How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
No I didn't.

How does that demonstrate that Bitcoins are a test of the algorithm ?

You said:

The test is whether the bitcoin network (not the exchanges) is secure enough to work without resorting to external authorities.

Which implies there's a test. You have yet to demonstrate that. Showing that it could be a test or how it could be a test doesn't achieve this.
 
Are you really going to split hairs over whether putting bitcoin on the internet constitutes a test? That seems such a trivial point to me.
 
In what sense might the bitcoin protocol need to resort to external authorities? Do you mean in the sense of an ANSI like body to oversee it in some way, or something else? I'm no economist, but surely almost everything involving dollars/bitcoins that requires control is associated with the way people use it rather than the dollars/bitcoins themselves. I guess there is the rate at which it is produced, but apart from that, what might there be relating to the protocol that would need outside assistance?
 
By the way, if a single mining group exceeds the 50% threshold, would that constitute a failure of the test?
 
The GLBSE ("Bitcoin Stock Exchange") is offline until sunday:

Hacking?
Fraud?
SEC crackdown?

The fun never stops with Bitcoin...
 
It is not possible to tell anymore whether you are referring to bitcoin's lack of physical existence or its lack of "intrinsic" value. Ever ytime you are challenged on the "bitcoin is nothing" mantra, you change tack.


I'm talking about both. Bitcoin's lack of intrinsic value is a result of the fact that it's backed up by nothing at all.


Bitcoin investors are paying a dollar amount to buy into a fantasy. Bitcoins represent no real world thing.
I suspect that it is no coincidence that "fantasy" could be interpreted either way.


The fantasy is fueled by the promotional efforts behind Bitcoin, intended to draw in investors.


I would never have mentioned the airplane game if I knew you had such a complicated code of values regarding gambling.


I do not have any "complicated code of values regarding gambling."

Do you mean to tell me you really don't understand that the Airplane Game is a scam?

Do you really and truly fail to understand why it's a scam?

It's actually very simple. The "Airplane Game" is not gambling. It is most definitely a scam. Pyramid schemes like the "Airplane Game" are generally recognized as scams by financial institutions, economists, financial advisors, regulatory authorities, and law enforcement agencies worldwide.

Why do you suppose all these experts and authorities consider pyramid schemes as scams?

The reason is simple. They're scams because they solicit investments in a pretend commodity that does not exist; the investments are literally applied toward nothing of intrinsic value. They're scams because they present a fictional construct as an investment opportunity, then take the money to enrich themselves.

And Bitcoin does the exact same thing. It takes money from investors and applies it to nothing of any intrinsic value. Instead of applying the money to something of real value, Bitcoin funnels it into a structure that is controlled by a very small oligarchy who can manipulate the value at will and cash in on it at the expense of other investors.


The irony is that most "legitimate" forms of gambling are "unfair" meaning that the punters will lose their money if they keep playing the game long enough. Where does that fit into your gambling code?


In an honest, above-board gambling casino, the odds are known (or at least can be computed). That's a big difference from a rigged game like Bitcoin where the returns can be controlled at will by the creators.


Why does there have to be a "big problem" for bitcoin to solve?


Because otherwise the whole concept of a "digital cryptocurrency" is nothing but a false pretense. Do you not understand that misrepresenting something is fundamentally dishonest?

I'm not alleging that Bitcoin was definitely created without any ideological goals in mind beyond making money for its creators, but the way it's designed is extremely suspect. It definitely appears to be designed to operate as a scam.


Obviously, somebody had an idea for a peerless currency transfer mechanism and wanted to give it a "soak test". If the algorithm holds up in the hostile environment of the internet then any number of useful spin-off technologies could evolve.


If that's indeed the case (it isn't quite so obvious to me), then it's extremely irresponsible of them to unleash something with the potential to cause widespread financial ruin for investors, just for the purpose of checking on a hunch.


I'm not going to speculate about the motives of the designers nor the people who spend money on bitcoin. It is totally irrelevant.


So let me try to figure out what aspects of Bitcoin you think are irrelevant:

  • the motives of the Bitcoin creators are irrelevant
  • the fact that the promoters of Bitcoin disingenuously refer to it as a "currency" is irrelevant
  • the fact that bitcoins have no intrinsic value but still cost money is irrelevant
  • the fact that they've been pre-programmed to cause artificial scarcity and overvaluation is irrelevant
  • the fact that the Bitcoin exchanges are fundamentally untrustworthy, regularly losing (or stealing) peoples' money is irrelevant
  • the fact that Bitcoin economy is overrun with swindlers and thieves is irrelevant
  • the fact that the entire thing can be manipulated by the top 1% to rip off investors for the benefit of the creators is irrelevant

So what is relevant? Just the fact that the crypto hasn't been cracked yet? The fact that you can make a little chump change wheeling and dealing in this fraudulent economy?

ETA: Oh yeah, for some reason you also argued that IP law was somehow relevant to Bitcoin, but you still haven't gotten around to explaining that one.


There is no denying the long term trend. You can find days where the bitcoin price fell "significantly" but the price would recover again.


As I said before, the fact that the "greater fools" still keep flocking to Bitcoin does not mean it's not a scam.

You're still ignoring the fact that the charts indicate an extreme volatility that makes Bitcoin extremely risky as an investment and practically useless as a medium of exchange.


This is just pure attempted word association. Bitcoin isn't associated with any of those words.


"Word association" based on facts and logic, perhaps. I've shown numerous similarities between Bitcoin and a number of financial scams. Those similarities do indeed support my argument that Bitcoin's functional operation generally resembles a scam.


That doesn't apply to bitcoin. The only hopes being raised come from the information you see on the price charts.


There's significant hype going on within the "Bitcoin community," much of it based on lies and false hopes.


You are just splitting hairs on the definition of "currency". It is not government sanctioned legal tender but you are trying to imply that it can't even perform the function of "medium of exchange".


It can indeed be used as a medium of exchange, but it's extremely ill-suited to that purpose. Calling it a "currency" is at best a lot of disingenuous media hype.


When you say "nothing real" are you referring to the lack of physical substance or lack of "intrinsic value"?


Both. The one is rather contingent upon the other.


Your entire case consists of "begging the question". You have assumed that bitcoin is a fraudulent rip off and used that to prove that bitcoin is a fraudulent rip off.


This is just wrong. I'm not begging any question.

I've looked at the facts about Bitcoin, and given heavy consideration to the subject. I've even cited sources to back up my points wherever possible, which is a lot more than most people around here bother to do.

I have examined how Bitcoin operates, the way it's marketed, the way it's being used, and the widespread outcome of its use, and have reached a provisional conclusion based on those observations.

Of course I don't expect my arguments to influence the 3 or 4 faithful Bitcoin enthusiasts and apologists who've argued against my position in this thread. They all have their own reasons for investing their money or confidence in this thing. Some folks see it through the filter of their own specific ideological biases, and others seem to want to justify it as a harmless opportunity to make a quick, easy buck.

As a disinterested critical thinker, I see no reason to give Bitcoin the benefit of the doubt. From all outward appearances, it has many hallmarks of a scam. It appears to operate like a scam. Bitcoin makes the news every month or two whenever some exchange gets "hacked," somebody gets their "wallet" stolen, a bunch of people fall prey to a pyramid scam, or some new malware comes along to leech off the Bitcoin economy.


Bitcoin was released onto the internet and a gambling industry soon formed around it.

Can you prove it is anything more than that?


Anything more than what?

Call me suspicious, but from the way this thing's been designed to operate, I suspect that the original intention of the Bitcoin creators all along was to create a rigged "currency market" that would lure investors for gambling purposes, that they could leech off of become rich. Even if they were honestly interested in creating a real, usable currency, you can tell by the engineering specs that at some point in the project's development, the lure of wealth must have sidetracked them from their original goal.


I'll admit I missed the point of the quoted legislation. It appeared to be showing that there are laws to be complied with when setting up a company.

...

The problem is that bitcoin is not a security...


Not just securities or companies. Any kind of financial instrument offered for sale for investors to buy into needs to be registered and regulated by the SEC, otherwise it's illegal.

I seriously doubt they'd touch some fraudulent sinkhole like Bitcoin though.


No matter how many of the bitcoins you have in your possession, you don't have one iota of a claim on anything.


Now you're getting it! Does that mean you're beginning to understand how something with zero intrinsic worth being sold $15 per share can be viewed as a scam?


If the price of bitcoins crashed permanently for any reason, the only people who would get hurt would be the people who traded in bitcoin so the securities act doesn't apply.

If the market crashed permanently tomorrow, everybody holding bitcoins that they paid good money for would be **** out of luck. A lot of merchants who accepted bitcoins in exchange for goods and services would be **** out of luck as well.


Do your really think your character is suprerior to mine just because of your views on gambling?


No, I think you're using "gambling" as an excuse to justify participating in a fraudulent con game with the hope of making money off a bunch of anonymous strangers.

Quite frankly, judging by your posts in this thread, you seem to profess a certain apathy where ethics are concerned. Pardon me if I'm wrong about this, but you appear to take the position that it doesn't really matter where one's money comes from, so long as one has enough of it; I consider that attitude to be unconscionable, and indicative of low character.

Not that I'm any kind of angel myself, but at least I try to consider the repercussions of my vices and appetites on the society around me, and act responsibly so as not to cause undue harm to others. Avoiding participation in predatory business opportunities is one of those things that I consider to be a "given." Your mileage may vary, apparently.


(You can start a thread about it but your views on the subject are all over the place).


You have no idea what my views on gambling are, so you have no business making such a presumptuous statement.


You have no basis whatsoever to claim that the top 1% of bitcoin holders paid "nothing" for their bitcoins. Whethere any of them did or not is totally irrelevant.


You seem not to comprehend the economics of how this thing works. Or maybe you're just pretending you don't, or else you don't even want to try to understand because you feel you've got too much invested in it already and would rather retain your plausible deniability than turn back and admit you're wrong.

The early adopters had over 2 years to accumulate vast amounts of BTC at very low-moderate difficulty with very little competition before Bitcoin started to blow up in April-May of 2011. That gave them a tremendous advantage over any of the miners who came on the scene later. By the time Bitcoin started getting heavily capitalized in June of 2011, the early adopters already possessed more BTC than anyone will ever be able to accumulate from then on. Within a few weeks, they suddenly were able to cash in their previously worthless BTC for enormous amounts of money, effectively gaming the market at the same time.

Now I don't know exactly how many of these people there are. I suppose I could try to estimate based on the Bitcoin stats, but even so I wouldn't how many accounts apiece they may own, or how many accounts they might share among themselves. If you just look at the basic mathematics of this thing it's obvious that 1% of BTC holders possessing over 50% of all units in existence is a hugely unfair advantage.

How can you trust any kind of investment strategy where the potential for abuse is so glaringly obvious?

Especially considering the huge amount of fraud, theft and probable graft we see reported in the news on a monthly or weekly basis?


A "manipulative system" that doesn't manipulate people into buying bitcoins isn't very manuipulative.

That part is true (depending on what precisely you mean by "currency").
"political radicals whose ideology clouds their financial judgment" have discussed how bitcoin fits in with their ideology. That is a very different thing. In any case, these aren't the people who are buying bitcoins. The gamblers are.
Some gamblers win and some gamblers lose. Or to put it in your more moralistic manner, some gamblers are "on the receiving end of somebody else getting swindled". (Except when it is "legitimate" gambling of course).


Your entire "gambling" argument is disingenuous at best. A rigged system like Bitcoin, a Ponzi scheme or a pyramid scheme is not fair gambling by any measure.


That one never occurred to me. Deliberately employing poor technical writers to obfuscate the technical details of bitcoin is a devilishly clever plot. You need to make up some more details if you are going to sell this.


Strawman argument. I never said that.

Maybe I didn't make myself clear. What I meant to say is that Bitcoin's excessive technical complexity tends to befuddle users from understanding of how it actually works, and that confusion can lead to foolish investment decisions.


Yes, if you fail to take proper security measures or if you store your bitcoins at an exchange centre that has inadequate security then your bitcoins are at risk of being stolen. Is somebody else supposed to be responsible for what security measures you take?


Where the exchanges are concerned, security is out of users' hands. Nobody really knows who those people are, and even the largest and "most reliable" of exchanges have "lost" huge amounts of their clients' money.


I gather you are talking about the 21M limit again. Nobody can "inflate" bitcoin away. Some might say this is necessary with a deregulated currency and some would say it is not a good idea. Not you however. For you it is proof to a mathematical certainly that the originators intended bitcoin to be a scam.


No, I'm talking about the exponential ramp of artificial scarcity that's built into the system. No economist in his right mind would argue that's a reasonable model for a currency, "deregulated" or not.



Actually you are continuously repeating the fallacy of division.You assume that the problems of bitcoin exchanges is a problem of bitcoin itself.


Wrong. Bitcoin is not a closed system. It is tied into the outside economy at large through the exchanges, otherwise nobody would be able to invest in it. Therefore, the exchanges are business-critical to the operation of Bitcoin, so it would be wrong to exclude them from consideration of Bitcoin as a whole.


No doubt, you believe that the designers were in cahoots with gambling operators to set up a sting operation.


Another strawman. I never said, nor even implied anything like that.


You could regulate exchanges if you wanted (tax them even) or abolish them entirely and drive the whole thing underground. But nothing you do to the exchanges or the associated gambling industry will change anything about bitcoin itself (except perhaps the price you could get for it).


You're a fool if you really believe that.

Permanently taking down the exchanges would certainly kill Bitcoin. Nobody would bother with it if they didn't think they could speculate on it to make money, because it's practically useless for any other purpose.



Just a word of advice: constantly putting up the "crazy" symbol make you look like an angry loser.


And constantly saying crazy and stupid things makes you appear crazy and/or stupid.


You have repeated this many times but repetition isn't proof. It doesn't even make any sense. The only people who make money out of bitcoinsare those who sell them and then only if they paid less (including nothing) for them than they sell them for. If all these "early adopters" are still holding onto their stash then they haven't made any money yet (and might not make any at all if your wish comes true).


I already explained in a nutshell how the Bitcoin market works. That you cannot be bothered to read or apply yourself to understanding is not my problem.
 
