How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
I think you are talking past my point and drawing some wrong conclusions.
My conclusion is that bitcoin is unsuitable as a currency because it has no long term growth.

To be inflation/deflation neutral, the quantity of any currency needs to match the quantity of goods produces/sold/bought in the long term. That's basic QTM theory.
That sounds like your conclusion too.

The use of two parallel currencies has centuries long precedent and Gresham's law, "weak currency drives out strong", applies.
Bitcoin could provide an interesting counter to Gresham's law (assuming it becomes a currency).

Traditionally, Gresham's law meant that people hoarded their gold while spending their paper money. The point being that paper money is easier to spend than bullion. With bitcoin, the opposite is the case. You can send bitcoins person to person at minimum cost and without involving a bank. Ironically, since it takes at least 10 minutes to do a bitcoin transaction, you would need banks to handle the small EFTPOS transactions that would take too long to do with bitcoin directly.
 
If you think the airplane game involves intellectual property then I must be talking way over your head.


No, I think that the Airplane Game has nothing at all to do with "intellectual property," and neither does Bitcoin. I think that's just a red herring intended to spin this discussion off into another irrelevant direction.

Why don't you try to explain how you figure "intellectual property" has anything at all to do with Bitcoin vs. government-backed legal tender.


Well that's better than seeing Adam Cohen's words all the time.


Again with the ad hominem attacks, but no statements of any real substance.

Point out a single instance where I plagiarized Adam Cohen.


The fact that you think that voting rights addresses the share price speculation issue seems almost retarded to me.


What "speculation issue"? Stock market speculation is irrelevant to the fact that Bitcoin operates as a scam.

So people speculate on stock prices. Big deal. That doesn't mean the stock market is just as big a con game as Bitcoin. You're trying to compare two very different things because of a shared superficial similarity.

Yeah, people buy and speculate on stocks. People buy and speculate on commodities. BFD.

People buy and speculate on Bitcoin too. But that's where the similarities end, because stocks and commodities represent real-world things, whereas Bitcoin represents nothing but imaginary value based on wishful thinking. Comparing bitcoins (imaginary money backed by nothing) to shareholders owning stock in a company is one of the most "retarded" arguments I've seen in this thread.


Unfortunately it also shows that you don't understand a single word that I post.


You apparently don't even understand the things you post.
 
Last edited:
No, I think that the Airplane Game has nothing at all to do with "intellectual property," and neither does Bitcoin. I think that's just a red herring intended to spin this discussion off into another irrelevant direction.

Why don't you try to explain how you figure "intellectual property" has anything at all to do with Bitcoin vs. government-backed legal tender.
Then it is time for you to research the concept of intellectual property.

No matter how incomprehensible it seems to you, "virtual" doesn't mean "nothing".
 
Then it is time for you to research the concept of intellectual property.

No matter how incomprehensible it seems to you, "virtual" doesn't mean "nothing".

It also doesn't mean "intellectual property", so why don't you explain how you think intellectual property law applies to Bitcoins?
 
er . . . 0.2g of gold? (I bet you thought I would say that bitcoins are worth their weight in gold :D)

Hoo boy. Let me put it this way: When you're standing on a termite-ridden, two-legged stool balanced atop of a hydraulic lift you're not really in a position chide people for trusting their safety to hydraulics.
 
Hoo boy. Let me put it this way: When you're standing on a termite-ridden, two-legged stool balanced atop of a hydraulic lift you're not really in a position chide people for trusting their safety to hydraulics.
If your point was that you trust the government more than an algorithm then why didn't you say so?

There is no way that I could have come up with the answer you did for your question.
 
Last edited:
If your point was that you trust the government more than an algorithm then why didn't you say so?


I've already pointed out that Bitcoin is not just an "algorithm." You're repeating the same compositional fallacy of defining the entire system by only a single one of its many attributes.


No matter how incomprehensible it seems to you, "virtual" doesn't mean "nothing".


There you go with yet another strawman. I never said "virtual" means "nothing." That's a deliberate misrepresentation of my position that you keep on reiterating, even after I've corrected you numerous times.


Then it is time for you to research the concept of intellectual property.


Your snarky comments notwithstanding, I know what "intellectual property" means. It's a term of art in the legal profession, used to grant exclusive rights over ideas like inventions, trade secrets, works of art, advertising logos, slogans, etc. "Intellectual property" generally denotes information protected under copyright, trademark, and patent law.

Why is it so difficult for you to articulate a cogent argument, instead of dropping these obtuse hints and then berating people for not being able to decipher your tortured logic?

Spit it out! What the hell does intellectual property have to do with the discussion at hand?
 
Last edited:
Can you own software?

Yes, but a) it's more common to license the rights to use it and b) bitcoins are not software.

You still need to explain how you believe that intellectual property law is important for bitcoins.
 
So bitcoins are not virtual?


Bitcoins are virtual, and they're also backed by nothing.

The entire market has not one penny of intrinsic value in it. All the money that anyone receives from the sale of bitcoins comes out of the pockets of the later investors, just like in a pyramid scheme. The entire thing is a confidence game based on wishful thinking.
 
Yes, but a) it's more common to license the rights to use it and b) bitcoins are not software.
How could bitcoins be anything but software? If it wasn't for the bits of code you have in the computer file called a "bitcoin wallet" you would have no bitcoins.

Is this some sort of "no true Scotsman" argument?

You still need to explain how you believe that intellectual property law is important for bitcoins.
I never said "law" although it makes an interesting aside.

The legal system could always get all funny about the status of bitcoins but it is most likely that they would have the same status as songs or poetry or any other idea that can be patented. If you can prove that you paid for some bitcoins and that somebody took those coins from your computer then you have a legal case for reimbursement.
 
How could bitcoins be anything but software? If it wasn't for the bits of code you have in the computer file called a "bitcoin wallet" you would have no bitcoins.

Is this some sort of "no true Scotsman" argument?

No, it's making a distinction between software and information. A text file is not software. An e-mail is not software. An encryption key is not software. A jpg file is not software. A database is not software. Your WoW character is not software. A bitcoin wallet and its contents are not software.

And just to preempt another common misconception: no, information is not generally protected as intellectual property. Intellectual property only comes into play if the information enshrines one of the concepts protected by intellectual property law: a copyrighted work, a patented invention, a registered trademark and, in some places, a trade secret. Bitcoins does not fall in under any of these categories, and thus intellectual property has no relevance to them.

I never said "law" although it makes an interesting aside.

I don't think it makes much sense to talk about "intellectual property" outside of the context of intellectual property law.

The legal system could always get all funny about the status of bitcoins but it is most likely that they would have the same status as songs or poetry or any other idea that can be patented. If you can prove that you paid for some bitcoins and that somebody took those coins from your computer then you have a legal case for reimbursement.

... You have no understanding of intellectual property law whatsoever. Songs and poetry are issues of copyright, never patents. There is a clear distinction between ideas and inventions and only the latter can (sometimes) be patented. Bitcoins are not creative works nor inventions and can be neither copyrighted or patented, nor can they be trademarked, protected as trade secrets or considered to be design rights.
 
Last edited:
You need to explain how intellectual property exists other than as a legal concept.
Why would I want to wade through that legalistic minefield?


Because you're the one who brought it up in the first place...

Because a number of people have asked you to clarify your position...

Because it's in your own best interest to make yourself understood...
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom