors, and redistributes those funds according to a structure wherein a small portion of the early adopters hold the largest share of monetary value. By taking in money from many and redistributing it to a few, Bitcoin operates in the manner of a pyramid scheme.
You have repeated this many times but repetition isn't proof. It doesn't even make any sense. The only people who make money out of bitcoinsare those who sell them and then only if they paid less (including nothing) for them than they sell them for. If all these "early adopters" are still holding onto their stash then they haven't made any money yet (and might not make any at all if your wish comes true).
 
Last edited:
Wait, so in response to both our requests to hear more about this "test" you seem to claim BTC is, you roll your eyes ?
I'm a little skeptical that John Albert doesn't know what I am referring to. One of the oldest tricks (fallacies) is to say, "I don't understand you therefore you must be talking nonsense".

Nevertheless, an explanation is in my previous post.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom