How To Use Bitcoin – The Most Important Creation In The History Of Man

Status
Not open for further replies.
Bitcoin is already copyrighted under the standard MIT open-source license.

No, Bitcoin is a protocol. Some of the software clients that implement that protocol have been licensed under open-source licenses, but that's another matter. The actual bitcoins themselves, of course, are just pieces of data that fall entirely outside the remit of intellectual property law.
 
... You have no understanding of intellectual property law whatsoever.
If you are a legal expert and you say that a case of bitcoin theft could not be brought before the courts - even if you can prove the facts of the matter - then I bow to your superior knowledge.
 
If you are a legal expert and you say that a case of bitcoin theft could not be brought before the courts - even if you can prove the facts of the matter - then I bow to your superior knowledge.

No, I'm not a legal expert but I do have a layman's knowledge of intellectual property laws.

Further, I do not say that a case of bitcoin theft could not be brought before the courts. As long as bitcoins have monetary value (which they do, even if it's down to fools) you have a case to bring before the courts1. It's just a matter of criminal law and not intellectual property law.

The law generally doesn't distinguish between virtual goods and actual goods: criminal cases have been successfully made over the theft of items in MMORPGs, for instance, and, in theory, income in bitcoins (or for that matter, WoW gold) is taxable.

[1] Granted, with bitcoins pseudonymous nature it will probably be difficult to prove anything.
 
No, Bitcoin is a protocol. Some of the software clients that implement that protocol have been licensed under open-source licenses, but that's another matter. The actual bitcoins themselves, of course, are just pieces of data that fall entirely outside the remit of intellectual property law.


I meant the (original) Bitcoin software. It's an open source software project licensed for public use under the MIT open source license.

And yes, I know that "bitcoins themselves" are not software. They're merely items of data encoded within the Bitcoin cipherblock chain. I also realize they cannot be patented or copyrighted under any IP law.
 
Last edited:
Further, I do not say that a case of bitcoin theft could not be brought before the courts. As long as bitcoins have monetary value (which they do, even if it's down to fools) you have a case to bring before the courts1. It's just a matter of criminal law and not intellectual property law.

The law generally doesn't distinguish between virtual goods and actual goods: criminal cases have been successfully made over the theft of items in MMORPGs, for instance, and, in theory, income in bitcoins (or for that matter, WoW gold) is taxable.

[1] Granted, with bitcoins pseudonymous nature it will probably be difficult to prove anything.


Good luck getting the cops to seriously investigate the disappearance of your ethereal Internet funny money off your computer's hard drive.

Actually, there was some talk of a lawsuit against the owners of "MyBitcoin" by victims seeking damages for lost bitcoins. MyBitcoin was an online company that provided exchange services as well as a "cloud wallet" service. It was allegedly "hacked" in August of last year, to the tune of $250 million BTC. Many people suspect career finance swindler and premier Bitcoin huckster Bruce Wagner of being in on the heist.
 
Last edited:
Further, I do not say that a case of bitcoin theft could not be brought before the courts. As long as bitcoins have monetary value (which they do, even if it's down to fools) you have a case to bring before the courts1. It's just a matter of criminal law and not intellectual property law.
Thanks for the clarification.

This is what I suspected is the case but I am not about to predict an individual judge's ruling over a bitcoin matter.
 
Good luck getting the cops to seriously investigate the disappearance of your ethereal Internet funny money off your computer's hard drive.

Oh, certainly. Practically you're likely to be sol because of lack of evidence, but in principle the law applies and you could take the culprit to court for theft or embezzlement.
 
Why would I want to wade through that legalistic minefield?


Because you posted:
You still need to explain how you believe that intellectual property law is important for bitcoins.
I never said "law" although it makes an interesting aside.


Highlighting from your post. You are clearly claiming that you were using the term "intellectual property" outside the context of intellectual property law. You therefore need to explain how intellectual property exists other than as a legal concept. you may not want to "wade through that legalistic minefield", but your argument requires you to do so.
 
You are clearly claiming that you were using the term "intellectual property" outside the context of intellectual property law. You therefore need to explain how intellectual property exists other than as a legal concept. you may not want to "wade through that legalistic minefield", but your argument requires you to do so.
I am probably using "intellectual property" in a non-legal sense.

Nevertheless, it is still possible to own software/information/ideas/data or whatever you want to call it.
 
I am probably using "intellectual property" in a non-legal sense.

Nevertheless, it is still possible to own software/information/ideas/data or whatever you want to call it.

It gets tricky. What you can certainly own is a physical expression or embodiment of the same: a print-out of a computer program, a set of index cards, a napkin with a hastily scribbled idea, a hard-drive containing a database of sensor readings.

Outside of intellectual copyright law (which may or may not apply depending on the specifics), unless they're depriving you of actual value you have no legal recourse if someone merely copies the information contained: types the program into a computer, photographs the index cards, glances at the napkin and reads the scribbles, copies the bits on the hard-drive.

(Not that legal access to the information is a separate issue. If you break into someone's house to read the idea they've scribbled on a napkin, you're still breaking and entering.)

In particular, it's worth noting that raw ideas have no legal protection. Only expressions of ideas -- inventions, creative works -- are protected. The underlying ideas are free for everyone to take. (As long as you don't also take the actual napkin it's written on.)

In Kremen vs. Cohen, the court used a three-part test to determine if (non-intellectual) property rights exists, which might relevant to this discussion: "First, there must be an interest capable of precise definition; second, it must be capable of exclusive possession or control; and third, the putative owner must have established a legitimate claim to exclusivity." Raw information is not, generally speaking, "capable of exclusive possession or control, but I would hazard a guess that the cryptological signing of bitcoins makes it pass that part of the test.
 
In Kremen vs. Cohen, the court used a three-part test to determine if (non-intellectual) property rights exists, which might relevant to this discussion: "First, there must be an interest capable of precise definition; second, it must be capable of exclusive possession or control; and third, the putative owner must have established a legitimate claim to exclusivity." Raw information is not, generally speaking, "capable of exclusive possession or control, but I would hazard a guess that the cryptological signing of bitcoins makes it pass that part of the test.
There is no need to get that complicated. This forum will never get around all the legal issues associated with bitcoin.

It is sufficient to have established that bitcoin is definitely not "nothing".
 
There is no need to get that complicated. This forum will never get around all the legal issues associated with bitcoin.

It is sufficient to have established that bitcoin is definitely not "nothing".

Uh? I fail to follow your argument. What is that supposed to be sufficient for?
 
Don't tell me you've been barracking for John Albert without knowing what he has been posting.

I have read his posts, and in all honesty I have to say your responses to him have tended to avoid his actual arguments and positions in favour of attacking tangential points and outright straw-men.

So, once again, I have to ask: what, exactly, is establishing "that bitcoin is definitely not 'nothing'" supposed to be sufficient for? Do you even know yourself at this point?
 
In particular, it's worth noting that raw ideas have no legal protection. Only expressions of ideas -- inventions, creative works -- are protected. The underlying ideas are free for everyone to take.


Unless of course, you're talking about software patents, which appear to be granted on a mostly arbitrary basis.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

ISF - Join now!

Every member here is approved by hand. No bots, no spam, just people who care about evidence and honest debate.

Membership is free!

Create your free account

Back
Top Bottom