Last edited:
If the market crashed permanently tomorrow, everybody holding bitcoins that they paid good money for would be **** out of luck. A lot of merchants who accepted bitcoins in exchange for goods and services would be **** out of luck as well.

I'm not sure it could permanently crash, unless the algorithm is cracked, though. Even if the market crashed because somehow the major holders managed to cash in on all or most of their bitcoins, the faithful will continue to use it, allowing the BTC to gain value again. In fact, one could argue that, assuming the designers had this in mind, they can continue to make money off of it through several such "crashes", which they will engineer themselves.
 
In what sense might the bitcoin protocol need to resort to external authorities? Do you mean in the sense of an ANSI like body to oversee it in some way, or something else?
I don't know which post you are referring to but nobody has said that the bitcoin protocol needs external regulation. The protocol has been designed to be immuned to human intervention. The generation rate is internally programmed and no bitcoins can be created except through mining.

I'm no economist, but surely almost everything involving dollars/bitcoins that requires control is associated with the way people use it rather than the dollars/bitcoins themselves.
Presently, transferring money from one person to another requires the co-operation of the banks and the amount of money we have in the economy is directly related to how much money the banks have loaned out (fractional reserve banking).

By the way, if a single mining group exceeds the 50% threshold, would that constitute a failure of the test?
Not according to the information I have seen so far. "Double spending" might become possible if the receiver doesn't wait for block confirmation of the transaction but once the transaction has been confirmed, nothing in the bitcoin protocol makes it possible for anybody to take the coins off you (although data files can still be stolen).
 
Not according to the information I have seen so far. "Double spending" might become possible if the receiver doesn't wait for block confirmation of the transaction but once the transaction has been confirmed, nothing in the bitcoin protocol makes it possible for anybody to take the coins off you (although data files can still be stolen).

What does that have to do with the 1% vs 50% thing ?

I think you would have to do more than just "pump and dump" to make money this way.

Why ? Sell a chunk of BTC, watch the price go down, buy as many BTC as possible, price go up, etc.
 
Not according to the information I have seen so far. "Double spending" might become possible if the receiver doesn't wait for block confirmation of the transaction but once the transaction has been confirmed, nothing in the bitcoin protocol makes it possible for anybody to take the coins off you (although data files can still be stolen).
Reverse transactions that he sends while he's in control. This has the potential to double-spend transactions that previously had already been seen in the block chain.
Prevent some or all transactions from gaining any confirmations
Prevent some or all other miners from mining any valid blocks

https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Weaknesses#Attacker_has_a_lot_of_computing_power

Preventing other miners from mining, or at least reducing the effectiveness, might be worth doing..? It just seems like a bit of a **** up in the design that such large blocks of compute power should have formed. Presumably there is some game theory advantage in bitcoin that encourages this.
 
The attacker can't:
  • Reverse other people's transactions
  • Prevent transactions from being sent at all (they'll show as 0/unconfirmed)
  • Change the number of coins generated per block
  • Create coins out of thin air
  • Send coins that never belonged to him
It seems that the most an attacker can do is minor mischief.
 
So what is relevant? Just the fact that the crypto hasn't been cracked yet?

Yes.


Well I'm sorry, but that's empirically wrong. It's like saying the motor is the only relevant attribute of a car.

It's also very very foolish to rely entirely on a single aspect of a security model while ignoring other aspects that have been proven untrustworthy.

Bitcoin without exchanges is nothing but a networking protocol. It would lose all value and disappear from the economic landscape overnight if there was suddenly no way to exchange BTC for real money.

That you refuse to acknowledge that fact demonstrates your intellectual dishonesty in this discussion.


I'm a little skeptical that John Albert doesn't know what I am referring to. One of the oldest tricks (fallacies) is to say, "I don't understand you therefore you must be talking nonsense".


In the face of an accusation like this, I demand that you point out exactly where I've done any such thing.

Throughout this discussion you've been making obtuse statements and refusing to back them up. Don't try to turn that around now and spin it as if I'm the one positing an argument from incredulity.


It seems that the most an attacker can do is minor mischief.


Reversing transactions, double-spending (stealing, basically) and waging DoS attacks on transaction processing and monetary expansion amount to rather more than "minor mischief." That kind of activity undermines the integrity of the whole system.

Psionl0, throughout this discussion you've never failed to either minimize or outright deny every single one of the many significant shortcomings of Bitcoin without even thinking twice. Why are you advocating so fervently for this thing?


You got the order wrong. It's put a big chunk on the market, watch the price go down, sell for bugger all.


:boggled:

What the hell are you talking about? That's a recipe for losing money!

The object is to buy low and sell high.

After dumping a big chunk on the market, the price will be down. Why would you want to sell low?

I can understand why an investor with your level of financial acumen would be drawn to a contrivance like Bitcoin.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom